Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 49609 (KAR)
VISHAL S/O DADA LOKHANDE v. BALASAHEB S/O BAPUSAHEB PATIL
MFA/30877/2012 · 2025-07-08
Ravi V Hosmani
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49609 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49609 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"!#$#
% $"&&"
""''
(&) *+
""''
(&)
*
+
! ! "
#
#
! #
$
# $%
" ! Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#$ $ "&' "! $ #
# $ # '("" # # #
"'")"
$
# $")* # # # # $ "+* $
(,# # # , $# $ #
$(, "&(* +, #
$
# $
*
+
! - 3 -
! "
#
#
! #
$
# $%
" ! #$ $ "&' "! $ #
# $ # '(""
#
#
#
"'&)"
$
# $")* # # # # $ -(*
$
(,# # # , $# $ #
$ (, &+.* +, #
$
# $
# $
#
- 4 -
# /# #
$! 0123 4567 89938:; 8<3 8<0;01= 5>6 5? ;8@3 A>B=@316 673C8<32:>443B65=3673<81B68D31>9?5<B0;95;8:
78::31=01=A>B=@31681B8E8<BB863B'("" 98;;3B 4C # 5* 0A89>< 86 0A89>< 01 #; 15"'") 81B"'&)"673;389938:;8<3?0:3B ' <0 5>A8:8=0 :38<13B 25>1;3: ;>4@0663B 6786 89938:; E3<34C 2:80@816; ?5< 3178123@316 5? 25@931;86051 6E8;;>4@0663B86".)9@51"(&"8DD8998E8;
<0B01= 8; 90::051 51 @565<2C2:3 438<01= 15# *"*&'"' 51 81=:5:8*#81=8:8E3B8<58B38<#881<0F3<4<0B=3B<0F3<5? 339 15# *.)*&(B<5F3 06 01 <8;781B 13=:0=316 @8113< 81B B8;73B 8=801;6 @565<2C2:3 28>;01= 8220B316 1 ;80B 8220B316 4567 <0B3<; ;>;68013B =<03F5>; 01A><03; 81B E3<3 8B@0663B 65 75;9068: 3;9063 6<386@316 673C ;>;68013B 93<@8131697C;028:B0;840:06C81B251;3G>316:C:5;;5?38<101= 2898206C 73<3?5<3 673C ?0:3B #; 15"'") 81B "'&)" <3;93260F3:C8=801;65E13<81B01;><3<5?339
- 5 -
. 1 25163;6 E73<301 5E13< E8; 9:823B 3H*98<63 01;><3< 5995;3B 2:80@ 93606051; B31C01= 8=3 522>986051 0125@393<@8131697C;028:B0;840:06C:5;;5?38<101=2898206C 8;E3::8;13=:0=31235198<65?B<0F3<5?339<04>18:?<8@3B 0;;>3;81B<325<B3B3F0B3123:80@816;3H8@013B673@;3:F3; 81B<#8=08;;"65'81B=56@8<D3BH;*"65"( 3;951B316 B0B 156 :38B 81C 5<8: 3F0B3123 4>6 259C 5? 01;><812395:02CE8;@8<D3BE067251;3168;*" ) 1 251;0B3<86051 6<04>18: 73:B 6786 8220B316 78B 522><<3BB>365<8;781B13=:0=316B<0F01=5?B<0F3<5?3398;
E3:: 8; <0B3< 5? @565<2C2:3 01 <8605 ( <04>18: 8;;3;;3B 25@931;860518;?5::5E; 1#15"'")" :5
38B; @5>16
" $5<980181B;>??3<01= '*
$5< @3B028: 81B 5673< 0120B3168: 3H931;3; )* ' $5<?>6><3B0;25@?5<681B>17899013;; )* . 5;;5??>6><30125@3B>365B0;840:06C
"-)* ,-. *
1#15"'&)" :5
38B; @5>16
" $5<980181B;>??3<01=
")*
$5< @3B028: 81B 5673< 0120B3168: 3H931;3; '*
- 6 -
' $5<?>6><3B0;25@?5<681B>17899013;; (* . 5;;5??>6><30125@3B>365B0;840:06C .(* ,-. *
+ 1 # 15"'")" 06 E8; ;>4@0663B 2:80@816 E8; 8 ;6>B3169893< F31B5< 81B 38<101= ;+* 9@
5E3F3<6<04>18:251;0B3<3B70;@5167:C0125@386;' E7027E8;51:5E3<;0B3 6E8;;>4@0663B8E8<B5?;)* E8; 8E8<B3B 65E8<B; :5;; 5? 8@310603; E7027 E8; 8:;5 51 :5E3< ;0B3 81B 6<04>18: B0B 156 8E8<B 81C 25@931;86051 65E8<B; :5;; 5?
38<101= B><01= :80B >9 93<05B ;'* 8E8<B3B65E8<B;9801 81B;>??3<01= 0; 8:;5 51:5E3< ;0B3 1 845F3=<5>1B;;5>=76?5<3178123@316 & 1#15"'&)";0@0:8<=<5>1B;E3<3><=3B ( 15673<781B<078<81848;8998#860::38<13B 25>1;3: ?5< <3;951B316 15 5995;3B 89938:; 6 E8;
;>4@0663B 6<04>18: 78B 251;0B3<3B 01A><03; ;>;68013B 81B 78B 8E8<B3B A>;6 25@931;86051 >1B3< ;398<863 738B; :38F01= 15 ;2593?5<3178123@316 -
38<B25>1;3:81B93<>;3BA>B=@31681B8E8<B
- 7 -
" $<5@845F3;012351:C2:80@816;8<30189938:?5< 3178123@3165?25@931;8605125@@51950166786E5>:B8<0;3 ?5<251;0B3<860510;
I73673< 2:80@816; 8<3 31606:3B ?5< 3178123@316 5? 25@931;860518;;5>=76?5<JK
"" 8@30;81;E3<3B98<6:C018??0<@860F3?5<?5::5E01= <38;51;
" 1 # 15"'")" 2:80@816 0; ;80B 65 78F3 4331E5<D01=8;;6>B3169893<F31B5<81B38<101=;+* 9@ 5E3F3< ;8@3 0; 156 ;>4;68160863B E067 81C ;9320?02 3F0B3123 1 84;3123 6<04>18: 8;;3;;3B 0125@3 1560518::C 560518:0125@3?5<C38<"8;93<278<69<398<3B4C 0; ;))* E7027 78; 65 43 251;0B3<3B 8; 70; @5167:C 0125@3<04>18:1563B2:80@816;>;68013B01A><03;51:3?681D:3
"H.H2@! :8<=3 E5>1B 25168@01863B 5F3< :3?6 81D:3 51 163<5 :8:3F8: 8;9326 3H95;01= :5E3< 31B 5? 60408 5>6 ;0B3 5? E5>1B 631B3<13;; 5? B5<;>@ 5? ?556 2<>;73B 81B 8F>:;3B B0;68:9>:;860519<3;316653@5F3@316;15695;;04:384<8;051 5F3< ?0=76 D133 L*<8C 5? :3?6 81D:3 ;75E; B0;:5286051 5? :3?6 B0;68:6040881B?04>:8A501681B=<8B3 25@95>1BB0;:5286051
- 8 -
5? :3?6 81D:3 E067 631B51 01A><C 5? B5<;>@ 5? ?556 673< 6<386@316 <325<B; E5>:B 01B02863 6786 2:80@816 78; 68D31 6<386@31681B>1B3<E316593<86051; 38:;53H8@013B*' B5265< 65 ;>4;68160863 B0;840:06C ; 93< H*") 0;840:06C 23<60?02863!2:80@816;>;68013B:0@4B0;840:06C653H63165?'65 '),>66<04>18:251;0B3<3BE75:345BCB0;840:06C86,
"' 51;0B3<01= ?826; 81B 20<2>@;68123; 8E8<B 5? ;'*65E8<B;980181B;>??3<01=0;A>;60?03BF31:5;;5? 38<101=2898206C8;;3;;3B86,0;A>;60?03B0D3E0;38E8<B 5? ;)* 65E8<B; @3B028: 3H931;3; E5>:B 43 01 25@9:363 <30@4><;3@316 5? @3B028: 40::; E5>:B 156 28:: ?5< 0163<?3<3123 :80@816 78; 68D31 01*9860316 6<386@316 ?5< 8 93<05B5?"'B8C;68D01=15635?;8@3;"*0;8E8<B3B 65E8<B;?55B86631B81681B5673<0120B3168:3H931;3;
". 5<@8::C?<826><3;E5>:B68D367<33@5167;65738:
51;0B3<01= ;8@3 8; :8C 5?? 93<05B ;"+)* 0; 8E8<B3B 65E8<B; :5;; 5? 0125@3 B><01= :80B >9 93<05B <04>18: 78; 8E8<B3B;)*65E8<B;?>6><3B0;25@?5<681B>17899013;; 03:5;;5?8@310603;81B;8@30;3178123B65;)*
- 9 -
") 5;; 5? 38<101= 2898206C 5? 2:80@816 E5<D; 5>6 65 ;'&+* ;))* H , H " L "(! 7>; 6568: 25@931;86051E5>:B43 1#15"'")" :5
38B; @5>16
" $5<980181B;>??3<01= '*
$5< @3B028: 81B 5673< 0120B3168: 3H931;3; )* ' $5<?>6><3B0;25@?5<681B>17899013;; )* . $55B 86631B816 81B 5673< 0120B3168: 3H931;3; * ) 5;;5?0125@3B><01=:80B>993<05B * + 5;;5??>6><30125@3B>365B0;840:06C '&+* ,-.
*
"+ 1 # 15"'&)" 2:80@816 0; ;80B 65 78F3 4331E5<D01=8;;6>B3169893<F31B5<81B38<101=;+* 9@ 5E3F3< ;8@3 0; 156 ;>4;68160863B E067 81C ;9320?02 3F0B3123 1 84;3123 6<04>18: 8;;3;;3B 0125@3 1560518::C 560518:0125@3?5<C38<"8;93<278<69<398<3B4C 0; ;))* E7027 78; 65 43 251;0B3<3B 8; 70; @5167:C 0125@3<04>18:1563B2:80@816;>;68013B2>6:823<863BE5>1B 01 436E331 1B 81B '<B 653 81B '<B 81B .67 653 B5<;>@ 65 9:8163<8;93265?<0=76?556@38;><01=)H2@84<8;05151<0=76 733:L*<8C5?<0=76?556;75E;?<826><35?9<5H0@8:978:81H653
- 10 -
)67<0=76?55681B?<826><35?738B5?'<B81B.67@36868<;8:?556
3655D01*98603166<386@316?5<93<05B5?B8C;51;0B3<01= ;8@38E8<B5?;")*65E8<B;980181B;>??3<01=E5>:B 43 A>;60?03B F31 8E8<B 5? ;'* 65E8<B; @3B028:
3H931;3; E5>:B 89938< 65 43 A>;6 81B 9<593< <04>18:
8;;3;;3B B0;840:06C 86 ", 3*25@9>686051 5? :5;; 5? ?>6><3 0125@3E5>:B43;""(* ;))*H",H"H"(! "& 5<@8::C ?<826><3; 68D3 ' @5167; 65 738: 0123 2:80@816;>;68013B?<826><35?@36868<;8:E7027738:?8;63<:8C 5?? 93<05B ;75>:B 43 251;0B3<3B 8; @5167; 81B 2:80@816 E5>:B 43 31606:3B ?5< ;""* 65E8<B; ;8@3 E8<B 5? ;(* 65E8<B; :5;; 5? 8@310603; 0; A>;6 81B 9<593< 3* 8;;3;;3B25@931;860510;8;?5::5E; 1#15"'&)" :5
38B; @5>16
" $5<980181B;>??3<01=
")*
$5< @3B028: 81B 5673< 0120B3168: 3H931;3; '* ' $5<?>6><3B0;25@?5<681B>17899013;; (* . 5;;5??>6><30125@3B>365B0;840:06C (* ) 5;;5?0125@3B><01=:80B>993<05B * ,-. *
- 11 -
"( 995<6051@316:0840:06C86<86055?(4C6<04>18:
0; 156 278::31=3B 3123 ;8@3 0; @80168013B 73<3?5<3 2:80@816 01 # 15"'")" E5>:B 43 31606:3B ?5< 25@931;86051 5? ;-+((* 81B 01 # 15"'&)" ?5< ;".+.*
"- 51;3G>316:C?5::5E01=5<B3< ! 0 9938:;8<38::5E3B0198<6
00 >B=@316 81B 8E8<B B863B '("" 01 # 15;"'") 81B "'&)" 0; @5B0?03B :80@816 01 #$ 15'(&+" # 15"'")"! E5>:B 43 31606:3B ?5< 25@931;86051 5? ;-+((* 81B 01 #$ 15'(&&" # 15"'&)"! E5>:B 4331606:3B?5<;".+.*
000 ; 93< 5<B3< B863B (&) 2:80@816; E5>:B1564331606:3B?5<0163<3;6?5<B3:8C3B 93<05B
- 12 -
0F 3;951B316*01;><3< 65 B395;06 3178123B 25@931;86051 E067 0163<3;6 43?5<3 6<04>18: E06701893<05B5?;0HE33D;
"/* (&&") $! 0;65":5"-