- 1 - ! "#$$ !! %$& ' !! " #$% " "$%& $"' $ % $ " # '( #" ) " *+' , % Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ", # "' ))) " *+' ! " ")- "!"! #' ( !"". " #! ,+*(( $ ) ,,+,+",+,,' ! " # "!"!" $")/ $ "+,, ""0, ! "' " )" !! ) " *#')" "$"! " ) " " ) " ! % " " *,, ! " " $ % % ) "" $ ,, " "")%" 1" " !! ) " % " $ " 2 %"$ $ - 3 - # "345 677869 45 :498; <= >38 ?964@6A> 588B4AC 8A36A?8@8A> D: ?D@78A56>4DA 65 6E6F;8; 4A >38 GH;C@8A>6A;6E6F;;6>8;*,,<=>38;;4>4DA69 8A4DF4I49%H;C86A;% )6A; "4;6F , F48: :6?>5 D: >38 ?658 986;4AC >D :494AC D: >38 ?964@78>4>4DA6F865HA;8F "36>DA++,,>38?964@6A>E657FD?88;4ACDA 345 @D>DF?=?98<86F4ACF8C45>F6>4DA D-1-+,6A; DA8 H<3653 E65 >38 74994DA F4;8F 6A; 6> 6<DH> +- 6@E38A>38=?6@8A86F 69B67HF4ACD6;4;6F6> >36> >4@8 F>4C6 6F <86F4AC F8C45>F6>4DA D - - *+ ?6@8 :FD@ F4ACFD6;6A; >38 ;F4I8FD:>38 564; ?6F E65;F4I4AC4>4A634C35788;6A;4A6F6536A;A8C94C8A> @6AA8F6A;;6538;>D>38@D>DF?=?98D:>38?964@6A>6A; ?6F >HFA8; >HF>98 5 6 F85H9> D: >38 564; 6??4;8A> >38 ?964@6A>5H5>64A8;CF48IDH54AGHF4856A;>DDB>F86>@8A>4A >38 3D574>69 "38 ?964@6A> :498; 6 ?964@ 78>4>4DA HA;8F 8?>4DA (( D: >38 D>DF $834?985 ?> 588B4AC - 4 - ?D@78A56>4DA "38 "F4<HA69 6558558; >38 ?D@78A56>4DA 6A; 76558; GH;C@8A> 6A; 6E6F; "38 ?964@6A> 588B4AC 8A36A?8@8A> D: >38 564; ?D@78A56>4DA 365 :498; >38 7F858A>677869 86F; 986FA8; ?DHA589 :DF >38 6778996A> 6A; 986FA8;?DHA589:DFF857DA;8A> D4A5HF6A?8?D@76A= 86FA8; ?DHA589 :DF >38 6778996A> EDH9; ?DA>8A;>36>>386??4;8A>365>6B8A796?84A>38=86F,, 6A; 65 78F >38 ?36F> 7F876F8; <= >38 6FA6>6B6 >6>8 8C698FI4?85H>3DF4>=>38AD>4DA694A?D@8:4J8;:DF>38 564; =86F 45 5*- 6A; >38 "F4<HA69 365 8FF8; 4A >6B4AC >38 4A?D@8 D: >38 ?964@6A> 6> 5- 78F @DA>3 8 :HF>38F ?DA>8A;8; >36> >38 ;D?>DF 365 5>6>8; >36>>38;456<494>=5H::8F8;<=>38?964@6A>45K>D>38 94@<6A;>38"F4<HA693658FF8;4A>6B4AC;456<494>=6>K >D>38E3D98<D;="38?964@6A>L558?DA;6A;>34F;>D85D: >38 F4C3> 98C 6F86@7H>6>8; 6A;:4:>3 >D8 45 4FF8CH96F6A; AD> :HA?>4DA4AC 6A; 38 E65 6;@4>>8; 4A >38 3D574>69 :DF - 5 - :DHF ;6=5 DA54;8F4AC >38 56@8 >38 ?D@78A56>4DA 6E6F;8;:DF764A6A;5H::8F4AC9D55D:4A?D@8;HF4AC964; H778F4D;6A;9D55D:6@8A4>4856F8DA>389DE8F54;84>3 >3858387F6=5>D699DE>38677869 986FA8; ?DHA589 :DF F857DA;8A> D4A5HF6A?8?D@76A= EDH9; ?DA>8A; >36>>38 "F4<HA69 365 F4C3>9= 6558558; >38 ;456<494>= 6A; ?D@78A56>4DA 6E6F;8; 45 GH5> 6A; 7FD78F 4>3 >3858 38 7F6=5 >D ;45@455>38677869 ( 6I4AC 386F; >38 986FA8; ?DHA589 :DF >38 76F>485 >345 DHF> 78FH58; >38 4@7HCA8; GH;C@8A> 6A; 6E6F;6A;D>38F@6>8F469796?8;DAF8?DF;"386C8D:>38 ?964@6A> 6??4;8A> 6A; 946<494>= D: >38 4A5HF6A?8 ?D@76A= 6F8 AD> 4A ;457H>8 "38 6??4;8A> 365 >6B8A 796?8 DA ++,, 6A; 65 DA >38 ;6>8 D: >38 6??4;8A> >38 ?964@6A>E656C8;6<DH>,=86F58A?8>3867794?6<98 @H9>47948F 45 * "38 AD>4DA69 4A?D@8 :4J8; :DF >38 =86F ,,<=>386FA6>6B6>6>88C698FI4?85H>3DF4>=:DF - 6 - ;457D569 D: >38 ?6585 4A DB-;696>3 45 5*- 6A; >38F8:DF8>384A?D@8>6B8A<=>38"F4<HA696>5- 78F @DA>3 45 AD> 7FD78F !, 45 >38 ;D?>DF E3D 365 >F86>8;>384AGHF8;6A;455H8;J!;456<494>=?8F>4:4?6>8 !,3655>6>8;>36>>38?964@6A>4536I4ACK;456<494>= >D >38 F4C3> 94@< "38 ;D?>DF 365 AD> 5>6>8; E36> 45 >38 6?>H69;456<494>=D:>38E3D98<D;=DA54;8F4AC>3856@8 >38"F4<HA69365F4C3>9=>6B8A;456<494>=6>K>D>38E3D98 <D;= 8A?8 >38 ?964@6A> 45 8A>4>98; :DF ?D@78A56>4DA >DE6F;59D55D::H>HF886FA4AC565HA;8F 5*-J,J*JKM5- * DA54;8F4AC>386@7H>6>4DAD:>ED>D856A;DA8 >D8 <8?D@8 4FF8CH96F 6A; AD> :HA?>4DA4AC >38 6E6F; D: ?D@78A56>4DA>DE6F;5764A6A;5H::8F4AC6>5-45 DA >38 9DE8F 54;8 6A; >38 ?964@6A> 45 8A>4>98; >D 5->DE6F;5564;386;"38?964@6A>458A>4>98;:DF ?D@78A56>4DA >DE6F;5 9D55 D: 6@8A4>485 4A 6 5H@ D: 5- 65 6C64A5> 5,- 6E6F;8; <= >38 "F4<HA69 "38 "F4<HA69 365 F4C3>9= 6E6F;8; ?D@78A56>4DA - 7 - >DE6F;5 6>>8A;6A> 6A; ?DAI8=6A?8 ?36FC85 4A 6 5H@ D: 5- "38 ?964@6A> 365 <88A 6;@4>>8; 4A >38 3D574>69 6A; 38 365 <88A 6;I458; F85> "38F8:DF8 38 45 8A>4>98; :DF ?D@78A56>4DA >DE6F;5 9D55 D: 4A?D@8 ;HF4AC 964; H7 78F4D; 4A 6 5H@ D: 5,- #5*- J @DA>35'656C64A5>5,-6E6F;8;<=>38"F4<HA69 AI48ED:>386<DI8>386778996A>?964@6A>45 8A>4>98;:DF>D>69?D@78A56>4DA65HA;8F 9 D 86;5 @DHA> D55D::H>HF84A?D@8 5- , !64A6A;H::8F4AC 5- D55 D: 4A?D@8 ;HF4AC 964; H7 78F4D; 5,- >>8A;6A> ?DAI8=6A?8 :DD; 6A;ADHF453@8A>?36FC85 5- 8;4?698J78A585 5(- ( D55D:6@8A4>485 5- ()* + , + "38F8:DF8>386778996A>?964@6A>458A>4>98;:DF >D>69 ?D@78A56>4DA D: 5,**,(- 65 6C64A5> 5(-6E6F;8;<=>38"F4<HA69E4>34A>8F85>6>>38 F6>8 D: (K 78F 6AAH@ :FD@ >38 ;6>8 D: 78>4>4DA >499 4>5 F8694N6>4DA - 8 - A>38F85H9>>38:D99DE4AC #4' "38 45?8996A8DH5 )4F5> 77869 45 699DE8; 4A 76F> #44' "38 GH;C@8A> 6A; 6E6F; ;6>8; *,, 76558; 4A $ D,, <= >38 ;;4>4DA69 8A4DF4I49%H;C86A;% )6A; "4;6F45 @D;4:48;65HA;8F #6' "38 6778996A>?964@6A> 45 8A>4>98; :DF >D>69 ?D@78A56>4DA D: 5,**,(- 65 6C64A5> 5(- 6E6F;8; <= >38 "F4<HA69 E4>3 4A>8F85> 6> >38 F6>8 D: (K 78F 6AAH@ :FD@ >38 ;6>8 D: 78>4>4DA>4994>5F8694N6>4DA #<' "38 F857DA;8A> D4A5HF6A?8 ?D@76A= 45 ;4F8?>8; >D ;87D54> >38 8A>4F8 ?D@78A56>4DA E4>3 4A>8F85> E4>34A 6 78F4D; D: 84C3> E88B5 :FD@ >345 ;6= :6494AC E34?3 4> 45 946<98 >D - 9 - 76= 4A>8F85> 6> >38 F6>8 D: +K 78F 6AAH@ #?' ::4?8 45 ;4F8?>8; >D 58A; 6 ?D7= D: >345GH;C@8A>>D>38"F4<HA69 -, %$$& # ! 45> D9 D, "$