- 1 - !"! #! $ %!#!! $ %! ! !## &'( )* ! !## + &'( ) * Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! " # # $ % %& ' ( ) #" *++ "* ,! ! *#!# $ " *++ "* ,! !*# !*# ( ) *#!!!+( ) "- - 3 - * + ! (!!!*+# "!*!+*! ,*!+*!) ' ( ". !#! & ) "" ()" ) / 0 $ " " $ !#!! & $& ! " "$ % +) * "- ( - ) ' ( ) - 4 - ! # # $ % %& * +! + #" *++ "* ,! ! *#!# , $ " - 5 - *++ "* ,! !*# !*# *#!!!+ ' ( " . +. ') + + , ! !#!*( "" ()" " $ !#!! ! $ "$ % " $ 1$ 1$ " % (1$ ) 23456728234925:;<9=28>;46723??288396=39538=; 672:;<9=283??234@9A>;467242=?;95296; 72=2 6B; 3??238= 342 >@825 3A3@9=6 672 C<5AD296 395 3B345 ?3==25 @9 ; ! :738829A@9A672E<396<D;>:;D?29=36@;93B34525FG672 - 6 - 4@F<9386;6726<92;>=+!! *>;467252367;>4@ 39<D39673 ; <663993 @9 3 4;35 3::@5296 6;;H ?83:2 ;9!! 72 >3:6<38 D364@I ;> :83@D396 F2>;42 672 4@F<938@==22H@9A672:;D?29=36@;9673672B3==6395@9A 36 3C;88@ F<= =6395 38;9A B@67 7@= :;8823A<2 4@9@J3= @9 ;4524 6; 366295 7@= 5;D2=6@: B;4H 36 6736 6@D2 42=?;95296 ; F2@9A 54@J24 ;> 672 ;44G F234@9A @6= 2A; *++ "* ,! :3D2 >4;D 3C383F3953 =@52 54;J2 @6 @9 7@A7 =?225 @9 3 43=7 395 92A8@A296 D39924 395 53=7253A3@9=67@D3=342=<8672735=<=63@925A4@2J;<= @9C<4@2= 395 =<::<DF25 6; 672 @9C<4@2= 29:2 :83@D ?26@6@;9 B3= >@825 FG 672 B@>2 ?34296= 395 38=; 672 :7@85429 :;96295@9A 6736 72 B3= B;4H@9A 3= 3A4@:<86<438 :;;8@2 395 2349@9A = !!! * ?24 D;967 72 8234925 :;<9=28 >;4 672 @9=<439:2 :;D?39G 3??23425 395 >@825 B4@6629 =6362D296 529G@9A 672 3J;:36@;9 395 38=; 672 @9:;D2 72 :83@D396 @9 ;4524 6; ?4;J2 672@4 :83@D 2I3D@925 672 *B@>2 343=@D73 395 38=; A;6 D34H25 - 7 - 5;:<D296=I 6; 72@9=<439:2:;D?39G9;68235 39G 2J@529:2 ;B2J24 A;6 D34H25 5;:<D296 I* @9=<439:2?;8@:G 72 4@F<938 73J@9A 63H29 @9:;D2 ;> = ! * 3B34525 :;D?29=36@;9 @9:8<5@9A 672 ><6<42 ?4;=?2:6<= <6 672 J24G :;96296@;9 ;> 672 @9=<439:2 :;D?39G 6736 672@9:;D2 63H29 = ! * @=;9 7@A724 =@52395:;D?29=36@;93B34525@=2I;4F@639639538=;;9 ;6724 7235= @6 @= ;9 7@A724 =@52 @9:8<5@9A 672 ><6<42 ?4;=?2:6<= 24 :;9643 8234925 :;<9=28 3??234@9A >;4 672 :83@D396= B;<85 =<FD@6 6736 4@F<938 63H29 672 @9:;D2 4@A768G = ! * F<6 :;D?29=36@;9 3B34525 ;9 ;6724 7235= @= J24G D23A24 ;98G 8;== ;> :;9=;46@<D 3B34525 =!!!! * 395 6439=?;4636@;9 395 ><6<42 ><92438 2I?29=2= = !!!! * 395 D29638 =7;:H 395 3A;9G 39 3D;<96 ;> = !!! * 395 8;== ;> 8;J2 395 3>>2:6@;9 =!!!!! *9388@6:;D2=6;=# !!! *395;<A76 - 8 - 6; 73J2 63H29 672 8;== ;> 8;J2 395 3>>2:6@;9 =!!!! * 23:7;>672=2B@>2?34296=39538=;672:7@85429672G342 @9 @9 9<DF24= 395 @6 :;D2= 6; =+!!!! * 395 38=; :;<9=28:;9629567362J29672><924382I?29=2=395;6724 2I?29=2= ;> =!!!! * B3= 9;6 63H29 395 38=; :;<9=28 B;<85=<FD@66736!K73=6;F235525 # 3J@9A 72345 672 8234925 :;<9=28 >;4 672 3??288396= 395 8234925 :;<9=28 3??234@9A >;4 672 42=?;95296 ; 395 38=; :;9=@524@9A 672 D3624@38 395 42:;45 72 ?;@96= 6736 B;<85 34@=2 >;4 :;9=@52436@;9 ;> 67@=;<46342 (@) 726724 672 4@F<938 :;DD@6625 39 244;4 @9 3B345@9A 2I;4F@6396 :;D?29=36@;9 3= :;9629625 FG 672 @9=<439:2:;D?39GL (@@) 726724 82==24 :;D?29=36@;9 B3= 3B34525 FG 672 4@F<938 3= :;9629525 FG672:83@D396=/:;<9=28L (@@@) 736;4524L - 9 - 3J@9A :;9=@52425 672 D3624@38 ;942:;45 @6@= 9;6 @9 5@=?<62 6736 3::@5296 B3= 63H29 ?83:2 @9 672 G234 ! 72 52:23=25 @= <9=H@8825 83F;<4 @2 3A4@:<86<42 :;;8@2 395 729:2 =<:7 F2@9A 672 :3=2 4@A768G 63H29 672 @9:;D2 ;> = ! * 395 38=; 73J@9A :;9=@52425 672 D<86@?8@24 35525 ><6<42 ?4;=?2:6<= 395 9; 5@=?<62 B@67 42A3456;63H@9A;>@9:;D239538=;3==2==D296;>8;==;> 52?29529:G<6672>3:6@=6736B729672:83@D396=342 @9 9<DF24= 395 67242 @= 3 >;4:2 @9 672 :;96296@;9 ;> 672 :;<9=28 3??234@9A >;4 672 :83@D396= 6736 @9 J@2B ;> 672 1 ;<A76 6; 73J2 3B34525 =!!!! * 23:7;967252?295296:83@D396=395729:2;<A766;73J2 63H29 672 =3D2 36 =+!!!! * 395 3?346 >4;D 6736 =!!!! * 6;B345= 672 ><92438 395 8;== ;> 2=6362 395 38=; 4@A768G ?;@9625 ;<6 FG 672 :;<9=28 3??234@9A >;4 672 :83@D396=6736!K;<A766;73J2F22935525 7242@= 1 !+$+ - 10 - 9; 5@=?<62 B@67 42A345 6; 672 :38:<836@;9 @= :;9:249 42A345@9A 63H@9A ;> @9:;D2 D<86@?8@24 3= B288 3= ><6<42 ?4;=?2:6<= 98G :;96296@;9 ;> 672 :83@D396= 6736 ;6724 7235=82==24:;D?29=36@;9@=A@J29673667242@=3>;4:2@9 672:;96296@;9;>672:;<9=283??234@9A>;4672:83@D396= 29:2 42J@=@625 B@67 42A345 6; 672 :83@D @= :;9:249 42A345@9A 8;== ;> 52?29529:G 9; 5@=?<62 @2 =++!! * 395 ;9 ;6724 7235= >@8@38 :;9=;46@<D 39 3D;<96;>=+!!!! *3953?346>4;D6736=!!!! * 6;B345=6728;==;>2=6362395><924382I?29=2=39538=; 355@9A ;> 672 =3D2 !K @6 :;D2=6; =!!! * 9 388 = ) 3= 3A3@9=6 =+!! * ::;45@9A8G 672 =3D2 @= D;5@>@25 3B345@9A 672 :;D?29=36@;9 - ) 3= 3A3@9=6 =+!! * ;B B@67 42A3456;672@96242=6@=:;9:24925672 4@F<938?3==2539 ;4524@9:3=2;>52>3<86@9?3GD296;>67252?;=@6@9A;>672 3D;<96B@67@96@D2?24@;5;>D;967=672@96242=6B;<85 F2K395;<A769;66;73J25@42:625?3G672@96242=636 - 11 - 6724362;>K?3;9672=3D242E<@42=6;F2D;5@>@25 3=#K + 9J@2B;>6725@=:<==@;9=D3523F;J2B2?3== 672>;88;B@9A ;676723??238=342388;B25@9?346 @67 42A345 6; 672 E<396<D 3= :;9629525 FG 672 @9=<439:2 :;D?39G @= 5@=D@==25 F<6 B@67 42A345 6; @96242=6 @= :;9:249672=3D2@=425<:256;#K3=3A3@9=6 K@9:3=2;>52>3<866723??238>@825FG672 :83@D396= @= 388;B25 @9 ?346 A4396@9A :;D?29=36@;9 ;> - ) 3= 3A3@9=6 =+!! *B@67@96242=6;>#K?3 D;<96@952?;=@6D352FG672@9=<439:2 :;D?39GF2>;4267@=;<46@>39G ;4524256; 6439=D@6 672=3D2 6; 4@F<938 >;467B@67 38;9A - 12 - B@67 @96242=6 3::4<25 72 F3839:2 3D;<96 @= ?3G3F82B@67@9#B22H=>4;D6;53G !.) &#!!( % !.) &( % @=6;8;! $