Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 49681 (KAR)

SATTEWWA W/O SABU METAGUDD v. BASAVARAJ S/O SABU METAGUDD AND ANR

MFA/200536/2023 · 2025-03-17

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #$ $ %%&' ( ) ! "# $%&!#' ( ) ) !*) ) ) $%&!#! *!+ *( ) * * !,! * ) ) ) ) #!!(#(( ) $ !#&(#!' Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) * * ) ) ) )- ) $ )- ) ./01 2113/.4.5 67 89. :;51<.08 205 2=235 528.5 #!!(#(( >2??.5 67 89. @.230.5 55/8/A02@ .0/A3 /4/@ ;51.205.<6.3:272>;32/0A!#&(#!' 89.>.8/8/A0.3/?6.BA3.89/?A;38/02>>.2@ ( 8/?89.C2?.AB89.>.8/8/A0.38928A0!&"(#!'28 ,## ><?9. =2? 2>/@@/A0 3/5.3 A0 89. <A8A3 C7C@. 6.23/01 A(&''%%20589.3/5.3AB20A89.3<A8A3C7C@.6.23/01 A(& #!!% C2<. B3A< 6.9/05 /0 32?9 205 0.1@/1.08 <200.3@A?8CA083A@20552?9.5212/0?889.<A8A3C7C@.A4.3 =9/C9 ?9.=2? 8324.@@/012?2>/@@/A03/5.39.>.8/8/A0.3B.@@ 5A=0205?;?82/0.5/0:;3/.?205?9.=2?82D.0 )A?>/82@ /:272>;320589.08A2?9A59232)A?>/82@/:272>;32?8@7 ?9. =2? ?9/B8.5 8A 2012<2/ )A?>/82@ A@2>;3 9. =2? 20 213/C;@8;3/?8 .230/01 ?(%###$ >.3 <A089 21.5 26A;8 7.23? 205 5;. 8A 89. 2CC/5.082@ /0:;3/.? ?9. 92? ?;BB.3.5 >.3<20.08 5/?26/@/87 9.3.BA3. ?9. ?A;198 25.E;28. - 3 - CA<>.0?28/A0 B3A< 89. A=0.3 205 /0?;3.3 AB 89. ABB.05/01 4.9/C@. ;3?;2088A89.0A8/C.?/??;.53.?>A05.08A?!205 ( 2>>.23.5 893A;19 89./3 CA;0?.@ 6;8 /8 =2? 89. 3.?>A05.08 A(2@A0.=9ACA08.?8.589.>.8/8/A0.?>A05.08A(5.0/.5 89. 32?9 205 0.1@/1.08 53/4/01 67 89. 3/5.3 AB 89. ABB.05/01 <A8A3 C7C@. 5.0/.5 1324/87 AB 89. /0:;3/.? ?;?82/0.5 67 89. >.8/8/A0.3 8.3<.5 89. CA<>.0?28/A0 C@2/<.5 2? 9/19@7 .FA36/8208 /<21/0237 205 ;08.026@. 8 =2? CA08.05.5 8928 89.3./?5.@27AB#"527?/0B/@/0189.CA<>@2/0820589.3/5.3 =2?0A8924/01242@/553/4/01@/C.0C.2052??;C989.8.3<? 205 CA05/8/A0? AB 89. >A@/C7 924/01 6..0 4/A@28.5 /8 6. 26?A@4.5B3A<@/26/@/87 " 089.62?/?AB89.26A4.CA08.08/A0?89.3/6;02@ B32<.52>>3A>3/28./??;.?2053.CA35.589.8.?8/<A0/.?AB89. >.8/8/A0.3 2? ! 89. AC8A3 =9A 2??.??.5 89. 5/?26/@/87 2? ( 205 F9/6/8? ! 8A !% =.3. <23D.5 /0 .4/5.0C. 9. ABB/C/2@AB3.?>A05.08A(=2?.F2</0.52?!205F9/6/8? !8A%=.3.<23D.5 - 4 - % B8.39.23/016A8989.?/5.?89.3/6;02@5/?</??.5 89. >.8/8/A0 ./01 2113/.4.5 67 89. ?2<. 89. >.8/8/A0.3 /? 6.BA3.89/?A;38/02>>.2@ 0 25</88/01 89. 2>>.2@ 3.?>A05.08 A?! 205 ( 924.2>>.23.5893A;1989./3CA;0?.@89.83/2@A;383.CA35? 924.6..0?.C;3.520589.231;<.08?AB6A8989.?/5.?=.3. 9.235 , 9. @.230.5 CA;0?.@ 2>>.23/01 BA3 89. >.8/8/A0.3 =A;@5 ?;6</8 8928 89. 3/6;02@ 92? 0A8 2>>3.C/28.5 89. .4/5.0C.A03.CA35/02>3A>.3<200.3205/8.33A0.A;?@7C2<. 8A 89. CA0C@;?/A0 8928 89. 2CC/5.08 /04A@4/01 89. <A8A3 C7C@. 6.23/01 A(& !!% /? 0A8 >3A4.5 ). ?;6</8? 8928 89. 5.@27 /0 B/@/01 89. CA<>@2/08 92? 6..0 >3A>.3@7 .F>@2/0.5 205 8928 89. 2CC/5.08 925 ACC;33.5 5;. 8A 89. 0.1@/1.0C. AB 89. 3/5.3AB89.ABB.05/014.9/C@.).CA08.05?892889.C9231.?9..8 92? 0A8 6..0 C92@@.01.5 67 89. 0?;320C. A<>207 205 89.3.BA3. 89. 3/6;02@ 92? B2?8.0.5 89. @/26/@/87 ;>A0 89. 0?;320C.A<>2072B8.32??.??/0189.CA<>.0?28/A02<A;08 ). ?;6</8? 8928 89. <.5/C2@ 3.CA35? =9/C9 ?9A=.5 B2@@ B3A< 6/D. CA;@5 924. 6..0 /08.3>3.8.5 8A <.20 8928 /8 =2? A0 - 5 - 2CCA;08 AB CA@@/?/A0 67 20A89.3 4.9/C@. ).0C. 9. ?..D? 3.2??.??<.08AB89..4/5.0C. & 89.@.230.5CA;0?.@BA33.?>A05.08A( =A;@5 ?;6</8 8928 89.3. 23. <A3. 8920 A0. C/3C;<?820C.? =9/C9 ?9A= 8928 89. <A8A3 C7C@. A=0.5 67 3.?>A05.08 A! 92?6..0B2@?.@7/<>@/C28.59.?;6</8?892889.5.@27AB#" 527?/0B/@/0189.CA<>@2/08+89.CA<>@2/020820589.A=0.3AB 89.ABB.05/01<A8A3C7C@.23.0A0..@?.892089.8=A?A0?AB 89.>.8/8/A0.3+<.08/A0.5/089.CA<>@2/08892889.CA<>@2/0208 925.0E;/3.589.3.?>A05.08A!6.BA3.B/@/0189.CA<>@2/08+ <.5/C2@ 3.CA35? ?9A=/01 89. C2;?. AB 89. /0:;37 2? GB2@@ B3A< 6/D.H+ 3.CA35? 924/01 0A8 6..0 >3A5;C.5 8A 5/?C235 89. ?;?>/C/A;? C/3C;<?820C.?+ 3.?>A05.08 A! D..>/01 ?2@/.08 5.?>/8.?.34/C.AB0A8/C.23.2@@89.C/3C;<?820C.?=9/C9?9A= 8928 89. <A8A3 C7C@. /0?;3.5 67 3.?>A05.08 A( =2? B2@?.@7 /<>@/C28.59.?;6</8?892889.3/6;02@92?3/198@72??.??.5 89..4/5.0C.2055/?</??.589.>.8/8/A0 ' 9.>.3;?2@AB89.*28F!=A;@5/05/C28.8928 89A;1989.2CC/5.088AAD>@2C.A0!&"(#!'28,##><89. CA<>@2/08=2?@A51.5A0(!"(#!'28,"%><9.CA<>@2/08 - 6 - <.08/A08928A0!&"(#!'89.CA<>@2/0208)A002>>22059/? <A89.3 /. 89. >.8/8/A0.3 =9/@. 8324.@@/01 A0 <A8A3 C7C@. 6.23/01A(&''%%?;BB.3.5202CC/5.088?828.?89282 <A8A3C7C@.3/5.36702<.0/@232?2>>22@A821/C2<.B3A< 6.9/05 A0 <A8A3 C7C@. A(& #!!% 205 52?9.5 B3A< 6.9/059.CA<>@2/08 <.08/A0 8928 9.2059/?.@5.363A89.3 =.3..0121.5/09/?2?=.@@2?9/?<A89.3H?83.28<.08205 2??;C989.3./?25.@27/0B/@/0189.CA<>@2/0882@?A<.08/A0 892889A;19>A@/C.925CA<.8A89.9A?>/82@A0!'#"(#!'9. 925?.0889.<62CD?27/0189289.=208?8ACA0?;@89/?B2</@7 <.<6.3? !# 8 /? 3.@.4208 8A 0A8. 8928 89. CA<>@2/08 0A=9.3. <.08/A0892889.<A8A3C7C@.A(& #!!%=2?A=0.567 0A0..@?.8920 9/? 63A89.3 2?24232: 9. CA<>@2/08 28 F! <.08/A089289.925.0E;/3.59/?63A89.3 2?;9/??9A=?8928 89.3. =2? CA0?;@828/A0 205 5.@/6.328/A0? BA3 A4.3 893.. 527? 6.BA3.B/@/0189.CA<>@2/08 !! 9. <.5/C2@ 3.CA35? .?>.C/2@@7 89. C.38/B/C28. /??;.5672?9A59232)A?>/82@28F?"205%?9A=892889. >.8/8/A0.32059.3?A0)A002>>2=.3.25</88.58A89.9A?>/82@ - 7 - =/8989.9/?8A37ABB2@@B3A<8=A=9..@.30.232<>;3A0 !&"(#!'089.?.5AC;<.08?89.3./?0A<.08/A0ABCA@@/?/A0 6789.ABB.05/014.9/C@. !( 9. H? 3.>A38 28 F =9/C9 /? >238 AB 89. C9231.?9..8 /05/C28.? 8928 89.3. =.3. </0A3 52<21.? 8A 89. ABB.05/014.9/C@.6;889.3.=.3.9.24752<21.?2889.B3A08AB 89.4.9/C@.A4.3=9/C989.>.8/8/A0.3=2?2>/@@/A03/5.39.3. /? C@.23 </?<28C9 26A;8 89. 52<21.? 8A 89. 4.9/C@. 205 89. 023328/A0/089.CA<>@2/08 ! 9A;19 89. >.8/8/A0.3 92? >3A5;C.5 89. 2@@.1.5 C2?.?9..8 AB 2012<2/ )A?>/82@ 205 2?9A59232 )A?>/82@ 28 F?!(205!89.75A0A8CA082/089.25</??/A00A8.?67 89.2?;2@87.5/C2@BB/C.382>>.23?892889.?.@.C8.5>21.? 2@A0. 23. >3A5;C.5 6.BA3. 89. 3/6;02@ 9. 0A8.? AB 89. .5/C2@ BB/C.3 =A;@5 924. ?9A=0 89. 9/?8A37 =/89 =9/C9 89. >.8/8/A0.3 =2? 25</88.5 8A 89. 9A?>/82@ 4/5.08@7 89. .1/?8.3F832C892?0A86..0>3A5;C.5 !" 8 /? >.38/0.08 8A 0A8. 8928 89. <A8A3 C7C@. A4.3 =9/C989.>.8/8/A0.3=2?2>/@@/A03/5.3=2?A=0.5670A0..@?. - 8 - 89209.39;?62052?<.08/A0.5/089.CA<>@2/0828F!9. ?2/54.9/C@.=2??./I.5;05.32>20C9202<22?<.08/A0.5/0 89.C9231.?9..89./80.??/?8?9A=?892889.<A8A3C7C@. A4.3=9/C989.>.8/8/A0.3=2?3/5/012?2>/@@/A0=2?0A8924/01 242@/5/0?;320C.9/?C/3C;<?820C.<2D.?89./04A@4.<.08AB 89. 4.9/C@. A=0.5 67 3.?>A05.08 A! 5A;68B;@ 9. 3.?>A05.08 A! /? 0A0. .@?. 8920 89. 20A89.3 ?A0 AB 89. >.8/8/A0.3 !% A3.A4.3 89.3. =2? 0A /<>.5/<.08 BA3 89. 3/5.3 )A002>>2=9A@A51.589.CA<>@2/088A89.>A@/C.8A<.08/A0 8928 89. ABB.05/01 4.9/C@. =2? A=0.5 67 0A0. .@?. 8920 9/? 63A89.3 2?24232: 4.0 89. >.8/8/A0 5A 0A8 <.08/A0 8928 2?24232: /? ?A0 AB 89. >.8/8/A0.3 8 /? 0A8 89. C2?. AB 89. >.8/8/A0.38928 2?24232:92??A@589.4.9/C@.8A2076A57.@?. 9.3.BA3.26A4.C/3C;<?820C.?C@.23@7/05/C28.8928>.8/8/A0.3 925?;?82/0.589./0:;3/.?67B2@@/01B3A<89.6/D.A=0.5679.3 9;?620553/4.0679.3?A0)A002>>2=9/C95/50A892589. /0?;320C. CA4.3 9.3. /? 0A 3.2?A0 8A 5A;68 89. <.5/C2@ 3.CA35?AB2?9A59232)A?>/82@ - 9 - ! 05.389.?.C/3C;<?820C.?89.CA0C@;?/A0?3.2C9.5 67 89. 3/6;02@ 2? 5/?C;??.5 /0 >232? !% 205 ! AB 89. /<>;10.5 :;51<.0823. >3A>.3 205 CA33.C8 9.3. /? 0A 0..5 BA3/05;@1.0C.6789/?A;38).0C.89.2>>.2@/?6.3.B8AB207 <.3/8?205@/26@.8A6.5/?</??.5 !, CCA35/01@789.2>>.2@/?5/?</??.5=/89CA?8? 5$ &$ ( $ 8?0J /?8A!@A'