Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 49802 (KAR)
BHAGWAN v. SANTOSH AND ANR
MFA/200705/2023 · 2025-10-27
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49802 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49802 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
# $ %
%%
&'( )* %% ! &'(
)
*
! "
#
$
% $ & $
%
"
'(
% &
$
)%(
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%
*&'(
! +
, #
%('!#
#
)%
+
# +
$
)% +
!)
*
$ % $ &
$
%
"
'(
! +
#
% &
$
)%( %
"
'(
- 3 -
!"
, % ' %$#
%('!#
+
$
+
)%
+
"
+ $
-
- . +
$
/01234/01567/839:;<:349=2/9
4/9/3>:0??/0@901/;=@/2050=89334/0>012:;34/ 1=<680@=8 :)%203/2?099/2<A34/ :613 :; 34/ /8=:1 =B=@ +625/ 082 22=3=:80@ 090B0C0@A080!;:194:13D34/1=<680@E#
)
' 551=/B/2 <A 34/ 90=2 :12/1 34/ 896108F/ :7?08A?1/;/11/234=90??/0@08270=8@AF:83/82/2340334/ B/4=F@/ >09 8:3 =8B:@B/2 =8 34/ 0FF=2/83 3 >09 ;0@9/@A =7?@=F03/2 4/ :>8/1 0@@:>/2 34/ B/4=F@/ 3: </ 21=B/8 <A 0 ?/19:8 >4: =9 8:3 4:@2=85 B0@=2 21=B=85 @=F/89/ 082 =3 =9 =8 B=:@03=:8 :; 34/ ?1:B=9=:89 :; 34/
F3 082 3/179 :; 34/
- 4 -
?:@=FA996F434/896108F/:7?08A=98:3@=0<@/3:?0A34/ F:7?/8903=:8
: /A/ >=38/99 >09 /G07=8/2
4/ :7?@0=8083>09@:25/2<A34/>=;/:;34/=8H61/208234:654 34/A 40B/ 8:3 ?1:26F/2 08A 31/037/83 1/F:12 34/ 1=<680@ 51083/27/2=F0@/G?/89/9082;6361/7/2=F0@/G?/89/9>=34:63 08A<09=94/1/;:1/1/I6/93/2;:10@3/103=:8
!+)
& 4=90??/0@=9;=@/2<A34/F@0=7083;:1/8408F/7/83 050=89334/0<:B/90=20>012=8>4=F4=3=9F:83/82/234034/ 96930=8/2 51=/B:69 =8H61=/9 082 0@9: /G07=8/2 $ 2:F3:1 082 4/ 099/99/2 34/ 2=90<=@=3A 09 &&J 63 34/ 1=<680@ 409 30C/8 :8@A &(J 4/ 07:6839 51083/2 682/1 :34/1 4/029 01/0@9::834/@:>/19=2/0828:07:683>0951083/2;:1@:99 :; 07/8=3=/9 082 @:99 :; =8F:7/ 261=85 @0=2 6?
?/1=:2 4/1/;:1/1/I6/93/2;:1/8408F/7/83
4/F@0=7083=8 :(%'409/G07=8/2 $0824/=996/27/2=F0@2=90<=@=3AF/13=;=F03/=8>4=F4=3>09 9303/23403K34/1/>/1/L9:;?01=/30@<:8//G3/82=853:
9I607:69 3/7?:10@ <:8/ 082 51/03/1 >=82 :; 9?4/8:=2 082 1::;:;:1<=3082/G3102610@4/703:70>=347=2@=8/94=;3/
- 5 -
682/1>/83 2/F:7?1/99=B/ F108=:3:7A =9 9F08 :;
F/1B=F0@ 9?=8/ >09 2:8/ 082 ;:682 3: </ $ / >09 930<=@=M/2 082 2=9F4015/2 :8 N'(O 082 082 ;=80@@A 34/ 2:F3:1099/99/234/2=90<=@=3A09&&J3:34//83=1/<:2A4/ 1=<680@ 409 1=543@A F:89=2/1/2 %'12 :; 34/ 2=90<=@=3A 082 34=9 :613;=8298:1/09:893:=83/1;/1/>=3434/2=90<=@=3A099/99/2 <A34/1=<680@/3=3=:8/14099303/234034/>:1C/2=8
69F03 ;:1@093A/019082/018=859&)%?/17:834<634/409 8:3 ;=@/2 08A =8F:7/ ?1::; / 7/3 >=34 08 0FF=2/83 :8 N( 4/8F/ 09 ?/1 34/ 56=2/@=8/9 :; 34/ 018030C0 303/ /50@ /1B=F/9 634:1=3A 4=9 8:3=:80@ =8F:7/ =9 3: </ 30C/8 09 9% / >09 05/2 '& A/019 4/8F/ 34/ 76@3=?@=/1=93:</30C/809D)EFF:12=85@A34/@:99:;;6361/ =8F:7/F:7/93: GG)GJPN% ) 4/ 1=<680@ 51083/2 9% 3:>0129 7/2=F0@/G?/89/909?/134/<=@@9;=@/2<A4=70820@9:51083/2 9%;:1;6361/7/2=F0@/G?/89/908234=9:613;=829 8:1/09:83:=83/1;/1/>=3434/90=2:12/1G&=934/>:682 F/13=;=F03/ 082 4/ >09 4:9?=30@=M/2 ;:1 & 20A9 09 ?/1 G
- 6 -
2=9F4015/ F012 082 4/ 0@9: ;=@/2 GN * 2=90<=@=3A F/13=;=F03/ 4/1/;:1/34=9:613;=829=31/09:80<@/3:510830807:683:; 9% ;:1 ?0=8 082 96;;/1=85 9'% ;:1 @:99 :; 07/8=3=/9 ( /7=5438:340B/033/82/208A:34/1>:1C03@/093 ;:1 0 ?/1=:2 :; & 7:8349 26/ 3: 34/ =8H61A 96930=8/2 =8 34/ 0FF=2/83 34/1/;:1/ 9& !G&# ;:1 @:99 :; =8F:7/ 261=85 @0=2 6? ?/1=:2 082 0@9: /83=3@/2 ;:1 9% ;:1 31089?:1303=:8/G3108:61=947/83082033/82083F4015/9
4/ =896108F/ F:7?08A =8 :N% 34:654=3=99303/23403=3=98:3@=0<@/3:?0A34/F:7?/8903=:8 34/90=2=996/>092/0@3<A34/1=<680@=82/30=@082;093/8/2 34/ @=0<=@=3A :8 34/ =896108F/ F:7?08A 4=9 F:613 ;=829 8: 1/09:83:=83/1;/1/>=3434/90=2:12/1 N 80@@34/3:30@F:7?/8903=:8F:7/93:)% >=34 =83/1/93 03 34/ 103/ :; )J ?/1 08867 ;1:7 34/ 203/ :; ?/3=3=:83=@@1/0@=M03=:8
4/07:6830>012/2<A34/1=<680@=97:2=;=/209 682/1-
- 7 -
,-./ 012342/ :99:;;6361/=8F:7/ N% 0=808296;;/1=85 % ':99:;07/8=3=/9 '% &
/2=F0@ /G?/89/9 082 ;6361/ 7/2=F0@/G?/89/9 (% 1089?:1303=:8 /G310 8:61=947/83 082033/82083F4015/9 %
):99:;/018=85261=8534/@0=26? ?/1=:2;:1)7:8349 &% 3-5
)
FF:12=85@A 34/ 0??/@@083 =9 /83=3@/2 ;:1 0 3:30@ F:7?/8903=:8 :; /
) 09 050=893 9&&% 4/ F@0=7083 =9 /83=3@/2 ;:1 08 /8408F/2 F:7?/8903=:8 :; /! )
834/1/96@334/;:@@:>=85:12/1=9?099/2- =# 4/ 0??/0@ =8
:N% =9
082 34/ 0??/0@ =8
:(%'=9 ==# /9?:82/83 896108F/ F:7?08A 409 0@1/02A 2/?:9=3/2J:;34/0>012/207:683<A34/ 1=<680@ 34/1/;:1/ 34/A 01/ 2=1/F3/2 3:
- 8 -
2/?:9=334/<0@08F/07:683>=34=83/1/930334/ 103/:;)J>=34=8:8/7:834;1:734/203/:; 34=9:12/1 ===# 896F42/?:9=334/0??/@@083%F@0=7083=8
:(%' =9 ?/17=33/2 3: >=34210> 34/ 07:6830@:85>=34=83/1/930FF16/2:8=3 =B# 4/ 07:683 0@1/02A 2/?:9=3/2 </;:1/ 34=9 :613=93:</31089;/11/23:
/.) &% ( $
=93 :-@ :-& -+