- 1 - ! "#$## # % %&'( %'' ) ! "# $ % " " &'&% ( ) "" &'&%( ! $ Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " '( " ! $ &(' ! )$ ) * +(( %+'((% " " "" & , " " ) " (( " " " " ) - ! - $ ./0123456/72/3434564894:/7;<100=8/75%>.5 48 3./ 5>6/? 59 3./ 05:7 835?1@/ 61A/:< B1C 5:7 35?1@/D 843=13/7 13 :53 5(, 167 (' 167=? /81?131@4 %83 .18/ 67=83?41: ?/1 .1.1;17 517 1:1;=?1@48//E46@F=18.46@593./2?50//746@82/6746@46 5+((1?4846@5=359?4A/5%+'((%95?3./ 599/60/8 2=648.1;:/ =67/? /034568 & 167 , 59 3./ - 3 - 1?6131E1 ?/G/63456 59 :1=@.3/? 167 ?/8/?G13456 59 133:/03((!95?8.5?3B3./03((D$ ( ./ @483 59 3./ 2?58/0=3456 018/ 48 3.13 3./ 8/0567 ?/82567/6305A2:146163 =256 ?/0/4G46@ 0?/74;:/ 4695?A13456 56 (((% 13 1;5=3 1A 3.13 1C 5:7 35?1@/ 843=13/7 >43.46 3./ C=?487403456 59 3./ ?/82567/6325:40/13167=?67=83?41:?/1>18/6@1@/7 468:1=@.3/?46@167835?46@0133:/A/13460563?1G/6345659 3./2?5G484568593./03((:57@/7105A2:1463 18/7 56 3./ 8147 05A2:1463 1 018/ >18 ?/@483/?/7 167 46G/834@13456 >18 31E/6 =2 256 05A2:/3456 59 3./ 46G/834@13456 3./ 6G/834@1346@ 9940/? 94:/7 3./ 0.1?@/ 8.//31@146833./100=8/72/?8568 ./2?/8/632/3434564894:/7;<3./5>6/?593./ 814705:7835?1@/>.5.18;//61??1</718100=8/75% ./ 2?460421: @?4/G160/ 59 3./ 2/343456/? 48 3.13 7/8243/ 9=?648.46@1052<593.//1G/16740/68/@?//A/6335 3./6G/834@1346@9940/?7=?46@3./05=?8/5946G/834@13456 3./0.1?@/8.//3.18;//6/??56/5=8:<:1471@14683.4A3 - 4 - 480563/67/72:1046@?/:4160/563./81471@?//A/633.13 56/=94C=:51E1?>1846:1>9=:2588/88456 1670563?5:593./05:7835?1@/=67/?1/1G/16740/68/ @?//A/63 /H/0=3/7 ;/3>//6 3./ 2/343456/? 167 3./ 8147 :40/68// 56 %(%(( 8 2/? 3./ 3/?A8 59 3./ 8147 1@?//A/633./05:7835?1@/2?/A48/8>18;/46@52/?13/7 167A161@/7/H0:=84G/:<;<3./:40/68// ./2/343456/?9=?3./?0563/6783.137=?46@3./ 4682/03456 0567=03/7 ;< 3./ 1=3.5?434/8 43 >18 3./ 8147 =94C=:>.5>1895=672?/8/63167460.1?@/593./ 52/?134568 13 3./ 05:7 835?1@/ 5>/G/? 85:/:< 56 3./ 2?/A48/3.133./2/343456/?483./5>6/?593./2?/A48/8 3./ 6G/834@1346@ 9940/? >43.5=3 17G/?346@ 35 5? 122?/041346@ 3./ 3/?A8 59 3./ /1G/ 167 40/68/ @?//A/63 .18 2?50//7/7 35 ?/@483/? 3./ 0?4A/ 167 8=;8/F=/63:< 94:/7 1 0.1?@/8.//3 1@14683 3./ 2/343456/? 95?3./599/60/82=648.1;:/=67/?/034568&167,593./ 03(( - 5 - & .48 5=?3 .18 ./1?7 3./ :/1?6/7 05=68/: 122/1?46@ 95? 3./ 2/343456/? 167 3./ :/1?6/7 4@. 5=?3 5G/?6A/63 :/17/? ?/2?/8/6346@ 3./ 313/ 167 .18 01?/9=::< 2/?=8/7 3./ A13/?41:8 1G14:1;:/ 56 ?/05?7 460:=746@3./0.1?@/8.//3212/?8 + 25610:58/?/H1A4613456593./0.1?@/8.//3 A13/?41:8 46 056C=603456 >43. 3./ /1G/ 167 40/68/ @?//A/63 /H/0=3/7 ;/3>//6 3./ 2/343456/? 167 =94C=: 51E1?3.485=?348593./056847/?/7G4/> 3.13 /G/6 49 3./ 0.1?@/8.//3 1::/@134568 1?/ 100/23/7 46 3./4? /634?/3< 3./ /88/6341: 46@?/74/638 59 3./ 599/60/8 2=648.1;:/ =67/? /034568 & 167 , 59 3./ 03 (( 1?/ 653 A17/5=31@146833./2/343456/?34865346 7482=3/3.133.5=@.3./2/343456/?483./5>6/?593./05:7 835?1@/ ./ 48 1 2/?A16/63 ?/847/63 59 =A;14 >./?/18 3./ 05:7 835?1@/ 48 843=13/7 13 167=? /81?131@4 %83 .18/ 67=83?41: ?/1 .1.1;17 517 1:1;=?1@4 1G46@ ?/@1?7 35 3./8/ 04?0=A83160/8 43 ;/05A/8 6/0/881?< 35 17G/?3 35 3./ /1G/ 16740/68/ @?//A/63 - 6 - /63/?/7 4635 ;/3>//6 3./ 2/343456/? 167 3./ 8147 =94C=: 3./?/:/G1630:1=8/859>.40./:=04713/3./613=?/59 2588/88456 167 ?/825684;4:43< :1=8/8 &!1$ 35 !7$ ;/46@ @/?A16/353./0563?5G/?8<1?//H3?103/7./?/46;/:5> ! " #$"%& ' ( ) " * ! #$ " ) ! ( ! ( " ! ! #$ - 7 - ' " ( + #$ ' ( , ' ! #$ ) " " ! #$ - , 6101?/9=:?/1746@593.//H3?103/725?345659 3.//1G/16740/68/@?//A/6343;/05A/8/G47/633.13 0:1=8/8 !;$ 167 !0$ 59 21?1@?12. 5& 188=A/ 21?340=:1? 84@64940160/ 46 7/3/?A4646@ 3./ A14631461;4:43< 59 3./ 0?4A461:2?50//746@84643413/71@146833./2/343456/?=67/? 3./03((./81470:1=8/8>./6?/1746056C=603456 >43. 3./ 53./? ?/0431:8 =6A4831E1;:< 7/A5683?13/ 3.13 - 8 - 1:3.5=@.3./2/343456/?.5:781G1:47:40/68/488=/7;<3./ 05A2/3/631=3.5?434/83552/?13/105:7835?1@/9104:43<95? 3./:4A43/72=?258/591;=991:51;13354?.1G46@10121043< 59 %+ 164A1:8 2/? 71< 463/67/7 18 1 ?/67/?46@ =643 95? ;56/87/;5646@59;=991:5A/131677/8E46646@461.4 3/0. 8:1=@.3/? .5=8/ 43 >18 3./ :40/68// 61A/:< =94C=: 5 1E1? >.5 >18 /63?=83/7 >43. 167 46 103=1:0563?5:593./71<3571<19914?8593./05:7835?1@/ ' ./ ?/0431:8 46 3./ 1@?//A/63 A1E/ 43 1;=67163:< 0:/1? 3.13 3./ :40/68// >18 85:/:< ?/825684;:/ 95?/68=?46@05A2:4160/>43.1::8313=35?<5;:4@134568167 52/?134561: ?/F=4?/A/638 =67/? G1?45=8 /6103A/638 6< G45:13456 59 3./ 3/?A8 167 0567434568 59 3./ :40/68/ 5? A48=8/593./2?/A48/8>183./?/95?/133?4;=31;:/353./ :40/68// 167 653 35 3./ 2/343456/? >.5 .17 A/?/:< 2/?A433/7 3./ =8/ 59 3./ 2?/A48/8 =67/? 1 :1>9=: 0563?103=1:1??16@/A/63 - 9 - 6 3.48 ;10E7?52 3./ 6G/834@1346@ 9940/? >18 7=3<;5=67 35 17G/?3 35 167 /H1A46/ 3./ /1G/ 167 40/68/@?//A/632?45?351??14@646@3./2/343456/?1816 100=8/7 3?16@/:< 3./ "4?83 695?A13456 /25?3 438/:9 7480:58/83.13=94C=:51E1?>183./2/?856 460.1?@/593./05:7835?1@/133./?/:/G16334A/1673.13 1:: 0?/74;:/ 4695?A13456 ?/@1?746@ 438 52/?13456 167 5>6/?8.42.17;//6/:4043/79?5A.4A /8243/8=0.0?=041: A13/?41: ;/46@ 1G14:1;:/ 56 ?/05?7 3./ 6G/834@1346@ 9940/? .18 914:/7 35 0567=03 1 914? 167 3.5?5=@. 46G/834@13456167>43.5=3180/?314646@3./2/?856103=1::< ?=6646@ 3./ /831;:48.A/63 .18 0.58/6 35 2?58/0=3/ 3./ 2/343456/?85:/:<563./2?/A48/3.13./.122/6835;/3./ :1>9=:5>6/?593./05:7835?1@/ % =0.16122?510.463./5246456593.485=?3 ?/9:/038 1 213/63 656122:4013456 59 A467 167 1 7/9/034G/ 46G/834@13456 ./ 1G14:1;:/ A13/?41:8 56 ?/05?7 1?/ 8=99404/63352?50//71@14683=94C=:51E1? >.5 >18 46 2.<8401: 2588/88456 167 A161@/A/63 59 3./ - 10 - 05:7 835?1@/ 167 >.5 122/1?8 35 .1G/ G45:13/7 3./ 2?5G484568593./03((5>/G/?3./056346=1345659 0?4A461:2?50//746@81@146833./2/343456/?>.5>1865346 0563?5: 5? A161@/A/63 59 3./ 2?/A48/8 13 3./ ?/:/G163 254635934A/>5=:70568343=3/161;=8/593./2?50/8859 :1>./?/95?//G/6493.//634?/0.1?@/8.//3A13/?41:48 100/23/7 13 910/ G1:=/ 65 46@?/74/638 59 3./ 1::/@/7 599/60/8 1?/ A17/ 5=3 1@14683 3./ 2/343456/? ./ 2?50//746@83./?/95?/>1??163463/?9/?/60/=67/?/03456 '(593./57/59?4A461:?50/7=?/352?/G/631;=8/59 2?50/88167358/0=?/3.//67859C=8340/ %% "5? 3./ 95?/@546@ ?/18568 3.48 5=?3 2?50//78 3521883./95::5>46@ !4$ ./?4A461:/34345648./?/;<1::5>/7 !44$ ./ /634?/ 2?50//746@8 46 5+(( 1?4846@5=359?4A/5%+'((%5964G/?843< 5:40/ 313456 1:1;=?1@4 ?/@483/?/7 95? 3./ 599/60/8 2=648.1;:/ =67/? /034568 & 167 , 59 - 11 - 3./ 1?6131E1 ?/G/63456 59 :1=@.3/? 167 ?/8/?G1345659133:/03((1672?/8/63:< 2/6746@ ;/95?/ 3./ 5=?3 59 3./ 77434561: 4G4: =7@/ 167 " 1:1;=?1@4 468591? 18 3./< ?/:13/ 35 3./ 2/343456/? 1?/ ./?/;< F=18./7 !444$ 4;/?3<48?/8/?G/7353./05A2/3/631=3.5?434/8 35 4643413/ 122?52?413/ 2?50//746@8 5? 35 94:/ 1 9?/8. 05A2:1463 1@14683 3./ 2/?856 >.5 >18 46 2.<8401: 2588/88456 167 0563?5: 59 3./ 05:7 835?1@/ 167 >18 ?/825684;:/ 95? 3./ 1::/@/7 G45:13456859/034568&167,593./03(( 461005?7160/>43.:1> !4G$ :: 2/6746@ 463/?:50=35?< 122:40134568 49 16< 83167748258/759 *( %##' $ 4835(:5+