- 1 - !"#"" "$ %&'%()* +%)) , ! !! "!! ! #$ % &'( ! (&((' ) *''( '% Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $('( ) ! ((+ '' ! ! % " " ,,-./01(231((+ ''1345/627/1645/ 7/893/0/32192:27-0;/830!-<38=80619.5194 >92871-94 2.2<?-;323;45/@-0;</3416,13:2,4213830 190/9 16 ./34/3,/ 084/0 $('( ,13:2,423; 52< 619 45/166/3,/.?-32.58=7/-30/9/,4213.$#$830'& 1645/30283/38710/(A+'619.5194>) 830-30/9 /,4213(A$161419 /52,7/.,4619.5194> ,4) 830 ./34/3,23;41-30/9;1.2<?7/2<?92.13</346198?/921016 13/B/8961945/166/3,/?-32.58=7/-30/9/,4213'&16 C 41 ?8B 623/ 16 .*'' D 619 45/ 166/3,/ ?-32.58=7/ -30/9/,4213$16C41?8B623/16.(''' D61945/ 166/3,/?-32.58=7/ -30/9 /,4213$# 16C 41 ?8B 623/ 16.*'' D61945/166/3,/?-32.58=7/-30/9/,4213(A$ - 3 - 16 45/ ,4 E245 0/68-74 ./34/3,/. E52,5 E8. ,13629</02392<2387??/871*''( '1345/627/16 7/893/0 002421387 2.492,4 830 /..213. -0;/ 2089 .24423; 84 8.8:8F87B83 619 .5194 >!29.4 ??/7784/ 1-94) :20/ @-0;</34 084/0 (&((' 1E/:/9 24 58. <10262/045/190/916./34/3,/61945/166/3,/?-32.58=7/ -30/9 /,4213 '& 16 830 ./34/3,/0 45/ 8??/77834 8,,-./0 1( 41 -30/9;1 .2<?7/ 2<?92.13</34 6198?/92101662:/<1345. /890 92 8<808?-9 7/893/0 ,1-3./7 619 45/ 9/:2.213 ?/424213/9 830 92 8<8089 5858=-0023 7/893/02;51-941:/93</347/80/961945/9/.?130/34 D 484/ /9-./0 45/ <84/9287. 13 9/,190 23,7-023; 45/ 92871-94830!29.4??/7784/1-949/,190. 3 :2/E 16 45/ 92:87 ,134/34213. -9;/0 =B 45/ 7/893/0,1-3./7619=14545/?8942/.45/?12344584E1-70 892./619<B,13.20/9842132. - 4 - !"! !# B 83.E/9 41 45/ 8=1:/ ?1234 2. 61945/61771E23; & :/3 451-;5 45/ 9/:2.213 ?/424213/9 58. 982./0 ./:/987;91-30.2345/9/:2.213?/4242136192<?-;323;45/ @-0;</34 16 ,13:2,4213 830 190/9 16 ./34/3,/ ?8../0 =B 45/ 9287 1-94 830 45/ !29.4 ??/7784/ 1-94 7/893/0 ,1-3./7 619 45/ 9/:2.213 ?/424213/9 58. 9/.492,4/0 52. 89;-</34. .//F23; 7/32/3,B E527/ ./34/3,23; 45/ ?/424213/9 619 45/ 166/3,/ ?-32.58=7/ -30/9 /,4213 '& 16/893/0,1-3./7.-=<24.45845/2.314,5877/3;23; 45/ @-0;</34 16 ,13:2,4213 16 45/ ?/424213/9 13 83B ;91-30 / 6-945/9 .-=<24. 4584 .23,/ 45/ 9/:2.213 ?/424213/92.45/092:/97/32/3,B<8B=/.51E2352.68:1-9 23 ./34/3,23; 52< -30/9 /,4213 '& 16 =B ./4423; 8.20/ 45/ .-=.48342:/ ./34/3,/ /893/0 ,1-3./7 87.1 - 5 - .-=<24. 4584 26 45/ 1-94 6230. 24 3/,/..89B 45/ 623/ 8<1-34<8B=//3583,/061945/166/3,/?-32.58=7/-30/9 /,4213'&16E52,5E1-70< 30.16@-.42,/ * /893/0 2;5 1-94 1:/93</34 7/80/9 1??1./.45/ .-=<2..213 <80/ =B 45/ 7/893/0 ,1-3./7619 45/?/424213/9830.-=<24.458445/92871-9458..51E3 7/32/3,B 41 45/ ?/424213/9 E527/ 2<?1.23; 45/ ./34/3,/ 5/!29.4??/7784/1-9458.9/0-,/045/./34/3,/4162:/ <1345.61945/166/3,/?-32.58=7/-30/9/,4213'&16 5/ 8,,20/34 2. ,8-./0 =B 45/ 9/:2.213 ?/424213/9 E52,558.9/.-74/0234E10/845.83045/9/619/242.3148 624 ,8./ 619 .51E23; 7/32/3,B 1E/:/9 48F23; 2341 ,13.20/984213 45/ 8:1,84213 16 45/ 9/:2.213 ?/424213/9 7/893/0 2;5 1-94 1:/93</34 7/80/9 .-=<24. 4584 02.,9/4213<8B=//G/9,2./0=B?8..23;8??91?9284/190/9. + 3?/9-.871645/<84/9287.139/,19045/9287 1-9483045/!29.4??/7784/1-9461-30458445/8,,-./0 E8.98.58303/;72;/3423092:23;45/:/52,7/830,8-./0 - 6 - 45/8,,20/34E52,558.9/.-74/0234E10/845.E51E/9/ ?91,//023;1345/<1419,B,7/5/92871-94./34/3,/0 45/9/:2.213?/424213/98..484/08=1:/5/!29.4??/7784/ 1-94 23 92<2387 ??/87 1*''( ' E527/ ,13629<23; 45/ ./34/3,/ 619 45/ 166/3,/. ?-32.58=7/ -30/9 /,4213. $#830$16830-30/9/,4213(A$1645/ ,4 <10262/0 45/ ./34/3,/ 619 45/ 166/3,/ ?-32.58=7/ -30/9 /,4213 '& 16 029/,423; 52< 41 -30/9;1 .2<?7/ 2<?92.13</34 619 8 ?/9210 16 62:/ <1345. 23.4/80 16 13/ B/89 $ 13.20/923; 45/ .-=<2..213 <80/ =B 45/ 7/893/0 ,1-3./7 619 45/ ?/424213/9 4584 45/ 9/:2.213 ?/424213/92.8?119092:/9<823482323;52.68<27B8304584 5/2.31458:23;83B,92<2387834/,/0/34.4277084/8<16 45/ 1?23213 4584 6-945/9 7/32/3,B <8B =/ .51E3 23 ./34/3,23; 52< =B <1026B23; 45/ 190/9 619 45/ 166/3,/ ?-32.58=7/ -30/9 /,4213 '& 16 ,,19023;7B 83.E/9 45/ 8=1:/ ?1234 830 ?91,//041?8..45/61771E23; - 7 - 2 5//:2.213/4242132. 22 5/ 2<?-;3/0 @-0;</34 16 ,13:2,4213 084/0 $('( ?8../0 23 1((+ '' =B 45/ 7/893/0 /3219 2:27 -0;/ 830 ! -<38=80E52,52.,13629</0=B45/7/893/0 002421387 2.492,4 830 /..213. -0;/ 2089 .24423; 84 8.8:8F87B83 23 92<2387 ??/87 1*''( ' =B @-0;</34 084/0 (&((' ,13:2,423; 45/ 9/:2.213 ?/424213/9 8,,-./0 619 45/ 166/3,/ ?-32.58=7/ -30/9 /,4213. $# 830 $ 16 830 /,4213(A$16 ,42.5/9/=B 222 5/ 190/9 16 ./34/3,/ 619 45/ 166/3,/ -30/9 /,4213 '& 16 ?8../0 =B 45/ !29.4 ??/7784/1-942.<10262/08.-30/9 8 5/9/:2.213?/424213/9 8,,-./01( 2. ./34/3,/0 41 -30/9;1 .2<?7/ 2<?92.13</34 619 8 ?/9210 16 4E1 - 8 - <1345. 830 41 ?8B 8 623/ 16 .*'''' D 619 45/ 166/3,/ ?-32.58=7/ -30/9 /,4213 '& 16 830 23 0/68-74 16 ?8B</34 16 623/ 5/ .5877 -30/9;1 .2<?7/ 2<?92.13</34 619 8 ?/9210 16 13/ <1345 = 5/ ?/424213/9 2. /34247/0 619 ./4 166 8. ?91:20/0 -30/9 /,4213 &A 16 9 , /;2.49B2.029/,4/041./30=8,F45/ 9287 1-94 9/,190. 619 23619<84213 830 619 3/,/..89B 8,4213 2/ 619 2..-83,/16,13:2,4213E89983426314 879/80B2..-/0 -* %"") # 2.41(71$