Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 49645 (KAR)
QUASIM ALI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/201482/2025 · 2025-10-27
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49645 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49645 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#$%$$
$
& &'() (( *
! ! "# $#%
&' ( #
##)
#* ## # '
'# ' ' ##*
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#+! #$
## ,##
'
&' (' #
#'*- )
# '
*
*'( )
*
+!(
$) '
$ # '
# '#
. *
"
" *
+ +++ /
* # **
'
#
()( ) , ! !() !() * + * #
'
* *#
' #'
# '
* # $ #
#
0
"#
#
('#
0
"#
#
)
12345678 27343456 49 :4;78 <= :13>7? <?53>7? 168 94937? 5: 1@@A978 5 977B46C DA19>46C 5: 3>7 2?5@77846C9 276846C 46
5 +:5? 3>75::76@79 2A649>1<;7A687?7@34569 ()(E),!!()168
- 3 -
!() 5: >1?134=1
=1=1 16>431 +! 1?4946C 5A3 5:
?4E7
5 +5: A8>5;'5;4@7313456
>7<?47::1@395:3>72?597@A3456@1971?73>13 1@@A978
5<746C3>79565:1@@A978
5491;;7C7835 >1F7 7931<;49>78 2>=94@1; ?7;134569 G43> 3>7 97@568 ?792568763@5E2;146163563>7:1;972?737H35:E1??41C7 3 49 :A?3>7? 1;;7C78 3>13 8A?46C 1 9A<97DA763 216@>1=13 @56F7678 46 ?7;13456 35 3>7 9148 46@48763 3>7 2?79763 273434567?9 1<A978 168 >AE4;41378 3>7 @5E2;146163 ;71846C 35 3>7 ?7C493?13456 5: 3>7 2?79763 @?4E7 >7 G?43376 @5E2;1463 ;58C78 <= 3>7 97@568 ?792568763 @A;E46137846?7C493?134565:3>7*1681:37?@5E2;73456 5:46F7934C134561@>1?C79>773>1965G<776:4;781C14693 3>71@@A97827?9569 ! #71?8 3>7 ;71?678 @5A697; 12271?46C :5? 3>7 273434567?9 168 3>7 ;71?678 #4C> 5A?3 5F7?6E763 ';7187? ?72?7976346C ?792568763
5I3137 >7?7 49 65
- 4 -
?72?79763134565?@563793353>72?797632734345656<7>1;:
5:?792568763
5I@5E2;146163
7:5?7 18F7?346C 35 3>7 ?4F1; @5637634569 168 7H1E4646C 3>7 @197 56 439 E7?439 3>49 5A?3 877E9 43 122?52?4137 35 7H3?1@3 3>7 ?7;7F163 25?3456 5: 3>7 G?43376 @5E2;1463 ;58C78 <= 3>7 97@568 ?792568763 G>4@> ?7189 19:5;;5G9
! "#$$%& '( )* +,&-./ -01&+*)( '. 2 3! 4,. 5 6 78 " 9 6(" 0$ 7* + : 3 ;+, 1 <%& =, 3%& 9 ;
>? @"AB
>? @C%&=+=;67 DE
627?A91;5:3>7?7;7F16325?34565:3>7G?43376 @5E2;1463 43 49 7F48763 3>13 3>7 56;= ?7E537 1;;7C13456 ;7F7;;78 1C14693 3>7 2?79763 273434567?9 49 3>13 8A?46C 1 216@>1=13 @56F7678 <73G776 3>7 :1E4;479 5: 3>7 @5E2;146163 168 3>7 1@@A978 3>7 273434567?9 1;;7C78;= 1<A978 3>7 97@568 ?792568763 3 49 :A?3>7? 931378 3>13
- 5 -
273434567? 51@@A978
5 >18 199A?78 21=E763 5:
++++++ 35 3>7 @5E2;146163 168 >18 2?525978 35 1??16C7 3>7 E1??41C7 5: 1@@A978
5 G43> 1653>7? G5E16 H@723 :5? 3>797 F1CA7 168 5E64<A9 1997?34569 3>7?71?71<95;A37;=65927@4:4@5?46@?4E461346C1;;7C134569 133?4<A346C16=5F7?31@3353>7273434567?9951935JA934:= 3>74?
2?597@A3456:5?3>7 5::76@791;;7C78 >7@5E2;1463 7F76 4: 1@@72378 13 439 :1@7 F1;A7 8579 653 849@;597 3>7 79976341; 46C?7847639 @569343A346C 3>7 5::76@79 46F5B78 1C146933>797273434567?9
@1?7:A;?71846C5:3>77634?7@5E2;1463G5A;8 ?7F71; 3>13 3>7 C493 5: 3>7 1@@A913456 49 @7637?78 1?5A68 1@@A978
5 G>5 49 1;;7C78 35 >1F7 >18 2>=94@1;
?7;134569 G43> 3>7 @5E2;146163 56 1 :1;97 2?5E497 5: E1??41C7>7E137?41;956?7@5?8A6E4931B1<;=9>5G3>13 3>797@568?7925687631681@@A978
5G7?7@56976346C 18A;39168>181@569769A1;97HA1;?7;134569>42$>73>7? 9A@>@568A@35:1@@A978
51E5A63935165::76@7491 E1337? :5? @569487?13456 46 122?52?4137 2?5@77846C9-
- 6 -
>5G7F7? 1@@A978
5 653 <746C <7:5?7 3>49 5A?3 3>49 5A?3?7:?1469:?5E7H2?79946C16=5246456563>131927@3
695:1? 19 3>7 2?79763 273434567?9 1?7 @56@7?6783>7?7491@5E2;7371<976@75:16=E137?41;35 9ACC7933>74?46F5;F7E763463>71;;7C781@39@569343A346C 3>7 5::76@79 A687? 3>7 >1?134=1
=1=1 16>431 +! >77634?7@5E2;146313439>4C>793?7F71;93>131:37?3>7 ?7;134569>42 <73G776 1@@A978
5 168 3>7 @5E2;146163 95A?781216@>1=13G19>7;8G>7?73>7:1E4;=E7E<7?9 5:1@@A978
5G7?71;952?79763>7E7?721?34@4213456 46 9A@> 1 E77346C 168 3>7 1;;7C78 7H@>16C7 5: G5?89 G43>5A3 16= @56@?737 5? 927@4:4@ 1@3 @569343A346C 16 5::76@7@16653133?1@3@?4E461;;41<4;43=
3 49 1221?763 3>13 3>7 @5E2;146163 <746C 1CC?47F78 <= 3>7 27?9561; ?7;134569>42 653 @A;E461346C 46 E1??41C7 >19 @>5976 35 :1;97;= 4E2;4@137 3>7 :1E4;= E7E<7?9 5: 1@@A978
5 61E7;= >49 1C78 :13>7? 168 94<;46C919161@35:?731;413456A@>1@5A?971E5A63935
- 7 -
@;71? E49A97 5: 3>7 @?4E461; 2?5@799 168 16 1337E23 35 7H7?3 A68A7 2?799A?7 56 3>7 2?46@421; 1@@A978 >7 273434567?9 G>5 1?7 3>7 :13>7? <?53>7? 168 94937? 5:
1@@A978
5 @16653 <7 E187 35 :1@7 3>7 ?4C5A?9 5: 1 @?4E461; 3?41; 46 3>7 1<976@7 5: 16= 927@4:4@ @?784<;7 5? ;7C1;;=9A931461<;71@@A913456 , '73434567? 5 49 1C78 1<5A3 =71?9 168 273434567?9
59 168 ! 1?7 E7?7;= 94<;46C9 5: 1@@A978 5 G>5 12271? 35 >1F7 <776 8?1CC78 4635 3>7 2?5@77846C956;=<7@1A975:3>74?:1E4;41;?7;134569>42G43> 3>7 2?46@421; 1@@A978 '7?E43346C 3>7 @56346A13456 5: 3>7 @?4E461;2?5@77846C91C146933>7E87924373>71<976@75:
16= E137?41; 7F4876@7 G5A;8 1E5A63 35 1<A97 5: 3>7 2?5@7995:;1G168G5A;8@1A97C?1F746JA934@7 + 6 3>7 @569487?78 5246456 5: 3>49 5A?3 3>7 :1@395:3>72?79763@197G1??1637H7?@4975:3>746>7?763 JA?4984@3456 A687? 7@3456 5: 3>7 >1?134=1
1C1?4B
- 8 -
A?1B9>116>431+!352?7F7639A@>1<A975:2?5@799 1683597@A?73>776895:JA934@7
>7?4E461;'7343456491;;5G78 >72?5@77846C946
5 +276846C<7:5?7 3>7 JA?4984@34561; 1C493?137 :5? 3>7 5::76@79 2A649>1<;7 A687?7@34569 ()(E),!!()168!()5:3>7 >1?134=1
=1=1 16>431 +! 1?4946C 5A3 5: ?4E7 5 +5: A8>5;'5;4@73134564695:1?193>7=?7;137 353>72?79763273434567?91?7>7?7<=DA19>78
+) &$$( %
493
5;
5