Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 49719 (KAR)
RAJEPPA S/O MANIKAPPA BAVAGI v. THE STATE
CRL.RP/200053/2020 · 2025-06-09
V Srishananda
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49719 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49719 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#!$
#$
%
&%'()*+%(( ,
! "
#
$
##
! " $
# %& ' ( ) #
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
)* ) *+ * *
#
)*+* )+ *& ** ) '
# ##
# '
,
" , $
-./0/12/23.4.5..6.78-./9-0:;294-8<;/ =>-?-=1=1;9-/.90/1.@.0./>.>.3200198-./9-01A> ;2/=;5-/9@-9=8-.0-/<;/=>-/-4?;90-9==.=-
* >- /-5141;9 ?-=1=1;9-/ 14 =>- .::24-0 B>; 42<<-/-0.9;/0-/;<:;951:=1;9<;/=>-;<<-9:-4?2914>.38- 290-/ -:=1;94 *&% .90 ( ;< .90 -:=1;9 )& ;<
:=
- 3 -
>- <.:=4 19 =>- 92=4>-88 <;/ 014?;4.8 ;< =>- /-5141;9?-=1=1;9./-.4290-/ ?;9 =>- :;@?8.19= 8;0A-0 36 /1 0 .@--/ 2@9.3.0 /.<<1: ;81:- /-A14=-/-0 . :.4- 19 /1@- ;*&* )+;9*& ** )+191=1.886<;/=>-;<<-9:-4290-/ -:=1;94*&%.90;</-.0B1=>-:=1;9)&;<
:=
( 14= ;< =>- :;@?8.19= .5-/@-9=4 B;280 /-5-.8 =>.= ;9 *& ** )+ 19 =>- @;/919A >;2/4 .4 242.8 =>- 4;9 ;< =>- :;@?8.19.9= 8-<= =>- >;@- =; /-.:> .4.5.7.86.9 ; 0/;? >1@ .= =>- 324 4=;? =>- 6;29A-/ 4;9;<=>-:;@?8.19.9= 0 2C.<./=;;7>14=B;B>--8-/ 3-./19A ;
%)%% <=-/ =>-6 8-<= <;/ 324 4=.=1;9 ;9=>-=B;B>--8-/:;@?8.19.9=B.4?/;:--019A=;B./04 >14@-:>.91:4>;? = .3;2= & .@ B>-9 >- B.4 9-./ 291;/ ;88-A- ;9
.882/ /;.0 >14 6;29A-/ 4;9 0 2C.<./ B.4 ?/;:--019A =;B./04 >14 >;24- ;9 . @;=;/:6:8- = =>.=
- 4 -
C29:=2/-.8;//63-./19A;*(D))&:.@-</;@=>- B/;9A 410- .90 0.4>-0 .A.194= =>- @;=;/:6:8- /100-9 36 >14 6;29A-/ 4;9 0 2C.<./ 4 42:> >- <-88 0;B9 .90 424=.19-0 19C2/1-4 ;9 =>- 8-A .90 =>- >-.0 @@-01.=-86 :;@?8.19.9= .90 >14 </1-90 3028 .<--E 4>1<=-0 =>-
0 2C.<./=;2@.9.3.0;5-/9@-9=;4?1=.8
+ .4-0 ;9 =>- :;@?8.19= ?;81:- /-A14=-/-0 =>- :.4-.4.<;/-4.10.90?/;:--0-0=;195-4=1A.=-=>-@.==-/ .=-/ ;9 >14 4;9 0 2C.<./ 01-0 ;9 .::;29= ;< =>- .::10-9=.8 19C2/1-4 .90 >- 01-0 19 ./@.0. ;4?1=.8 ;8.?2/=>-;<<-9:-290-/-:=1;9 (;<B.4=>24 195;7-0 36 =>- ?;81:- .90 .<=-/ =>;/;2A> 195-4=1A.=1;9 :>./A-4>--=:.@-=;3-<18-0
& >- ?/-4-9:- ;< =>- .::24-0 B.4 4-:2/-0 .90 .<=-/ 02- =/1.8 .::24-0 B.4 :;951:=-0 <;/ =>- .<;/-4.10 ;<<-9:-4 .90 >- B.4 ;/0-/-0 =; 290-/A; 41@?8- 1@?/14;9@-9= <;/ ;9- 6-./ <;/ =>- ;<<-9:- 290-/ -:=1;9 ( ;< .90 41@?8- 1@?/14;9@-9= <;/ 41F @;9=>4 <;/
- 5 -
=>-;<<-9:-290-/-:=1;9*&%;<.901@?;4-0<19-;< 4 .90 4) <;/ =>- .<;/-4.10 -F?-94-4 /-4?-:=15-86 #;/ =>- ;<<-9:- 290-/ -:=1;9 )& ;<
<19-;<4) B.41@?;4-036=>-/1.8 .A14=/.=-
-19A.AA/1-5-036=>-4.@-.::24-0<18-0.9 .??-.8 19 /1@19.8 ??-.8 ;)* ) -./9-0 20A- 19 =>-#1/4=??-88.=-;2/=.<=-/4-:2/19A=>-/-:;/04>-./0 =>- ./A2@-9=4 ;< 3;=> 410-4 .90 36 C20A@-9= 0.=-0 *+ * * 014@144-0 =>- ??-.8 ;< =>- .::24-0 .90 :;9<1/@-0=>-;/0-/;<:;951:=1;9.904-9=-9:-
% -19A<2/=>-/.AA/1-5-036=>-4.@-.::24-014 3-<;/-=>14;2/=
) /1 2/23.4.5.
.6.7 8-./9-0 :;294-8 <;/ =>-/-5141;9?-=1=1;9-//-1=-/.=19A=>-A/;29042/A-019=>- /-5141;9?-=1=1;9:;9=-90-0=>.=3;=>=>-;2/=4>.5-9;= ?/;?-/86.??/-:1.=-0=>-@.=-/1.8-510-9:-;9/-:;/0.90 B/;9A86:;951:=-0=>-.::24-0.904;2A>=<;/.88;B19A=>- /-5141;9
- 6 -
)) - B;280 .84; :;9=-90 =>.= 19 =>- -5-9= =>14 ;2/= 2?>;8019A =>- ;/0-/ ;< :;951:=1;9 =>- ;2/= @.6 :;9410-/ -9>.9:19A =>- <19- .@;29= .90 4-= .410- =>- 1@?/14;9@-9=
)*
/1 .@.0./ >.>.320019 8-./9-0 1A> ;2/= ;5-/9@-9= 8-.0-/ 42??;/=4 =>- 1@?2A9-0 C20A@-9=
) - B;280 <2/=>-/ :;9=-90 =>.= 19 =>- :.4- ;9 >.90=>-:;@?8.19.9=149;9-;=>-/=>.9=>-<.=>-/;<=>- 0-:-.4-0 B>; >.0 B1=9-44-0 =>- .::10-9= .90 .84;
9-1A>3;/ ;< =>- :;@?8.19.9= >.0 B1=9-44-0 =>- .::10-9= .90 =>-6 >.5- 4>1<=-0 =>- 19C2/-0 =; =>- 2@9.3.0 ;5-/9@-9=;4?1=.8.==>-<1/4=194=.9:-.908.=-/;9<;/ >1A>-/@-01:.8:./->-B.44>1<=-0=;./@.0.;4?1=.8 ;8.?2/ B>-/-19 =>- 19C2/-0 42::2@3-0 =; =>- 19C2/1-4 0-4?1=-3-4==/-.=@-9=
)( >-/-<;/- =>- ;/0-/ ;< :;951:=1;9 /-:;/0-0 36 3;=> =>- ;2/=4 9--04 9;= 19=-/<-/-9:- - B;280 .84;
- 7 -
:;9=-90=>.=419:-=>-.::24-00109;==/6=;=.7-4=-?4=;
4>1<= =>- 19C2/-0 =; =>- >;4?1=.8 9; @-/:6 :.9 3- 4>;B9 .90/-5141;9?-=1=1;99--04=;3-014@144-019=;=;
) .519A>-./0=>-./A2@-9=4;<3;=>410-4=>14 ;2/= ?-/24-0 =>- @.=-/1.8 ;9 /-:;/0 @-=1:28;2486 9 42:> ?-/24.8 ;< =>- @.=-/1.8 ;9 /-:;/0 =>- 19:10-9= >.4 ;::2//-0;9=>-<.=-<280.6B>1:>140-?;4-036=>-<.=>-/ ;< =>- 0-:-.4-0 .90 >14 9-1A>3;/ -=.18-0 :/;44 -F.@19.=1;9;93->.8<;<0-<-9:-0109;=8-.0.96?;41=15- @.=-/1.84=;0143-81-5-=>-;/.8=-4=1@;96;<=>-<.=>-/;< =>-0-:-.4-0
)+
;=;/:6:8- 14 0.@.A-0 .90 .<=-/ =>;/;2A> 195-4=1A.=1;9 =>- :>./A- 4>--= :.@- =; 3- <18-0 .A.194= =>-0/15-/;<=>-8;//6
)& >- :;951:=1;9 ;< =>- .::24-0 290-/ -:=1;9 )& ;< =>- := <;/=1<1-4 =>- :.4- ;< =>- ?/;4-:2=1;9 #2/=>-/=>-/-149;?/;?-/0-<-9:-=.7-936=>-.::24-0
- 8 -
19.4@2:>.4>->.40-91-0=>-.::10-9=1=4-8<.==>-=1@- ;</-:;/019A.::24-04=.=-@-9=
) 91=1.886 =>- 19C2/-0 B.4 4>1<=-0 =; =>- ;5-/9@-9=;4?1=.82@9.3.0.908.=-/;9=>-19C2/-0 B.4 =.7-9 =; ./@.0. ;4?1=.8 ;8.?2/ B>-/-19 >- 42::2@3-0=;=>-19C2/1-4
)%
0 2C.<./ 3-19A =>- 4;9 ;< =>- :;@?8.19= >.519A 8;4= >14 81<- 19 =>- /;.0 =/.<<1: .::10-9= =>- ?;81:- B-/-C24=1<1-019195;719A=>-;<<-9:-290-/-:=1;9 ( ;<.4191=1.886=>-:.4-B.4/-A14=-/-0290-/-:=1;94 *&%.90;<
* #2/=>-/ =>- ?;4= @;/=-@ /-?;/= 4?;= 47-=:> 4-1E2/- ;< =>- 8;//6 .90 =>- @;=;/:6:8- .90 /-?;/= B;280<;/=1<6=>-:.4-;<=>-?/;4-:2=1;9
*) = 14 ?-/=19-9= =; 9;=- =>.= 9;9- ;< =>- ?/;4-:2=1;9 B1=9-44-4 92/=2/-0 .96 ?/-51;24 -9@1=6 ;/
- 9 -
.91@;41=6 4; .4 =; <.84-86 1@?81:.=- =>- ?-=1=1;9-/ 19 =>- 19:10-9=
** /;B919A .88 =>-4- .4?-:=4 ;< =>- @.==-/ 9; -F?8.9.=1;9B>.=4;-5-/14<;/=>:;@19A;9/-:;/0;93->.8< ;<=>-.::24-0B1=>/-A./0=;=>-19:10-9=
* 9 .
@.==-/ ;< =>14 9.=2/- 1= 14 -F?-:=-0 </;@ =>-.::24-0=;?8.:->145-/41;9;9/-:;/0.8=-.4=.==>- =1@-;</-:;/019A=>-.::24-04=.=-@-9=<=>-.::24-014 0-813-/.=-86 <.184 =; 2=181E- 42:> ;??;/=291=6 =>- :;94-G2-9:-4198.B4>;280<;88;B
*( 1-B ;< =>14 ;2/= 19 =>14 /-A./0 14 <;/=1<1-0 36 =>-C20A@-9=;<=>-;9H38-2?/-@-;2/=19=>-:.4-;<
/-?;/=-019 90-/ 42:> :1/:2@4=.9:-4 =>- ;/0-/ ;< :;951:=1;9/-:;/0-036=>-/1.8 .A14=/.=-.90:;9<1/@-0 36 =>- #1/4= ??-88.=- ;2/= <;/ =>- ;<<-9:-4 ?2914>.38- 290-/ -:=1;94 *&% .90 ( ;< .90 -:=1;9 )& ;<
:=9--049;19=-/<-/-9:-
- 10 -
* .519A 4.10 =>24 =>- A/;2904 2/A-0;93->.8< ;<=>-/-5141;9?-=1=1;9-/=>.==>-4-9=-9:-1419.??/;?/1.=- 9--04:;9410-/.=1;936=>14;2/=
*+ 0@1==-086 =>- 19C2/-0 B.4 4>1<=-0 =; =>- >;4?1=.8.9028=1@.=-86>-42::2@3-0=;=>-19C2/1-4.90 =>-/-<;/-=>-;<<-9:-290-/-:=1;9 (;<>.43--9 195;7-0.90=>-.::24-0>.43--9:;951:=-0<;/=>-4.@-
*& 19:- =>-/- 14 ;986 ;9- 0-.=> 9; 4-?./.=- 4-9=-9:- ;<1@?/14;9@-9= :.9 3-A/.9=-0 <;/ =>- ;<<-9:- 290-/ -:=1;9 *&% ;< .4 1= @-/A-4 B1=> =>- >1A>-/ ;<<-9:-9.@-86-:=1;9 (;<
* #2/=>-/ ;9- 6-./ 41@?8- 1@?/14;9@-9= >.4 3--9 A/.9=-0 <;/ =>- ;<<-9:- 290-/ -:=1;9 ( ;< .719A9;=-;<=>-01:=2@;<=>-;9H38-2?/-@-;2/=19 =>- :.4- ;< ! /-?;/=-0 19 " "
=>14 ;2/= 14 ;< =>- :;9410-/-0;?191;9=>.==>-1@?/14;9@-9=;<;9-6-./<;/ =>- ;<<-9:- 290-/ -:=1;9 ( ;< 9--04 =; 3-
- 11 -
/-02:-0=;41F@;9=>41@?/14;9@-9=36-9>.9:19A=>-<19- .@;29=19.42@;<4)
*% ::;/019A86=>-<;88;B19A
"1$ >-?-=1=1;914.88;B-019?./=
"11$ '>18-@.19=.1919A=>-:;951:=1;9;<=>-.::24-0 <;/=>-;<<-9:-4?2914>.38-290-/-:=1;94*&% .90 (;</-.0B1=>-:=1;9)&;<=>-
:==>-4-9=-9:-;/0-/?.44-036=>-/1.8 ;2/= .90 :;9<1/@-0 36 =>- #1/4= ??-88.=- ;2/= 14 @;01<1-0 36 01/-:=19A =>- .::24-0 =;
290-/A; 41F @;9=>4 1@?/14;9@-9= <;/ =>- ;<<-9:-290-/-:=1;9 (;<
"111$ >-4-?./.=-4-9=-9:-;<1@?/14;9@-9=;/0-/-0 <;/ =>- ;<<-9:- 290-/ -:=1;9 *&% ;< 14 >-/-364-=.410-
"15$ #19-.@;29=<;/=>-;<<-9:-290-/-:=1;9 ( ;< 14 -9>.9:-0 36 .9;=>-/ 42@ ;< 4) B>1:> 14 ?.6.38- ;9 ;/ 3-<;/- ) &* *
- 12 -
"5$ 1@- 14 A/.9=-0 <;/ =>- /-5141;9 ?-=1=1;9-/ =; 42//-90-/3-<;/-=>-/1.8;2/==188) &* *
"51$ #.182/-=;?.6-9>.9:-0<19-.@;29=.4?-/=>14 ;/0-/ B;280 .2=;@.=1:.886 /-428= 19 /-4=;/.=1;9 ;< 4-9=-9:- ;< ;/0-/ ?.44-0 36 =>- /1.8 ;2/= .90:;9<1/@-036=>-#1/4=??-88.=-;2/=
"511$ <<1:- 14 01/-:=-0 =; /-=2/9 =>- /1.8 ;2/= /-:;/04 B1=> . :;?6 ;< =>14 ;/0-/ <;/=>B1=> <;/ 1442.9:-;<@;01<1-0:;951:=1;9B.//.9=
0 %$( ! 14=;)8;&%