- 1 - ! "!# #! $ %!#!! $ %! ! !## &'( ) ! " #$% # "#" ! ! !! ! &$'() " Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #$% # "#" ! ! !! ! &$'() % " #%) # "#" ! ! !! ! &$'() * ! " #*' #+ " %" ,$-- "# # # &*%)) %. " )/)$ * - 3 - -% /'' )-))* )-") 0 # # 1 1 % # 1 234 566758 34 9387: ;< 5667885=>03=4?@5=A7 ABC65=< A5883=D 3= E?74>3B= >27 F?:DC7=> 5=: 5G5@: :5>7: )-))*3= B)-")65447:;< ::87=3B@ 3H38?:D75=: 03F5<56?@527@73=59>7@@797@@7: >B 54 I@3;?=58J B= >27 D@B?=: B9 835;383>< >B 65< ABC67=45>3B= 5>7 B9 5AA3:7=> 3=HB8H7C7=> B9 B997=:3=D H723A87 5=: :75>2 B9 ?;2542 23=D7 5@7 =B> 3= :346?>7 27 B=8< 344?7 34 G3>2 @7D5@: >B 835;383>< >B 65< ABC67=45>3B= ;< >27 3=4?@5=A7 ABC65=< B= >27 D@B?=: - 4 - >25> :@3H3=D 83A7=47 6@B:?A7: ;< >27 :@3H7@ B9 B997=:3=D H723A873495K7 AAB@:3=D8<3=4?@5=A7ABC65=<34477K3=D 9B@ 7LB=7@5>3B= B9 3>4 835;383>< 5;4B8?>78< >25= 65< 5=: @7ABH7@<B@:7@7:;<>27@3;?=58 % 75@: C>@77>3 5>38 78K?=:3 875@=7: AB?=478 9B@ =4?@5=A7 BC65=< 5=: @3 545@5F 5>2 875@=7:AB?=4789B@@746B=:7=>4=B>B% * @3 @77>3 5>38 78K?=:3 875@=7: AB?=478 9B@ =4?@5=A7 BC65=< GB?8: H727C7=>8< AB=>7=: >25> "0254;77=7L5C3=7:5=:3=2347H3:7=A7A875@8< 4>5>7: >25> >27 :@3H3=D 83A7=47 6@B:?A7: 54 >25> B9 >27 67@4B=:@3H3=D>27B997=:3=DH723A873495K75=:>27@734=B AB@@746B=:3=D@7AB@:B9453::@3H3=D83A7=473=>27@7D34>7@ C53=>53=7: ;< >27 5?>2B@3>< AB=A7@=7: > 34 9?@>27@ 4?;C3>>7: >25> >2B?D2 >27 45C7 254 ;77= 6@BH7: ;79B@7 >27 >@3;?=58 >27 >@3;?=58 95387: >B AB=43:7@ >27 45C7 5=: :3@7A>7: >B 65< >27 ABC67=45>3B= 6@3C5@38< 5=: @7ABH7@ 9@BC BG=7@ >27@759>7@ > 34 584B 4?;C3>>7: >25> >27 3=4?@5=A7 ABC65=< 34 =B> 835;87 >B 65< ABC67=45>3B= 3= - 5 - H37G B9 H3B85>3B= B9 6B83A< AB=:3>3B=4 7H7= 9B@ 65< 5=: @7ABH7@<5467@>27F?:DC7=>4@7=:7@7:;<B=J;87 67L B?@> AAB@:3=D8< 4B?D2> >B 588BG >27 566758 5=: 47> 543:7 >27 :3@7A>3B= >B 65< 5=: @7ABH7@ >27 ABC67=45>3B= 5=:7LB=7@5>7>273=4?@5=A7ABC65=<5;4B8?>78< $ 79?>3=D >27 453: 4?;C3443B= 875@=7: AB?=478 9B@ A853C5=>4 H727C7=>8< AB=>7=:4 >25> >@3;?=58 59>7@ AB=43:7@3=D >27 7=>3@7 C5>7@358 685A7: ;79B@7 3> 4B 584B >5K3=D3=>BAB=43:7@5>3B=>27=B>393A5>3B=@7D5@:3=D67@C3> 254@3D2>8<D3H7=593=:3=D>25>C7@7D@B?=:B9=B:@3H3=D 83A7=47 B@ 95K7 :@3H3=D 83A7=47 :B74 =B> D3H7 5=< @3D2> >B 3=4?@5=A7 ABC65=< >B 477K 7LB=7@5>3B= 9@BC 3>4 835;383>< 5;4B8?>78< B=J;87 67L B?@> 3= >27 A547 B9 @76B@>7:3= A875@8< 4>5>7: >25> >27 ;@75A2 B9 6B83A< AB=:3>3B= 7D :34E?58393A5>3B= B9 :@3H7@ B@ 3=H583: :@3H3=D 83A7=A7B9>27:@3H7@54AB=>53=7:3=?;047A>3B=533 B97A>3B=*/25H7>B;76@BH7:>B25H7;77=ABCC3>>7: ;< >27 3=4?@7: 9B@ 5HB3:3=D 835;383>< ;< >27 3=4?@7@ 7@7 - 6 - 5;47=A7 95K7 B@ 3=H583: :@3H3=D 83A7=A7 B@ :34E?58393A5>3B= B9 >27 :@3H7@ 9B@ :@3H3=D 5> >27 @787H5=> >3C7 5@7 =B> 3= >27C478H74:797=A745H5385;87>B>273=4?@7@5D53=4>73>27@ >27 3=4?@7: B@ >27 >23@: 65@>374 B 5HB3: 3>4 835;383>< >BG5@:43=4?@7:>273=4?@7@254>B6@BH7>25>>273=4?@7: G54D?38><B9=7D83D7=A75=:95387:>B7L7@A347@754B=5;87 A5@7 3= >27 C5>>7@ B9 9?893883=D >27 AB=:3>3B= B9 >27 6B83A< @7D5@:3=D ?47 B9 H723A874 ;< :?8< 83A7=47: :@3H7@ B@ B=7 G2BG54=B>:34E?583937:>B:@3H75>>27@787H5=>>3C7B 584B @7837: B= >27 F?:DC7=> B9 ! " # $% @76B@>7:3=!& '(G27@73=B=J;87 67LB?@>3=A875@>7@C4 254278:>25>C7@75;47=A795K7B@3=H583::@3H3=D83A7=47 5> >27 @787H5=> >3C7 =B> >27C478H74 5H5385;87 :797=A74 G3>23= >27 6@BH343B=4 B9 7A>3B= */ B9 A> 5=: 5AAB@:3=D8<4B?D2>>B:34C344>275667585=:>B@7>53=>27 B@:7@65447:;<>@3;?=58>B65<5=:@7ABH7@< ( 5H3=D275@:>27AB?=4789B@>2765@>3745=:B= 67@?458 B9 C5>7@358 B= @7AB@: 4B 584B >27 F?:DC7=>4 - 7 - 685A7: 4?6@5 B=8< 6B3=> >25> GB?8: 5@347 9B@ B?@ AB=43:7@5>3B=34# )* + " "# # " , $ " %- # , # "-#./ - ?@5=4G7@>B>2745C7343==7D5>3H79B@>27 9B88BG3=D# !! ' @BC >27 @7AB@:4 3> 34 H7@< >25> 5 83A7=47 34 6@B:?A7: B= ;72589 B9 :@3H7@ B9 B997=:3=D H723A87 27 3=4?@5=A7ABC65=<2547L5C3=7:>27540G2B 254 4>5>7: >25> >27 :@3H3=D 83A7=47 6@B:?A7: 34 =B> 5 83A7=47344?7:;<>27AB=A7@=7:5=:3>34595K7B=7 =H37GB985G853::BG=3=>27A547B94?6@554 G788 54 $ % 4?6@5 3> 34 H7@< A875@ >25> 3= 5;47=A7B95=<6@BB9>25>>273=4?@7:G3>2588K=BG87:D7 7=>@?4>7:>27H723A87>B567@4B=G2B254DB>=B83A7=47 B@ 3=H583: 83A7=47 B@ :34E?583937: >B 2B8: 83A7=47 B@ 95K7 - 8 - 83A7=47 3=4?@5=A7 ABC65=< A5==B> 74A567 3>4 835;383>< >B 65< >27 ABC67=45>3B= 27 B;47@H5>3B= B9 B=J;87 67L B?@>3=>27A547B94?6@5347L>@5A>7:;78BG9B@ 754<@797@7=A7# )0000 000 10000 10000 12 " , "# " 3 % 4 ," , - - -% "" , -3 " + " 111 , " '53 - - " # ,-% ## 6 "3,7- -% "" 4 ," , - , -% - 3 - ," - % 2 - # $ 3 - $ % # , % %" , 0" " , , , % " , "# %% , - " # # " -$ $ 4 , - - / / =65@5D@562=B'B9>273C6?D=7:B@:7@>27 @3;?=58 254 4>5>7: >25> >27@7 34 7L>7=43B= B9 67@C3> 3= H37G B9 0/ 27 @3;?=58 254 4>5>7: >25> 0 3= - 9 - 234 A@B44 7L5C3=5>3B= 254 A5>7DB@3A588< 5:C3>>7: >25> 3= H37G B9 46@75: B9 0/ 65=:7C3A DBH7@=C7=> 254 344?7: A3@A?85@ 7L>7=:3=D >27 H583:3>< B9 >27 67@C3> 9@BC 5@A20)) >B 76>0) = >2747 A3@A?C4>5=A7 >27 D@B?=:B967@C3>34584B=B>5H5385;879B@>275667885=> ) = H37G B9 >27 B;47@H5>3B=4 C5:7 ;< B=J;87 67L B?@> 3= >27 59B@7453: A5474 G7 :B =B> 93=: 5=< 3=93@C3><3=>27:3@7A>3B=344?7:;<>27@3;?=58>B65<>27 ABC67=45>3B=5=:@7ABH7@>2745C79@BC>27BG=7@B9>27 B997=:3=D H723A87 B@ >27 9B@7DB3=D @754B=4 G7 5=4G7@ >27 6B3=> 9B@ AB=43:7@5>3B= 5D53=4> 5667885=>03=4?@5=A7 ABC65=<5=:3=95HB?@B9@746B=:7=>40A853C5=>4 AAB@:3=D8<G76544>279B88BG3=D 3 6675834:34C3447: 33 7D34>@< 34 :3@7A>7: >B >@5=4C3> >27 5CB?=> 3= :76B43> 9B@>2G3>2 >B >27 AB=A7@=7:@3;?=58 - 10 - 333 585=A7 5CB?=> B9 ABC67=45>3B= 58B=D G3>23=>7@74>B@:7@7:;<@3;?=5842588;7 :76B43>7: ;< >27 5667885=>03=4?@5=A7 ABC65=< G3>23= 43L G77K4 9@BC >27 :5>7 B9 @7A736> B9 A7@>3937: AB6< B9 >234 B@:7@ ;79B@7>27AB=A7@=7:@3;?=58 3H BB@:7@54>BAB4> !*+ &#!!( % !*+ &( % 34> B#8 B#' #