Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 49666 (KAR)
DATTU JADHAV S/O NARSING JADHAV v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR
CRL.P/200985/2019 · 2025-12-09
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49666 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49666 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$"% ""
"
&' &()* & )) +
!"# $ %&
# '%
%
'%
%% %
#"! &
% %( &
'' ) !"#
$ &&
*+,
#- '' #"."
& '
! '
'
& #/#
"#0 ( #0
"#
'
''
#!#!0#! "! ( #!. ' ' ' &'
Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
& '
& ( &
& 1&
%
&&
234 56783+9:; 7:8383+9 34 *3<:; => 655?4:; +#" ?9;:, :583+9 +*26,683>66@6,3A ?,6A426 692386
" 4::A39@ B?64239@ +* 82: 7,+5::;39@4 7:9;39@ 39 +#0
"# 6,3439@ +?8 +* ,3C: +#/#
"#0 ,:@348:,:; => ?,6; +<35: 8683+9 3;6, 348,358 +9 82:
*3<: +* 82: 3D3< ?;@: 69; &' +?,8 ?,6; 3;6, 348,358 *+, 82: +**:95:4 7?93426=<: ?9;:, :583+94 #! #!0#! 69;"!,:6;E382 :583+9#!.+*82:
2:@348+*82:7,+4:5?83+9564:647,+F:58:;39 82: 5+C7<6398 <+;@:; => 82: F?,34;3583+96< 6243<;6, +9 #0" "#0 34 8268 +9 #/" "#0 +9: ,6A642 + &+83,6C %6;6C 7644:; 6E6> 39 69:427?,6 D3<<6@: 69;
C:C=:,4 +* 82: 5+CC?938> 26; @682:,:; 8+ 7:,*+,C 234 *?9:,6< ,38:4 39 >+ # 2: 4:5+9; ,:47+9;:98
- 3 -
6243<;6, 26D39@ 7:,C388:; 82: 463; 5+CC?938> 8+ =?,> 82:;:5:64:;3982:463;<69;7,+5::;:;8+82:47+86<+9@ E382234 486**8+:94?,:<6E*?< 5+9;?58+*82:=?,36< 834 6<<:@:; 8268 68 8234 F?958?,: 6 @,+?7 +* !"G" 7:,4+94 5+9434839@ +* =+82 C:9 69; E+C:9 6,C:; E382 4835A4 *+,C:; 82:C4:<D:4 398+ 69 ?9<6E*?< 644:C=<> 2:> 6<<:@:;<> 6=?4:; 82: 6243<;6, 39 *3<82> <69@?6@: 344?:;
82,:684 69; +=48,?58:; 23C 69; +82:, +**3536<4 *,+C *653<386839@ 82: =?,36< 39 E268 34 ;:45,3=:; 64 6 ;347?8:; <69; 9 82:4: 6<<:@683+94 82: 6243<;6, <+;@:; 82: 7,:4:985+C7<6398E23525?<C3968:;39,:@348,683+9+*82:
5,3C:<82+?@282:5+C7<639869;'
;+9+8;345<+4:+, 96C:82:7,:4:987:8383+9:,2:264=::9526,@:42::8:;
64 655?4:; +#" 4+<:<> +9 82: 6<<:@683+9 8268 2: E64 7,:4:986882:47+8E2:982:3953;:988++A7<65:
2:<:6,9:;5+?94:<*+,82:7:8383+9:,,:38:,6839@ 82: @,+?9;4 ?,@:; 39 82: 7:8383+9 5+98:9;4 8268 82: 526,@:42::8<65A469>C68:,36<5+99:5839@82:7:8383+9:, 8+82:6<<:@:;?9<6E*?<6584D:93*82::983,:7,+4:5?83+9
- 4 -
96,,683D: 34 655:78:; 64 8,?: 82: 526,@:42::8 ;+:4 9+8 688,3=?8: 69> +D:,8 658 8+ 82: 7:8383+9:, C?52 <:44 69> D3+<:98 5+9;?58 82,:684 +, 6=?43D: <69@?6@: ;3,:58:; 68 82: 4:5+9; ,:47+9;:98 6243<;6, 8 34 *?,82:, 4?=C388:;
8268 82+?@2 82: 526,@:42::8 E64 *3<:; 39 "# 82:
F?,34;3583+96< &6@348,68: 264 9+8 >:8 *,6C:; 526,@:4 2:,:*+,:5+9839?683+9+*5,3C396<7,+5::;39@46@6394882:
7:8383+9:, 39 82: 6=4:95: +* 47:53*35 69; 7,3C6 *653:
395?<768+,> C68:,36< E+?<; ,:4?<8 39 @,+44 6=?4: +* 82: 7,+5:44+*<6E
!
:, 5+98,6 82: <:6,9:; 3@2 +?,8 +D:,9C:98 <:6;:, E+?<; 4?=C38 8268 82: 526,@:42::8 C68:,36<4 ;+ 39;3568: 82: 7,:4:95: +* 82: 7:8383+9:, 68 82: 45:9: +* +55?,,:95: +9 82: ;68: +* 82: 3953;:98 E2:9 6 @,+?7 +* !"G" 39;3D3;?6<4 6<<:@:;<> ,:4348:; 82: =?,36< 69; 82,:68:9:; 82: 6243<;6, 55+,;39@ 8+ 82: 868: 4?52 7,:4:95:344?**353:98688234486@:8+7,+5::;6@6394882: 7:8383+9:,*+,+**:95:4,:<686=<:8+?9<6E*?<644:C=<>69; ,3+839@
- 5 -
6D39@ 2:6,; 82: <:6,9:; 5+?94:< +9 =+82 43;:4 69; +9 :H6C3939@ 82: C68:,36< 7<65:; +9 ,:5+,; 82: *+<<+E39@7+3986,34:4*+,5+943;:,683+9
!" #$%
/7:,?46<+*82:5+C7<639869;'
,:D:6<482689+ 39;3D3;?6< 96C:4 +* 64463<6984 +, 76,835376984 E:,:
C:983+9:; 82:,:39 2: 6243<;6,I4 @,3:D695: 34 8268 6 <6,@: @,+?7 +* !"G" 7:,4+94 =:56C: 6@3868:; ?7+9 <:6,939@826882:;:6;=+;>+*67:,4+9=:<+9@39@8+82:
&6,686 5+CC?938> E64 7:,C388:; 8+ =: =?,3:; 39 >+ # 69; 8268 ;:4738: 7+<35: 7,+8:583+9 82: @,+?7 +=48,?58:; 82: +**3536<4 6=?4:; 82: 6243<;6, 69; :D:9 6446?<8:;82:C
0 8 34 8,38: 8268 8+ 688,658 82: +**:95:4 7?93426=<: ?9;:, :583+94 #! #!0 69; #! +* 82: 82:
- 6 -
7,+4:5?83+9C?487,3C6*653::486=<34282::H348:95:+*69 ?9<6E*?< 644:C=<> 69; *?,82:, ;:C+948,68: 8268 82:
655?4:; E64 6 C:C=:, +* 4?52 644:C=<> 65839@ 39 *?,82:,695:+*3845+CC+9+=F:58 :583+9#!7,:45,3=:4 7?9342C:98 *+, C:,: C:C=:,4237 +* 69 ?9<6E*?< 644:C=<> =?8 4?52 C:C=:,4237 5699+8 =: 39*:,,:; +9 D6@?: +, 4E::739@ 6<<:@683+94- 82:,: C?48 =: 4+C:
7+4383D: C68:,36< 42+E39@ 8268 82: 655?4:; 426,:; 82:
5+CC+9+=F:58+*82:644:C=<> :583+9#!0,:<68:48+82:
+**:95: +* ,3+839@ E2352 9:5:446,3<> ,:B?3,:4 7,++* 8268 *+,5:+,D3+<:95:E64?4:;=>82:?9<6E*?<644:C=<>+,=> 69> C:C=:, 82:,:+* :583+9 #!
=:39@ 69 6@@,6D68:; *+,C+*,3+839@,:B?3,:4826882:655?4:;E646,C:;E382 6 ;:6;<> E:67+9 +, E382 69>8239@ E2352 ?4:; 64 6 E:67+9 +* +**:95: 34 <3A:<> 8+ 56?4: ;:682 +?,84 26D:
5+94348:98<> 2:<; 8268 C:,: 7,:4:95: 68 82: 7<65: +* +55?,,:95: E382+?8 69> +D:,8 658 +, :D3;:95: +* 426,39@ 82:5+CC+9+=F:5834394?**353:988+,+7:396939;3D3;?6< ?9;:, 82:4: 7,+D343+94 2: ?9;:,<>39@ 7,39537<: 34 8268
- 7 -
5,3C396< <36=3<38> *+, ?9<6E*?< 644:C=<> 34 5+948,?583D: 39 968?,: 69; C?48 82:,:*+,: =: 39D+A:; E382 56?83+9- E2:,: 82: 526,@:42::8 ;+:4 9+8 ,:D:6< 47:53*35 6584 +, 53,5?C48695:4 39;356839@ 8268 82: 655?4:; E64 6583D:<> 76,835376839@ 39 +, :95+?,6@39@ 82: 644:C=<>I4 ?9<6E*?< 5+CC+9 +=F:58 5+9839?683+9 +* 7,+5::;39@4 E+?<; 6C+?988+696=?4:+*7,+5:44
2+?@282:526,@:42::8C:,:<>39;3568:4826882:
7:8383+9:, E64 7,:4:98 68 82: 47+8- 38 ;+:4 9+8 688,3=?8:
69> 47:53*35 +D:,8 658 8+ 23C 2:,: 34 9+ C68:,36< 8+ ;:C+948,68: 8268 2: 426,:; 6 5+CC+9 +=F:58 E382 82:
6<<:@:; ?9<6E*?< 644:C=<> 8+ 5+CC38 ,3+839@ 6446?<8 +, +=48,?583+9+*7?=<354:,D6984&:,:7,:4:95:6882:45:9: E382+?8 69> 4?77+,839@ C68:,36< 39;356839@ 6583D: 76,83537683+9+,6426,:;?9<6E*?<5+CC+9+=F:585699+8 =: 6 =6434 8+ 5+C7:< 69 39;3D3;?6< 8+ *65: 6 *?<<*<:;@:;
5,3C396< 8,36< 2:,:*+,: 5+9839?683+9 +* 82: 7,+5::;39@4 6@63948 82: 7:8383+9:, E+?<; 6C+?98 8+ 69 6=?4: +* 82: <:@6<7,+5:44
- 8 -
.2:C68:,36<7<65:;+9,:5+,;*?,82:,,:D:6<48268 82:3953;:98677:6,48+26D:=::9*?:<<:;=><+9@4869;39@ ;347?8:4 69; ,3D6< 5<63C4 =:8E::9 8E+ *6583+94 ,:@6,;39@ =?,36<,3@284+D:,82:<69;8346E:<<,:5+@93J:;7,39537<:
8268 39 438?683+94 39D+<D39@ @,+?7 ,3D6<,3:4 38 34 5+CC+9 *+, 5+C7<6396984 8+ 3C7<3568: 6 <6,@: 9?C=:, +* 7:,4+94 39;345,3C3968:<> +?,84 82:,:*+,: C?48 56,:*?<<> 45,?8393J: 82: ,:5+,; 8+ ;:8:,C39: E2:82:, 47:53*35 69;
7,3C6 *653: C68:,36<4 :H348 6@63948 :652 96C:; 655?4:;
9 82: 7,:4:98 564: 6 82+,+?@2 :H6C39683+9 +* 82: 526,@:42::8,:D:6<49+395,3C396839@C68:,36<E2684+:D:, 6@63948 82: 7:8383+9:, *+, +**:95:4 7?93426=<: ?9;:, :583+94 #! #!0 #! 69; "! ,:6; E382 :583+9 #!. +* 82: 2: *658 8268 82: 564: 264 ,:C639:; 486@9698 4395: *3<39@ +* 82: 526,@:42::8 39
"# E382+?8 69> 7,+@,:44 39 *,6C39@ 526,@:4 *?,82:, *+,83*3:4 82: 5+95<?43+9 8268 6<<+E39@ 82: 7,+5::;39@4 8+ 5+9839?: E+?<; =: ?9F?48 69; +77,:443D: :95: 82: 7+398*+,C?<68:;6=+D:34694E:,:;39
- 9 -
#"'+,82:*+,:@+39@,:64+948234+?,87644:482: *+<<+E39@
3 2:5,3C396<7:8383+9346<<+E:;
33 2::983,:7,+5::;39@439+#0
"# 6,3439@ +?8 +* ,3C: +#/#
"#0 ,:@348:,:; => ?,6; +<35: 8683+9 3;6, 348,3587:9;39@=:*+,:82:3D3<?;@:69; &'+?,8?,6;*+,+**:95:47?93426=<: ?9;:, :583+94 #!
#!0 #! 69;"!,:6;E382 :583+9#!.+*82: 6,: 2:,:=> B?642:; 394+*6, 64 82: 7:8383+9:,345+95:,9:;
333 << 7:9;39@ 398:,<+5?8+,> 677<35683+94 3* 69>4869;;347+4:;+*
,* & "") %
348+ <+