Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 49629 (KAR)
REVANSIDDAPPAGOWDA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/203203/2025 · 2025-10-27
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49629 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49629 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$##
%#&
! "
"
"
#$%&&&! '
#$$!&! (
#$$!&! #$$!&! Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$
#$$!&! %
"
) #$$!&! )
" ''% ''* " "
'$!&'&' !!$'&'#'$ +#
'""
,
"
"
"
,
"
"
-)
- 3 -
-)
./0 123/3/45 /0 6/728326 9:9/503 3.2 47627 69326 '$!&'&' 190026 ;< 3.2 7201456253 4' 1746=826 93 552>=72# ;<?./8.3.2890328273/@/89323.93.96;225 /00=26 /5 @9A4=7 4@ 3.2 123/3/4527 A/62 4 &&(B!B'(&B%%.90;225.2C634;2/CC2:9C
' 902 4@ 3.2 123/3/4527 /0 3.93 .2 ;2C45:0 34 9C9?979 89032 ?./8. /0 7284:5/D26 90 E8.26=C26 7/;2F =56273.24503/3=3/458.26=C267/;20 7627!B$&90 127 3.2 :9D2332 543/@/893/45 69326 '&&('&'& /00=26 ;< 3.2 3932 4@ 975939G9 .93 3.2 123/3/4527 ?90 1400200/5: 648=H2530 /53.2 593=72 4@ 08.44C 8273/@/89320 54345C<4@./H02C@;=39C044@./00/;C/5:0?./8.2A/62582 3.2 @983 4@ .2 ;2C45:/5: 34 9C9?979 8.26=C26 7/;2 84HH=5/3< 0/582 ;/73. 3 /0 3.2 0128/@/8 8902 4@ 3.2 123/3/4527 3.93 .2 .96 52/3.27 911C/26 547 8C9/H26 34 ;2 ;2C45:/5: 34 95< 84HH=5/3< 47 89032 43.27 3.95 3.2 9C9?979 8.26=C26 7/;2 4?2A27 6=7/5: 3.2 <297
- 4 -
'&!B 9 0379< 89032 8273/@/8932 89H2 34 ;2 /00=26 /5 3.2 59H24@3.2@93.274@3.2123/3/4527?745:C<0.4?/5:./0 89032909;;9C/:9932:47<#.93.2.9652A27911C/26 @47 95< 0=8. 89032 8273/@/8932 .93 ;9026 45 3./0 2774524=0 956 =589CC26 @47 8273/@/8932 7201456253# =3.47/3/20 /5/3/9326 3.2 1748226/5:0 720=C3/5: /5 /H1=:52647627;2/5:190026
( 297526 84=502C @47 3.2 123/3/4527 39G/5: 3./0 4=73 3.74=:. 3.2 648=H2530 1746=826 93 552>=72#EF 027/20 0=;H/30 3.93 3.2 648=H2530 04 1746=826 ?4=C6 8932:47/89CC< /56/8932 3.93 123/3/4527 956 ./0 0/;C/5:0 ;2C45:/5:
34 9C9?979 8.26=C26 7/;2 84HH=5/3< 4?2A27/53.2C/:.34@98273/@/893284H/5:/5342>/032582 45!'&$'&!B9CC2:26C</00=26;<3.29.0/C6979679H/ A/62 4 '&(B!B''(*B%* 0.4?/5: 3.2 89032 4@ 3.2 123/3/4527909;;9C/:9932:47<#3.272014562534'I 00/03953 4HH/00/4527 .90 190026 3.2 /H1=:526 47627 .936201/321746=83/454@3.2648=H253093552>=72#EF 027/20 4@ 3./0 ?7/3 123/3/45 ;2@472 3.2 7201456253 4' #
- 5 -
00/039534HH/00/45273.272/052/3.2795<72@272582547 6/08=00/45453.209H2.=00.20=;H/303.933.247627 190026 /0 ?/3.4=3 911C/893/45 4@ H/56 8453797< 34 3.2 0233C2617/58/1C24@C9?900=8.022G0@47J=90./5:4@3.2 09H2
C297526 128/9C 4=502C 911297/5:
@47 3.2 72014562530 39G/5: 3./0 4=73 3.74=:. 3.2 174A/0/450 4@ 283/45 #" 4@ 3.2 975939G9 8.26=C26 90320 8.26=C26 7/;20 956 43.27 98G?976 C90020 2027A93/45 4@ 114/53H2530
83 !BB& K.272/59@327 72@27726 34 90 3.2 E83 !BB&FL 0=;H/30 3.93 90 9:9/503 3.2 47627 190026 ;< 7201456253 4' # 00/03953 4HH/00/4527 =5627 283/45 # 4@ 3.2 83 !BB& 3.272 /0 95 9C327593/A2 956 2@@/898/4=0 72H26< 4@ 72A/0/45 174A/626956 3.2 123/3/4527;272C2:9326349A9/C 0=8. 72H26< 2582 022G0 @47 6/0H/009C 4@ 3.2 ?7/3 123/3/45
- 6 -
$ 2 @=73.27 0=;H/30 3.93 93 C4.
4@ 3.2 43/@/893/45174A/626@4798G?976C90020932:47<3.272 /0 9 H253/45 4@ 9C9?9799C?97 4<9 .93 3.2 09/6 84HH=5/3/20 972 6/@@27253 956 6/03/583 E9C?97 4<9F 64 543@9CC=56273.28932:47<4@8.26=C267/;200=8.95 25J=/7</53./072:976/09C0472J=/72634;28456=8326
% =;H/00/45/039G2545728476 * 2976 27=0263.27284760
"9830597793269;4A26454372J=/7272/32793/45 .2 /H1=:526 47627 190026 ;< 3.2 7201456253 4' # 00/039534HH/00/45277296090=5627
! " #$% &'(()*(
+&',- . ,
/0,
1")*2
3( *45 /+ 6 47 849)
:( ;/* )*7"5/<
=7> < ?)*
@
6% (A !(# B ?0 /7 / ) +0 C 8 BD
")BD EDC(F 3GHHHA:I:GEJ ! FK 4!(L
"" @3
MB ?0) )*." N
"O40P BD .;Q$
" = E.
L ?0 /7 / ),
)( 8"." )R6 .;Q$
".) S)"T"."
U T
". /7 /P
"5)C 1 /
1")*2
- 7 -
1*4
")
" 0% .;Q$ ?0A.;Q$
""
E)* 0
"T +*40 8,L )5 3VVI W 3VV: BD 1 XEYL
SZ E
!([
IIGV3V:GIV\\]L ?0 /7 /P
"5)C )*^+ BD
)(
S"
) )*^+P S* . &' _
.) /
7 =)
"`$) ^BD S
"O4))C,) +a
7)) 6 )C*# 1*[ , :3A3IA:I:X
" +a
7) R)CN4b(
@
, /
7" +a
7)) R 6
)(
)*7"5c<
^ H)* 0 7) /7 / C 3 ." 3I)* 0 ) ?0 C 6^ ,
"d[-*
7 / ^ )C*" 7) /7 /
S
)* ^ )C*"
" * [ *45 /+ 8." )" 2d _
E
! [ IIGV3V:GeHI\eL /7 / BD% T C
?0
)" ^
"P [
)(
" 1.* _ /+ 8 )*7"5c< 8 Cf
"C
E(L ?0) )*."
)" a) ,P , :eA3IA:I:X
" g =)% BD
)(
@
". /
7" . &'+"5
"O40P C
" 1.* _ /+ 8 BD a) ,P .;*B4%
".
/0, , ( 3:AeA:I3V
" /+ *45
." E
!([
:IGV3V::GHV\HL /@3 E MB ?0
)"% C Tf /+ *45
." , 3HA33A:I::
" E
!([
IIGV3V:GIV\\]L BD .;Q$
"
)" ?0 /7 / ),
T" ,
T"." g ))
")*2
h*733e:I:X@:e
, :eA3IA:I:X
F*i )BD +." S2Z ;/* )*7"5c< 8 / 3 E MBL ?0 /7 / C .;Q$
"
&)*
) &)*
) ?0 /7 / )" )C[ T
". E
!([
IIGV3V:GIV\\]L ?0 /7 / S)C S")*;4")(
A@ E !" #$ &'(()*L
+&',- . +&'% j
- 8 -
B .4=:. /5 3.2 9@47209/6 /H1=:526 47627 96A273/5:343.20=;H/00/450H962;<72014562534'# 7/2A950/669119:4?69?.4/03.2123/3/4527/53./0?7/3 123/3/45 7201456253 4' I 00/03953 4HH/00/4527 .90 543263.933.29.0/C6979679H/90?2CC903.22A25=2 50128347 9679H/ .96 0=;H/3326 9 1958.959H9 721473 69326'$!&'&'546239/C04@3.209/61958.959H9972 @=75/0.26 "=73.27 ?./C2 96A273/5: 34 3.2 8453253/4=0 /00=2090543269;4A22>821372@272582343.28273/@/89320 69326 !'&$'&!B 956 !*!!'&'' 54 @/56/5:0 972 :/A25 453.2A9C/6/3<4743.27?/024@09/68273/@/893202/3.27.2 8458C=6/5:1473/454@3.2/H1=:5264762790543269;4A2 /0;272@34@95<729045?.93042A27
!&
"=73.27 90 14/5326 4=3 ;< C297526 84=502C @47 3.2123/3/4527=1453.272J=20304H962;<3.2123/3/4527 3.2 9.0/C697 .90 /00=26 2564702H253 69326 ''&B'&'$ =5627 3.2 /:.3 34 5@47H93/45 83 34 3.2 123/3/4527 956 ./0 84=502C 14/53/5: 4=3 3.93 3.2 8273/@/8932 4@ 3.2 <297 '&!B .96 ;225 /00=26=5627 MA27.24=5327N 1748200
- 9 -
9563.209/68273/@/8932?90543/00=26=14595<72J=2034@ 3.2123/3/45273/052820097<3454323.29.0/C697?.4 .90/00=263.22564702H25369326''&B'&'$/03.21973< 34 3.2 1748226/5:0 956 3.2 /H1=:526 47627 1746=826 552>=72# A25 3.2 09/6 9.0/C697 .90 543 014G25 95<3./5: 9;4=3 3.2 8/78=H0395820 =5627 ?./8. 3.2 8273/@/893269326!'&$'&!B89H234;2/00=26
!! .2 45F;C2 12> 4=73 956 3./0 4=73 3/H2 9569:9/5.9A22H1.90/D263.272J=/72H2534@1900/5:9 72904526476272A25;<3.2=90/ )=6/8/9C=3.47/3/2090 3.93 4@ 3.2 7201456253 4' ?.4 972 A20326 ?/3. 3.2 O=6/8/4=0 14?270 34 62327H/52 3.2 8/A/C 7/:.30 4@ 3.2 1973/20 "/56/5:0 956 8458C=0/450 17282626 ;< 3.2 C2:9CC< 1C9=0/;C272904509723.2.29734@95<O=6/8/9C476277627 902>37983269;4A2@9CC0@470.4734@3.209/672J=/72H253
23/3/4527 ?.4 8C9/H0 34 .9A2 0=;H/3326 648=H253 1746=826 /5 552>=72#EF 027/20 ?./8. 972 9;4=3 !B /5 5=H;270 64 543 @/56 H253/45 /5 3.2 /H1=:526 47627 =@@/82 34 03932 3.93 3.2 47627 190026 ;< 3.2 7201456253
- 10 -
4' 6420 543 H223 3.2 72J=/72H253 4@ 17/58/1C20 4@ 593=79C O=03/82 956 911C/893/45 4@ H/56 34 3.2 /00=2 4@ 845374A270<
!' .4=:. C297526 84=502C 911297/5: @47 3.2 7201456253#=3.47/3/200=;H/33263.933.272/0972A/0/45 174A/62672C2:93/5:3.2123/3/452734022G72A/0/454@3.2 /H1=:526476274@3./0593=72?4=C6;24@549A9/C903.2 /H1=:5264762790543269;4A2/09087<13/890/384=C6 ;2
!( 53.93A/2?4@3.2H933273./04=73/04@3.2 A/2?
3.93 3.2 /H1=:526 47627 /0 C/9;C2 34 ;2 023 90/62 88476/5:C<3.2@4CC4?/5:
/ 7/3 23/3/45/0
// 7627 69326 '$!&'&' A/62 4!!$'&'#'$ 1746=826 93 552>=72# 190026;<3.272014562534' /0 J=90.26 93327 /0 72H/3326 ;98G 34 3.2 72014562534'@47@720.8450/62793/45
- 11 -
/// 23/3/4527 /0 93 C/;273< 34 @=75/0. 3.2 648=H25301746=826/53./0?7/3123/3/4593 552>=72#EF 9C45: ?/3. 3.2 2564702H2530 3.93 972 1746=826 93 552>=720#" 956 "! 039326 34 .9A2 ;225 /00=26 ;< 3.2 7201456253 4 I 9.90/C697 ?/3./5 !$ 69<0 @74H 3.2 6932 4@ 7282/13 4@ 8273/@/26 841<4@3./047627
/A .2 00/03953 4HH/00/4527 0.9CC C44G /534 3.2 H27/30 47 43.27?/02 4@ 3.2 8C9/H ;2/5:
H962 ;< 3.2 123/3/4527 956 1900 6239/C26 47627 39G/5: /534 8450/62793/45 3.2 8453253/450 =7:26 ;< 3.2 123/3/4527 956 9@3279@@476/5:0=@@/8/253411473=5/3<34;43. 3.2 1973/20 90 6/728326 9;4A2 ?/3./5 95 4=327C/H/34@%&69<03.2729@327
'( %##& $
/034!C4!