Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 49720 (KAR)
THE GENERAL MANAGER, THE NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD., v. NARASAPPA @ SANNA NARASAPPA AND ANR
MFA/200497/2021 · 2025-03-17
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49720 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49720 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!! " !#
$ %"%"
""&&'( ) *+
""&&'( )
* +
! " # ! $ % &' %
(
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$% & )
*
'%( % (
! "#
'&"#
* ) &
& %
*
* +
! " # ! $
% $
- 3 -
%
(
$% &
) *
'%( % (
! "
+
#
'&"#
* ) &
&&%
*
* )
, * *
%! "
, * *
#
-./0 1-./2-0 34526-1.77-./829 :4/;<- .77-11.2;6 265/.23-4=7.2>82?4;<.77-.1642-.77-./6:4/;<- /-67420-2;6
- 4 -
-829.99/8-@-0?>;<-A509=-2;.20.B./082
4& .20 &&% 0.;-0 & ?> ;<- 1-./2-0 -284/ 8@81 *509- C .098/ ":4/ 6<4/;
D;<-/8?52.1E#;<-/-67420-2;4 265/.23-4=7.2>86 82.77-.16?-:4/-;<8645/;
& <-6<4/;7482;;<.;86/.86-0?>1-./2-034526-1 .77-./829 :4/ ;<- .77-11.2;6 86 ;<.; ;<459< ;<- 74183> 34@-/829;<-@-<831-4B2-0?>;<-/-67420-2;486.2 3;
21>4183>;<-/8?52.1-//-082:.6;-2829;<-18.?818;> 42 ;<- .77-11.2;265/.23- 4=7.2> 4@-/144F829 ;<- 18=8;64:;<-3;
21>4183>
( <- 7-;8;842-/6 82 ?4;< ;<- 3.6-6 8-
46& .20 &&% B-/- ;/.@-11829 82 . *--7 ?-./829 4 '%( :/4=.098/;4<82;.F52;.-./4;.9-/. @811.9- ;<- 0/8@-/ 4: ;<- 6.80 *--7 0/4@- ;<- 6.=- 82 . <89< 67--0 .20 2-9189-2; =.22-/ .20 8; ;5/2-0 ;5/;1- 42 ;<- /4.0 /-651;829 82 .2 .3380-2; B<-/- ;<- 7-;8;842-/6 656;.82-082A5/8-6<-/-.642:4/653<.3380-2;B.6;<.; ;<- .9/8351;5/86;6 <.0 64/9<5= <-.0 "<./@-6;-0 3/47# 42
- 5 -
;<-/4.0.20.6653<;<-*--76F800-0.20;5/2-0;5/;1- <-7-;8;842-/6656;.82-0;<-82A5/8-6
<- 31.8= 7-;8;8426 B-/- 47746-0 ?> ;<- /-67420-2; 4 342;-20829 ;<.; ;<-/- B.6 24 653< 2-9189-23- 42 ;<- 7./; 4: ;<- 0/8@-/ .20 -@-2 8: ;<-/- 86 .2>2-9189-23-;<-@-<831-B.634@-/-0?>8265/.23-.20 .6 653< ;<- 18.?818;> <.6 ;4 ?- :.6;-2-0 5742 ;<- /-67420-2;4
G <- /-67420-2; 4 82 8;6 B/8;;-2 6;.;-=-2; 342;-20-0 ;<.; ;<- 0/8@-/ 4: ;<- *--7 B.6 24; <.@829 . @.180 0/8@829 183-23- ;<- 74183> 8665-0 B.6 .2 3;
21> 4183> B<83< 080 24; 34@-/ ;<- 82=.;-6 4: ;<- *--7 ;<- 34=7-26.;842 31.8=-0 ?> ;<- 7-;8;842-/6 B.6 <89<1> -H4/?8;.2;8=.982./>.2052;-2.?1-
' <-/8?52.1:/.=-0.77/47/8.;-8665-682?4;< 3.6-6 .20 7-;8;842-/6 82 ?4;< 3.6-6 B-/- -H.=82-0 .6 )6.20&.20.
-083.1
::83-/B<4<.0.66-66-0;<- 086.?818;>B.6-H.=82-0.6) .20H6;4 B-/-
- 6 -
=./F-0 <- /-67420-2; 4 265/.23- 4=7.2> -H.=82-08;64::838.1.6).2094;=./F-0H
<- /8?52.1 .:;-/ <-./829 ?4;< 680-6 7/43--0-0;4.B./0;<-34=7-26.;8424:6 %.20 6 I% 82
4& % .20 &&% /-67-3;8@-1>?>:.6;-2829;<-18.?818;>5742;<-/-67420-2; 4 265/.23-4=7.2>-829.99/8-@-0?>;<-6.=- ;<- .77-11.2;6265/.23- 4=7.2> 86?-:4/- ;<86 45/; 82 .77-.16
I ; 86 /-1-@.2; ;4 24;- ;<.; ;<- 8=7592-0 A509=-2; 4: ;<- /8?52.1 24B<-/- 0863566-0 .?45; ;<- 342;-2;842 4: ;<- .77-11.2;6 B<83< B.6 /.86-0 82 7./.9/.7<4(4:;<-B/8;;-26;.;-=-2;<-.77-11.2; 8265/.23-34=7.2>827./.(4:8;6B/8;;-26;.;-=-2;<.6 342;-20-0.6?-14B
- 7 -
!"#$ %&'
(
)
*
)
(
)
+
<- 74183> 4: ;<- @-<831- 82@41@-0 82 ;<- .3380-2;867/4053-0.;H7-/56.14:HB4510 6<4B;<.;8;863;421>74183>.20.6653<;<-82=.;-64:
;<-@-<831-./-24;34@-/-0
?@84561>24-H;/.7/-=85= <.6 ?--2 7.80 ;4 34@-/ ;<- 7-/642.1 82A5/8-6 4: ;<- 82=.;-6<-/-:4/-8;B.68235=?-2;5742;<-;/8?52.1;4 0B-11 5742 ;<- J5-6;842 4: ;<- 34@-/.9- 4: ;<- 3; 421> 74183>4B<-/-;<-;/8?52.10863566.?45;;<-2.;5/-4: ;<-74183>.208;634@-/.9-
- 8 -
<86 45/; 82 4'( 4: 0.;-0 ( & <.6 342680-/-0 ;<- 1.B 42 ;<- 7482; -1>829 42 . .;-2. 4: 0-3868426 ;<86 45/; 3.=- ;4 ;<- 3423156842;<.;.23;421>74183>0424;34@-/;<-82=.;-6 4:;<-@-<831-)<81-34=829;4653<3423156842;<8645/; <.671.3-0/-18.23-42:4114B8290-3868426
# -B208.665/.23-4=7.2> 8=8;-06 6<..28.204;<-/6" &# &
# /8-2;.1 265/.23- 4=7.2> 8=8;-0 6 50<./F./.2 * (
&# -B208.665/.23-4=7.2> 8=8;-06
*.>..204;<-/6 * '
(# =/8; .1440.20.24;<-/6.56<.1>. -@8<.7./.204;<-/6II*&
# .;842.1 265/.23- 4=7.2> 8=8;-0 6 *59.186<4/-I* '"#
G# 8F<8.=.20.24;<-/6=;5F</.28. .204;<-/6 &((G
'# *46-"/#6<.3F4
" # '(
# /8-2;.1 265/.23- 4=7.2> 8=8;-0 6 50<.F./.2" #'(
I# 28;-0 208. 265/.23- 4=7.2> 8=8;-0 6<81.F829<" G#(((
- 9 -
# /.23< .2.9-/ -B 208. 665/.23- 4=7.2> 8=8;-06 .<.0-@.205/.29 .;81 ./2.;.F.
# .;842.1 265/.23- 4=7.2> 8=8;-0 6 /.2.> -;<8 .20 4;<-/6 I' '
2 ;<.; /-@8-B 4: ;<- =.;;-/ ;<- .77-.16 6533--0-651;.2;1>;<-18.?818;><.6;4?-:.6;-2-05742 ;<-/-67420-2;4-23-;<-:4114B829
"8# 77-.16./-.114B-0
"88# <- .77-11.2;8265/.23- 34=7.2> 86 .?641@-0 :/4= 7.>829 ;<- 34=7-26.;842 .=452;;4;<-7-;8;842-/6
"888# <-/-67420-2;4%4B2-/4:;<-@-<831- 86 18.?1- ;4 7.> ;<- 34=7-26.;842 ;4 ;<- 7-;8;842-/6.64/0-/-0?>;<-/8?52.1
"8@# -6; 4: ;<- 4/0-/ 7.66-0 ?> ;<- /8?52.1 /-=.82652.1;-/-0
- 10 -
"@# <- .=452; 0-7468;-0 ?-:4/- ;<86 45/; 86 4/0-/-0;4?-/-:520-0;4;<-.77-11.2;6
0% '%" ) %! GG