Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 49660 (KAR)
PAVAN PAWAR v. VITHAL AND ANR
MFA/202047/2022 · 2025-09-22
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49660 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49660 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$$ !! %$&
'
! "
#
$%& '(
)
*+&+%,"
Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
",$ '
"
*+&+",
# -
"%",,
"! # #
"'"! #
# '$,%$,
+% ,"
#
#
#
#
- 3 -
. # /012/ 3/45 677869 45 94538: ;0< 6:=45540>
?43/ 3/8 @0>58>3 0; 986<>8: @01>589 ;0< A03/ 54:85
43 45 36B8> ;0< ;4>69:4570569
/4567786945;498:AC3/86778996>3$@964=6>3588B4>2 8>/6>@8=8>30;@0=78>56340>656?6<:8:AC3/8$::9 8>40< 4D49 1:28 E
696A1<624 /8<84>6;38< <8;8<<8:3065F3/8<4A1>69G;0<5/0<3!:638:',%,4> 0+% ,"
<48;;6@35986:4>230;494>20;@964=7834340>6<8 3/63
0> ,,,"
63 6A013 +,, 7= >86< >6>:
/6A6
6>B1< @<055
3/8 @964=6>3 690>2 ?43/ /45 ;<48>:5 ?8<8 7<0@88:4>2 0> =030<@C@98 A86<4>2 0$ % &+H,+&%& ;0< :<4>B4>2 386 ?/8> 3/8C ?8<8 536>:4>2>86<>6>:/6A6
633/6334=8
636>B8<A86<4>2 0$%& '(:<4D8>AC435:<4D8<4>6<65/6>:>829428>3
- 4 -
=6>>8<6>::65/8:303/8@964=6>36>:/45;<48>:556 <85193
3/8 @964=6>3 515364>8: 2<48D015 4>I1<485 /8 @964=6>3 ;498: 3/8 @964= 7834340> 588B4>2 @0=78>56340> /8 <4A1>69 6558558: 3/8 @0=78>56340> 6>: 76558: 3/8 6?6<: 84>2 622<48D8: AC 3/8 56=8
3/8 @964=6>3 ;498: 3/87<858>3677869588B4>28>/6>@8=8>30;@0=78>56340>
86<: 986<>8: @01>589 ;0< 3/8 6778996>3 6>: 986<>8:@01>589;0<<8570>:8>30$>51<6>@80=76>C
% 86<>8: @01>589 ;0< 3/8 6778996>3 ?019:
@0>38>: 3/63
3/8 @964=6>3 /65 51;;8<8: 2<48D015 4>I1<485 48 :8;0<=43C 0; <42/3 3/42/
;<6@31<8 0; <42/3 ;8=1< 6>:
03/8< 4>I1<485 0D8< 3/8 A0:C 6>: $0@30< ?/0 8J6=4>8: /4= /65 45518: :456A4943C @8<34;4@638$J", ?/8<84> 43 45 53638: 3/63 /8 /65 515364>8: :456A4943C 30 ?/098 A0:C 63 K 6>: 3/8 <4A1>69 /65 8<<8: 4> 36B4>2 3/8 :456A4943C 63 K
8 ;1<3/8< 51A=435 3/63 @0=78>56340>6?6<:8:1>:8<03/8</86:5450>3/890?8< 54:88;1<3/8<51A=4353/63;0<<8=0D690;4=796>353/8
- 5 -
@964=6>3 <8L14<85 8J78>585 0; 5%,
,,, $ 6>: 3/8 <4A1>69 /65 >03 6?6<:8: 6>C @0=78>56340> 30?6<:5 ;131<8 =8:4@69 8J78>585 43/ 3/858 /8 7<6C8: 30 6990? 3/8677869
+ 986<>8: @01>589 ;0< <8570>:8>3 0$>51<6>@80=76>C?019:@0>38>:3/633/8<4A1>69 /65 <42/39C 36B8> :456A4943C 6>: 6?6<:8: @0=78>56340> ?/4@/ 45 I153 6>: 7<078< 6>: 3/8<8 6<8 >0 2<01>:5 ;0< 8>/6>@8=8>343/3/858/87<6C8:30:45=4553/8677869
H 6D4>2 /86<: 986<>8: @01>5895
3/8 01<3 /65 78<158: 3/8 4=712>8: I1:2=8>3 6>: 03/8< =638<4695 796@8:0><8@0<:
' /8 @964=6>3 ?65 628: C86<5 6>: /8 45 62<4@1931<69 @00948 /8 :638 0; 6@@4:8>3 6>: 3/8 946A4943C 0> 3/8 >51<6>@8 0=76>C 6>: 628 0; 3/8 @964=6>3 6<8 >034>:457138
- 6 -
& $0@30<
?/0 8J6=4>8: 3/8 @964=6>3 /65 45518: :456A4943C @8<34;4@638$J", 6>: 53638: 3/63 3/8 @964=6>3 45 /6D4>2 :456A4943C 30 3/8 ?/098 A0:C 63 K /8 <4A1>69 /65 @0==4338: 6> 8<<0< 4> 36B4>2 3/8 :456A4943C 63 K 0>9C /8 <4A1>69 012/3 30 /6D8 36B8>
" <:0;3/8:456A4943C6553638:AC3/80@30<
?/4@/@0=85 30""K/8<4A1>69/65<42/39C677948:=19347948<65F"&G /84>@0=836B8>AC3/8<4A1>69635"%
+, $457<078< > D48?
0; 3/8 6A0D8
3/8 @964=6>3 45 8>34398: 30 @0=78>56340>30?6<:590550;;131<84>@0=8651>:8< 5"%
+, $J"J"&J""KM())**+
( /8<4A1>69/65<42/39C6?6<:8:@0=78>56340> 30?6<:5764>6>:51;;8<4>24>651=0;()+6>: 9055 0; 6=8>43485 4> 6 51= 0;()+- 6>:6950 ;0< =8:4@698J78>5850;(,+
", /8 @964=6>3 45 8>34398: 30 @0=78>56340> 30?6<:5 9055 0; 4>@0=8 :1<4>2 3<863=8>3 ;0< 6 78<40: 0;
- 7 -
3/<88=0>3/54>651=0;( +5"%
+, $J! 656264>535&
+,, $656?6<:8:AC3/8<4A1>69
"" /8 @964=6>3 ?65 6:=4338: 4> 0574369 ;0< ", :6C56>:3/8<8;0<8
/8458>34398:30@0=78>56340>30?6<:5 6338>:6>3 6>: @0>D8C6>@8 @/6<285 63 (+ 65 6264>535,
,,, $6?6<:8:AC3/8<4A1>69
" /8 :0@30< ?/0 8J6=4>8: 3/8 @964=6>3 /65 074>8: 3/63 ;0< <8=0D69 0; 4=796>3 /8 /65 30 578>3 5%,
,,, $ 6>: 3/8 <4A1>69 /65 >03 6?6<:8: 6>C @0=78>56340> 30?6<:5 ;131<8 =8:4@69 8J78>585 0>54:8<4>2 3/8 56=8
3/8 @964=6>3 45 8>34398: 30 ()+30?6<:5;131<8=8:4@698J78>585
" /15 3/8 @964=6>3 45 8>34398: 30 30369 @0=78>56340>1>:8<3/8;0990?4>2/86:5
- 8 -
-
./0( 1234 /5/60.07849. 6:723/- 1234 /5/60.078 49:(264
" 0550;;131<84>@0=8 5(
%, $ 5
&
+&, $
64>6>:51;;8<4>2 5,
,,, $ 5,
,,, $
8:4@698J78>585 5%+
"+H $ 5%+
"+H $ % 0550;4>@0=8:1<4>2 964:1778<40: 5&
+,, $ 5%
'+, $ + 338>:6>36>: @0>D8C6>@8@/6<285 5,
,,, $ 5",
,,, $ H 0550;6=8>43485 5,
,,, $ 5,
,,, $ ' #131<8=8:4@698J78>585 $$$$ 5,
,,, $ 4/- ( ;;,+ ( ,*,+ 39/3<.1.34 ( ;+
"% >D48?0;3/86A0D8
3/8;0990?4>2
4! /8677869456990?8:4>$76<3
44! /8I1:2=8>36>:6?6<::638:',%, 76558: 4>
0+% ," AC 3/8 $::9 8>40< 4D49 1:28 E 696A1<624
45=0:4;48:651>:8<
6! /8 6778996>3$@964=6>3 45 8>34398: 30 30369 @0=78>56340> 0; 5+
H
%&H $ 6264>53 5
++
((H $ 65 6?6<:8: AC 3/8<4A1>69690>2?43/4>38<853633/8
- 9 -
<638 0; HK 76 ;<0= 3/8 :638 0; 7834340>3499<8694N6340>-
A! 8570>:8>3 0$>51<6>@8 0=76>C 45 :4<8@38: 30 :870543 3/8 8>34<8 @0=78>56340>6=01>3?43/4>678<40:
0; 842/3 ?88B5 ;<0= 3/45 :6C
;6494>2 ?/4@/
435/69976C4>38<853633/8<638 0;(K76349976C=8>3
@! /8 <853 0; 3/8 0<:8< 0; 3/8 <4A1>69 <8=64>51>6938<8:
0+ %$$& #
" , 3-DB