- 1 - !"# $! % &!$! % &!#&' # ! !$$ (') * !" "# $ % &'( & ) % *)+ & + % &)( Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & % & ,,%+ " "" % " & - & " ++%,+ % & - # &)) !""" +* % ()))+ $ (+!$ - )())+ )+.%)) " - " - & & /" - /" -- - 3 - & !& /" - $ 01234453612789051:2;<3:=5=>?43:8@165A;:A5< 5=91>:(+!$>@905 >9><501=652=9.!@><20><9 905 =9B$ 751:C 3CC<15D5A 78 905 E;AC?5:9 3:A 3F3<A A395A )())+ 43225A 78 905 AA6 5:1>< 1D16 -;AC5 3:A 31=0;<1: >)+.%))7>90>:G;3:9;? 32F56632613716198 ) 3=92 C1D1:C <125 9> 905 @161:C >@ 905 344536 7<15@6829395A3<59039>:+))3937>;9.3? F1@5>@=631?3:9 >3:A?>905<>@=631?3:9 >2)3:A+ :3?568?9-38320<55F324<>=55A1:C9>=>665C5@><A;98 >: 05< ?>9><=8=65 :3?568 =>>98 753<1:C 5C >, +'% ,).+) =3;91>;268 F05: 205 <53=05A 3<3?520F3< =>6>:8 =<>22 >: 31=0;<, 3:9<3683 <>3A 39 9039 91?5 3 <3H >>@3: D501=65 753<1:C 5C >,++%,+ =3?5 @<>? 1<=653931=0;<1:<3203:A:5C61C5:9?3::5< F190>;9 @>66>F1:C 9<3@@1= <;652 019 905 ?>9><=8=65 A;5 9> 9051?43=9 231A -3820<55 @566 A>F: >: 905<>3A 3:A F32 - 4 - A<3CC5A 9> 37>;9 ) @559 F01=0 ?3A5 05< 9> 2;2931: C<15D>;2 1:E;<152 >D5< 05< <1C09 21A5 053A F<1292 03:A2 65C2 F190 1:95<:36 1:E;<152 ??5A139568 205 F32201@95A 9> 3D55:>2419363931=0;<7;92052;==;?75A9>905 1:E;<1523937>;9)3? + <1><9>9053==1A5:9A5=5325AF32F><I1:C32 5=9;<5< 1: J3055<373A <5,:1D5<2198 >665C5 39 31=0;< 3:AF3253<:1:C2''%,4?322363<83:A205F323 016 <3A;395 3:A 03A 4<>?>91>: >44><9;:19152 05 F32 3C5A 37>;9 853<2 3:A 205 03A <5?31:1:C 25<D1=5916605<<591<5?5:9 ;5 9> 2;AA5: A5390 >@ 231A ?9 -38320<55 905 =631?3:92 6>29 905 A545:A5:=8 6>D5 3:A 3@@5=91>: 631?3:9 >3C5A37>;9'853<212;:37659>?31:931: 012@3?1685:=5=631?3:92@165A905=631?459191>:;:A5< 5=91>:''>@905=975@><5905631?2<17;:36255I1:C =>?45:2391>: - 5 - ;<2;3:9 9> 905 2;??>:2 <524>:A5:9 >2 3:A ) 34453<5A 3:A @165A 9051< 2543<395 29395?5:92 524>:A5:9 > 5H=549 3A?1991:C 905 1:=1A5:9 A5:15A >905< 459191>: 3D5<?5:92 524>:A5:9 >) A5:15A 905 459191>:3D5<?5:923:A4<385A9>A12?122905459191>: ' :90573212>@9054653A1:C2>@90543<9152905 631?2<17;:36@<3?5A905122;523:A905<53@95<<5=><A5A 9055D1A5:=5 : ><A5< 9> 4<>D5905 =325 =631?3:9 >+ C>9 05<256@ 5H3?1:5A 32 , 3:A C>9 5H017195A A>=;?5:92 :3?568 H 9> H)+ : 75036@ >@ <524>:A5:9290<55F19:522523<55H3?1:5A3229>+ 3:AC>9?3<I5A25D5:955:A>=;?5:9232H29>( ( 05631?2<17;:36789051?4;C:5AE;AC?5:9 056A9039 905 3==1A5:9 9>>I463=5>: 3==>;:9>@ <320 3:A :5C61C5:9 A<1D1:C >@ 905 A<1D5< >@ 905 >@@5:A1:C <3H >>@3: D501=65 753<1:C 5C >,++%,+ 32 3 <52;69 >@ F01=0 A5=5325A 2;2931:5A 1:E;<152 3:A 2;==;?75A9>9051:E;<15205<17;:36;4>:=>:21A5<1:C - 6 - 905><363:AA>=;?5:93<85D1A5:=5463=5A75@><519056A 9039 905 =631?3:92 3<5 5:91965A 9> =>?45:2391>: >@ 2+'%,36>:CF1901:95<52939905<395>@'K43 3:A A1<5=95A <524>:A5:9 >) 9> A54>219 905 =>?45:2391>: "51:C 3CC<15D5A 78 905 E;AC?5:9 3:A 3F3<A9053445663:9:2;<3:=5=>?43:8121:9012344536 1?4;C:1:C 905 613716198 3:A 32 F566 32 905 G;3:9;? >@ =>?45:2391>: 05 653<:5A =>;:256 @>< 905 3445663:9 1:2;<3:=5=>?43:8<3125A905@>66>F1:C=>:95:91>:2& 3$ 912=>:95:A5A90399053==1A5:9>==;<<5AA;5 9> <320 3:A :5C61C5:9 <1A1:C >@ ?>9><=8=65 78 A5=5325A F0> F32 =>?1:C @<>? >44>2195 21A5 F190>;9 C1D1:C 3:8 21C:36 3:A 9>>I LB 9;<:* 905<5@><5 A5=5325A 032 =>:9<17;95A 9> 905 3==1A5:9 ";9 905 <17;:36 032 =>??1995A5<<><1:0>6A1:C9039905A<1D5<>@905>@@5:A1:C D501=651236>:5:5C61C5:91:=3;21:C9053==1A5:9 - 7 - 7$ 5=>:A68 19 12 =>:95:A5A 9039 19 12 D5<8 =653< @<>? <54><9 24>9 ?303M3< 3:A 905 5D1A5:=5 >@ 9039A5=5325A032362>=>:9<17;95A9>9053==1A5:9 >F5D5<905<17;:36032@3165A9>=>:21A5<90123245=9>@ 905 ?3995< 3:A 905<5@><5 4<385A 9> 23AA65 2;7293:9136 4><91>:>@613716198>:905A5=5325AF0>F32905<532>:1: =3;21:C9053==1A5:9 =$ : <5245=9 >@ G;3:9;? 12 =>:=5<:5A 19 12 =>:95:A5A9039<17;:36032=>:21A5<5A?>:90681:=>?5>@ A5=5325A 39 2..%, 905 23?5 12 >: 905 01C05< 21A5 3:A905<17;:36032:>9A5A;=95A1:=>?593H5D5:90>;C0 =631?3:9203D54<>A;=5A9051:=>?593H<59;<: A$ 3296819122;7?1995A9039=>:21A5<1:C9053C5 3:A 3D>=391>: >@ A5=5325A 905 >D5<366 =>?45:2391>: 3F3<A5A78905<17;:3612>:90501C05<21A55:=5>: 90525C<>;:A24<385A9>366>F905344536 . 653<:5A =>;:256 34453<1:C @>< 905 =631?3:92%<524>:A5:92 03D5 =>:95:A5A 9039 905 3==1A5:9 - 8 - 032 >==;<<5A A;5 9> <320 3:A :5C61C5:9 A<1D1:C >@ 905 >@@5:A1:C <3H >>@3: D501=65 753<1:C 5C >,++%, +05A<1D5<>@905>@@5:A1:CD501=65=3?51:301C0 2455A <320 3:A :5C61C5:9 ?3::5< 3:A 9>>I LB 9;<: 3:A A3205A9>905?>9><=8=65=>>98>@905A5=5325A;59> 905 1?43=9 205 @566 A>F: 3:A 2;2931:5A 1:E;<152 3:A 2;==;?75A 9> 905 1:E;<152 05<53@95< 1??5A139568 =>?4631:9 032 755: 6>AC5A 3C31:29 905 A<1D5< >@ 905 >@@5:A1:C D501=65 05 4>61=5 3@95< 90><>;C0 1:D5291C391>: @165A =03<C5,20559 3C31:29 905 A<1D5< >@ 905 >@@5:A1:C D501=65 >:21A5<1:C 9012 3245=9 >@ 905 ?3995< 905 <17;:36032<1C0968056A9039905A<1D5<>@905<3H>>@3: 36>:512:5C61C5:91:=3;21:C9053==1A5:9 :<5245=9>@G;3:9;?>@=>?45:2391>:05032 =>:95:A5A9039A5=5325AF32F><I1:C325=9;<5<1:<5, :1D5<2198>665C531=0;<05803D54<>A;=5A4382614 3245<H.9>20>F9039A5=5325AF32C5991:C?>:9068 C<>222363<8>@2''%,05<17;:363@95<A5A;=91:C - 9 - 4<>@5221>:36 93H 3:A 1:=>?5 93H 032 3225225A ?>:9068 1:=>?5392..%, 32968 05 032 =>:95:A5A 9039 =>:21A5<1:C 905 3C53:A3D>=391>:>@A5=5325A905>D5<366=>?45:2391>: 3F3<A5A78905<17;:3612E;293:A<532>:3765 ) 53<A905653<:5A=>;:256@><9053445663:93:A 905 <524>:A5:92 45<;25A 905 E;AC?5:9 3:A 3F3<A 1:=6;A1:C9053445364345<2 + 9 12 905 =325 >@ 905 =631?3:92 9039 >: +))3937>;9.3?A5=5325A?9-38320<55 F32 4<>=55A1:C 9> =>665C5 @>< A;98 >: 05< ?>9><=8=65 :3?568 =>>98 753<1:C 5C >,+'% ,).+) =3;91>;268 F05: 205 <53=05A 3<3?520F3< =>6>:8 =<>22 >: 31=0;<, 3:9<3683 <>3A 39 9039 91?5 3 <3H >>@3: D501=65 753<1:C 5C >,++%,+ =3?5 @<>? 1<=65 39 31=0;< 1: <320 3:A :5C61C5:9 ?3::5< F190>;9 @>66>F1:C 9<3@@1= <;652 019 905 23?5 9> ?>9><=8=65 >@ A5=5325AA;59>9051?43=9A5=5325A?9-3820<55@566 - 10 - A>F:>:905<>3A3:AF32A<3CC5A9>37>;9)@5593:A 2052;==;?75A9>9051:E;<152 >4<>D5905=325905=631?3:9 >+032755: 5H3?1:5A323:A905803D54<>A;=5A)+A>=;?5:92 32H29>)+ :A5< 905 >9>< 501=652 =9 1: 905 =631? 459191>:75@><5905631?2<17;:36905293:A3<A>@4<>>@12 ?;=0 756>F 903: F039 12 <5G;1<5A 1: 3 =<1?1:36 =325 32 F566 32 1: 905 =1D16 =325 > A>;79 75@><5 905 <17;:36 905<5 ?;29 75 2>?5 ?395<136 >: 905 73212 >@ F01=0 905 <17;:36 =3: 3<<1D5 >< A5=1A5 901:C2 :5=5223<8 9> A5=1A5 @>< 3F3<A1:C =>?45:2391>: 7;9 905 <17;:36 12 :>9 5H45=95A9>93I5><9>3A>493:1=598>@3=1D16><=<1?1:36 =325 @95< 366 19 12 3 2;??3<8 5:G;1<8 3:A 19 12 905 65C126391>:@><905F56@3<5>@905>=1598054<>=55A1:C2 ;:A5< 905 >9>< 501=652 =9 3<5 :>9 3I1: 9> 905 4<>=55A1:C2 ;:A5< =1D16 <;652 5:=5 29<1=9 <;652 >@ 5D1A5:=53<5:>9<5G;1<5A9>75@>66>F5A1:9012<5C3<A: - 11 - 905=325>@ +, ! $# ( -) ! 905 >:B765 45H>;<9032056A3205<51:756>F& ! " # $ !" %"$ $ $ " " $$$ " ! " " $ ! "" " " ""& ' 1:05<5D1A5:=5<5195<395A9053D5<?5:92 ?3A51:905=631?459191>:05A54>25A90391??5A139568 3@95< 905 3==1A5:9 3 =>?4631:9 32 45< H) 3C31:29 905 - 12 - A<1D5<>@905>@@5:A1:CD501=65032755:6>AC5A054>61=5 <5C1295<5A =325 1: 32 45< H @95< 90><>;C0 1:D5291C391>:9054>61=503D5@165A=03<C5,20559 ( 05 <565D3:9 43<3C<340 >@ 905 =03<C5,20559 12 5H9<3=95A32;:A5<& “ !"#$%& –'()*+ # , -* .,/,0 #.( # 1! 23& .4 5 67 8&9 :(9 ;:( <=> 4< .>?@ABCD>&BE)2.&BFG89# A HI& (. %D / 1J < #D .4) 1 < K <$ .G, .& 8) / 1J ,LH.& 8)M N %K <$O'# .&L K "''D- 5 P PDN9J'#N).7' Q.4 N. 95 ,LH > &L / 1J <=> 4< .>?@ABC PD O'% ,LH.& 89# PIRSJ.T9# PMN)5 ).J'D.'G!DJ /GU 8N).7' ,LH.&E O'%<=> 4<NV' 2 P O'%4<U'.%W%) N2 4< U' >% .& 8J /5H P O'% ', 9(* . <S P .#'#.3.)X' Y %J P Y6'Z .' = KI'(5 . 2 # NV' 5 K - 13 - X 'H.%[ B O'<S P A '# ” 05<565D3:94><91>:2>@ 54><9125H9<3=95A 32;:A5<& ! $ <>?F0>?<5G;12191>: <5=51D5A 5291<=6531=0;< ) 395>@<5=5149>@<5G;12191>: )) + 39591?53:A463=5>@ 1:245=91>: ))N+3?N <3@@1=<5?1252 39591?53:A463=5>@3==1A5:9 >9?5:91>:5A ;?75<>@45<2>:2$1665A )$:E;<5A >9?5:91>:5A ' $./01234./5,6712465 ) !F>$ 3$ ;?75<>@501=6521:D>6D5A '671246+ '671246+ 7$5C129<391>: ;?75< -- " =$6322>@501=65 ! %"$ % A$?3I5 ><=5<3H>>@3: 5C> 5$>6>;< 16D5< <3:C5 ( 5=03:1=36>:A191>:>@905 501=65 -- <>:97;?45<39<1C091:=6;A1:C 1:A1=39><4<5225A1:F3<A23:A A3?3C5A " <>:9203451:=6;A1:C053A 61C09;:197>901:A1=39><2@<>:9 F0556?;AC;3<A4<5225A3:A A3?3C5A )@<>:9=03221275:A "<3I58295? -- 5295A905 >:<>3A3:A@>;:A9039905 7<3I51:><A5< " 5295A905 3929391>:5<8=>:A191>:3:A - 14 - @>;:A90399057<3I5 =>::5=91>:2F5<51:><A5< . 725<D391>:2?3A53990524>9 >@9053==1A5:9 16 "<15@3<91=;63<2>@=3;25>@ 3==1A5:9!>41:1>:$ 3?>@905>41:1>:90399012 3==1A5:9F32=3;25A:>9A;59> 3:8?5=03:1=36A5@5=92>@7>90 905D501=652 5:5<36<5?3<I2>@905 1:245=9><>@?>9><D501=65 % <5G;5295A9>D5<1@8905 D501=652A>=;?5:923:A >@ <1D5<B2 395&)) A%, 3C3D3:A 3?53:A1C:39;<5>@ :245=9><>@ >9><501=652 . 0524>9?303M3<1239H+912D5<8=653< @<>? 9012 A>=;?5:9 9039 905 A<1D5< >@ 905 <3H >>@3: A<>D5 905 D501=65 1: 3 <320 3:A :5C61C5:9 ?3::5< 3:A 2;AA5:689>>ILB9;<:1:A>;765<>3A990523?591?5 A5=5325A 362> =3?5 @<>? >44>2195 A1<5=91>: >: 05< ?>9><=8=653:A9>>ILB9;<:3@95<93I1:C366=3;91>:23:A 205 F32 <1A1:C 905 ?>9><=8=65 D5<8 26>F68 0>F5D5< 905 A<1D5< >@ 905 <;=I 032 A3205A 3C31:29 905 ?>9><=8=65 ;5 9> 905 1?43=9 205 @566 A>F: 3:A 2;==;?75A 9> 905 1:E;<5205<5@><51912D5<8=653<9039A<1D5<>@905<3H >>@3:A<>D5905>@@5:A1:CD501=651:01C02455A<3203:A :5C61C5:9 ?3::5< F0> 12 905 A<1D5< 32 F566 32 - 15 - >F:5< >@ 905 >@@5:A1:C D501=65 3A?1995A 905 >==;<<1:C >@ 3==1A5:9 7;9 05 032 A5:15A 9039 05 F32 :>9 :5C61C5:9 1: =3;21:C 905 3==1A5:9 ";9 05 032 :>9 6>AC5A 3:8 =>?4631:91:9039<5C3<A>:21A5<1:C9055D1A5:=5>@905 43<9152=03<C5,2055924>9?303M3<3:A <54><9 905 <17;:36 032 <1C0968 3:2F5<5A 122;5 > 1: 905 @@1<?391D5 ) :<5245=9>@905G;3:9;?12=>:=5<:5A39905 91?5>@9053==1A5:9A5=5325AF32F><I1:C325=9;<5<1: <5,:1D5<2198 >665C5 39 31=0;< 05 =631?3:9 032 4<>A;=5A4382614>@A5=5325A3245<H.F01=020>F2 9039A5=5325AF32C5991:C?>:90682363<8>@2''%, 05 <17;:36 3@95< A5A;=91:C 4<>@5221>:36 93H >@ 2)%, 3:A1:=>?593H>@2'(%,032<1C09683225225A?>:9068 1:=>?5 >@ A5=5325A 32 2..%, 05<5@><5 905 <17;:36 12 E;291@15A 1: 3F3<A1:C 905 =>?45:2391>: 3:A @3295:1:C 905 613716198 >: 905 <524>:A5:9 1:2;<3:=5 =>?43:8 - 16 - ) ==><A1:C68 905 344536 751:C A5D>1A >@ ?5<192 12A12?1225A )) 05 3?>;:9 1: A54>219 20366 75 9<3:2?1995A 9> 905=>:=5<:5A<17;:36 !89 ($!) & (!89 #&' #) & " 129 >&6 >&'