- 1 - ! " #!$!%!! !!%% &' ( ! " # $% &'( )*(++#+ % # )*,++%# ! %- # #+ %+%* #" Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - +!#" *%$++) !. " #,/ 0 '( %+%%#* +# %+%$ 1 1 2 $ # 34567786945:498;<=>38:6>38?@:>38;8A8658; 6B69656< @C;6DE94 588F4CD 8C36CA8G8C> @: >38 A@G78C56>4@C 6D64C5> >38 E;DG8C> 6C; 6H6?; ;6>8; #* +$ %+%$ 76558; 4C @ '(%+%% <= >38 ?4CA4769 8C4@? 4B49 E;D8 6C; @GG4554@C8? :@? G79@=885 @G78C56>4@C4I6=67E?6!:@?53@?>J>38>?4<EC69K" % 38;8A8658;6B6956<@C;6DE94H65H@?F4CD65 6A986C8?EC;8?>388G79@=G8C>@:?857@C;8C>@ #6C;@C + +( %+%%38G8>H4>36C6AA4;8C>5E5>64C8;4CIE?4856C; ;48; 386D8@:>38;8A8658;H65%#=86?565@C>38;6>8 - 3 - @: >38 6AA4;8C> 88F4CD A@G78C56>4@C >38 A964G6C>:6>38? @: >38 ;8A8658; :498; 67794A6>4@C EC;8? 8A>4@C %% @: >38 A> :@? 6 5EG @: 5 %++++++) 69@CD H4>3 4C>8?85> 6> >38?6>8@:#,/78?6CCEG:?@G>38;6>8@:78>4>4@C>499>38 ;6>8 @: ?8694L6>4@C @C54;8?4CD >38 8C>4?8 8B4;8CA8 @C ?8A@?;>38>?4<EC696H6?;8;65EG@:5 #$%'++)69@CD H4>34C>8?85>6>>38?6>8@:#%/78?6CCEG:?@G+ +( %+%% 4 8 :?@G>38;6>8@:6AA4;8C>>499>38;6>8@:?8694L6>4@C@:>38 8C>4?8A@G78C56>4@C6G@EC> > 45 5E<G4>>8; >36> >38 ;8A8658; 6B6956< @C;6DE944 8 5@C@:>38A964G6C>H656A986C8?4C>38?EAF <86?4CD ?8D45>?6>4@C @ )%%),$,, 6C; 4> 45 5>6>8; >36> 38H6586?C4CD65EG@:5 %*+++)65G@C>39=H6D856C; 65EG@:5 #++)78?;6=65<36>>6 38>?4<EC69365>6F8C >38 4CA@G8 @: >38 ;8A8658; @C 9@H8? 54;8 6C; >38 34D38? ?898B6C>:6A>@?45695@>6F8C@C>38<6545@:3456D86C;>38 4C>8?85>45>@<88C36CA8;:?@G#%/>@#,/ $ 86?; >38 6?DEG8C>5 :?@G <@>3 54;85 6C; 78?E58;>38G6>8?4695796A8;@C?8A@?; - 4 - * 38A964G6C>365C@>7?@;EA8;6C=4CA@G87?@@: @:>38;8A8658;6B6956<@C;6DE94>@7?@B83454CA@G8 5 78?>386G8C;8;6L8>>8@>4:4A6>4@C;6>8;+ +# %+%+>38 4CA@G8 >38 ;8A8658; >@ <8 A@C54;8?8; 65 5 #*+++) 78? G@C>36C;*+/@:4>A@G85>@5 *++) 38;8A8658;H65 6D8; %# =86?5 6C; >38 ?898B6C> :6A>@? 45 %%% #/ A69AE96>4@C A@G85 >@ 5 #'+%*) E?>38? 6 5EG @: 5 *+++)456H6?;8;>@H6?;5:EC8?698M78C585 8CA8>38 >@>69 A@G78C56>4@C A@G85 >@ 5 #'*%*) 69@CD H4>3 4C>8?85>6>>38?6>8@:#%/:?@G>38;6>8@:6AA4;8C>>499>38 ;6>8@:?8694L6>4@C ' 86?C8; A@EC589 :@? >38 ?857@C;8C> @ %) C5E?6CA8A@G76C=5E<G4>5>36>>38A@G78C56>4@C6G@EC> 4 8 5 #$%'++) 69@CD H4>3 4C>8?85> 6> >38 ?6>8 @: #%/ 6H6?;8; <= >38 >?4<EC69 45 69?86;= ;87@54>8; <8:@?8 >38 >?4<EC69 AA@?;4CD9=>38:@99@H4CD@?;8?1 - 5 - !4" 3867786945699@H8;4C76?>- !44" 38 A964G6C> 45 8C>4>98 >@ >@>69 A@G78C56>4@C 5 #'*%*) 69@CD H4>3 4C>8?85> 6>>38?6>8@:#%/:?@G>38;6>8@:6AA4;8C>>499>38 ;6>8 @: ?8694L6>4@C 65 6D64C5> 5 #$%'++) 6H6?;8;<=>38>?4<EC69- !444" CB48H@:>385E<G4554@C@:>38986?C8; A@EC589 :@? >38 ?857@C;8C> @ %)C5E?6CA8 A@G76C=>38?857@C;8C>@ %)C5E?6CA8A@G76C= 45 ;4?8A>8; >@ ;87@54> >38 8C36CA8; A@G78C56>4@C @:5 %+%%*)69@CDH4>34C>8?85>6>>38?6>8@: #%/78?6CCEGH4>34C678?4@;@:@C8G@C>3 !4B" C 5EA3 ;87@54> >38 A964G6C> 45 78?G4>>8; >@ H4>3;?6H >38 8C>4?8 A@G78C56>4@C 6G@EC>69@CDH4>34C>8?85>6AA?E8;>38?8@C )*+ &%!! ' $ 45>@ 1#9@ 1%