- 1 - ! " #$!%% #$!%% $""$ &"'"( ' $""$) &"'"( ' ! "#$ %&##!' $ " Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ($ (" " % %&##)( " # & %&!!(# ( &! & "! % ($ % ! * $ % + ", + (, + &! - 3 - + + ) + "##)$#$$ $$# + + + + )' "! &'"&) ! "#$ %&##!' $ " ($ (" " % %&##)( - 4 - " # & %&!!(# ( &! &'"&) & &! &'"&) ($ &'"&) ! * $ - 5 - &'"&) + ", + &, ( ! + + ) ( + "##)$#$$ $$#+ + + + + )#)$#$& + + + + % - - *% ! - ./0/123455/46047/896/:;<1./:/8/=:4=130$4=:( 9= 3$$# >.466/=?9=? 1./ @A:?B/=1 4=: :/>7// :41/: "##)$#$$ 5400/: 1./7/9= ;< 1./ /=937 9C96 A:?/ /6645A7 ./=>/8371. 7/8/77/: 13 40 D7946 3A71E ;< 2.9>. 1./ 0A91 837 - 6 - 54719193= 4=: 0/54741/ 5300/0093= 38 1./ 5649=19880E &1. 0.47/ /4>.240:/>7//:9=5471 $ ./ 54719/0 0.466 ./=>/8371. ;/ 7/8/77/: 13 40 1./< 2/7/ 4774</: ;/837/ 1./ 7946 3A71 ./ 455/664=1 9= +3##&'!$#$$ 240 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3$ 2.96/ 1./ 455/664=19=+3##!$#$$2401./:/8/=:4=13(./ 7/053=:/=1 30 13 " 9= ;31. 1./ 455/460 2/7/ 1./ 5649=19880 2.96/ 1./ 7/053=:/=1 30( 4=: ! 9= +3##&'!$#$$ 2/7/1./:/8/=:4=130"&4=: " 9./0A919= 3$$#240896/:83754719193= 4=: 0/54741/ 5300/0093= 38 1./ 5649=19880- 0.47/ 9= 1./ 0A91 5735/719/0./5649=1988047/1./:4A?.1/704=::/8/=:4=130$ 4=: " 47/ 1./ 03=0 38 1./ =32 :/>/40/: :/8/=:4=1 3% B1 4C91.79/?:/4=:41/4B4F790.=4/?:/./:/8/=:4=1 3(901./03=:/8/=:4=13&901./:4A?.1/74=::/8/=:4=1 3901./298/38:/8/=:4=13$ 99 ./ 0A91 5735/719/0 47/ 4?79>A61A746 5735/719/0 091A41/:413:64?4::/C9664?/2.9>.47/:/0>79;/:400>./:A6/ DE5735/719/07/09:/=19465735/719/0413:64?4::/:/0>79;/:40 - 7 - 0>./:A6/ DE 5735/719/0 4=: B3C4;6/ 5735/719/0 :/0>79;/: 40 0>./:A6/DE5735/719/0 999 ./ 5649=19880 >649B/: 1.41 1./< 2/7/ B4779/: 4=: 2/7/ 014<9=? 9= 1./97 7/05/>19C/ B4179B3=946 .3B/0 ./< >649B/: 1.41 1./< 2/7/ >3547>/=/70 463=? 291. 1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$4=:"4=:>3=0191A1/:4@39=184B96<./<>649B/:1.41466 1./ 0A91 0>./:A6/ 5735/719/0 47/ 4=>/01746 5735/719/0 38 41/4B4F790.=4/?:/4=:5649=198804=::/8/=:4=130$4=: " ./< >649B/: 1.41 1./97 841./7 :9/: 3= #$$#$ 6/4C9=? ;/.9=: 1./ 5649=19880 4=: :/8/=:4=1 30 13 " 40 6400% 6/?46 ./970 ./ 5649=19880 >649B/: 1.41 ;/9=? @39=1 84B96< B/B;/70 1./< 5300/00/: /GA46 79?.10 9= 1./ 0A91 5735/719/0 4=: 2/7/ 9= @39=14=:>3=017A>19C/5300/0093=381./04B/./<>649B/:1.41 1./< 47/ /=1916/: 13 1. 0.47/ /4>. ./< 466/?/: 1.41 1./ :/8/=:4=130$4=:"2/7//H>6A09C/6</=@3<9=?1./9=>3B/38 1./ 0A91 5735/719/0 291.3A1 0.479=? 91 291. 1./B ./< >649B/: 1.411./<7/GA/01/:1./:/8/=:4=130$4=:"1354719193=4=: .4=: 3C/7 0/54741/ 5300/0093= 38 1./97 0.47/0 32/C/7 1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " :9: =31 .//: 1./97 7/GA/010 ;A1 2/7/ 400/719=?/H>6A09C/79?.10291.3A14=<@A01989>4193=./<466/?/: - 8 - 1.41 1./ :/8/=:4=10 >649B/: 1.41 1./ 5735/719/0 38 1./ @39=1 84B96< 2/7/ 54719193=/: 9= 1./ </47 $# 4=: 1./7/837/ 1./ 5735/719/0 47/ =31 4C4964;6/ 837 54719193= ./ 5649=19880 >649B/: 1.411./<2/7/=3109?=41379/0134=<:3>AB/=1037573>//:9=?0 488/>19=?1./9779?.103C/71./0A915735/719/0./<4603>649B/: 1.41 1./< 2/7/ =31 54719/0 13 4=< :/>7// 837 54719193= /=1/7/: 9=13;/12//=1./:/8/=:4=130$"4=:(./<>649B/:1.41 1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " 47/ 4>>3A=14;6/ 837 B/0=/ 5738910 873B 1./ 47/>4 ?47:/= 40 1./ :/8/=:4=10 2/7/ /47=9=? B37/ 1.4= 0(######% 5/7 4==AB ./< >3=1/=:/: 1.41 3= #$$# 2./= 1./< :/B4=:/: 1./97 0.47/ 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3$7/8A0/:1354719193=1./5735/719/03=1./?73A=:1.411./7/ 240467/4:<4:/>7//9=4=379?9=460A91./<>3=1/=:1.412./= 1./<C/7989/:1./>649B381./:/8/=:4=13$1./<>4B/13F=32 1.4140A91240896/:;<1./:/8/=:4=13(83754719193=2.9>. 2407/8/77/:133F:46412./7/1./0A91240>3B573B90/:4=: 1./5735/719/02/7/:9C9:/:4B3=?011./:/8/=:4=130$"4=: (./<1./7/837/03A?.18374:/>7//381./971.0.47/9=1./ 0A91 0>./:A6/ DE DE 4=: DE 5735/719/0 4=: 03A?.1 837 4 :/>6474193= 1.41 1./ >3B573B90/ :/>7// :41/: $#($# 9= 3&$# :9: =31 ;9=: 1./B 4=: 1./97 0.47/ ./< 4603 - 9 - 03A?.1837B/0=/57389108371.7//</47057937131./8969=?381./ 0A914=:8375/75/1A469=@A=>193=137/01749=1./:/8/=:4=10873B 9=1/78/79=?291.1./975300/0093=381./0A915735/719/0 ( A79=?1./5/=:/=><381./0A911./:/8/=:4=13 B31./7:9/: & 9 ./ :/8/=:4=1 3$ 896/: 4 27911/= 0141/B/=1 :905A19=?1./>377/>1=/00381./:/0>795193=381./0A915735/719/0 / >649B/: 1.41 1./ .3A0/ ;/479=? 3) 38 :4?A=:9 74B 4=>.4<41240>3=017A>1/:9= <3"383:64?4::/C9664?// >649B/: 1.41 1./ /=197/ 64=: 9= <3" 38 3:64?4::/ 9664?/ ;/63=?/:13.9B4=:2401./0A;@/>1B411/738 3"'))( 2.9>.240:/>7//:9=1./</47))(910/68/>649B/:1.411./ .3A0/ ;/479=? 3) 240 :/B3690./: 9= 1./ </47 $#$ 4=: 4 =/2 .3A0/ 240 >3=017A>1/: ;< .9B / >649B/: 1.41 1./ 049: .3A0/2401./7/837/=314C4964;6/83754719193=/4:B911/:1./ 7/64193=0.95;/12//=1./5649=198804=:1./:/8/=:4=130$4=: "/46034:B911/:1.411./5649=198802/7/B4779/:57937131./ </47)!)/:/=9/:1.415649=198804=::/8/=:4=130$4=:" 2/7/>3547>/=/704=:>3=0191A1/:49=:AA=:9C9:/:84B96</ 4603 :/=9/: 1.41 1./ 0A91 0>./:A6/ 5735/719/0 2/7/ @39=1 84B96< - 10 - 5735/719/0 38 41/4B4F790.=4 /?:/ 5649=19880 :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " / 4:B911/: 1.41 4B4F790.=4 /?:/ :9/: 3= $#$$#$ / :/=9/: 1.41 5649=19880 2/7/ B/B;/70 38 4 @39=1 84B96< 4=: .4: /GA46 79?.10 4=: 2/7/ 9= @39=1 4=: >3=017A>19C/ 5300/0093= 38 1./ 0A91 5735/719/0 / 4603 :/=9/: 1.41 5649=19880 2/7//=1916/:1354719193=4=:0/54741/5300/0093=381./971. 0.47/ /4>. 0.47/ /4>. / >649B/: 1.41 1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " .4: 54719193=/:1./0A915735/719/0B/=193=/:9=DE0>./:A6/4=:1./ 0A915735/719/0B/=193=/:9=DE0>./:A6/405/71./>3B573B90/ :/>7//:742=9= 3&$# 99 ./:/8/=:4=13$:/=9/:1.41./2401./B4=4?/7 381./@39=184B96</4603:/=9/:1.411./5649=19880:/B4=:/: 54719193=381./970.47/09=1./0A915735/719/0/>649B/:1.41 1./0A91896/:9= 3&$#240=31>366A09C/40>649B/:;< 1./ 5649=19880 / 4:B911/: 1.41 5649=19880 2/7/ =31 54719/0 13 3&$# / :/=9/: 1.41 1./ :/>7// 5400/: 9= 3&$# 240 874A:A6/=1 4=: B90>.9/C3A0 4=: 240 9=1/=:/:13:/579C/1./6428A60.47/381./5649=19880/>649B/: 1.415649=19880.4:=379?.11916/379=1/7/013C/71./0A910>./:A6/ DE4=:0>./:A6/DE5735/719/04=:>649B/:1.410A91DE0>./:A6/ - 11 - 5735/719/0 :9: =31 /H901 / >649B/: 1.41 466 1./ 4=>/01746 5735/719/0 ;/63=?9=? 13 1./ 84B96< 38 41/4B4F790.=4 /?:/ 2/7/ 54719193=/: ;/12//= .9B 4=: :/8/=:4=1 3" 9= 1./ </47 ))(910/684=:9=1./</47$#1./5735/719/02/7/466311/:13 1./ 0.47/ 38 1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$ ( 4=: :/8/=:4=1 3" ./7/837/./>3=1/=:/:1.41837466574>19>465A7530/054719193= .4:14F/=564>/9= 3"'))(/>649B/:1.419=1./049: 0A911./:/8/=:4=134=:41/4B4F790.=4/?:/.4:?9C/= A5 1./97 0.47/ 9= 0A91 0>./:A6/ DE 5735/719/0 9= 84C3A7 38 :/8/=:4=130$4=:"4?49=017/>/9513840AB380#####% /4>. / >649B/: 1.41 481/7 1./ >3B573B90/ .41.4 38 1./ 4?79>A61A7/ 64=:0 240 >.4=?/: 13 1./ =4B/ 38 1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " 4=: 1./< .4C//=@3</:1./ 0A91 4?79>A61A74664=:0 / 1./7/837/ >3=1/=:/: 1.41 09=>/ 1./ 5735/719/0 2/7/ 54719193=/:9=1./</47))(910/681./5649=198802/7/=31/=1916/: 13 4=< 0.47/ 40 1./ 9=:A A>>/0093= B/=:B/=1 >1 $##& 240=3145569>4;6/ 999 ./ :/8/=:4=1 3$ >649B/: 1.41 ./ 4=: :/8/=:4=1 3" 0A;B911/: 4C474:.913 1./ 9664?/ >>3A=14=1 9= 1./</47 )) 13 /=1/7 1./ =4B/ 38 41/4B4F790.=4 /?:/ 4=: - 12 - :/8/=:4=1 3 9= 7/05/>1 38 $# ?A=140 /4>. 9= <3" 38 3:64?4::/9664?/031.411./<4603./6:03B/5735/71<9=1./97 =4B/0 >>37:9=?6< 3&"# 38 3:64?4::/ C9664?/ 240 /=1/7/: 9= 1./ BA14193= 7/?901/7 4=: >/71989/: / >649B/: 1.41 1./ 049: /=17< 90 =31 6/?46 4=: C469: / >649B/: 1.41 1./ :/8/=:4=134=:41/4B4F790.=4/?:/:9:=314>GA97/4=< 79?.13C/74=47/438$#?A=140/4>.9= <3"383:64?4::/ 9664?//>649B/:1.411./049:64=:02/7/>A619C41/:;<.9B 4=: :/8/=:4=1 3" @39=16< 4=: 240 32=/: 4=: 5300/00/: ;< 1./B / >649B/: 3&"# 240 >3=1747< 13 1./ >3B573B90/ :/>7//9= 3"'))(4=:1./7/837/1./7/C/=A/:3>AB/=10 240A=/=837>/4;6/ 9C /8A71./7>649B/:1.41481/71./>3B573B90/:/>7// 9= 3"'))( 240 5400/: ./ 4=: :/8/=:4=1 3" .4: @39=16< :/C/635/: 1./ 4?79>A61A746 64=:0 B/=193=/: 9= 0A91 0>./:A6/DE5735/719/02.9>./H>6A09C/6<;/63=?/:131./B4=: 8A71./7 873B 1./ 9=>3B/ 38 1./ 0A91 0>./:A6/ DE 5735/719/0 ./ .4:>3=017A>1/:4.3A0/B/=193=/:40 63044=:;381./ 0A91 0>./:A6/ DE 5735/719/0 9F/290/ :/8/=:4=1 3" .4: >3=017A>1/: 630> 4=: : 9= 0A91 0>./:A6/ DE 5735/719/0 - 13 - .A0./>649B/:1.411./5735/719/0B/=193=/:9=1./0>./:A6/ DE2/7/1.//H>6A09C/5735/719/0381./:/8/=:4=130$4=:" />649B/:1.411./:/8/=:4=13(.4:896/:40A9183754719193= 4=:0/54741/5300/0093=381./0>./:A6/DE4=:DE5735/719/09= 1./ </47 $# 45471 873B B3C4;6/ 5735/719/0 4>GA97/: 481/7 ))( ;< 1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " 873B 1./ 9=>3B/ 38 1./ 0>./:A6/ DE 5735/719/0 ./ 0A91 896/: /=:/: 9= 4 >3B573B90/ ;/837/1./3F:46414=:4>>37:9=?6<4:/>7//2405400/:3= $#($#/>649B/:1.41291.3A1461/79=?1./0.47/0?9C/=13 1./54719/09=1./>3B573B90/:/>7//5400/:9= 3"'))( 1./>3B573B90/:/>7//9= 3&$#.40;//=?9C/=/88/>1 13 0 5/7 1./ >3B573B90/ :/>7// 9= 3&$# 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3( 240 466311/: .90 0.47/ 3A1 38 1./ 0.47/ 38 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3$ 2.96/ 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3" 240 466311/: .90 $ 0.47/9=1./0A915735/719/0/>649B/:1.41:/8/=:4=134=: 41/4B4F790.=4/?:/1.3A?.:9:=315300/004=<79?.13C/7 1./ 0A91 5735/719/0 3= .AB4=914794= >3=09:/74193=0 1./< 2/7/ ?9C/=$#?A=1403864=:/4>.9= <3"383:64?4::/9664?/ 12404?7//:1.41481/71./:/41.384B4F790.=4/?:/.90$# ?A=140 23A6: ?3 13 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3$ 4=: 481/7 1./ :/41. 38 :/8/=:4=1 3 ./7 #%$# ?A=140 9= <3" 23A6: ?3 13 1./ - 14 - :/8/=:4=1 3" / >649B/: 1.41 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3( .4: 896/: H3$$#$ 13 ;98A7>41/ 1./ 64=: 40 5/7 1./ >3B573B90/ :/>7//5400/:9= 3&$#4=:1./3A7124056/40/:13 :97/>1 1./ 0A7C/< :/5471B/=1 13 /88/>1 ;98A7>4193= / >649B/: 1.41 /C/7< 19B/ 1./ 0A7C/<37 >4B/ 13 ;98A7>41/ 1./ 5735/719/0 1./:/8/=:4=13"A0/:137490/3;@/>193=03=3=/371./31./7 ?73A=:/8A71./7>649B/:1.41./4=:1./:/8/=:4=13(.4: :/C/635/: 1./ 4?79>A61A746 64=:0 466311/: 13 1./B A=:/7 1./ >3B573B90/:/>7//;A11./:/8/=:4=13":9:=31:/C/6351./ 64=: 190>649B/:1.411./:/8/=:4=130$4=:".4:14F/=1./ 4>1A465300/0093=381./5735/719/0B/=193=/:9=1./>3B573B90/ :/>7// 9= 3"'))( 4=: 1.41 1./ 049: :/>7// 240 =31 >.466/=?/: 9= 4=< B4==/7 2.4103/C/7 / 1./7/837/ >649B/: 1.41 1./ >3B573B90/ >4==31 ;/ 7/C3F/: 37 7/%35/=/: 9= 1./ 9=014=10A91/>649B/:1.411./:/8/=:4=13".4:9=019?41/: 1./ 5649=19880 13 :74? .9B 13 3A71 ;< 8969=? 1./ 9=014=1 0A91 837 54719193=/4603>649B/:1.419=37:/7130A553711./5649=19880 1./:/8/=:4=13".4:896/:427911/=0141/B/=1>3=1747<131./ >3B573B90/:/>7//9= 3"'))( - 15 - C 91. 1./0/ >3=1/=193=0 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3$ 574</: 1.411./0A91896/:;<1./5649=19880;/:90B900/: ./ :/8/=:4=1 3" 4603 896/: 4 27911/= 0141/B/=1 4:B9119=? 1./ 7/64193=0.95 38 1./ 5649=19880 291. .9B / 4603 4:B911/: 1.41 5649=19880 2/7/ B4779/: 4=: 2/7/ 2/66%0/116/: 9= 1./97 69C/0 / >649B/: 1.41 1./ 5649=19880 0.3A6: 0.32 .AB4=914794= >3=09:/74193= 741./7 1.4= /=837>9=? 1./97 79?.1 38 54719193= 4?49=01 1./ :/8/=:4=10 / .32/C/7 4:B911/: 1.41 5649=19880 2/7/ >3547>/=/70 4=: .4: /GA46 79?.10 9= 1./ 0A91 0>./:A6/ 5735/719/0 4=: >3=1/=:/: 1.41 1./< >4==31 ;/ :/=9/: 1./97 79?.1 9= C9/2 38 1./ 9=:A A>>/0093= B/=:B/=1 >1 $##&/>649B/:1.41 3&$#240>3B573B90/:2./= .90841./74B4F790.=4/?:/240469C/4=:291.3A19B56/4:9=? 1./5649=198804054719/0./:/8/=:4=13"4:B911/:1./0141A0 38 1./ 5649=19880 4=: 4:B911/: 1.41 1./< 2/7/ =31 54719/0 9= 3&$#/4:B911/:1.//H901/=>/381./0A910>./:A6/ 5735/719/0 4=: 7/GA/01/: 1./ 3A71 13 :/>9:/ 1./ >40/ 38 1./ 54719/0 / >649B/: 1.41 1.3A?. 1./7/ 240 >/7149= 6/?46 573>//:9=?09= 3"'))(91240=319=1/=:/:1354719193= 1./ 0A91 5735/719/0 4=: 1./ 04B/ :9: =31 488/>1 1./ A=:9C9:/: - 16 - @39=1 84B96< 0141A0 38 1./ 54719/0 40 2/66 40 1./ =41A7/ 38 1./ 5735/719/0 / >649B/: 1.41 1./ :/>7// 5400/: 9= 3"'))(240=/C/74>1/:A53=4=:240=31/=837>/:41 4=< 539=1 38 19B/ / >649B/: 1.41 1./7/ 240 =3 0/C/74=>/ 38 0141A0381./@39=184B96<40.90841./74=:B31./7>3=19=A/:13 69C/9=1./@39=184B96<4=:2/7/633F9=?481/71./4884970381./ @39=184B96<402/66409105735/719/0/574</:1.419=1.//C/=1 1./ 3A71 2/7/ 13 :/>647/ 1./ 0.47/0 38 1./ 5649=19880 1./= .90 0.47/B4<4603;/:/>647/: ! ./:/8/=:4=13(4603896/:427911/=0141/B/=13= 09B964769=/0401./:/8/=:4=13$ ' ./ 5649=19880 1./= 896/: 4 7/@39=:/7 13 1./ 27911/= 0141/B/=1896/:;<1./:/8/=:4=130$4=:(:/=<9=?1.411./7/ 240 4 54719193= 38 1./ 5735/719/0 9= 3"'))( ./< 4603 :/=9/: 1.41 1./ 54719/0 .4: :9C9:/: 1./ 5735/719/0 40 5/7 3&$#./<>649B/:1.411./049::/>7//:9:=31;9=: 1./979=1/7/01 ) 40/: 3= 1./0/ >3=1/=193=0 1./ 17946 3A71 874B/: 1./8366329=?900A/0 - 17 - ! " #" " $ # $ $ # % " % &'& &(& &(& ) &*& &+& &(& ) , $ - 18 - # =0A55371381./>3=1/=193=381./5649=198805649=1988 3240/H4B9=/:40 %4=:0./B47F/:40H013' ./:/8/=:4=13"240/H4B9=/:40 %./:/8/=:4=13$ 240 /H4B9=/: 40 %$ ./ .A0;4=: 38 5649=1988 3$ 240 0ABB3=/:4=:/H4B9=/:40 %291=/00134 966/H/>A1/: ;< 41/4B4F790.=4 /?:/ 9= 84C3A7 38 :/8/=:4=1 3$ 240 /H4B9=/:40 %(4=:1./<B47F/:H0 13 # 40/: 3= 1./ 56/4:9=?0 3746 4=: :3>AB/=147< /C9:/=>/1./79463A71./6:1.411./5649=19880.4:573C/:1.41 1./<2/7//=1916/:13&1.0.47/9=1./0A910>./:A6/5735/719/0 1 ./6: 1.41 1./ >3B573B90/ :/>7// 9= 3"'))( :9: =31 7/0A619=40/C/74=>/9=1./0141A0381./@39=184B96<4091240 =31:742=3=4014B5545/74=:240=31:A6<7/?901/7/: 14603 ./6:1.411./5649=1988047//=1916/:134=A=:9C9:/:0.47/9=1./ 7/09:/=1946.3A0/0402/66401./B3C4;6/0 $ /9=? 4??79/C/: ;< 1./ 4837/049: @A:?B/=1 4=: :/>7//1./:/8/=:4=130$4=:(.4C/896/:1./0/123455/460 " A79=?1./5/=:/=><381./0/455/4601./:/8/=:4=1 30$4=:(.4C/896/:45569>4193=0A=:/77:/7* A6/$!38 3:/389C9673>/:A7/)#'./=>/8371.7/8/77/:1340D-13 - 19 - 573:A>/4::9193=46:3>AB/=147</C9:/=>/.903A719=1/7B038 4=37:/7:41/:$)#($#$&./6:1.41 3$#$&45569>4193= 896/: ;< :/8/=:4=1 3$ 23A6: ;/ >3=09:/7/: 463=? 291. 1./ B49=455/46./45569>4193=896/:;<1./:/8/=:4=13(904603 14F/=A5837>3=09:/74193=463=?291.1./0/455/460 ( ./ 6/47=/: >3A=0/6 837 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3$ 7490/: 1./8366329=?>3=1/=193=0 9 .41 1./ 5735/719/0 9= GA/0193= 2/7/ 54719193=/: 9= 3"'))(4=:1./7/837/1./5649=1988047/=31 /=1916/:134=<0.47/9=1./0A910>./:A6/5735/719/0 />3=1/=:/:1.411./841./7 794B4F790.=4/?:/ .4:0/C/7/:873B1./@39=184B96<4=:1./7/837/1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " >3=19=A/: 40 @39=1 1/=4=10 4=:=311/=4=109=>3BB3=/1./7/837/>3=1/=:/: 1.41 1./7/ 90 =3 @39=1 84B96< 37 >3547>/=47< 4=: ./=>/ 1./ 5649=19880 47/ =31 /=1916/: 13 4 0.47/ /09:/0 1.90 ./ >3=1/=:/: 1.41 837 1./ 9=:A A>>/0093= B/=:B/=1 >1 $##& ./=>/8371. 7/8/77/:1340D1./>1$##&E134556<1./5649=19880 BA01 ;/ I$ J 4=: 09=>/ 1./ - 20 - 841./7240=363=?/74>3547>/=/7403=1./:41/38 1./ >1 $##& >3B9=? 9=13 837>/ 1./ 5649=19880 2/7/ =31/=1916/:1340.47//7/69/:3=1./@A:?B/=138 1./ 4:740 9?. 3A71 9= !"! #" $%& #!'( 99 />3=1/=:/:1.411./:/8/=:4=130$4=:"2/7/ 9= 5300/0093= 38 1./97 7/05/>19C/ $ 0.47/ 4=: 1./ :/8/=:4=13$.4::/C/635/:.90537193=2.96/1./ :/8/=:4=13".4:6/8191A=>A619C41/:/1./7/837/ 0A;B9101.411./:/8/=:4=130$4=:".4:467/4:< :9C9:/:1./5735/719/0/>3=1/=:01.411./5649=19880 2/7/ 8A66< 4247/ 38 1./0/ 84>10 / >3=1/=:0 1.41 % 240 1./ .A0;4=: 38 1./ 5649=1988 3$ 4=: ;/9=? 4= :C3>41/ 240 ./659=? 794B4F790.=4 /?:/9=84B96<:905A1/0/>3=1/=:01.4191240./ 2.3 :7481/: 4 >3B573B90/ :/>7// H ) 9= 3&$#4=:1./7/837/4661./5649=198802/7/ 4247/381./84>11.411./:/8/=:4=130$4=:".4: 467/4:<5.<09>466<:9C9:/:1./5735/719/0 - 21 - 999 .41 1./ 0A91 90 ;477/: ;< 1./ 642 38 69B914193= / >3=1/=:0 1.41 1./ 69B914193= 57/0>79;/: 837 >.466/=?9=? 4 >3B573B90/ 90 1.7// </470 873B 1./ :41/38F=326/:?/A=:/7719>6/&)381./9B914193= >1 )" / >3=1/=:0 1.41 % 4=: 1./ 5649=1988 3$F=/24;3A11./>3B573B90/9= 3&$# 9=1./</47$#910/682.9>.90/C9:/=1873BH0 ' 4=: ) 4=: 123 :3>AB/=10 573:A>/: 463=? 291. 3$#$& ./7/837/ 1./ 0A91 896/: 9= 1./ </47 $# 240 ;/<3=: 69B914193= 4=: ./=>/ 1./ 0A91 90 ;477/:;<1./6423869B914193=/>3=1/=:01.411./ 7946 3A71 240 ;3A=: 13 874B/ 4= 900A/ 7/?47:9=? 69B914193= 40 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3$ .4: 14F/= 0A>. 4 :/8/=>/9=.900141/B/=1 9C .411./5649=198804=:1./:/8/=:4=13".4C/=31 >.30/= 13 >.466/=?/ 1./ :/>7// 5400/: 9= 3"'))( C/= 1./= 1./ 7946 3A71 573>//:/: 13 =A6698< 1./ @A:?B/=1 ;< .36:9=? 1.41 1./ 04B/ 240 =31 4>1/: A53= 4=: 1.41 91 240 >366A09C/4=:=31;9=:9=?A53=1./5649=19880 14603 - 22 - >3BB911/: 4= /7737 9= .36:9=? 1.41 1./ :/>7// 90 A=/=837>/4;6/401./.3A0/5735/719/04=:B3C4;6/0 2/7/=319=>6A:/:9=1./0A91/>3=1/=:01.41 % .4: 4:B911/: 4;3A1 1./ :/>7// 9= 3"'))( 4=:1.411./5649=198802/7/9=017AB/=1469=;79=?9=? 4;3A1 4 >3B573B90/ 3= $"#))( / >3=1/=:0 1.41 481/7 1./ :/>7// 9= 3"'))( 1./7/ 240 4=A=:/7014=:9=?411./;/./01381./5649=198804=: % 1.41 1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " 0.3A6: ?9C/ 424<03B/64=:131./841./74=:B31./74=:1.4191 23A6:7/C/71131./:/8/=:4=10481/71./:/41.381./ 841./74=:B31./7/>3=1/=:01.414>>37:9=?6<4= 3746A=:/7014=:9=?240/=1/7/:9=139=1./</47)) ;/12//=1./841./7B31./74=:1./:/8/=:4=130$ 4=:"9=1/7B0382.9>.>3=0/=1240?9C/=13BA141/ 1./=4B/0381./841./74=:B31./79=7/05/>138$# ?A=140 /4>. 9= <3" 3&"# 4=: 1./< /H/>A1/: 966 :41/: #"#)) H ' ;/GA/41.9=?1./7/05/>19C/537193=0131./:/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " / >3=1/=:0 1.41 1.90 966 240 4603 ;73A?.1 4;3A1 41 1./ 9=014=>/ 38 1./ 5649=19880 4=: - 23 - %"133F4=4>19C/736/2.9>.90/C9:/=1873B1./ /C9:/=>/38 %4=: %(/1./7/837/>3=1/=:0 1.411./5649=198804=: %2.32/7/9=017AB/=146 9= ;79=?9=? 4;3A1 4 :9C9093= 38 1./ 5735/719/0 ;/12//= 1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " 47/ =32 /01355/: 873B >3=1/=:9=? 1.41 1./7/ 240 =3 54719193=9=1./84B96</>3=1/=:01.411./C/7<84>1 1.41 1./7/ 240 4= 3746 54719193= 0A;0/GA/=1 13 1./ :/>7//9= 3"'))(B4:/91B37/1.4=/C9:/=1 1.411./54719193=2404>1/:A53= C .41 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3" 481/7 ;/9=? 4 5471< 13 4 >3B573B90/9= 3"'))(4=: 3&$# .40 0291>./: 09:/0 13 ./65 1./ 5649=19880 ./7/837/ ./ >3=1/=:0 1.41 1./ 4:B90093=0 9= 1./ /C9:/=>/ 38 :/8/=:4=1 3" % 0.3A6: 1./7/837/ =31 2/9?. 9= 84C3A7 38 1./ 5649=19880 3=/1./6/00 1./ 7946 3A71 .40 7/69/: A53= .90 /C9:/=>/ 13.36: 1.41 1./ 5649=19880E>40/904:B911/:;<1./:/8/=:4=13"4=: /77/: 9= .36:9=? 1.41 1./ >3B573B90/ :/>7// 9= 3"'))(90=314>1/:A53= - 24 - C9 .41/C/=1.3A?.1./5649=19880.4:=31573:A>/:4=< /C9:/=>/ 13 /014;690. 1./ /H901/=>/ 38 B3C4;6/0 9= 0A910>./:A6/DE5735/719/0</191?74=1/:4:/>7// 9=7/05/>1381./0/5735/719/0/>3=1/=:01.412.41 240:/0>79;/:9= 3&$#240?36:C46A/:41 0&#####% ;A1 1./ :/8/=:4=10 .4C/ ?9C/= 4 :/0>795193=381./C46A4;6/0/>3=1/=:01.41981./ :3>AB/=10 573:A>/: 463=? 291. 3$#$& 90 5/7A0/: 1./< >3=149= 1./ 57/>90/ :/14960 38 1./0/ 37=4B/=10 / >3=1/=:0 1.41 1./ :3>AB/=10 463=? 291. 3$#$& 23A6: 0.32 .32 1./ 5649=19880 .4:4?7//:13:/46291.1./B3C4;6/0381./84B96< / 1./7/837/ >3=1/=:0 1.41 1./0/ :3>AB/=10 47/ =/>/0047<8371./5A7530/38:/>9:9=?1./>40/ & ./6/47=/:>3A=0/68371./:/8/=:4=13(4:351/: 1./>3=1/=193=0381./6/47=/:>3A=0/68371./:/8/=:4=13$ = 4::9193= ./ >3=1/=:/: 1.41 40 5/7 1./ >3B573B90/ 9= 3"'))( 1./ 7/C/=A/ /=179/0 2/7/ /88/>1/: 9=13 1./ =4B/0 38 1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " ./ 547/=10 38 1./ :/8/=:4=130$4=:"2/7/?9C/=$#?A=1403864=:9= <3" - 25 - 481/71./>3B573B90/4=:1./<9=1A7=/H/>A1/:1./977/05/>19C/ 966;/GA/41.9=?1./5735/719/0;4>F131./:/8/=:4=130$4=: "./0/ 96602/7/411/01/:;<5649=19883$/>3=1/=:01.41 5649=1988 3$ :/69;/741/6<:9: =31 01/59=13 1./ 291=/00 ;3H;A1 ./7.A0;4=: %4:B911/:1.411./ 966240/H/>A1/:411./ 9=014=>/38 %4=:1./5649=19883$2404=411/019=?291=/00 /1./7/837/>3=1/=:01.411./5649=1988047//01355/:873B=32 >3=1/=:9=? 1.41 1./7/ 240 =3 54719193= ;/12//= 1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$4=:"/>3=1/=:01.41 1./54719/047/9=5300/0093=38 1./977/05/>19C/0.47/01./7/90=3=//:135400489=46 :/>7// 4=: 4>1A466< 54719193=9=? 1./ 0.47/0 = 1.90 7/?47: ./ 7/69/: A53=1./@A:?B/=19=)* + * !"! ,- ./,0 0 1 ! " ! $%222( ./ 6/47=/: /=937 3A=0/6 837 1./ 5649=19880 A7?/: 1./8366329=?>3=1/=193=0 9 .41 1./ 5649=19880 2/7/ =31 ;3A=: 13 >.466/=?/ 1./ :/>7// 9= 3"'))( 40 91 240 3=6< 4 57/69B9=47< :/>7//4=:=379?.10381./:/8/=:4=130$4=:".4: >7<0146690/:/133F1./3A711.73A?.1./>3B573B90/ - 26 - :/>7// 4=: >3=1/=:/: 1.41 1./ 841./7 4=: B31./7 .4: 1.3A?. 7/69=GA90./: 1./97 0.47/ 9= 84C3A7 38 1./ :/8/=:4=130$4=:";A1.4::97/>1/:1./:/8/=:4=10 13 .36: 1./ 5735/719/0 @39=16< ./7/837/ ./ >3=1/=:0 1.41 1./7/ 240 =3 4>1A46 :9C9093= 38 1./ 5735/719/0 / 9=C91/: 1./ 411/=193= 38 1./ 3A71 13 />193= 38 1./ 9=:A A>>/0093= B/=:B/=1 >1 $##& 4=: >3=1/=:/: 1.41 54719193= B/4=0 4= 4>1A46 54719193= ;< B/1/0 4=: ;3A=:0 / >3=1/=:/: 1.41 9= 1./ 9=014=1 >40/ 1./ :/>7// 5400/: 9= 3"'))( 90 3=6< 4 57/69B9=47<:/>7// =1.907/?47:./>3593A06<7/8/77/: 131./@A:?B/=1381./3=E;6/5/H3A719=+ "! * ! $-. 3 ( / 4603 7/8/77/: 13 45 6 !7 " * 8 $-. 3 &&( ," , , ! $-33. 2 9( : ! " 11 ! $ -'. 0 6 &( " # , $% ;, '( / >3=1/=:/: 1.41 1./ :/>7// 5400/: 9= 3"'))( 90 =31 /=?7300/: 3= 014B5 - 27 - 545/74=:1./7/837/90=314:/>7//9=1.//</38642 =1.907/?47:./564>/:7/694=>/3=1./@A:?B/=1384 3%37:9=41/ /=>. 9= ! "! 6! ! - &33. / 4603 7/69/:3=1./8366329=?@A:?B/=10 4 - . / !0 1 2,% ; 3 ." / '45 ! * ,%%, > 3# 6 78 5 ( 9 :; ** * :! : - <=" 3,: ! 99 / >3=1/=:0 1.41 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3( .4: 0141/: 9= 1./ 5649=1 9= 3&$# 1.41 1./ 84B96< 90 01966 @39=14=:1./5735/719/047/./6:@39=16</1./7/837/ >3=1/=:/: 1.41 1./ @39=1 84B96< .40 >3=19=A/: 4=: 1./7/ 90 =3 0/C/74=>/ 0 4 B411/7 38 84>1 ./ >3=1/=:0 1.41 9= 1./ >3B573B90/ 7/5371/: 9= 3&$#1./:/8/=:4=130$"4=:(.4C/ 0141/:1.411./<.4C/14F/=4>1A465300/0093=381./ 5735/719/0 / >3=1/=:0 1.41 40 1./ 5735/719/0 47/ - 28 - =31 4>1A466< 54719193=/: 57937 13 $#$$##( 1./ 5649=1988047//=1916/:1340.47/ 999 />3=1/=:01.411./:/>7//9= 3"'))(90=31 /=837>/4;6/ 40 4 0A91 837 5471946 54719193= 90 =31 B49=149=4;6/ / >3=1/=:0 1.41 1./ 7/09:/=1946 5735/719/04=:1./B3C4;6/02/7/=319=>6A:/:9=1./ 0A914=:1./7/837/9190=314=/=837>/4;6/:/>7// = 0A55371 38 1.90 >3=1/=193= ./ 7/69/: A53= 1./ 8366329=?@A:?B/=10 6 $" ( $ $" / ::% % ** :% # .77 .7 7 / !! ** 6 : -8 # / 415 ::2 6 02 65 5 8 > / 5?' ,% !: 9C / >3=1/=:/: 1.41 1./ :/>7// 9= 3"'))( 0133: 0A5/70/:/: ;< 1./ :/>7// 9= 3&$# 4=: 1./7/837/ 1./ 79?.10 38 1./ 5649=19880 240 =31 - 29 - 488/>1/:401./0A915735/719/0>3=19=A/:13;/@39=140 3= 1./ :41/ 38 >3BB/=>/B/=1 38 1./ 9=:A A>>/0093=B/=:B/=1>1$##&/7/69/:3=1./ 8366329=?:/>9093=0 7 ( $ / '45 : 7 ,0 # 37$ > / 7'@-::0% !!; ## 8 + 3 / :2; ** ( ,%0 C />3=1/=:/:1.411./0A91896/:90291.9=69B914193=40 1./7/ 90 =3 69B914193= 57/0>79;/: 837 4 0A91 837 54719193= =>40/383A01/71./B/B;/73A01/:.404 79?.1 13 >649B ;4>F 5300/0093= 291.9= $ </470 40 57/0>79;/: 9= 719>6/ # 38 1./ 9B914193= >1 / >3=1/=:01.4109=>/1./5735/719/09=1./9=014=1>40/ >3=19=A/:13;/@39=19=1./</47$#1./0A91896/:9= 1./ </47 $# 90 291.9= 69B914193= = 1.90 7/?47: ./ 7/69/: 3= 1./ @A:?B/=1 38 4 9C9093= /=>. 38 1.90 3A719=4 10 !" ,*5 !$20 6'3(A37:/7 - 30 - :41/: ##)$#( 9= 3!##$#" 37:/7 :41/: ##'$#$ 9= +73; 3#$$#$ 11 <11 " 60011<11 !$%=2692( >1 # , "!= *,*$'0 29( C9 / >3=1/=:/: 1.41 1./ @A:?B/=1 7/69/: A53= ;< 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3$ 9= )* + * "! , $% & #! '( 90 GA31/: 3A1 38 >3=1/H1 40 9= 1.41 >40/ 1./ 841./7 :9/: 9= )!& 9/ BA>. 57937 13 1./ 9=:A A>>/0093=B/=:B/=1>1$##&>4B/9=13837>/ C99 / >3=1/=:/: 1.41 1./ @A:?B/=1 38 1./ 9C9093= /=>.384:7409?.3A719=#! 60","! 505 5 $2 0 #! 2&''(900GA47/6<45569>4;6/131./84>10381.90>40/ C999 .41 1./7/ 90 =3 @A01989>4193= 13 46632 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3$136/4:4::9193=46/C9:/=>/411.90014?//.40 4603 =31 /014;690./: 2.< 1./0/:3>AB/=10 >3A6: =31 ;/573:A>/:411.//4769/01539=13819B//.404603 =310.32=.321./0/:3>AB/=1047/B41/79468371./ - 31 - 5A7530/ 38 >3=09:/74193= 38 1.90 >40/ / .40 7/69/: A53=1./@A:?B/=19=%/> !" > %$-.&9&( ! = 7/56< 13 1./ 4;3C/ 1./ 6/47=/: >3A=0/6 837 1./ :/8/=:4=13$0A;B911/:408366320 9 ./ >3B573B90/ :/>7// 9= 3"'))( 240 /=?7300/: 3= 014B5 545/7 3= $!#($#! .41 1./7/90=369B914193=837/=?73009=?4:/>7//3=4 014B5545/7.90:3/0=31B/4=1.411./0A91837 54719193= 9= 3"'))( 240 5/=:9=? 1966 1./ :/>7// 240 /=?7300/: 3= 014B5 545/7 / >3=1/=:01.413=>//=?7300/:91:41/0;4>F131./ :41/381./0A91 =1.907/?47:./7/69/:A53=1./ @A:?B/=1 38 1./ 3=E;6/ 5/H 3A71 9= ? @00 /, ! 0 0 1 ! " ! "! ;! /, ! 0 0 1 ! " ! $-'. 9 ( 5? ""!# $-2.( 99 / >3=1/=:/: 1.41 :/8/=:4=1 3" 896/: 9C96 90>3$#)>.466/=?9=?1.//=?7300B/=1381./ - 32 - >3B573B90/ :/>7// 9= 3"'))( 4=: 1./ 04B/ 240 :90B900/: ;< 1./ 3A71 3= $)#$$#$( 4=: ./6: 1.41 /=?7300B/=1 >4= ;/ :3=/ 41 4=< 19B/ 999 / >3=1/=:/: 1.41 1./ :/>7// 9= 3"'))( 90 1.3A?. 5471946 1./ 04B/ 90 B49=149=4;6/ 4=: /=837>/4;6/ =0A55371381.90>3=1/=193=./7/69/: 3= 1 " 00 -;>. " !! %) A $&3&2. ''+ 4=: #5!7, " !! %) A$-332.%233( ' / .4C/ >3=09:/7/: 1./ 56/4:9=?0 3746 4=: :3>AB/=147< /C9:/=>/ @A:?B/=1 38 1./ 17946 3A71 4=: 1./ 47?AB/=10 >4=C400/: ;< 1./ 6/47=/: >3A=0/6 837 1./ :/8/=:4=130$4=:(4=:1./6/47=/: /=9373A=0/68371./ :/8/=:4=13"4=:1./6/47=/:>3A=0/68371./5649=1988 ) ./8366329=?539=104790/8373A7>3=09:/74193= 9 A ,2::% - 33 - " " B $ , # < ' 'A !! $ $ " # % $# 0 847 40 1./ 89701 539=1 90 >3=>/7=/: 2/ 47/ >3=0>93A0 38 1./ 5309193= 38 642 1.41 B/7/ 8969=? 38 4 0A91 837 54719193= :3/0 =31 7/0A61 9= 0/C/74=>/ 9= 1./ 0141A0 38 1./ @39=1 84B96< 4=: 91 >3=19=A/0 13 ;/ @39=1 A=196 4= 4>1A46 54719193= 90 /88/>1/: ;< B/1/0 4=: ;3A=:0 / 47/ 4603 >3=0>93A0 38 1./ 5309193= 38 642 1.41 57/69B9=47< :/>7// :3/0 =31 7/0A61 9= 4= 4>1A4654719193= /47/4247/38/H564=4193=13 />193=131./ 9=:A A>>/0093= B/=:B/=1 >1 $##& 2.9>. /H5649=0 1.41 837 1./ 5A7530/0 38 1.41 0/>193= I54719193=J B/4=0 4 54719193= B4:/ ;< 4 ://: :A6< 7/?901/7/: 37 4 54719193= /88/>1/: ;< 4 :/>7//3843A71./3=E;6/5/H3A719=+ "! * ! ! $-. 3 ( ./6: 9= - 34 - /H>/5193=46 >40/0 2./7/ 3746 54719193= 90 0A55371/: ;< 5A;69> :3>AB/=104=:54719193=24089=466</C9=>/:9=1./04B/B4==/7 409891.4:;//=/88/>1/:;<4:/>7//3843A7191B4<4>>/51 0A>. 54719193= = 1.90 >40/ 1.3A?. 1./7/ 90 =3 89=46 :/>7// 54719193=9=?1./5735/719/01./7/47/4;A=:4=184>102.9>.=//: 13;/59/>/:13?/1./713>./>F2./1./71./:/8/=:4=130$4=: " .4: :9C9:/: 1./97 K 0.47/ 5A70A4=1 13 1./ :/>7// 5400/: 9= 3"'))( ./ 84>10 9= 1.90 >40/ 57/0/=10 4 5/78/>1 >40/ 01A:<837401A:/=13864213F=322.414=I/H>/5193=46>40/38 4=374654719193=J>4=;/9=1./69?.1 381./3;0/7C4193=0381./ 3=E;6/ A57/B/3A719=+ "!* ! ! $ 32 >3B9=? 13 1./ 84>10 38 1.90 >40/ 794B4F790.=4 /?:/ 4=: .90 ;731./7 .4: 54719193=/: 1./ 5735/719/038.9084B96<03B/2./7/9=)&(4=:1./64=:;/479=? <30$"(4=:"383:64?4::/8/6613.900.47/.9090 /C9:/=1 873B 1./ 7/>91460 9= 1./ :/>7// 9= 3"'))( 4=: 4603 1./ BA14193= 13 ;79=? 4;3A1 1./ =4B/ 38 4B4F790.=4 /?:/ 9= 1./ 7/C/=A/ 7/>37:0 H$ / 1./7/481/7 896/: 3)!&4?49=01.90;731./74=:01/5B31./79=7/05/>138 - 35 - .3A0/ 5735/719/0 4=: 455A71/=4=1 C4>4=1 054>/ 9= <30" ' "$( "$& "$$ 38 /6645A7 404;4 /6645A7 46AF 1.41 2/7/ =31 54719193=/: 9= )&( % .A0;4=: 38 5649=1988 3$ 240 1./ 4:C3>41/ 2.3 7/57/0/=1/: 794B4F790.=4 /?:/ 9= 3)!&>3B573B90/240:7481/:;< %4=:1./049: 0A91240:/>7//:3=)#()!&H #./7/90=3>6A/4013 2.41.455/=/:131.30/5735/719/0401./<2/7/=/91./7547138 1./ :/>7// 9= 3"'))( =37 1./ 0A91 896/: ;< :/8/=:4=1 3( 9= 3&$# 37 9= 1./ 57/0/=1 0A91 A1 1./ 84>1 7/B49=01.414B4F790.=4/?:/7/149=/:1./64=:1.41./?3141 1./54719193=9=1./</47)&( $$ >7A>946 84>1 1.41 .40 ?3=/ A==319>/: ;< /C/7<3=/ 4=:2.9>.89=:0B/=193=9=1./:/>7//9= 3"'))(901.41 1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " 2.3 2/7/ 1./= B9=370 .4: 03B/ 64=:0 9= 1./97 =4B/0 41 46?A69 C9664?/ ./ 57353091A0 4B4F790.=4 /?:/ 4 0.7/2: ;A09=/00B4= 9= 47/>4=A1 8/61 91 4557357941/130/66424<1./64=:0;/63=?9=?13:/8/=:4=130$ 4=: " 837 9B573C/B/=1 38 1./ 64=:0 41 3:64?4::/ 4=: ./ 4>>37:9=?6< :9: 1.41 3=/ 38 1./ 54719/0 .4C/ 411/B51/: 13 - 36 - :90>630/2.411.30/64=:02/7/2.412401.//H1/=14=:.32 1./:/8/=:4=130$4=:"32=/:1./64=:04146?A69 $" 0 5/7 1./ 7/>91460 38 1./ >3B573B90/ :/>7// 9= 3"'))( 4B4F790.=4 /?:/ .4: .4=:/: 3C/7 1./ B4=4?/B/=1 38 1./ 5735/719/0 13 1./ :/8/=:4=10 $ 4=:" 033= 481/7 1./< >4B/ 388 4?/ / 4=: .90 298/ 7/69=GA90./: 1./97 9=1/7/019=1./5735/719/04?49=017/>/951380#####%/4>. 12404603B/=193=/:1.411./57353091A04=:.90298/2/7/13 ;/ 633F/: 481/7 ;< 1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " = C9/2 38 1./ 57353091A0 7/69=GA90.9=? .90 0.47/ 1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " 2/7/1./3=6<3=/02.32/7//=1916/:83740.47/4=:1./7/837/ 91240B/=193=/:1.411./:/8/=:4=130$4=:"0.466.4C/.468 0.47/9=1./0A915735/719/04=:1.411./<0.466=31:9C9:/1./B :A79=? 1./ 698/ 19B/ 38 4B4F790.=4 /?:/ 4=: .90 298/ B1 4C91.79/?:/ 81./84B96<381./:/8/=:4=130$4=:" >3=19=A/:69F/1.901./=5/7.4501./>3=1/=193=0381./6/47=/: /=937>3A=0/68371./5649=198801.411./7/240=3:9C9093=9=1./ 84B96<23A6:.4C/;//=4>>/51/:./:90>A0093=9=1./8366329=? 5474?745.0 0.32 .32 1./ 54719/0 >3=:A>1/: 1./B0/6C/0 2.9>. - 37 - ?/=/741/ 4 0173=? 9B57/0093= 1.41 1./ 54719/0 .4: 9=://: 5.<09>466<:9C9:/:1./975735/719/0 $( ./5735/719/09=C36C/:9= 3"'))(2/7/64=: 9= <30$"(($4=:"383:64?4::/C9664?/ 190 0//= 873B H) 1.41 BA14193= /=179/0 2/7/ /88/>1/: 9= 3&)/C9:/=>9=?1./84>11.41;31.:/8/=:4=130$4=:" 5300/00/:K0.47/9=1./4;3C/5735/719/0 $& 9 81/7 :/>7// 9= 3"'))( 91 455/470 1.41 1./7/ 240 :905A1/ ;/12//= 1./ :/8/=:4=10 $ " 4=: 4BF790.=4/?:/2.9>.2407/036C/:4=:91240:/>9:/:1.41 :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " 0.466 B4F/ 3C/7 $# ?A=140 38 64=: 13 4B4F790.=4 /?:/ 4=: $# ?A=140 13 B1 4C91.79 /?:/ 9= <3"4=:4>>37:9=?6<3&"#240>/71989/:9=1./</47 ))9=1/7B0382.9>.1./97=4B/02/7//=1/7/:9=1./7/C/=A/ 7/>37:0 40 5/7 H& 1 90 0//= 1.41 /C/= 481/7 1./ 4;3C/ 1./7/2/7/>/7149=:905A1/0;/12//=1./:/8/=:4=130$4=:" 3C/79:/=1989>4193=381./537193=0381./5735/719/09= <30$ 4=: " 4=: 91 240 4B9>4;6< 7/036C/: 41 1./ 9=014=>/ 4=: 9=1/7C/=193= 38 .A0;4=: 38 5649=1988 3$ % 9= 1/7B0 38 2.9>.45.<09>46:9C9093=3864=:9= <3"24013;//88/>1/: - 38 - /C9:/=>9=? 537193=0 1.41 2/7/ 466311/: 13 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3$ :/8/=:4=1 3" 4B4F790.=4 /?:/ 4=: .90 298/ >>37:9=?6< <3" 240 :9C9:/: 9=13 83A7 537193=0 =4B/6< <3" 9= 84C3A7 38 4B4F790.=4 /?:/ <3"$ 9= 84C3A7 38 4C91.79 /?:/ <3""9=84C3A738:/8/=:4=13"4=: <3"( 9= 84C3A7 38 :/8/=:4=1 3$ ./ BA14193= /88/>1/: 9= ($##&%# 9= 7/05/>1 38 <3" "$ "" 4=: "( 7/8/70134I9;.4@4=J4=:BA14193=2405A70A4=1134=37:/738 1./ 4.096:47 :41/: #)$##& ./7/837/ 1./ 7/>9146 9= 1./ :/>7//9= 3"'))(1.41:/8/=:4=130$4=:"0.3A6:=31 54719193=1./5735/719/0:A79=?1./698/19B/3857353091A04=:.90 298/ 6301 09?=989>4=>/ .90 :9C9093= 90 4:B911/: ;< :/8/=:4=1 3";A1./>3=1/=:/:1.411.90240:3=/0340137490/4634=9= 1./=4B/38 794B4F790.=4/?:/./84>17/B49=01.411.90 64=:240;98A7>41/:9=1/7B038454719193=./5649=19880:9:=31 573:A>/ 1./ 37:/7 5400/: ;< 1./ 4.096:47 7/8/77/: 4;3C/ 4=: 1.90 >3A6: .4C/ 1.732= 03B/ 69?.1 40 13 2./= 4=: .32 1./ I9;.4@4=J240/88/>1/: $ ./@39=184B96<69C/:9=4=36:.3A0/>3=017A>1/:9= 1./ </47 )!$ 3= 1./ 64=: ;/479=? <3" ./ :/8/=:4=1 - 39 - 3$ >649B/: 1.41 ./ :/B3690./: 1.90 .3A0/ 4=: >3=017A>1/: 4 =/2 .3A0/ /8/=:4=1 3" 4:B911/: 9= .90 /C9:/=>/ 1.41 :/8/=:4=1 3$ >3=017A>1/: 4 .3A0/ 9= 1./ </47 $## 9= <3";A1>649B/:1.411./36:.3A0/4603/H901/:1.3A?../ :9: =31 8A7=90. 4=< /C9:/=>/ 13 /014;690. 91 ./ 6/401 1.41 ./ >3A6:.4C/:3=/24013573:A>/45.313?745.381./36:.3A0/ 2.9>. ./ :9: =31 ./ :/8/=:4=1 3" 4:B911/: 1.41 ./ >3=017A>1/:4.3A0/9= <3$9=1./</47$#./7/837/1./ :/8/=:4=130$4=:"2/7/7/09:9=?0/54741/6< $! 9 ./ :/8/=:4=1 3$ 4:B911/: 1.41 ./ 4=: :/8/=:4=1 3" .4: 0/54741/ 634= 4>>3A=10 41 79B47< ?79>A61A746 7/:91 3%35/7419C/ 3>9/1< :4?A=:9 9F/290/ 4B4F790.=4 /?:/ 4=: 4C91.79 /?:/ .4: 0/54741/ 634= 4>>3A=10 /8/=:4=1 3" :/530/: 1.41 ./ 09?=/: >3B573B90/ :/>7//9= 3"'))(408366320 C ! "#$% & '( ) *'+,- < - ./0 * 1+ + 23 4 ! 5637 8 .9:;%< 2# = 67,- < ->,= ?,@ABCDDE37'(2( - 40 - * ./0 FGH 6#I = 57,- 99 ./7/ 90 =3 :3A;1 1.41 4 0141/B/=1 240 B4:/ ;< :/8/=:4=13$9=.90>7300%/H4B9=4193=2./7/./04<0 -JKCC 37 $$ 1+L 37 * /M/3728#,* 5 .NOPNLPN37=QNO R# /Q2PN 2($I%7= *8#, * * < S CTBJKCC U #, 1 7 * =7 'V & #,- $' .902405/7.4504:/8/=>/14F/=130.331:32=1./ 0A91896/:4?49=01.9B;<1./:/8/=:4=13(9= 3&$# .90 :/5309193= 38 :/8/=:4=1 3$ .32/C/7 :9: =31 >.4=?/ 1./ 84>1 091A4193= =4B/6< 1./ 0/54741/ 7/09:/=>/ :9C9093= 38 <3" $) .41 =//:0 13 ;/ =31/: 90 1.41 794B4F790.=4 /?:/4=: B1 4C91.79/?:/.4:;/GA/41./:1./97537193=038 64=:9= <30"4=:"$9=84C3A7381./:/8/=:4=130$ 4=:"9=1./</47))649=19883$2403=/381./>3=1/019=? 291=/00 13 1.90 966 ./ 6428A6 /H/>A193= 38 1./ 966 90 - 41 - /014;690./: ;< %" ./ 41 H 837 1./ </47 $#&% 0.320 1.41 <3( 240 9=14>1 .32/C/7 ;< 3&) <3(240:9C9:/:9=13 <30(4=:($9=13123/GA46 537193=0=4B/6<$4>7/0&K?A=1404=:$4>7/0(K?A=140 7/05/>19C/6< "# ./ 4;3C/ 84>10 23A6: /014;690. 1.41 ;31. 1./ :/8/=:4=130$4=:".4:0/54741/7/09:/=>/0./:/8/=:4=1 3$ .4: 467/4:< >3=017A>1/: 4 .3A0/ 9= <3" 4=: 91 90 9B573;4;6/1.41./>3A6:.4C/:3=/03291.3A19:/=198<9=?.90K 0.47/ 1./7/9= 9F/290/ 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3" .4: >3=017A>1/: 4 .3A0/9= <3$4=:91909B573;4;6/1.41./>3A6:.4C/:3=/ 03291.3A1?/119=?.90.4680.47/:/B47>41/:.90573;4;9691<90 :A/131./84>11.417/64193=0.95;/12//=1./54719/02403=1./ 73>F0 033= 481/7 :/8/=:4=1 =3$ 896/: 3"'))( 4=: 1./7/481/7 2./= 1./< ;31. :/>9:/: 1.41 03B/ 537193=0 0.466 ;/ 7/149=/:9=1./=4B/381./97547/=104=:5793713))2./=1./ 54719/0 2/7/ >3A=0/66/: ;< 1./ .A0;4=: 38 1./ 5649=1988 =3$ 13 :9C9:/ 1./ 64=: 9= <3" 13 9:/=198< 1./ 7/05/>19C/ 0.47/0 ./7/837/ 13 >3=1/=: 1.41 :/0591/ 466 1./ 4=9B30919/0 1./ - 42 - :/8/=:4=10 $ 4=: " >3=19=A/: 13 ;/ @39=1 90 69F/ 9B4?9=9=? 1./ A=9B4?9=4;6/ " ./ 4;3C/ 84>10 23A6: :/B3=01741/ 1.41 <3" 240:9C9:/:405/71./BA14193=/=179/09=1383A7547104=:1./ 3=/0 1.41 8/66 13 1./ 0.47/ 38 4B4F790.=4 /?:/ 240 ;/GA/41./:9=84C3A738:/8/=:4=13$4=:3=/381./291=/00/0 13 1.90 2966 240 1./ 5649=1988 3$ <3( 240 :9C9:/: 9=13 <3(4=:($9=13123/GA46537193=0=4B/6<$4>7/0& K?A=1404=:$4>7/0(K?A=1407/05/>19C/6<./7/837/1./7/ 240 =31.9=? /60/ 1.41 7/B49=/: 13 ;/ 54719193=/: 0 79?.16< >3=1/=:/:;<1./6/47=/:>3A=0/68371./:/8/=:4=13$1./0/ >97>AB014=>/0:9:/014;690.1.411./54719/0.4:4>1/:A53=1./ :/>7//9= 3"'))(4=::9C9:/:1./5735/719/0291.3A11./ 9=1/7C/=193=381./3A71 "$ ./ :/>7// 9= 3"'))( 240 /=?7300/: 3= 014B5 545/7 :A79=? 1./ </47 $#! 2.9>. 240 >.466/=?/: ;< :/8/=:4=1 3" 9= 9C96 90>3$#) H) 3= C4793A0 ?73A=:03=/382.9>.2401.4191240:742=;/641/:6<481/7$" </470873B1./:41/381./:/>7//./049:9C9690>3$#) 240 45547/=16< :90B900/: .3A?. 1./ 6/47=/: /=937 3A=0/6 - 43 - 8371./5649=198807/8/77/:130/C/746:/>9093=09=1.907/?47:1./ 84>1 7/B49=0 1.41 1./ :/>7// 240 /=?7300/: 3= 014B5 545/7 1.3A?. ;/641/:6< 4=: 9= C9/2 38 1./ @A:?B/=1 38 1./ 3=-;6/ 5/H3A719=? @00/,!0 0 1 ! " !"! ;!/,!0 0 1 ! " !$-'.9 ( 2./7/91240./6:1.41/=?7300B/=1384:/>7//3=014B5545/7 23A6:7/C/71;4>F131./:41/381./:/>7//4=:1./7/90=319B/ 69B91837?/119=?4:/>7///=?7300/:3=014B5545/7./7/837/ 1./ >3=:A>1 38 1./ 54719/0 0.320 1.41 1./7/ 240 4= 4>1A46 :9C9093= 38 1./ 5735/719/0 ;/12//= 1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " 5A70A4=1 13 1./ :/>7// 5400/: 9= 3"'))( 2.9>. 240 57937 13 1./ 9=:A A>>/0093= B/=:B/=1 >1 $##& >3B9=? 9=13837>/ "" 0847401./0/>3=:4=:1.97:539=1047/>3=>/7=/: 91907/6/C4=113=31/1.411./5649=198802/7/466B4779/:5793713 )!)2.9>.90/C9:/=1873B1./:/5309193=38 %.90904603 573C/:;<1./84>11.41 %1./.A0;4=:381./5649=19883$ :/530/:1.4191240./2.3:7/2A51./>3B573B90/5/19193=9= 3)!& H # 2.9>. 240 4 0A91 896/: ;< 794B4F790.=4/?:/4?49=01.90;731./74=:01/5B31./7837 - 44 - 54719193= 4=: 0/54741/ 5300/0093= 38 .90 0.47/ 9= 03B/ 38 1./ 5735/719/01.412/7/6/813A13854719193=9=1./</47)&( ./= 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3$ 896/: 3"'))( 1./ 3=6< 5/703=0 9=1/7/01/: 9= 1./ >3%547>/=/7< 2/7/ 1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$ " 4B4F790.=4/?:/4=:7/B31/6<1./:/8/=:4=13./84>1 1.411.900A91240>3B573B90/:;/12//=1./B90=319=:905A1/ ./ 400AB5193= 38 1./ 7946 3A71 1.41 1.90 >3B573B90/ 240 >366A09C/240=31;40/:3=4=</C9:/=>/;A1240;40/:3=1./ 04< 38 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3" ./7/ 90 =3 7/403= 13 ;74=: 1./ >3B573B90/40>366A09C/;A13=1./>3=1747<1./84>11.41 % 1./ .A0;4=: 38 1./ 5649=1988 3$ 4= 4:C3>41/ ;< 5738/0093= 2401./?313B4=9=1./84B96<2.3./6:024<3C/7:905A1/09= 1./84B96<90/C9:/=1873BH )2.9>.05A77/:1./:9C9093=38 1./ 5735/719/0 ;/12//= 794B4F790.=4 /?:/ B1 4C91.79 /?:/:/8/=:4=13$4=::/8/=:4=13"4=:2407/>37:/:;< %9=.90.4=:27919=? %1.3A?.4:B911/:1.41H )240 9=.90.4=:27919=?./179/:13/H179>41/.9B0/68;<>649B9=?1.41 :/8/=:4=13$.4:?314>3B573B90/1<5/:9==?690.4=:1.41 ./B/7/6<174=0641/:9100AB9=?1.90460313;/17A/./>3A6: =31.4C/:/=9/:F=326/:?/381./>3=1/=1038H )8/238 1./7/6/C4=1>64A0/0>3=149=/:9=H )47//H174>1/:;/632 - 45 - -W( * * % J@XYXCDDE 72 QZ2N? GO37 .PN F 37 + 23 *'[ H @ABCDDE U3, 1 37 & .&O % JXYXCDDE & '( % JAXYXCDDE ) , 3 & '(37 % */0 [8 56\ .5 7+[ + P8! G]# Q 2 R, R7, RQ+ Q 2 % /M 72 + 7 7# ( .PN F8 W( * * + W( PN^ * R )H . + CBJ .$+ 3[ _ *[HQ `#R, .,, ,, V+( =,,, a+O C CJ U YXCbXK KXbXK TYXKD O J C@ U JXKXK KXbXK JbXCA X @ CEBC U JXTXK KXKXA CCXEC X E CEBJ U JXEXA KXKXA CCXEC X T @Y U KXC@XK KXCXK JXKK X 13Q 2 6 8L3*/0[8 R#. c6R+,3Q 2+ d$?=G(TCD - 46 - e CJf F 5\ O 2N? gZL /M 2*/M 26( e5-*f2NCY37H_537+, ++37 h /8 ,,C@ V+( J=XKXXK eUXbXKf [ %: 1 *8 3 % @CXCXCDDY 2a . 1 H Q 2+ #R, C, W(;^0* R23 ,,C@2g' U =XX KXJKXK KXKXA J, 6(* R23 ,,C@2g' U =XX KXJKXK KXKXA @, *;^0* R23 ,,C@2g' U =XX KXJKXK KX@XK E, PN^;^0* R23 ,,C@2g' U =XX KXJKXK KX@XK 3Q 2+ d$?=G(T@K e CJf F 5\L O 2N? gZL /M 2*/M 26( e5-*fe2NCYf37H_537+, "7i&'(37W(;^0* 2 .9:^ )37 F 37 5 *[ . .F .'X.$ N5L F 8 + "2PN +3#L F F/ML O 2 L2 . +LP7+LR 5QNOLQ^j ()L *k R+ %L ( 55 F Q%O^] +QWl+2 H/ 8L"2PN +.9:;%< R+ % ^ 37 *I . +L + + g Z - 47 - +I PN +3I5 5 ( QO) \+, 13( .^j)371) %& '( + ++ 2a 2 + 258 PN2 I O + V+( * QL2(+ m L 6LW(;^0*+W(6 6( * R $L L 6 m R+ % ^ * 5*/0[ cU37[*[Q%O^]+ QWl+4 * %6# 54 2PN 2+( \ Q$l\+, 2PN2+([ */0[ c6*4`,- "( ./7/ 90 =3 :41/ B/=193=/: 3= H ) ;A1 2/ >4= :/89=91/6< .36: 1.41 1.90 240 481/7 1./ BA14193= 9= 3&"# 4=:;/837/1./ 966:41/:#"#))H '240/H/>A1/:;< 794B4F790.=4/?:/9=84C3A738:/8/=:4=13$9=7/05/>138 $# ?A=140 9= <3" .90 5/7.450 240 1./ ;4090 837 1./ BA14193= /=179/0 9= ($##&%# 9= 7/05/>1 38 <3" "$""4=:"(383:64?4::/H )240>/7149=6<:742= A5;/837/1./>3B573B90/2407/5371/:9= 3&$#896/: ;< 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3( 40 ./ 240 =31 0.32= 40 3=/ 38 1./ 54719/09=H ) "& >47/8A67/4:9=?38H )0.3201./8366329=?84>10 2.9>.>4==31;/:905A1/: - 48 - 9 1.411./5649=198802/7/0A914;6<?981/:291.C46A4;6/0 411./19B/381./97B47794?/ 991.41 1./ 5649=19880 2/7/ 4247/ 38 1./ :/>7// :41/: $'#))(5400/:9= 3"'))( 9991.41 481/7 1./ :/>7// 9= 3"'))( 7/C/=A/ /=179/02/7/B4:/9=BA14193=/=17<3&) 9C1.41 1./ 5649=19880 4603 >3=0/=1/: 13 1./ 4774=?/B/=1/=1/7/:9=139= 3"'))( C1.41 3&"# ;< 2.9>. 7/C/=A/ 7/>37:0 2/7/ >.4=?/:9=7/05/>138$#?A=140/4>.9= <3"38 3:64?4::/ 84C3A79=? 794B4F790.=4 /?:/ 4=: B1 4C91.79/?:/ C91.41481/71./:/>7//9= 3"'))(1./7/2/7/ :905A1/0 ;/12//= 4B4F790.=4 /?:/ :/8/=:4=1 3 :/8/=:4=1 3$ 4=: :/8/=:4=1 3" :A/ 13 =3= ;98A7>4193= 38 537193=0 2.9>. 240 7/036C/: ;/12//= 1./B 9= 1/7B0 38 2.9>. 794B4F790.=4 /?:/ 4=: B1 4C91.79 /?:/ 2/7/ ?9C/= $# ?A=140/4>. 9= <3"383:64?4::/405/71./ BA14193=1.412404>>/51/:9=3&"# - 49 - C99 1.41 1./ 5649=19880 .4: >3=0/=1/: 13 1./ 4;3C/ >3B573B90/ " 9 ./7/837/ 1.90 90 =31 4 01749?.1 >40/ 2./7/ :4A?.1/70.4C/455734>./:1.903A710//F9=?8371./970.47/9= 1./ 4=>/01746 5735/719/0 8 1./< .4: 7/>/9C/: C46A4;6/0 41 1./ 19B/ 38 B47794?/ 1./< 2/7/ ;3A=: 13 05/66 3A1 2.41 2/7/ 1./ C46A4;6/0 4=: 2.41 240 1./97 C46A/ 4=: 2./1./7 91 240 >3BB/=0A741/ 13 1./97 0.47/ 400AB9=? 1.41 4 54719193= 240 /88/>1/:1./=:B911/:6<466381./B2/7/?9C/=132/660/116/: 89=4=>9466< 2/66 388 4=: 7/5A1/: 84B969/0 ./7/837/ 1./7/ 90 03B/1.9=?B37/1.4=2.41B//101.//</.//=:/4C3A7381./ 3A7190=3113B/>.4=9>466<4556<1./642;A113:37/46@A019>/ ;/12//=1./54719/0./54719/0B4<17<13.9:/03B/1.9=?4=: 91 90 1./ :A1< 38 1./ 3A71 13 17< 13 89=: 3A1 1./ >7AH 38 1./ B411/7 /C/= 98 91 B/4=0 ?39=? ;/.9=: 973= >A7149=0 ./ 3A71 >4==31B9001./233:08371./17//04=:9?=37/1.//6/5.4=19= 1./733B6/019123A6:;/69F/0//9=?1./0F9=4=:B9009=?1./ 03A6./;4:;633:;/12//=1./5649=19880:/8/=:4=13"4=: :/8/=:4=1 3$ 90 03 /C9:/=1 873B 1./ 411/B510 B4:/ ;< 1./ 3A71137/036C/1./:905A1/4B9>4;6<;/12//=1./54719/0.90 - 50 - 3A71/C/=411/B51/:13>3B5/61./5649=19880:/8/=:4=13"13 C9091 1./ .3A0/ 38 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3$ 837 237F9=? 3A1 4 0/116/B/=1 4=: 1./ B/B;/7 0/>7/147< 38 1./ 90179>1 /?46 /7C9>/0240:97/>1/:13;/57/0/=1411./>3B573B90/B//19=? ./573>//:9=?0381./>3B573B90/B//19=?2407/>37:/:2.9>. :90>630/0 1.41 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3$ .4: 388/7/: 13 54< 4 0AB 38 0#######% 13 1./ 5649=19880 ;A1 1./ 5649=19880 :/B4=:/: 0"&######%4=:&4>7/03847/>4?47:/= 99 00AB9=?1.411./5649=1988047//=1916/:83740.47/9= 4661./0A915735/719/01./<23A6:?/14;3A1$13$&4>7/04=: 1./5649=19880.4C/B/=193=/:1./C46A/38/4>.381./970.47/41 0$######% 9= 1./ 0A91 ./ 0A91 240 896/: 9= 1./ </47 $# 4=:9= 1./6401)</4701./C46A/>3A6:=31.4C//0>4641/:09H 19B/05471873B1.901./5649=198802/7/=31F//=3=>649B9=? 1./970.47/873B1./:/8/=:4=13"./7/837/1./7/0//B013 ;/03B/900A/;/12//=1./:/8/=:4=13"4=::/8/=:4=13$ 4=: :/8/=:4=1 3" .40 A0/: 1./ 5649=19880 13 64A=>. 4 50/A:3 ;4116/4=:5A669=?1./0179=?0873B;/.9=: "! ./ 5649=19880 4=: :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " .496 873B 371. 4=474 =32 47247 :90179>1 2./7/ /C/= 1./ 069?.1/01 - 51 - >4A0/384>193=83746919?4193=9083A?.1;911/76<A5131./.9?./01 3A71/C/=98./370./90.4=?9=?3=131./6401017423A710 >4==31564<9=131./.4=:0380A>.A=F=32=A=0//=79=?B401/70 2.31375/:31./0>/=/13>3C/7A5.90./7174>F04=:57/0/=14 0//B9=?6<9==3>/=1>40/ "' 1 90 /C9:/=1 873B 1./ /C9:/=>/ 38 % /H174>1/: 4;3C/4=:1./27911/=0141/B/=1896/:;<1./:/8/=:4=13"40 2/6640./0A553719=?1./>40/381./5649=198809=.90:/5309193= 1.411./5649=1988047/57355/:A5;<1./:/8/=:4=13" 1B4< ;/ 1.41 :/8/=:4=1 3" 90 :90?7A=16/: 3C/7 =31 ?9C9=? /88/>1 13 1./ >3B573B90/ 4779C/: 41 40 5/7 H ) 4=: 9= 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3$ 0/119=? A5 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3( 13 896/ 4=31./7 0A91 9= 3&$#:905A19=?1./>649B384B4F790.=4/?:/4=: 4C91.79 /?:/ 9= <3" 38 3:64?4::/ ./:/8/=:4=1 3$ >649B/:9=.90/C9:/=>/1.411./:/8/=:4=13".4:/=>734>./: 9=13 03B/ 837/01 64=: 4:@39=9=? 1./ 64=: 9= <3$ 38 3:64?4::/C9664?/ 1>4==31;/7A6/:3A11.411.90>3A6:4603;/ 4 >4A0/ 837 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3" 13 0/1 A5 1./ 5649=19880 % 4:B911/:1.41:905A1/0;/12//=1./:/8/=:4=130$4=:"4730/ 9=1./</47$#$4=:1.411./5649=198800133:9=0A55371381./ - 52 - :/8/=:4=1 3" ./ :/8/=:4=1 =3" 896/: 4 27911/= 0141/B/=1 4:B9119=? 1./ >40/ 38 1./ 5649=19880 4=: >3=>/:/: 1.41 1./ 5649=19880 .4C/ 4 0.47/ 3=/ 38 1./B .4C/ :90>630/: 2.41 240 1./7/46900A/;/12//=1./54719/0 ") A793A06< 1./ 5649=1988 3$ ;/9=? 4= 411/019=? 291=/00 13 1./ 966 :41/: #"#)) H ' 837 7/403=0 A=F=32=:9:=31/=1/71./291=/00;3H1.3A?.0./24057/0/=1 9=1./3A71411./19B/387/>37:9=?1.//C9:/=>/38 % (# ./47?AB/=1381./6/47=/: /=9373A=0/68371./ 5649=198801.411./:/>7//9= 3"'))(909=1./=41A7/384 57/69B9=47<:/>7//4=::3/0=31488/>11./79?.10381./5649=19880 A=:/7 />193=381./9=:A A>>/0093=B/=:B/=1>1$##& 90 1.3A?. 41 89701 ;6A0. 455/470 2371.< 38 4>>/514=>/ 91 90 =/>/0047<13C90A469L/1./091A4193=9=1./84B96</C/=;/837/1./ 9=:A A>>/0093= B/=:B/=1 >1 $##& >4B/ 9=13 837>/ 0 0141/: 4;3C/ 1./ :905A1/ ;/12//= 1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " 2409=7/05/>138 <30$"(383:64?4::/2.9>.240 7/036C/:;<H )4=:466381./B2/7//H5/>1/:13>3%35/741/ 837 ;79=?9=? 4;3A1 >377/053=:9=? 7/C/=A/ /=179/0 9= 7/05/>1 38 1./970.47/0 1901.A0>7<0146>6/471.411./:/8/=:4=130$4=: - 53 - " 2/7/ 9= 7/05/>19C/ 5300/0093= 38 1./97 K 0.47/ 9= 1./ 0A91 5735/719/0 40 5/7 1./ :/>7// 9= 3"'))( 3=0/GA/=16< 40 79?.16< >3=1/=:/: ;< 1./ 6/47=/: >3A=0/6 837 1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$4=:(1./7/240=3=//:837489=46:/>7//4054719/02/7/ 467/4:<9=5300/0093=381./977/05/>19C/0.47/0 ( ./ >3=1/=193= 38 1./ 6/47=/: >3A=0/6 837 1./ 5649=198801.411./:/8/=:4=102/7/;3A=:13.36:1./5735/719/0 @39=16<405/71./:/>7//5400/:9= 3"'))(A=1961./698/ 19B/ 38 4B4F790.=4 /?:/ 4=: 1.41 1./7/837/ 1./7/ 240 =3 54719193= 90 ;A01/: ;< 1./ 84>1 1.41 1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " .4:481/71./:/>7//9= 3"'))(461/7/:1./975309193=4=: B4:/3C/7$#?A=140134B4F790.=4/?:/9= <3"4=:$# ?A=1409= <3"13 B1 4C91.79/?:/2.9>.B/4=11.411./ 54719/02/7/9=7/05/>19C/5300/0093=381./97K0.47/ ($ 4C9=? ./6: 40 4;3C/ 1./ >3=0/GA/=>/ 23A6: ;/ 1.411./5649=1988023A6:=31;//=1916/:134=<0.47/9=1./0A91 5735/719/09=C9/238573C90313 />193=381./9=:A A>>/0093= B/=:B/=1 >1 $##& 2.9>. B4=:41/0 1.41 1./ :4A?.1/70 23A6:=31;//=1916/:1340.47/9=>3547>/=47<5735/71<989190 /91./7 469/=41/: 37 54719193=/: ;/837/ $#$$##( ./ 3=-;6/ - 54 - 5/H3A719=+ " * ! ! .407/4::32=1./H564=4193=13 />193=38 1./ >1 $##& 13 9=>6A:/ A=:/7 05/>946 >97>AB014=>/0 4= 3746 54719193= 2.9>. >4= ;/ :/B3=01741/: ;< 7/6/C4=1 7/C/=A/ :3>AB/=109=1./8366329=?237:0 C =A " #A A # " " 4 " * * A # # A " " A $ A " A A $ A A # ($" 7 $A '45 : 3* , A +$# 3 +A '45 :: * ; 2 ;DD - 0 B # # # - 55 - A A B # # # # # A # " ) $ $E @ $ # * (" ./7/837/ 1./ 0/>3=: 4=: 1.97: 539=10 837 >3=09:/74193=47/4=02/7/:4?49=011./5649=198804=:9=84C3A738 1./ :/8/=:4=1 3$ 4=: 91 90 ./6: 1.41 1./ 5649=19880 47/ =31 /=1916/:83740.47/9=1./0A915735/719/0./79463A719=01/4: 38 09819=? 1./ /C9:/=>/ 3= 7/>37: 13 40>/7149= 1./ 84>10 38 1./ >40/573>//:/:3=1./57/B90/1.41=389=46:/>7//240:742= 4=:1./7/837/1./84B96<4=:1./5735/719/0>3=19=A/:13;/@39=1 4=:1.411./7/837/1./5649=198802/7//=1916/:1340.47/ 14603 >3BB911/: 4= /7737 9= .36:9=? 1.41 1./ >3B573B90/ 9= 3"'))( 240 >366A09C/ /C/= 1.3A?. 1./ 57353091A0 4=: .90 298/ 2/7/ 469C/ 1966 #$$#$ 4=: .90 298/ 240 469C/ 1966 $$#' 7/05/>19C/6< 4=: 1./< :9: =31 >.466/=?/ 1./ 049: :/>7// 0 4 B411/7 38 84>1 1./ 5649=19880 ;/9=? :4A?.1/70 B4779/:57937131./</47)!)2/7/=31/C/==/>/0047<54719/0 13 1./ 0A91 9= 3"'))( ./ >3B573B90/ 9= - 56 - 3&$#BA01.4C/;//=1/01/:3=1./4=C9638H ) 2.9>.1./179463A71:9:=31 (( 07/?47:01./83A71.539=1837>3=09:/74193=4;47/ 5/7A046387:/7* A6/$!381./0.3201.414::9193=46 /C9:/=>/ 41 1./ 455/6641/ 014?/ >4= ;/ 46632/: A=:/7 1.7// >97>AB014=>/0 9 ./= 1./ 7946 3A71 .40 7/8A0/: 13 4:B91 1./ /C9:/=>/ 99 ./= :/0591/ /H/7>90/ 38 :A/ :969?/=>/ 0A>. /C9:/=>/240=31291.9=.90F=326/:?/37/C/=481/7 /H/7>90/ 38 :A/ :969?/=>/ ./ >3A6: =31 573:A>/ 1./B 999./ 455/6641/ 3A71 =//:0 1./ :3>AB/=10 13 573=3A=>/ @A:?B/=1 37 837 4=< 31./7 0A;014=1946 >4A0/ (& ./3=-;6/5/H3A719=@,65" *$-. 9(2.96/>3=09:/79=? 1./0>35/383A1387:/7* A6/$!381././6:408366320 F; 4 $ - 57 - " 8 <"A ) A % 5 ; *3* # 8 ) 4 # " 5 ) A $A <"A A " $ # # # $ # " # A # " = A " % 5 ; *3* # # A " B # $ # 8 2 ' # # * ' ' * ' ## *A # A A " $ $ A # " B $ - 58 - # # $ # 4 # 5 ! A 7 11 00 ) 5 ! /0 1 5) @5 0! / 7 5 * ) ! 0 " ) ! 5 / 5) E @ $ G = # * ( 91.1./4;3C/9=B9=:982/5/7A0/1./>649B381./ 5649=19880 1./ 0A91 3= .4=: 90 896/: 837 54719193= 4=: 0/54741/ 5300/0093=389BB3C4;6/4=:B3C4;6/5735/719/09=>6A:9=??36: 37=4B/=10./79463A71:/>7//:1./0A91=313=6<9=7/05/>1 389BB3C4;6/5735/719/0;A146031./B3C4;6/0 1907/6/C4=113 =31/1.411./5649=19880:9:=31573:A>/4=<374637:3>AB/=147< /C9:/=>/7/?47:9=?1.//H901/=>/381./B3C4;6/5735/719/0./ :/8/=:4=13$4=:(>649B/:9=1./9727911/=0141/B/=11.411./ B3C4;6/5735/719/047/=319=/H901/=>/./79463A719=01/4: 38564>9=?1./;A7:/=38573C9=?1.//H901/=>/381./--0>./:A6/ 5735/719/03=1./5649=19880564>/:1./;A7:/=38573C9=?1./900A/ 3=:/8/=:4=13(;<874B9=?1./8366329=?900A/ - 59 - I % C*F ) # F (! ./5649=19880 B47F/: H"2.9>. 90 1./ 5649=1 9= 3&$# 2.9>. 0.32/: 1.41 :/8/=:4=1 3( .4: 4:B911/: 1./ B3C4;6/0 ;/63=?9=? 13 1./ @39=1 84B96< ./ >3B573B90/ :/>7// 9= 3&$# 0.32/: 1.41 1./ B3C4;6/02/7/460354719193=/:;/12//=:/8/=:4=130$"4=: ( ./7/837/ 1./ /H901/=>/ 38 B3C4;6/0 240 573C/: ;< 1./ 5649=19880 (' 32/C/73=/84>11.41.405/756/H/:1./B9=:381./ 3A71 90 40 13 .32 1./ 5649=19880 .4C/ :/0>79;/: 1./ 2/9?.1 38 /4>.?36:37=4B/=1/C/=1.3A?.1./<2/7/466B4779/:5793713 1./ </47 )!) +A71./7 1./ 54719>A6470 38 ?36: 37=4B/=10 240 =31 B/=193=/: 9= 3&$# ;A1 3=6< 1./ C46A/ 240 B/=193=/:400&#####% 1455/4701.411./:/14960381./ 37=4B/=10 4=: 1./ 7/05/>19C/ 2/9?.10 47/ B/=193=/: 9= 1./ 4::9193=46:3>AB/=101.4147/03A?.113;/573:A>/:463=?291. 3$#$&./7/9047/>91469=1./0/:3>AB/=101.41>359/0 381./:3>AB/=102/7/8A7=90./:131./5649=19880./7/837/2/ - 60 - 47/381./C9/21.411./5649=19880.4::/0>79;/:1./C46A/4=: 1./ 2/9?.1 38 /4>. 38 1./0/ ?36: 37=4B/=10 ;40/: 3= 1./ 4::9193=46 :3>AB/=147< /C9:/=>/ 2.9>. 47/ 03A?.1 13 ;/ 573:A>/:;<1./:/8/=:4=13$A=:/7 3$#$& () ./ :3>AB/=10 896/: ;< :/8/=:4=1 3$ 463=? 291. 1./45569>4193=A=:/77:/7* A6/ $!381./0.3201.41 03B/ A=:/7014=:9=? 240 4779C/: 41 ;/12//= :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=:"9=1./57/0/=>/385649=19883$4=:./7.A0;4=:7/6419=? 131./:9C9093=3864=:;/12//=:/8/=:4=130$4=:"9=0A7C/< 30 $ " ( 38 3:64?4::/ 9664?/ 4=: 03B/ B3C4;6/0 .90 A=:/7014=:9=? 90 5A75371/:6< 7/:A>/: 9=13 27919=? 4=: 90 09?=/:;<5649=19883$4=:./7.A0;4=:2.3240/H4B9=/:40 % 1907/6/C4=113=31/1.41 1./.A0;4=:385649=19883$ %;/9=?4=4:C3>41/564</:459C3146736/9=4009019=?1./ 84B96<9=6919?4193=4=:46039=036C9=?1./573;6/B09=1./84B96< +366329=?1./4;3C/A=:/7014=:9=?1./57353091A04B4F790.=4 /?:/ 4C91.79 /?:/ :/8/=:4=1 3$ 4=: :/8/=:4=1 3" 5649=19883$4=: %/=1/7/:9=134=31./7A=:/7014=:9=?3= #$##7/?47:9=?1./B4==/738:9C9093=38B3C4;6/041/7 1./ 5649=19880 :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " /=1/7/: 9=13 4=31./7 - 61 - A=:/7014=:9=? 3= "#!$#" 7/?47:9=? 1./ 45537193=B/=1 38 1./ B3C4;6/0 1 455/470 1.41 1./ A=:/7014=:9=? :41/: "#!$#" 90 09?=/: ;< 466 1./ 5649=19880 4=: :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=:"./7/837/1./0/:3>AB/=1047/09?=/:;<4661./5649=19880 4=: :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " ./7/837/ 1./0/ :3>AB/=10 2/7/ 7/6/C4=1 837 1./ 5A7530/ 38 >3=09:/79=? 2./1./7 1./ 5649=19880 2/7//=1916/:1340.47/9=1./B3C4;6/5735/719/0 &# 326/1A0/H4B9=/2./1./71./:/8/=:4=13$.40 0419089/: 1./ 17956/ 1/01 837 573:A>9=? 1./0/ 4::9193=46 :3>AB/=147< /C9:/=>/ 41 1./ 455/6641/ 014?/ =:905A1/:6< 1./0/ :3>AB/=10 2/7/ =/91./7 573:A>/: ;/837/ 1./ 7946 3A71 =37 2/7/ 1./< :9046632/: ;< 1./ 7946 3A71 0 7/?47:0 1./ /H/7>90/ 38 :A/ :969?/=>/ 91 90 0141/: 9= 1./ 4889:4C91 4>>3B54=<9=? 1./ 45569>4193= 1.41 I4 # " # J 4=: I4 " " 4 J4=:I $ # # # J./4;3C/7/403=047/C4?A/4=::3=31B//11./ - 62 - >791/794 1.41 :/0591/ /H/7>90/ 38 :A/ :969?/=>/ 1./ :3>AB/=10 >3A6:=31;/0/>A7/:4=:573:A>/:./:/8/=:4=13$3A?.113 .4C//H5649=/:9=:/1496.324=:2./=./>4B/9=5300/0093=38 1./0/:3>AB/=10./7/837/./.408496/:9=1./0/>3=:1/01 = 03847401./6401691BA01/0145/7A046381./:3>AB/=100.32 1.41 03B/ A=:/7014=:9=? 240 /=1/7/: 9=13 ;/12//= 1./ 54719/0 4;3A1 1./ B4==/7 38 :9C9093= 38 1./ B3C4;6/0 4=: 9BB3C4;6/ 5735/719/0 ./7/837/ 0A;@/>1 13 4:B9009;9691< 4=: 7/6/C4=>/ 1./<2/7/C/7<BA>.=/>/0047<8371./5A7530/38:/1/7B9=9=? 1.//=1916/B/=1381./5649=198809=1./B3C4;6/5735/719/04=:9= 37:/7 13 /014;690. 1./97 736/ 9= 1./ 7/036A193= 38 1./ :905A1/ ;/12//= 1./ :/8/=:4=1 30$ 4=: " ./7/837/ 2/ 47/ 38 1./ C9/2 1.41 1./0/ :3>AB/=10 2/7/ =/>/0047< 837 1./ 5A7530/ 38 >3=09:/79=? 1./ >40/ 38 1./ 5649=19880 9= 03 847 40 B3C4;6/ 4=: 9BB3C4;6/5735/719/047/>3=>/7=/:.3A?.2/.4C/./6:1.41 3$#$&0.3A6:;/46632/:9=C9/2381./4=02/7013539=1 30$4=:"=3A0/8A65A7530/23A6:;/0/7C/:9=:97/>19=? 4::9193=46/C9:/=>/13;/14F/=3=7/>37: & 0 7/?47:0 1./ 4::9193=46 :3>AB/=147< /C9:/=>/ 573:A>/:;<1./:/8/=:4=13(1./<47/4667/C/=A/:3>AB/=10 - 63 - 4=:9=C9/2383A789=:9=?03=539=1994=:9991./<47/=31 =/>/0047<8371./5A7530/38>3=09:/79=?1./>40/381./54719/0 &$ = C9/2 38 1./ 4;3C/ / 573>//: 13 5400 1./ 8366329=?37:/7 9 ./0/455/46047/00 7 99 ./ 9B5A?=/: @A:?B/=1 4=: :/>7// :41/: "##)$#$$ 5400/: ;< 1./ /=937 9C96 A:?/ /6645A7 9= 3$$# 90 0/1 409:/ 4=: 1./ 0A91 896/: ;< 1./ 5649=19880 9= 3$$# 90 :90B900/: 999 ./54719/013;/471./9732=>3010 ,' &%( % ,' &%( % 9013) 63

MANOHAR RAMAKRISHNA HEGDE v. SMT. K SAROJINI W/O K RAMASWAMY

Judgment text