Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 49700 (KAR)

RAMESH SAKARAM RATHOD v. SARADAR NENEPPA DOLLI AND ANR

MFA/200299/2022 · 2025-03-26

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "# # $$%& ' () $$*%& ' ( ) !" #$"%&' % %( ) #$&&&' ( * Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( % ( ( + ( ( , & %%&%& ( #- ++%& ! *( ) $ !+ #$"%&' % %( ) #$&&&' ( * ( % - 3 - ( ( + ( ( , & %%&%& ( #- +"%& ! ( ( , . # . /01234/5/016/27896:/5;81<834:=2/: % 4/>/3=3=86/1:</=6?0??1=/@/2<A34/B90639C 8; 34/ 78C>/6:03=86 0D012/2 =6 8 +"%& ! 062 8 ++%& ! <A 34/ 5/016/2 #225 /6=81 =@=5 92?/ E #- =F0A0>910 01/ </;81/ 34=: 8913 ://G=6?/64067/C/638;34/78C>/6:03=86 4/70:/8;34/>/3=3=86/1=:340386%%& %& ! 03"&D4=5/34/AD/1/310@/5=6?=634/19=:/1//> </01=6? 8#%#!+ ;18C 40207406 38 =@010?= 4/ 21=@/1 8; 34/ //> 218@/ 34/ :0C/ =6 0 6/?5=?/63 - 4 - C066/1 062 20:4/2 38 0 107381# 10=5/1 1/:953=6? =6 077=2/63 4/ >/3=3=86/1 =6 8 +"%& ! =5=> :9;;/1/2;107391/8;34/750@=75/=634/:0=2077=2/63 4/ >/3=3=86/1=68 ++%& !#0C/:4:9;;/1/2=6F91=/: 38 4=: ;07/ >013=795015A 4/ 58:3 :8C/ 3//34 062 :9;;/1/2 :8C/507/103/2D8962:8348;34/C01/:4=;3/238 06?0 8:>=305D4/1/34/A962/1D/6331/03C/6350=C=6?3403 34/A D/1/ /016=6? :+$&&# >/1 C8634 <A 7885=/ D81G 06234/A</0?/2%'A/01:062%A/01:1/:>/73=@/5A;=5/2 0750=C>/3=3=86:</;81/34/ 1=<9605 ! 6=::9067/8;683=7/34/1/:>862/638 062 % 0>>/01/2 34189?4 34/=1 7896:/5: 062 ;=5/2 D1=33/6 :303/C/63: /:>862/63 8 2/6=/2 06A 6/?5=?/67/ 86 4=: >013 062 7863/62=6? 3403 5=0<=5=3A =; 06A 40: 38 </ ;0:3/6/2 9>86 34/ 1/:>862/63 8% 062 :89?43 ;81 2=:C=::058;>/3=3=860?0=6:34=C $ 4/ 1/:>862/63 8%#=6:91067/ 78C>06A 7863/62/2 3403 34/ 21=@/1 8; 34/ //> D0: 683 40@=6? 0 @05=2 21=@=6? 5=7/6:/ 062 34/1/;81/ 34/ 3/1C: 062 - 5 - 7862=3=86:8;34/>85=7A@=8503/20620::974=3=:6835=0<5/ 38 >0A 34/ 78C>/6:03=86 834 34/ 1/:>862/63: 3/1C/2 34/ 78C>/6:03=86 750=C/2 0: 4=?45A /H81<=3063 062 =C0?=601A " 4/ 1=<9605;10C/20>>18>1=03/=::9/:=6<834 34/:/>/3=3=86:06234/>/3=3=86/1:D/1//H0C=6/20:, 062,% 4/87381:D480::/::/234/=12=:0<=5=3AD/1/ /H0C=6/20:,062,!H 38H D/1/C01G/2 4/8;;=7=058;34/1/:>862/638%D0:/H0C=6/20:, 34/78>A8;=6:91067/>85=7A=:C01G/20:H + ;3/1 4/01=6? <834 34/ :=2/: 34/ 1=<9605 40: 0D012/278C>/6:03=86962/12=;;/1/634/02:0:</58D* +&, (- 6F91=/:>0=6062:9;;/1=6? :%&&&&# % /2=705/H>/6:/: :$ &'# (8826891=:4C/63:>/7=052=/3 062=67=2/63057401?/: :$&&&# ! 33/620637401?/: :$&&# $ 8::8;0C/6=3=/: :$&&&# " (9391/58::8;=678C/860778963 8;>/1C06/632=:0<=5=3A :$+ %&# + 8::8;=678C/291=6?50=2#9> >/1=82 : !&&&# ./0 1*( - 6 - +&,(-34/>/3=3=86/1D0:0D012/2 078C>/6:03=868;:!&&&&# /=6? 0??1=/@/2 <A 34/ :0C/ 34/ >/3=3=86/1: 01/</;81/34=:8913=60>>/05 ' 4/ 01?9C/63: <A 5/016/2 7896:/5 ;81 34/ 0>>/5506306234/1/:>862/638%D/1/4/012 & 4/ ;073 3403 34/1/ D0: 06 077=2/63 =6@85@=6? 34/ 19=:/1 //> 8D6/2 <A 1/:>862/63 8 062 =6:91/2 <A1/:>862/638%=:683=62=:>93/805:834/5=0<=5=3A 8; 34/ 1/:>862/63 8% #=6:91067/ 78C>06A 38 >0A 34/ 78C>/6:03=8640@=6?<//69>4/52<A34/ 1=<9605062683 </=6? 74055/6?/2 =3 40: 0330=6/2 ;=605=3A 8D/@/1 34/ 1=<960540:683/2340334/>/3=3=86/1</=6?96093481=:/2 >0::/6?/1: 34/ =6:91067/ 78C>06A D0: 2=1/73/2 38 >0A 34/78C>/6:03=860621/78@/134/:0C/;18C1/:>862/63 8 0=2;=62=6?8;34/ 1=<9605=:05:8683=674055/6?/ </;81/34=:8913 - 7 - 4/>/3=3=86/1=68 +"%& !I=5=>402 :9;;/1/2750@=75/;107391/0620:>/134/3/:3=C86A8;34/ ,% 4=: 2=:0<=5=3A =: &J 4/ ;107391/ 8; 34/ 750@=75/ D4=74 =: 8160C/6305 <86/ D8952 683 1/:953 =6 C974 ;9673=86052=:0<=5=3A8D/@/1786:=2/1=6?34/;073340334/ >/3=3=86/1 D0: 0 0?1=79539105 50<891/1 34/ 2=:0<=5=3A =: 786:=2/1/203"J 4/1/;81/4852=6?34/683=8605=678C/ 03:+$&&#0:>1/:71=</2<A34/?9=2/5=6/:=::9/2<A34/ ;81 :/335/C/63 8; 2=:>93/: </;81/ 8G#205034 ;81 34/ A/01 %& ! D4=74 =: 9>4/52 =6 9C>3//6 69C</1 8; F92?C/63: 34/ ;9391/ 58:: 8; =678C/ =: 70579503/2 03 :+$&&#- %H +H"JK1,( % 86:/B9/635A 4852=6? 34/ 50=2 9> >/1=82 38 </ 341// C8634: :974 58:: =: 70579503/20: :+$&&# H K 1( 4/ 78C>/6:03=86 0D012/2 <A 34/ 1=<9605 962/1 34/ 4/02 8; >0=6 062 :9;;/1=6? 6//2: 38 </ /64067/2381( 06234/58::8;0C/6=3=/:=65=;/ 6//2: 38 </ /64067/2 38 1( /67/ 34/ - 8 - >/3=3=86/1 =: /63=35/ 34/ 78C>/6:03=86 38 34/ 1/C0=6=6? 4/02: 286831/B9=1/ 06A /64067/C/63 4/>/3=3=86/1 =: /63=35/2;81038305:9C8;1*,*( 962/1;8558D=6? 4/02: 5 8 /02: D012<A34/ 1=<9605 D012<A34=: 8913 0=6062:9;;/1=6? :%&&&&# :%$&&&# % /2=705/H>/6:/: :$ &'# $ &'# (882 6891=:4C/63 :>/7=05 2=/3 E =67=2/63057401?/: :$&&&# $&&&# ! 33/620637401?/: :$&&# $&&# $ 8::8;0C/6=3=/: :$&&&# $&&&# " (9391/ 8:: 8; =678C/8607789638; >/1C06/632=:0<=5=3A :$+ %&# ' &&# + 8:: 8; =678C/ 291=6?50=29>>/1=82 : !&&&# %%$&&# 8305 : $$+ # % '# /::D012<A34/ 1=<9605 : $$+ # ./02+3/+4252+. 1,,( ! 8;010:34/>/3=3=86/1=68 ++%& !# 0C/:4=:7867/16/24/402:9;;/1/2793507/103/2D8962 C/0:91=6?H%H 7C:8@/134/:705>0:>/134/D8962 7/13=;=703/03H %91>1=:=6?5A34/D89627/13=;=703/28 683C/63=8606A58::8;3//348D/@/134/H =::9/2 - 9 - <A140G=54C/2:48D:3403>/3=3=86/140258:3"9>>/1 3//34 062 $ 58D/1 3//34 062 34/1/;81/ 4/ 8>=6/: 3403 34/1/ =: 0 2=:0<=5=3A 8; &J 3 =: D8134 38 683/ 3403 3489?4 34/ >/3=3=86/1 :0A: 3403 4/ 40: 58:3 34/ 3//34 86 07789638;34/=6F91=/::9:30=6/2=634/077=2/6334/1/=: 68 7811/503=86 </3D//6 34/ D8962 7/13=;=703/ 062 34/ 7/13=;=703/ =::9/2 <A 140G=5 4C/2 H7/>3 34/ 8105 3/:3=C86A 8; 34/ , 34/1/ =: 6834=6? /5:/ D4=74 D8952 /:30<5=:4 34/ :0C/ 8D/@/1 34=: 8913 8<:/1@/: 3403 >/3=3=86/1 402 05:8 :9:30=6/2 =6F91A =6 34/ :0=2 077=2/63 834=6? =: /5=7=3/2 =6 34/ 718::#/H0C=603=86 D4=74 D8952 :9??/:3340334/1/D0:68:9747811/503=86</3D//658::8; 3//34 062 34/ 077=2/6305 =6F91=/: 6 3403 @=/D 8; 34/ C033/1 D=34893 ?8=6? =638 34/ ;9134/1 C/1=3: 8; 34/ C033/1 34/ >/3=3=86/1 =: /63=35/2 ;81 06 022=3=8605 ?58<05 78C>/6:03=868;1( $ 6 34/ 1/:953 <834 34/ 0>>/05: 2/:/1@/ 38 </ 0558D/2=6>0130624/67/34/;8558D=6? - 10 - = 83434/0>>/05:01/0558D/2=6>013 == 4/ =C>9?6/2 F92?C/63 062 0D012 >0::/2<A34/ 1=<9605=:4/1/<AC82=;=/2 === 4/ 0>>/55063 =6 ( 8%&&&&%&%% =: /63=35/2 ;81 0 :9C 8; 1*,( =6 022=3=8638D40340:<//60D012/2<A34/ 1=<9605 =@ 4/ 0>>/55063 =6 ( 8%&&%''%&%% =: /63=35/2 ;81 ?58<05 78C>/6:03=86 8; 1( =6022=3=8638D40340:<//6 0D012/2<A34/ 1=<9605 @ 4/ 6:91067/ 8C>06A =: 5=0<5/ 38 >0A =63/1/:303"J>/10669C;18C34/203/8; >/3=3=86 3=55 1/05=L03=86 86 /63=1/ 78C>/6:03=86 @= 4/ 6:91067/ 8C>06A =: 2=1/73/2 38 2/>8:=334//64067/278C>/6:03=860586? - 11 - D=34 =63/1/:3 D=34=6 0 >/1=82 8; &" D//G: ;18C 34/203/8;1/7/=>3 8; 0 78>A8; 34=: F92?C/63 @== 4/ 1/:3 8; 812/1 >0::/2 <A 34/ 1=<9605 1/?012=6? >0A 062 1/78@/1A 1/C0=6 96053/1/2 2# %# ' # =:38 58"!