- 1 - ! "! #$!%!$$ $ & '()* '!!)+ , ! ! ! " #$% &' ( ) "* Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ " # $ &+ , "" # &' ( ) $- "* $ $ + $ # '.+ ) +'+ " * $ $ " ! ! $ $ " $ $ $$ .,)*++' ,$ $$ / ! - 3 - ) / ! * 0121234056702489::;60<3613 243'. + 34 1=0 >2?0 3> 1=0 ?09540< 04235 2@2? !;<80 94< ! $ =359A;5 B>35 6=351 C1=0 529? 3;51DE )24 52F0 3'+ 3> 0F7=9@2 3?2:0 191234* 950 600G248 13 H;96=1=0 :52F249? A53:00<2486 24212910< 9892461 1=0F >35 1=0 3>>04:06 A;426=97?0 ;4<05 0:12346 . ,++'509<I21=0:1234,3> 095< 52 5;4G;F95 F958;4<9AA9 ?09540< :3;460? >35 1=0 A0121234056 94< F1 5912 912? ?09540< 28= 3;51 3@054F041 ?09<05 >35 506A34<041 3 J 191006A34<04131=3;8=605@0<=9650F9240<;4& 50A5060410< 4 @20I 3> 1=0 52@9? :3410412346 ;580< 7K 1=0 ?09540<:3;460?>35731=1=0A9512061=0A32411=91I3;?< 95260>35FK:3462<059123426 - 4 - !"# K946I05131=0973@0A32412624 >35 1=0>3??3I248 !! 06A34<0413=96>2?0<>256124>35F91234I21= 0F7=9@2 3?2:0 191234 9892461 9::;60< 36 13 9??08248 :3FF266234 3> 1=0 3>>04:06 A;426=97?0 ;4<05 0:12346 . , + +' 509< I21= 0:1234,3> 94<1=0$:9F01370508261050<24 52F0 3'+ 3> 0F7=9@2 3?2:0 191234 34 ++ 6 A05 1=0 9??08912346 F9<0 24 1=0 >2561 24>35F912341=024:2<041=9<3::;550<34+94< 1=0 509634 >35 1=0 <0?9K 24 >2?248 1=0 >2561 24>35F91234 26 1=91 6=0 <26:;660< I21= =05 50?912@06 94< >2?0< 1=0 >2561 24>35F9123470?910<?K - 5 - =0 F910529?6 34 50:35< <26:?360 1=91 506A34<041 3 =9< F95520< 9::;60< 3 34 ++ 4?K >35 63F0 A0523< 6=0 5062<0< 24 1=0 F9152F3429? =3;60 94< 1=0509>105 6=0 501;540< 13 =05 A950419?=3;60=0A0121234056=9@0A53<;:0<:3AK3>1=0 98500F041 61K?0< 96 L$ $ % &M <910< +'+'+ 6 A05 1=26 98500F041 041050< 2413 701I004 9::;60< 3 94< 506A34<041 3 24 1=0 A50604:0 3> 31=05 I21406606 50>0550< 13 1=05024 506A34<0413=969::0A10<96;F3>6+++++&13 82@0 :346041 >35 <2663?;1234 3> F9552980 =0 <3:;F041 9?63 50>056 13 A9KF041 3> 6+++++& 13 506A34<041 37K9::;60<3241=0A50604:03>I21406606 ' 1 26 61910< 1=91 506A34<041 3 =96 >2?0< 5? 26:3+70>3501=0?09540<042352@2?!;<80 94< ! $ =359A;5 <;5248 :13705 + :?92F248 F92410494:0 9892461 9::;60< 3 ;4<05 0:1234 5 =0 69F0 26 A04<248 :3462<0591234 94< 24 1=0 F09412F01=0A506041:3FA?9241:9F01370>2?0< - 6 - . 4 A05;69? 3> 1=0 >2561 24>35F91234 ?3<80< 7K 506A34<0413>35:3FF2662343>1=03>>04:0A;426=97?0 ;4<05 0:1234 , 21 26 13 70 4312:0< 1=91 79?< 94< 804059?9??08912346I21=3;194K6A0:2>2:<0192?6950F9<0 3I0@05 21 26 61910< 1=91 34 + 91 '++ 9F 9::;60< 36 13 :9F0 13 =05 A950416D =3;60 97;60< 506A34<041 3 24 >2?1=K ?948;980 9::;60< 3 A;??0< =05 =925 9669;?10< 94< G2:G0< =05 9::;60< 36 94< 9669;?10< =05 I21= =94<6 9::;60< 3 1520< 13 3;15980 =05 F3<061K 94< 9?? 1=0 9::;60< =9@0 :52F249??K 2412F2<910<=05 >10519G2482413:3462<05912341=0>9:11=911=0 A012123405 =96 A53<;:0< :3AK 3> 1=0 <3:;F041 61K?0< 96 L$ $ % &M <910< +'+'+ 13 :34104< 1=91 <;5248 !;40 + 506A34<041 3 =96 9::0A10< 9 6;F 3> 6+++++& 94< 1=0 F9552980 I96 <2663?@0< 24 1=0 A50604:0 3> A94:=96 94< ?9105 >2?0< 1=0 >2561 24>35F91234 70?910<?K 966;F06 2FA35194:0 - 7 - 0A0910<?K 4312:06 I050 266;0< 13 506A34<041 3 1=53;8= 3;51A3?2:0 94< 9?63 7K 605@248 1=0 :3;460? 50A506041248 506A34<041 3 24 5? 26:3+ 46A2103>1=916=050F9240<97604194<=96431:=360413 9AA095 70>350 1=0 3;51 ?? 1=060 >9:16 94< :25:;F6194:06 82@0 5260 13 9 50963497?0 <3;71 973;1 1=0 :341041234 19G04 7K 506A34<041 3 50895<248 :3FF266234 3> 1=0 3>>04:0 @04 1=3;8= 1=0 98500F041 61K?0<96L$$ % &M50?20<7K1=0 A0121234056I2??431=9@094K?089?694:121K13:34104<1=91 1=050 I96 <2663?;1234 3> F9552980 1=0 >9:1 50F9246 1=91 96A051=26<3:;F0419=0>1K6;F3>6+++++&I96 A92<7K9::;60<313506A34<0413>35<2663?;12343> F9552980>1=26>9:12613709<F2110<1=0:3410412343> 506A34<04131=9134+9??1=09::;60<:9F0 94<:3FF2110<1=03>>04:024=05A950419?=3;6026=95<13 70?20@0 1=91 133 I=04 5? 26:3+ I96 >2?0< <;5248 :13705+ 600G248 F92410494:0 >53F 9::;60< 3 - 8 - , =0 4@0612891248 >>2:05 =96 24@06128910< 2413 1=0 F91105 94< >2?0< 1=0 :=9580 6=001 3 I3;4< :0512>2:910 26 A53<;:0< 9?348 I21= 1=0 >249? 50A351 > 1=0 9??08912346 F9<0 7K 506A34<041 3 26 13 70 19G04 2413 :3462<0591234 6=0 F;61 =9@0 6;619240< 24N;5206 I=04 9::;60<3613=9@075;19??K9669;?10<=05G2:G0<=05 94<1520<133;15980=05F3<061K41=097604:03>94K 6;:= F910529?6 9F 3> 1=0 3A24234 1=91 :34124;91234 3> :52F249? A53:00<2486 9892461 1=0 A0121234056262497;603>A53:0663>?9I94<1=069F026 ?297?0 13 70 H;96=0< ::35<248?K 946I05 1=0 973@0 A3241241=0C9>>25F912@0D94<A53:00<13A9661=0>3??3I248 )2* =0A012123426 )22* 04<248 :52F249? A53:00<2486 24212910< 98924611=0A01212340562452F03'+ 3> 0F7=9@2 3?2:0 191234 A04<248 24 3'.+ 34 1=0 >2?0 3> ?09540< 042352@2?!;<8094<! $=359A;5>35 1=0 3>>04:06 A;426=97?0 ;4<05 0:12346 - 9 - ., + +'509< I21= 0:1234 , 3> 26 =0507K !-* '$$) % 2613?3