- 1 - !" # $# % ## # & ' &()* '& )) + !"" # $ %& ! %' ( !"" " ' % % % ) ) !*++" ' !*!"! # $!%, " & Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " $& " +-+ "+" --- "+" $ ! "+"& % ' ' --- "+" % '' .' $ .' & /012/ 3/4 563347 89 :8934; <07 6;589980= >83/ 3/4 ?0=94=30<:467=4;?01=94:<07@03/3/4A673849838936B4= 1A<07<8=6:;89A096: " /4A438380=47@48=26??194;0"89944B8=230 C169/ 3/4 ?7858=6: A70?44;8=29 8=838634; 6268=93 /47 8= 0--- "+" 0= 3/4 <8:4 0< :467=4; ;;8380=6: 8D8: '1;246=;'8=2691217$ 0! "+"&742893474; <073/40<<4=?4A1=89/6@:41=;474?380=! 0<420386@:4 =937154=39?3! !$<079/073E ?3F& - 3 - 467; 78 6/6=349/ 638: :467=4; ?01=94: <07 3/4 A438380=47 49A0=;4=3 0! 3/012/ 947D4; >83/ =038?4/6974568=4;1=74A7494=34;038?430749A0=;4=3 0"89;89A4=94;>83/ 47194;3/45634786:90=74?07; =D84>0<3/491@589980=56;4@G3/4:467=4; ?01=94: <07 3/4 A438380=47 3/4 A08=3 3/63 >01:; 67894 <07 5G?0=98;476380=89 !"#$% G6=9>47303/46@0D4A08=3898=3/4 <073/4<0::0>8=2 49A0=;4=3 0! @48=2 3/4 ?05A:68=6=3 <8:4; 3/4 A78D634 ?05A:68=3 8= 0! "+" 6268=93 6??194; 09!6=;"6::428=2?05589980=0<3/40<<4=?4A1=89/6@:4 1=;474?380=! 0< ?3 3893/4?0=34=380=0<3/4 - 4 - ?05A:68=6=3 3/63 6??194; 0! 89 3/4 0>=47 6=; A70A784307 0< 01796=; 76D4:9 4 >69 8=370;1?4; 30 3/4 ?05A:68=6=3 @G 6??194; 0" ??194; 0! /69 6AA706?/4;3/4?05A:68=6=3627448=23094::3/44:4?378?6: @8B49<3476;4368:4;;89?19980=3/4?05A:68=6=3936734; ;4A09838=2 3/4 6501=3 >83/ 6??194; 0! <705 "+"+ 1;;4=:G6??194;0!930AA4;94=;8=23/44:4?378?@8B49 4D4= 6<347 74?48A3 0< 50=4G ;178=2 "+"" ??194; 0! /69=034D4=28D4=A70A4774A:G/89<6?3>698=<0754; 306??194;0"??194;0"/69=0336B4=6=G934A98= 3/6374267; * 3 89 93634; 3/63 6??194; 0! /6; 62744; 30 74A6G 3/4 3036: 6501=3 0< 9-+(- 6=; 9-+++++ 303/4?05A:68=6=374?48D4;@G/85<073/4 A17A094 94=;8=2 3/4 4:4?378? @8B49 = 3/63 74267; 6??194; 0! 89914; ?/4C14 @4678=2 0+++-+! 6=; ?/4C14 @4678=2 0+++-+" ;634; +!+"+" <07 9-+(- 6=; 9-+++++ 749A4?38D4:G 30>67;9 :426::G 4=<07?46@:4 ;4@3 /4= 3/4 ?/4C149 >474 - 5 - A7494=34; <07 4=?69/54=3 9654 >474 ;89/0=0174; >83/ 6=4=;079454=3EA6G54=3930AA4;@G;76>47F =9A8340< 74?48A30<=038?46??194;0!/69=0374A68;3/4?/4C14 6501=3 6=; 3/474@G /4 /69 ?0558334; 3/4 0<<4=?4 A1=89/6@:41=;474?380=! 0< ?3 ( /49A4?8<8?6::426380=56;4@G3/4?05A:68=6=3 893/633/46501=38=C149380=>69A68;306??194;0! 6=;30>67;974A6G54=30<3/4965483>696??194;0! >/0/6;89914;3/4?/4C1498=C149380=>/8?/>474?654 30 @4 ;89/0=0174; /4 0=:G 6::426380= 56;4 6268=93 6??194; 0" 89 3/63 /4 /6; 8=370;1?4; 6??194; 0! 30 3/4 ?05A:68=6=3 6=; /4 /69 ?/4634; >83/013 56B8=2 A70A476776=2454=3<07A6G54=30<3/46501=3/4=3/4 6::424;0<<4=?4891=;474?380=! 0< ?38389 0=:G 3/4;76>470<3/4?/4C149>/0?01:;@4/4:;749A0=98@:4 /4= 6;58334;:G 6??194; 0" >69 =03 3/4 982=6307G 30 3/4?/4C149/4?6==03@4/4:;749A0=98@:4<073/46::424; 0<<4=?4 =8386380= 0< ?7858=6: A70?44;8=29 6268=93 3/4 - 6 - A438380=47 6??194;0"898=6@1940<A70?4990<:6>6=; 3/4965489:86@:430@4C169/4; =D84>0<3/46@0D4 6=9>473/46@0D4A08=3 8=3/4 6=;A70?44;30A6993/4<0::0>8=2 /4?7858=6:A438380=89 4=;8=2 ?7858=6: A70?44;8=29 8=838634; 6268=93 3/4 A438380=47 6??194;0"8=0--- "+"0=3/4<8:40< :467=4; ;;8380=6: 8D8: '1;24 6=; ' 8=2691217 $ 0! "+"& 742893474; <07 3/4 0<<4=?4 A1=89/6@:4 1=;474?380=! 0< ?389/474@GC169/4; ,* &##) % 8930!:0!