Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 49635 (KAR)
BALARAJ MANIKAM v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/201373/2025 · 2025-09-22
M G Uma
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49635 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49635 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "!#
$#!%!## #
&' #
#
()*(+,&)(!!,,
&
'
! "
#
#
! "
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
# $
# ! "
%
# !"
&$''( #
## !"!"(!"&!'"!("'!"!" !'" ' & $'%
# ''
# #
&
'
'% )
! "
#
#
*(%(
! "
# $
# ! "
%
# !"
&$''(
#
# #
#
##
!"
- 3 -
!"(!"&!'"!("'!"!"!'"' &$'%
#''
&
'
'$
! "
#
#
! "
# $
# ! "
%
# !"
&$''(
#
# #
#
##
!" !"(!"&!'"!("'!"!"!'"' &$'%
#''
#
- 4 -
+
## ! + "
,- .-/0/012-34 02 /,-4- .-/0/0124 5-026 78894-: 14 ( 72: & 3-4.-8/0;-<= 02 30>- 1&$''( 1? 72769<0 1<08- /7/012 0@7=7.93 937< 038<- 73- 5-?13- /,04193/4--A0266372/1?570<92:-3-8/012%1?/,- ,737/0=776730A937A4,772,0/7''3-604/-3-:?13 /,- 1??-28-4 .9204,75<- 92:-3 -8/0124 !" !" (!" &!'" !(" '!" !" 72: !'" ' & $ 72: '% 1? /,- ,737/0=7 =7=7 72,0/7 '' !?13 4,13/ BC" .-2:026 12 /,- ?0<- 1? /,- <-732-: ::0/0127< -2013 0;0< 9:6- 72: # 193/ 747;727 76-D7:0
' 028-02/,-4-874-4/,-81>.<70272/0447>- :--> 0/ 7..31.307/- /1 /7A- 9. 7<< /,-4- 874-4 ?13 :04.147<92:-3/,0481>>1213:-3
- 5 -
,- ?78/4 1? /,- 874- 02 530-? 73- /,7/ /,- -2013 7276-3 1? 72737 72A 72769<0 3728, <1:6-:
/,- ?034/ 02?13>7/012 D0/, 72769<0 .1<08- 12 '&(''( 4/7/026 /,7/ 12 '(''( 7/ %( ,1934 /,- 4/3126 311> 72: 572A .3->04-4 D-3- <18A-: 72: 5936<73 7<73> D74 .9/ 12 206,/ >1:- ,- 2-E/ /D1 :7=4 0- '(''( 72: '((''( D-3- 6-2-37< ,1<0:7=4 /,-= 5-026 ?193/, 7/93:7= 72: 92:7=
2 '((''( 7/ 7> 12- 1? /,- 49513:027/- 4/7?? 02*8,736- 1? 47?-/= 1? /,- 53728, 21/08-: /,7/ /,- <18A .9/ /1 /,- 31<<0264,9//-3D74531A-2 >>-:07/-<=,-02?13>-:/,04 ?78//1/,-02?13>72/8813:026<=/,-02?13>72/394,-:/1 /,-4.1/72:21/08-:/,7//,-<18A.9//1/,->7024,9//-3 72:D02:1D630<<41?/,-53728,D-3-89/72:3->1;-:- 02?13>-: /,04 ?78/ /1 ,04 ,06,-3 1??08-3 72: 02/0>7/-: /,- .1<08-
2;-30?087/012,-?192:/,7//,->702:1131?/,- 4/3126 311> D74 1.-2-: 72: /D1 31:4 1? 630<< 67/- 1? 4/3126311>D-3-89/72:5-2/1D-;-3/,-4/3126311> :113D7402/78/D0/,19/72=:7>76--154-3;-:/,7/02
- 6 -
12- 1? /,- 4/--< 7<>037,4 812/702026 61<: @-D-<<-3= D74 ->./= 72: )61<: .78A-/4 D-06,026 ($%$ 637>4 1? 61<: D74 ?192: >044026 )' 637>4 1? 61<: @-D-<<-3= D-3- ?192: 02 /,- 53728, ,-3- 72: /,-3- 72: /,94 0/ 04 4/7/-:/,7//,-61<:@-D-<<-3=D-06,026(%$)&$637>4 D13/, 4('& 313-4 D74 4/1<-2 ,- 02?13>72/ 7<41 02?13>-: /,7/ 721/,-3 7<>037, 94-: ?13 4/13026 1?
874, D747<41?192:1.-272:874,1?4('(*D74?192:
4/1<-2 /D74?192:/,7//,-7<126D0/,,73: :04AD-3-7<414/1<-2,-3-?13-0/04494.-8/-:/,7/0/047 .3-*.<722-: 78/ -E-89/-: 5-/D--2 '(''( * $ ,1934 72: '((''( F ,1934 ,- 02?13>72/ 4/7/-:/,7//,-3-D74:-<7=02?0<026/,-81>.<702/:9-/1 /7A026/,-788192/1?/,-3->70202661<:.78A-/47;70<75<- 02/,-53728,/1744-44/,-78/97<61<:72:874,/,7/D74 4/1<-2 ,-3-?13- ,- 3-G9-4/-: /,- .1<08- /1 3-604/-3 /,- 874-72:020/07/-<-67<78/0128813:026<=/,-# 87>-/1 5- 3-604/-3-: 767024/ 92A21D2 .-34124 ?13 /,- 1??-28-4 .9204,75<- 92:-3 -8/0124 !" !" (!"
- 7 -
&!'" !(" '!" !" 72: !'" ' & $ 72: '%1?72:/,-02;-4/067/012D7492:-3/7A-293026 02;-4/067/012 74 >72= 74 ( .-34124 D-3- 733-4/-:
028<9:026 /,-4- .-/0/012-34 D,1 73- 7337=-: 74 78894-: 14 ( 72: & ,- .-/0/012-34 73- 5-?13- /,04 193/ 4--A0266372/1?570<
-73: 30 7:72 -4,.72:- <-732-: 81924-< ?13/,-.-/0/012-3472:301.7<A304,277:7;<-732-: 06,193/1;-32>-2/ <-7:-3?13/,-3-4.12:-2/*/7/- -394-:/,->7/-307<4123-813:
( 2 ;0-D 1? /,- 30;7< 812/-2/0124 936-: 5= /,- <-732-:81924-<?1351/,/,-.73/0-4/,-.102//,7/D19<: 7304-?13>=81240:-37/01204
=724D-3/1/,-751;-.102/0402/,-B C?13 /,-?1<<1D026
- 8 -
!! & / 04 /,- 812/-2/012 1? /,- <-732-: 81924-< ?13 /,-.-/0/012-34/,7//,-3-D740<<-67<7..3-,-240121?/,- .-/0/012-3*78894-: 1 12 '&''( D0/,19/ /,-3- 5-02672=733-4/72:,-D740<<-67<<=:-/702-:02894/1:= ,- ?7/,-3 1? 78894-: 1 ,7: ?0<-: 7 75-74 13.94 .-/0/012 5-?13- /,04 193/ 1D-;-3 /,- 2;-4/067/026 ??08-3 ,74 ?0<-: ,04 7??0:7;0/ 4/7/026 /,7/ 78894-: 1 D74 7..3-,-2:-: 02 8122-8/012 D0/, /,- .3-4-2/ 830>027< 874- 72: /7A026 02/1 81240:-37/012 /,- 47>- /,- 75-74 13.94 .-/0/012 87>- /1 5- 8<14-: 1D-;-3 <05-3/= D74 3-4-3;-:D0/,78894-:1/13704-498,0449-5-?13-/,- <-732-:7604/37/- ) -732-: 81924-< 495>0/4 /,7/ 40>0<73 812/-2/012 D74 3704-: 5-?13- /,- <-732-: 7604/37/- 5= ?0<026727..<087/0124--A026570<9//,-470:7..<087/012 87>- /1 5- :04>044-: 72: /,-3-?13- 78894-: 1 7<126 D0/,78894-:14(72:&73-5-?13-/,04193/
- 9 -
% 8813:026 /1 /,- <-732-: 81924-< ?13 /,- .-/0/012-34 212- 1? /,-4- .-/0/012-34 73- 02;1<;-: 02 /,- 874-72:/,-=73-?7<4-<=0>.<087/-:02/,->7//-3,7/04 D,= /,-3- 04 0213:027/- :-<7= 02 <1:6026 /,- ?034/ 02?13>7/012 D,08, D74 3-604/-3-: 12 '&(''( / 04 7<41,04812/-2/012/,7//,-3-73-21>7/-307<4 /18124/0/9/-72=1??-28-72:/,-3-?13-/,-.-/0/012-3473- -2/0/<-:?13570< $ ,- 495>044012 1? /,- <-732-: 81924-< ?13 /,- .-/0/012-34044-30194<=15@-8/-:5=/,-<-732-:06,193/ 1;-32>-2/ <-7:-3 D,1 495>0//-: /,7/ 12 494.08012 /,-.-/0/012-34D-3-/7A-2/1894/1:=72:1202/-33167/012 0/D74?192:/,7//,-=73-02;1<;-:0281>>0440121?/,- 1??-28- 72: /,-3-?13- /,-= D-3- 7..3-,-2:-: << <-67< ?13>7<0/0-4 D-3-?1<<1D-:5=/,- 2;-4/067/026
??08-372: /,-3- 04 21/,026 /1 812/-2: /,7/ -0/,-3 78894-: 1 13 72=1/,-378894-:D-3-:-/702-:0<<-67<<=7/72=/0>-- 7<41 495>0//-: /,7/ ,96- G972/0/= 1? 61<: @-D-<<-3= 5-<126026 /1 /,- 81>.<70272/*72A D-3- 3-81;-3-: ?31>
- 10 -
/,-4- .-/0/012-34 02 /,- ?13> 1? 61<: 0621/4 ,-3- 73- 4/3126>7/-307<481<<-8/-:5=/,- 2;-4/067/026 ??08-3 ,- 2;-4/067/012 04 4/0<< 02 .3163-44 2:-3 498, 80389>4/728-4/,-.-/0/012-3473-21/-2/0/<-:?136372/1?
570<8813:026<=.37=4?13:04>0447<1?/,-.-/0/0124 ,-7<<-67/0124>7:-767024//,-.-/0/012-3473- 1?4-3019427/93-;-2/,196,/,-# 04?0<-:767024//,- 92A21D2 .-34124 :93026 02;-4/067/012 78894-: 14 /1 ( D-3- 7..3-,-2:-: / 04 4/7/-: /,7/ 61<: 0621/4 1? D-06,026(637>4-78,D744-0H-:?31>/,-894/1:=1? 78894-: 14 72: ( 3-4.-8/0;-<= 72: 61<: 573 D-06,026 % 637>4 D74 4-0H-: ?31> /,- 894/1:= 1? 78894-:1& 92:-3/,-4-0H93->7,7H7372:/,-47>-D743-.13/-:/1 /,- <-732-: 7604/37/- ,- 02;-4/067/012 04 4/0<< 02 .3163-44 / /,04 4/76- /,-3- 73- 4/3126 >7/-307<4767024//,-.-/0/012-34?13,7;02681>>0//-:/,- 1??-28- / 87221/ 5- 8128<9:-: 7/ /,04 4/76- /,7/ /,- .-/0/012-3473-?7<4-<=0>.<087/-:02/,->7//-3
- 11 -
;-2 /,196, /,- <-732-: 81924-< ?13 /,- .-/0/012-34812/-2:-:/,7/78894-:1D747..3-,-2:-:
12 '&''( 72: ,- D74 0<<-67<<= :-/702-: 02 894/1:= D0/,19/ .31:98026 5-?13- /,- <-732-: 7604/37/- /0<< ')&''( :121/?02:72=>7/-307<402/,7/ 3-673:-E8-.//,-573-7<<-67/01245=/,-<-732-:81924-< ' / 04 /,- 812/-2/012 1? /,- <-732-: 81924-< ?13 /,- .-/0/012-34 /,7/ /,196, 78894-: 1 D74 7..3-,-2:-: 7/ 95<0 21 733-34/ 21/08- 13 >->1 D74 0449-: 1D-;-3 /,- 47>- D-3- 0449-: 12 ')&''( 4954-G9-2/<= 7/ 0@7=7.93 ,- >7/-307<4 12 3-813: :048<14-4/,7/74.-3/,-024/398/01245=/,- 2;-4/067/026 ??08-3/,-.1<08-1??0807<,7:/7A-2/,-.-/0/012-3*78894-:
1 02/1 894/1:= 72: ,- D74 .31:98-: 5-?13- /,- 2;-4/067/026
??08-39.12D,08,,-D747..3-,-2:-:5= ?1<<1D026 /,- .318-:93-4 74 812/->.<7/-: 92:-3 <7D /,-3- 04 81>.<0728- 1? /,- 3-G903->-2/4 ?13 7..3-,-2:026 /,- 78894-:
2<= 12 /,- 57404 1? /,- 7<<-67/0124>7:-5=/,-.-/0/012-340/87221/5-8128<9:-:
- 12 -
/,7/78894-:1D747..3-,-2:-:0<<-67<<=72::-/702-:
02 894/1:= D0/,19/ .31:98026 5-?13- /,- @9304:08/0127< 7604/37/- 74 3-G903-: 92:-3 <7D 1/, 12 /,04 8192/ 74 D-<<7412>-30/4 7>1?/,-1.02012/,7//,-.-/0/012-34 73-21/-2/0/<-:?136372/1?570< 8813:026<= 724D-3 /,- 751;- .102/ 02 /,- B !72:.318--:/1.744/,-?1<<1D026
<</,-.-/0/012473-
!-& (##, %
04/1<1