Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 49608 (KAR)
1. RAMKISHAN AND ORS v. 1. SHARNAMMA W/O MARUTIRAO AND ORS
RSA/200217/2017 · 2025-03-24
Anant Ramanath Hegde
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49608 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49608 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#"$"
%%&%' (
! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"
#
$
%
&' ()
* )
(
+ ,
! - )
! - 3 -
.%
/
&
(
'
0
.1
0
! ) !%
0
0
. )
!1
0
- 4 -
2
0
,
. (
%
(
!#
/
&
(
3 %4 (
#1!1
'
3 11
(
3
)
2.1 1.1% 3
3 ( )
3
%1 11
(
( 3 3
5
)
2.1 ( )
3
%1 3
3
)
3
3)
- 5 -
3
) (
6)
$" & 6)
'
*7$ 89* :*7;*$ "<=;>*: ??*7@;- +<7 ??*::;8> ;$ 89*:*7;*$"<=;>*:??*7@;-+<77*>?<;$*;8>
9@>*-=:7 *"<;$??*:@>7@>@;-+7<A$*"7** @;3@;:*"7**7<"**$@;->B*::>$*"7**?>>*$@;??*: <2.7@>@;-+7<A3@;:*"7**7<"**$@;-<1%1 ! ??*::;8>6"<;8*;8@<; *+<7*89*3@;:*"7**<=78 @>898><A*<+89*?7<?*78@*>;A*:C =7D*C<>22.;$ 1 <+ @??;@ (@::-* 7* 89* >*:+E"F=@7*$ ?7<?*78@*> <+ 89* ??*::;8> @>;<8""*?8*$;$@>7*G*"8*$ C89*3@;:$*"7** <=78 . 9* ??*::;8> +@:*$ ; ??*: *+<7* 89* 3@7>8 ??*::8* <=78 @; <2.1 <; 89* +@:* <+ $$@8@<;:
@>87@"8 )=$-* : =7-@ 9* 3@7>8 ??*::8* <=78 7*G*"8*$
- 6 -
89* "<;8*;8@<;> <+ 89* ??*::;8> ;$ $@>A@>>*$ 89* ??*:
*;"*89*?7*>*;8*-=:7 *"<;$??*:
*7;*$"<=;>*:??*7@;-+<789*??*::;8>B<=:$
"<;8*;$ 898 ! ?7<?*78@*> 7*+*77*$ 8< <D* ;A*:C =7D*C <>22 . ;$ 1 <+ @??;@ (@::-* 7* 89* >*:+E"F=@7*$ ?7<?*78@*><+89*??*::;8>
9*3@7>8??*::8*<=789>$@>A@>>*$89*??*:
7*G*"8@;- 89* "<;8*;8@<; <+ 89* ??*::;8> 7*:8@;- 8< 89* >*:+E
"F=@>@8@<; <+ 89* +<7*A*;8@<;*$ ?7<?*78@*> <; 89* ?7*A@>* 898 89* D*7C >A* "<;8*;8@<; B> 7@>*$ @; 89*
7@-@;: =@8 B9*7* 89* ??*::;8> B*7* $*+*;$;8> 9* 7@: <=78 9> 7*G*"8*$ 89* "<;8*;8@<; @; 89*
7@-@;: =@8 ;$ 89*7*+8*7 ;
??*: B> +@:*$ @; <.11% 9* 3@7>8 ??*::8* <=78 7@>*$?<@;8>+<7"<;>@$*78@<;@;89*>@$??*:7*:8@;-8<89* $*+*;"* <+ >*:+E"F=@>@8@<; @; 7*>?*"8 <+ +<7*A*;8@<;*$ !
?7<?*78@*> ;$ @; <.11% 89* 3@7>8 ??*::8* <=78 9*:$89889*?7<?*78@*> *7@;- =7D*C<>22.;$17* 89*G<@;8+A@:C?7<?*78@*><+89*?:@;8@++>;$$*+*;$;8> % 9* 3@7>8 ??*::8* <=78 9> :>< ;<8@"*$ 898 $*"7** @; <.11% @> "<;+@7A*$ @; <%%11#
- 7 -
?>>*$ C 89* <E<7$@;8* *;"9 <+ 89@> <=78 9*7*+8*7 7*D@*B?*8@8@<;B>+@:*$>**H@;-7*D@*B<+89*G=$-A*;8@; <%%11#9*>@$*D@>@<;*8@8@<;<..1@>:>< $@>A@>>*$ 2 9=> 89* 3@;: *"7** <=78 > B*:: > 89* 3@7>8 ??*::8*<=78"A*8<"<;":=>@<;89889*A88*7";;<8 * $G=$@"8*$ > 89* F=*>8@<; @> :7*$C $*"@$*$ @; 89* +<7*A*;8@<;*$
7@-@;: =@8 89* 3@7>8 ??*: > B*:: > 89* *"<;$??*:9*3@7>8*"7**<=78;$89*3@7>8??*::8* <=78 9D* 7@-98:C 9*:$ 898 @>>=* @> 9@8 C 89* ?7@;"@?:* <+
# 9<=-9 89* :*7;*$ "<=;>*: +<7 89* ??*::;8> D*9*A*;8:C "<;8*;$*$ 898 @; *7:@*7 ?7<"**$@;-> 89*>* >?*"8> B*7* ;<8 ?7<?*7:C "<;>@$*7*$ B@89 7*+*7*;"* 8< 89* $<"=A*;8> $$="*$ C 89* ?78@*> 89@> <=78 @> <+ 89* D@*B 89889*+@;$@;-<;89*@>>=*9D@;-88@;*$+@;:@8C89*>A*
";;<8 * $G=$@"8*$ +7*>9 @; 89* 3@;: *"7** 7<"**$@;- 9*>"<?*<++@;:$*"7**@>:@A@8*$9*3@;:*"7**<=78@> <=;$ 8< $7B 89* +@;: $*"7** ?=7>=;8 8< 89* ?7*:@A@;7C
- 8 -
$*"7**7*:@A@;7C$*"7**@>:7*$C?>>*$9<:$@;-89889* +<7*A*;8@<;*$!?7<?*78@*>7*:><G<@;8+A@:C?7<?*78@*> 1 ;$*789*>*"@7"=A>8;"*>89@><=78$<*>;<8+@;$ ;CA*7@8@;89*??*:<>= >8;8@:F=*>8@<;<+:BB<=:$ 7@>*@;89*??*:
""<7$@;-:C??*:@>
)*
&" ' $
( @>8< :<!