Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 49702 (KAR)
MALLAPPA v. SHEKARAPPA
RSA/101/2006 · 2025-03-25
Anant Ramanath Hegde
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49702 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49702 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "!#! $$%#& '( $$))
(
! "
! # $ %""" Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
&
'
! &
&&
%
&
(
)
*
)+*
%&
! ),*
""&
- 3 -
)* )
*)#* #
) *
)-*
&. ! )/*
! )0*
&"
! )1*
"
( )
#)* )
*)#*2
"" #) * *
#
""#
""'""
- 4 -
)#
3
&"" '% #
#
)*
"""& # #$ # #
#
#
! ))
(
&"
! . ! . ! (
)
*
- 5 -
! 4.&
%
&
&&
! 4.&
&
&
! 4.&"
. - 6 -
! 4.&
&
! 4.&
%
! 4.&%
. ! 4.&
'
%
! 4.&"
'+
',
""
- 7 -
! 4.&"
"
! 4.&"
&
! 4.&"
'
! 4.&"
. ! 4.&"
&
! 4.&"
- 8 -
&
! 4.&"
! 4.&"
(
)
# &
%5*
#
""#
#
" ""&". # # &"")''""*""%"
#
#
! #
6
- 9 -
#! )6
*
7""" 89 +:898;< 1:7= >?0 /8@0:<0;> 18;/8;<8;+9A8>17:8;BA;->87;
09C7;/0;>9 8; >?89 +CC0+D 18D0/
7''% 17: C0:=+;0;> 8;BA;->87; 8; :09C0-> 71 C:7C0:>E ,0+:8;< E 7& +;/ -D+8=0/ 8;BA;->87; 8; :09C0->71&+-:097A>71>7>+D.+-:09<A;>+9
?0 /010;/+;> F?7 89 >?0 +CC0DD+;> 8; >?89 +CC0+D:0989>0/>?09A8>
& ?0 CD+8;>811 -D+8=9 >7 ?+@0 CA:-?+90/ >?0 C:7C0:>E A;/0: :0<89>0:0/ 9+D0 /00/ /+>0/ ""&''" ?7A<? >?0 9+8/ 9+D0 /00/ 89 8;:09C0-> 71 E 7
>?0CD+8;>811-7;>0;/0/>?+>>?09A:@0E;A=,0:89F:7;<DE =0;>87;0/8;>?09+D0/00/+9E7+;/-7;>0;/0/ >?+>>?0C:7C0:>ECA:-?+90/89E7&
?0:8+D
7A:>7;+CC:0-8+>87;71>?00@8/0;-0 ?+9-7;-DA/0/>?+>>?0CD+8;>811?+91+8D0/>709>+,D89??89
- 10 -
C79909987;7@0:>?0C:7C0:>E,0+:8;<E7&>7>?0 0G>0;>71&+-:09+;//89=8990/>?09A8>
?8D0 /89=8998;< >?0 9A8> >?0 :8+D
7A:> ?+9 :0D80/7;>?07:/0:9C+990/,E>?0+?98D/+:+9F0DD+9>?0 9989>+;> 7==89987;0:
F?0:08;
>?0 9989>+;> 7==89987;0:?+9?0D/>?+>E7F?8-?89:010::0/ >7 8; >?0 9+D0 /00/ /+>0/ ""&''" 89 8; 1+-> E 7&
% 08;< +<<:80@0/ ,E >?0 +17:0=0;>87;0/ BA/<=0;>+;//0-:00 >?0CD+8;>8118;7''%18D0/ +;+CC0+D8;7&""?0+CC0+D89+DD7F0/+;/ >?0 9A8> 89 /0-:00/ <<:80@0/ ,E >?0 +17:0=0;>87;0/ BA/<=0;>+;//0-:00 >?0/010;/+;>8;7''%89 ,017:0>?89
7A:>
. ?89
7A:> 7; ""&""% ?+9 +/=8>>0/ >?0 +CC0+D >7 -7;98/0: >?0 17DD7F8;< 9A,9>+;>8+>0 HA09>87; 71 D+F
- 11 -
' 7"".". 89 +:898;< 1:7= >?0 -7;-A::0;> 18;/8;< 8; +9A8> 17: /0-D+:+>87; +;/8;BA;->87; F?0:08;>?0/010;/+;>8;7''% 18D0/+9A8>8;
7&"" 7; >?0 18D0 71 0;87:
8@8D A/<0
8;<+9A<A:)D/77''""*?0CD+8;>8118;>?0 9+8/ 9A8> 8; 7&"" 97A<?> + /0-D+:+>87; +;/ 7F;0:9?8C8;:09C0->71E7899+=0+9A:8;<& +-:09+9C0:>?00-7:/718<?>0;>:80917:>?0E0+:'. >7 '' +;/ E7& +9 C0: >?0 -?+;<0/ 0;>:E 8; >0:=971>?07:/0:8;'3'%/+>0/"%''
" #:7=>?0-7;>0;>87;9:+890/,E,7>?C+:>809 8> 89 +CC+:0;> >?+> ,7>?
C+:>809 +:0 -D+8=8;< :8<?> +;/ C79909987;7@0:>?09+=0C:7C0:>E
; >?0 9+8/ 9A8> 8; 7&"" >?0 CD+8;>811F?789>?0+CC0DD+;>?0:08;-D+8=0/:8<?>7@0:>?0 9A8> C:7C0:>E ,+90/ 7; >?0 :0<89>0:0/ 9+D0 /00/ /+>0/
- 12 -
""&''" ?0 +CC0DD+;> -D+8=9 >?+> ?0 CA:-?+90/ >?0 C:7C0:>E 1:7= 7;0 +E+CC+ --7:/8;< >7 >?0 +CC0DD+;>
+E+CC+CA:-?+90/>?0C:7C0:>EA;/0:>?09+D0/00//+>0/
".'.9+8/>7?+@0,00;0G0-A>0/,E+;<+CC+
?0 /010;/+;> 8; >?0 9+8/ 9A8> 8;
7&"" -7;>09>0/>?09A8>/0;E8;<0G0-A>87;71 9+D0 /00/ ,E +;<+CC+ 8; 1+@7A: 71 +E+CC+ +;/ 1A:>?0:
-7;>0;/0/ >?+> >?0 +CC0DD+;> 81 +> +DD ?+9 CA:-?+90/ +;E C:7C0:>E >?0 9+8/ C:7C0:>E 8; E7 +;/ ;7> +;E C+:>71E7&
?0 :8+D
7A:> ?+9 /89=8990/ >?0 9A8> ?0 #8:9>CC0DD+>0
7A:>8;7"?+9/89=8990/>?0 +CC0+D0;-0 >?0C:090;>90-7;/+CC0+D9 & 1>0: -7;98/0:8;< >?0 9A,=89987;9 =+/0 +> >?0 ,+:
>?89 90-7;/ +CC0+D 89 +/=8>>0/ >7 -7;98/0: >?0 17DD7F8;<9A,9>+;>8+DHA09>87;71D+F
!" #$%&' (
- 13 -
8>? >?0 -7;90;> 71 D0+:;0/ -7A;90D +CC0+:8;< 17: >?0 +CC0DD+;>9 +;/ >?0 :09C7;/0;>9 ,7>? +CC0+D9 +:0 >+I0;AC17:-7;98/0:+>87;
0+:;0/-7A;90D17:>?0+CC0DD+;>9F7AD/9A,=8> >?+> >?0 +CC0DD+;>9$ 9A8> 17: /0-D+:+>87; +;/ 8;BA;->87;
F?8-? 89 + -7=C:0?0;98@0 9A8> ,+90/ 7; >?0 9+D0 /00/ /+>0/ ""&''" 89 0::7;07A9DE /89=8990/ ,E >?0 :8+D 7A:> 7; >?0 C:0=890 >?+> >?0 7:8<8;+D 9+D0 /00/ 89 ;7> C:7/A-0/ +;/ 9A8> 89 >8=0 ,+::0/ ?0 #8:9> CC0DD+>0 7A:> F8>?7A> -7;98/0:8;< >?0 @+D8/ -7;>0;>87;9 :+890/ :0D+>8;<>7>?0D8=8>+>87;+;/;7;3C:7/A->87;71>?07:8<8;+D 9+D0/00/?+9/0-8/0/>?0+CC0+D7;DE7;>?0C:0=890>?+> 7&""89/0-8/0/+<+8;9>>?0+CC0DD+;>9 +99A-? >?0+CC0DD+;>9+:0;7>0;>8>D0/>7900I:0D801-D+8=0/8;>?0 +CC0+D % 0+:;0/ -7A;90D 17: >?0 :09C7;/0;>9 7; >?0 7>?0:?+;/F7AD/-7;>0;/>?+>>?09A8>8;7''% >?7A<?0::7;07A9DE/89=8990/89:8<?>DE/0-:00/8;>0:=971 >?0 /0-:00 8; 7&"" F?0:0 >?0 :09C7;/0;>$9
- 14 -
C79909987; 89 -D0+:DE AC?0D/ +;/ +9 9A-? >?0 +CC0DD+;>9 +:0;7>0;>8>D0/>7900I+;E:0D801 . ?89
7A:> ?+9 -7;98/0:0/ >?0 -7;>0;>87;9 :+890/+>>?0,+:+;/C0:A90/>?0:0-7:/9 ' 9 -+; ,0 900; 1:7= >?0 BA/<=0;> 8; 7&"" 8>890@8/0;>>?+>>?0#8:9>CC0DD+>0
7A:> ?+9 ;7> /0-8/0/ >?0 >8>D0 71 >?0 +CC0DD+;> 8; >?0 9+8/ +CC0+D ?0 +CC0DD+;> 8; 7&"" ?+/ 18D0/ 7''%7;DE17:>?0:0D801718;BA;->87;?0
7A:> ?+9 7;DE ?0D/ >?+> >?0 CD+8;>811 8; 7''% ?+9 09>+,D89?0/ ?89 C79909987; 7@0: >?0 9A8> C:7C0:>E +;/ >?0 #8:9> CC0DD+>0
7A:> ?0D/ >?+> >?0 :8+D
7A:> 0::0/ 8; /89=8998;<>?09A8>,+90/7;>?07,90:@+>87;9=+/0,E>?0 +?98D/+:+;/>?09989>+;>
7==89987;0:?89
7A:>/709 ;7> 18;/ =A-? 1+AD> F8>?
>?0 9+8/ 7,90:@+>87;9 7F0@0:
F?+>89:0HA8:0/>7,0;7>8-0/89F?0;>?0+CC0DD+;>918D0/ >?0 #8:9> CC0+D 8; 7" >?0 CC0DD+>0
7A:> ?+9 ;7> -7;98/0:0/ >?0 18:9> CC0+D 7; =0:8>9 +;/ ?+9 C:7-00/0/>7/0-8/0>?0+CC0+D,E:0DE8;<7;>?018;/8;<9 8; 7&"" > 89 :0D0@+;> >7 =0;>87; ?0:0 >?+>
- 15 -
7"""89>?0+CC0+DC0;/8;<,017:0>?89
7A:> F?0:0>?0BA/<=0;>8;7&""89+99+8D0/
" ?A9
>?0 +/=8>>0/ 1+->A+D C798>87; 89 7" 89 ;7> /0-8/0/ F8>? :010:0;-0 >7 >?0 0@8/0;-0D0/,017:0>?0:8+D
7A:>7&"" ,08;< >?0 18:9> +CC0+D A;/0: 0->87; ' 71 >?0
7/0 71
8@8D :7-0/A:0 >?0 #8:9> CC0DD+>0
7A:> F+9 :0HA8:0/ >7 -7;98/0: >?0 0@8/0;-0 7; :0-7:/ ?0 18;/8;< 8; 7&"" -7AD/ ;7> ?+@0 ,00; >?0 ,+989 17: >?0 #8:9> CC0DD+>0
7A:> >7 ?7D/ >?+> >?0 +CC0DD+;> 8; 7&""89;7>>?07F;0:71>?09A8>C:7C0:>E?0 -D+8= 71 >?0 +CC0DD+;> F8>? :010:0;-0 >7 >?0 +DD0<0/ 9+D0 /00/+;/>?0+DD0<0/-?+;<071:0-7:/989;7>+/BA/8-+>0/ +>+DD
;/0:>?090-8:-A=9>+;-09 >?89
7A:>8971>?0 @80F>?+>>?08=CA<;0/BA/<=0;>+;//0-:008;,7>?>?0 +CC0+D9?+@0>7,090>3+98/0+;/>?0=+>>0:9?+@0>7,0 :0=8>>0/ >7 >?0 #8:9> CC0DD+>0 7A:> 17: 1:09? -7;98/0:+>87;
- 16 -
> 89 +D97 ;7>8-0/ >?+> 7&"" 89 18D0/ ,017:0 >?0 //8>87;+D 89>:8-> A/<0
+8-?A: +;/ 7" 89 18D0/ ,017:0 >?0 0-7;/ //8>87;+D 89>:8->A/<0 +8-?A:0;-0 ,7>?>?0+CC0+D9?+@0>7,0 ?0+:/>7<0>?0:+;/ +--7:/8;<DE >?0 =+>>0:9 +:0:0=8>>0/ >7 >?0 #8:9> CC0DD+>0
7A:> 17: 1:09? -7;98/0:+>87; 8; +--7:/+;-0F8>?D+F
>>?09+=0>8=0 8>89:0D0@+;>>7=0;>87;>?+> 8; 7""" >?0 :09C7;/0;> ?+/ >?0 ,0;018> 71 /0-:00 17: 8;BA;->87; 8; ?89 1+@7A: > 89 9>+>0/ >?+> 7C0:+>87; 71 >?0 /0-:00 F+9 ;7> 9>+E0/ +;/ 8> 89 +D97 1A:>?0:9>+>0/>?+>>?0C:7C0:>E:0-7:/9+971;7F9>+;/8;
>?0 ;+=0 71 :09C7;/0;> 8;971+: +9 E7& 89 -7;-0:;0/ & ;/0: >?090 -8:-A=9>+;-09 >?89
7A:> C+9909 >?017DD7F8;<
)8* 7>?>?0+CC0+D9+:0
- 17 -
)88* ?0BA/<=0;>+;//0-:00/+>0/""" 8;7&""7;>?018D071//8>87;+D 89>:8->A/<0+>+8-?A:+:090>+98/0
)888* ?0BA/<=0;>+;//0-:00/+>0/""&". 8; 7" 7; >?0 18D0 71
//8>87;+D89>:8->A/<0+>+8-?A:+:090> +98/0
)8@* 7>?
+CC0+D9 7&"" +;/ 7" +:0 :0=8>>0/ >7 >?0
7A:> 71 :8;-8C+D 89>:8-> A/<0 +> +8-?A: 17: /89C79+D8;+--7:/+;-0F8>?D+F
)@* ?0 :09C7;/0;> 8; 7""" F?7 ?+/ >?0 ,0;018> 71 /0-:00 71 8;BA;->87; 8;
?89 1+@7A:
+;/ +9 >?0 7C0:+>87; 71 >?0 /0-:00 F+9 ;7> 9>+E0/ +;/ >?0 C:7C0:>E :0-7:/9+971;7F9>+;/8;>?0;+=071>?0 9+8/ :09C7;/0;> 8; 97 1+: +9 E7&
9?+DD ?+@0 ,0;018> 71 >0=C7:+:E 8;BA;->87;
7:/0: 8; ?89 1+@7A: >8DD >?0 /89C79+D 71 >?0 +CC0+D,E>?0#8:9>CC0DD+>0
7A:>
)@8* > 89 1A:>?0: =+/0 -D0+: >?+> >?0 18;/8;<9 :0D+>8;<>7>0=C7:+:E8;BA;->87;9?7AD/;7> -7=08;>?0F+E71>?0#8:9>CC0DD+>0
7A:> /0-8/8;< >?0 +CC0+D 7; =0:8>9 +9 >?0 7,90:@+>87;9 :0D+>8;< >7 >0=C7:+:E
- 18 -
8;BA;->87; 9?7AD/ ;7> ,0 -7;9>:A0/ +9 0GC:09987; 7; >?0 =0:8>9 71 >?0 -D+8= 71 08>?0:71>?0C+:>809
)@88* DD-7;>0;>87;971>?0C+:>809+:0I0C>7C0;
)@888* 7>? +CC0+D9 ,0 ?0+:/ >7<0>?0: +;/ /0-8/0/,E+-7==7;BA/<=0;>
)8G* DD :0-7:/9 9?+DD ,0 90;> >7 >?0 #8:9> CC0DD+>0
7A:>
)G* ?0 0;>:809 8; >?0 C:7C0:>E :0-7:/9 9?+DD -7;>8;A0>8DD>?0/89C79+D71>?0-+90,017:0 >?0#8:9>CC0DD+>0
7A:>
)G8* ?0 C+:>809 9?+DD +CC0+: ,017:0 >?0 #8:9> CC0DD+>0
7A:>7;"&""F8>?7A>+;E 1A:>?0: ;7>8-0 1:7= >?0 #8:9> CC0DD+>0 7A:>
)G88* 77:/0:+9>7-79>9
*'
%! & #
89>7D7&