Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 49596 (KAR)

SUREKHA @ CHANNAVVA AND ANR v. GANESH AND ANR

MFA/203057/2024 · 2025-04-02

K Natarajan, Vijaykumar A Patil

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "## $#%# & & ! " # # " $%&' ( "" )# * & # $+, ) * " Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # " $%&' (" ) - * "" ,+)* ." " # '+'" .&&' " " # # " # " "" " & & " # " $%&' ( "" ) * & ! " # # " $%&' (" )# /- +$ * - 3 - "" ,+)* ." # '+' " " " # 0 # " .&&' "" " "" # ,'+'% 1" # 2 " 3# # 4## " %# )" 3## " * 56785 95:;: <==:<>; <?: >@;9:A B6? <AC@;;@6D E@95 95: F6D;:D9 6B >:<?D:A F67D;:> B6? G69595: =<?9@:; 95:H <?:9<I:D7=B6?B@D<>A@;=6;<> 5:;: <==:<>; <?: A@?:F9:A <8<@D;9 J7A8C:D9 <DA<E<?AA<9:A'+'=<;;:A@D 6.&&' 6D 95: B@>: 6B "?@DF@=<> :D@6? @K@> #7A8: <DA :CG:? 0@J<H<=7?<)B6?;56?9L5:?@G7D<>4* + 6'+'%,' @; B@>:A GH 95: F><@C<D9; ;::I@D8 B6? :D5<DF:C:D9 E5:?:<; 6'%'+ @;B@>:AGH95:D;7?<DF:6C=<DHF5<>>:D8@D895:B@DA@D8 - 4 - 6DD:8>@8:DF:<DA95:M7<D97C6BF6C=:D;<9@6D<E<?A:A GH95:?@G7D<> 6? 95: ;<I: 6B F6DK:D@:DF: =<?9@:; <?: ?:B:??:A96<;=:?95:@??<DI@D8G:B6?:95:?@G7D<> % ?@:BB<F9;>:<A@D896B@>@D86B95:;:<==:<>;<?: 95<9 6D ' 6D: C685@;@AA< 78<A: <>6D8 E@95 5@;B<95:?<K;<5:G78<A:<DA5@;C695:?7?:I5<E:?: =?6F::A@D86D95:@?C696?FHF>:G:<?@D8:8 6 0+0 0 .+B?6C<D86><96<A5:8<6D<995<99@C:E5:D95:H E:?: D:<? <A5:8<6D G?@A8: 95:H C:9 E@95 <D <FF@A:D9 A7: 96 <F9@6D<G>: D:8>@8:DF: 6D 95: =<?9 6B 95: A?@K:? 6B 95: >6??H G:<?@D8 :8 6 0+.0& ; < ?:;7>9 C685;@AA<<DA<K;<5:G;7;9<@D:A8?@:K67;@DJ7?@:;<DA ;7FF7CG:A 96 95: @DJ7?@:; <9 95: ;=69 5: >:8<> 5:@?; 6B A:F:<;:A C685;@AA<5<K:B@>:A95:F><@C=:9@9@6DG:B6?: 95:?@G7D<>;::I@D8F6C=:D;<9@6D & :;=6DA:D9; 6==6;:A 95: F><@C =:9@9@6D GH B@>@D8 6GJ:F9@6D; 9 @; <K:??:A 95<9 95: <FF@A:D9 6FF7??:A A7:96D:8>@8:DF:6D95:=<?96B95:?@A:?6BC696?FHF>:9 - 5 - @; B7?95:? <K:??:A 95<9 95: >@<G@>@9H 6B 95: @D;7?<DF: F6C=<DH @; ;7GJ:F9 96 B7>B@>C:D9 6B =6>@FH F6DA@9@6D; <DA 95:A?@K:? 6B 95: >6??H E<; D69 5<K@D8 K<>@A <DA :BB:F9@K: A?@K@D8 >@F:DF: <; 6D 95:A<9: 6B <FF@A:D9 <DA ;67859 B6? A@;C@;;<>6B95:F><@C=:9@9@6D , 5: ?@G7D<> 5<; ?:F6?A:A 95: :K@A:DF: 5: F><@C<D9 6:N<C@D:A5:?;:>B<;"0<DA869C<?I:A 95:A6F7C:D9;N;"096"0.-95:?:;=6DA:D9$D;7?<DF: 6C=<DH A@A D69 <AA7F: <DH :K@A:DF: G79 869 C<?I:A 95: @D;7?<DF: =6>@FH E@95 95: F6D;:D9 <; N0 5: ?@G7D<> 6D <==?:F@<9@6D 6B 6?<> <DA A6F7C:D9<?H :K@A:DF: =<?9>H <>>6E:A 95: F><@C =:9@9@6D GH <E<?A@D8 969<> F6C=:D;<9@6D 6B ;''''0 E@95 @D9:?:;9 <9 &O =:? <DD7C <DA ;<AA>:A 95: >@<G@>@9H 6D 95: @D;7?<DF: F6C=<DH ?@ 67J<><8@ >:<?D:A F67D;:> <==:<?@D8 B6? 95: <==:>><D9;F><@C<D9; ;7GC@9; 95<9 95: ?@G7D<> F6CC@99:A <D :??6? @D <E<?A@D8 C:<8?: F6C=:D;<9@6D6B ;''''0 96 95: F><@C<D9; E@95679 =?6=:?>H - 6 - <==?:F@<9@D8 5@; :<?D@D8; <DA 95: ?@G7D<> 5<; D69 <E<?A:A <DH F6C=:D;<9@6D 7DA:? 95: 5:<A 6B >6;; 6B B797?: =?6;=:F9; 5: <E<?A 6B F6C=:D;<9@6D 7DA:? 95: 5:<A6B>6;;6BF6D;6?9@7C@;<>;6?:M7@?:A96G::D5<DF:A <==?6=?@<9:>H :DF: 5: ;::I; 96 <>>6E 95: <==:<> GH :D5<DF@D895:F6C=:D;<9@6D . ?@<DK:DA?< :AAH >:<?D:A F67D;:> <==:<?@D8 B6? 95: <==:>><D9D;7?<DF: 6C=<DH ;7==6?9; 95:J7A8C:D9<DA<E<?A6B?@G7D<>@D;6B<?<;<;;:;;C:D9 6B @DF6C: 6B 95: A:F:<;:A 6E:K:? 95: ?@G7D<> 5<; B<@>:A96F6D;@A:?95:B<F995<995:A:F:<;:A<DA9E6695:? =:?;6D;E:?:=?6F::A@D86D95:C696?FHF>:<DA95:?@A:? 6B95:C696?FHF>:9?@:A966K:?9<I:95:>6??H<995<99@C: 95: <FF@A:D9 6FF7??:A5:?: @; < F>:<? D:8>@8:DF:6D 95: =<?9 6B 95: ?@A:? 6B 95: C696?FHF>: <; 5: F67>A D69 C<@D9<@D =?6=:? A@;9<DF: G:9E::D 95: 9E6 K:5@F>:; 5: ?@G7D<>67859965<K:;<AA>:AF6D9?@G796?HD:8>@8:DF:96 95: :N9:D9 6B %'O 6D 95: A:F:<;:A ?@A:? 6B 95: C696?FHF>:- :K:D 95: ?@A:? 6B 95: C696?FHF>: E<; D69 - 7 - 5<K@D8 A?@K@D8 >@F:DF: <9 95: 9@C: 6B <FF@A:D9 9 @; ;7GC@99:A 95<9 95: A:F:<;:A E<; < G<F5:>6? <DA <==?6=?@<9: A:A7F9@6D 96E<?A; =:?;6D<> <DA >@K@D8 :N=:D;:; ;567>A G: %'O :DF: 5: ;::I; 96 <>>6E 95: <==:<>B@>:AGH95:@D;7?<DF:F6C=<DH ' <K@D85:<?A95:<?87C:D9;6B>:<?D:AF67D;:> B6?95:=<?9@:;<DA6D=:?7;<>6B95:C<9:?@<><K<@><G>:6D ?:F6?A C:9@F7>67;>H 95: 6D>H =6@D9 95<9 <?@;:; B6? F6D;@A:?<9@6D@D95:;:<==:<>;@; 1 5: =>:<A@D8 <DA :K@A:DF: 6D ?:F6?A @DA@F<9:; 95<96D'A:F:<;:A C685@;@AA<78<A:<>6D8 E@955@;B<95:?<K;<5:G78<A:<DA5@;C695:?7?:I5< E:?: =?6F::A@D86D 95:@?C696?FHF>:G:<?@D8:8 6 0 +0 0.+ B?6C <D86>< 96 <A5:8<6D <9 95<9 9@C: E5:D95:HE:?:D:<?<A5:8<6DG?@A8:95:HC:9E@95<D <FF@A:D9 A7: 96 <F9@6D<G>: D:8>@8:DF: 6D 95: =<?9 6B 95: A?@K:? 6B 95: >6??H G:<?@D8 :8 6 0+.0& ; < - 8 - ?:;7>9 C685;@AA< <DA <K;<5:G ;7;9<@D:A 8?@:K67; @DJ7?@:; <DA ;7FF7CG:A 96 95: @DJ7?@:; <9 95: ;=69 5: A:F:<;:A E<; <8:A <G679 H:<?; <; 6D 95: A<9: 6B <FF@A:D9 5: F><@C<D9; 5<K: D69 =?6A7F:A <DH :K@A:DF: 96=?6K:95:@DF6C:6B95:A:F:<;:A<;5:E<;E6?I@D8<; < F66>@: 5: ?@G7D<> 5<;?@859>H<;;:;;:A 95: @DF6C:6B 95: A:F:<;:A <9 ;,%''0 =C GH F6D;@A:?@D8 95: D69@6D<> @DF6C: F5<?9 =?:=<?:A GH 95: <?D<9<I< 9<9: :8<>:?K@F:; 7956?@9H AC@99:A>H95:A:F:<;:AE<;< G<F5:>6?<DA;:>B0:C=>6H:A<DAE<;<8:A<G679H:<?; <; 6D 95: A<9: 6B <FF@A:D9 5:DF: 95:?: ;567>A G: <D <AA@9@6D6B'O6B95:<;;:;;:A@DF6C:96E<?A;95:B797?: =?6;=:F9; 6B 95: A:F:<;:A 5: A:A7F9@6D 96E<?A; =:?;6D<><DA>@K@D8:N=:D;:;6B95:A:F:<;:A@;%'O<DA <==?6=?@<9: C7>9@=>@:? @; 6E:K:? 95: ?@G7D<> 5<; :??:A@DD69<E<?A@D8<DHF6C=:D;<9@6D7DA:?95:5:<A6B >6;; 6B B797?: =?6;=:F9; 6B 95: A:F:<;:A ; =:? 95: ><E ><@AA6EDGH95:95: 6D4G>:7=?:C:67?9@D95:F<;:6B - 9 - 95: F><@C<D9; <?: :D9@9>:A B6? <D <AA@9@6D 6B 'O 6B <;;:;;:A @DF6C: 96E<?A; 95: >6;; 6B B797?:=?6;=:F9; D;6B<? <; 95: F6D9:D9@6D 6B F6D9?@G796?H D:8>@8:DF:7?8:AGH95:>:<?D:AF67D;:>B6?95:@D;7?<DF: F6C=<DH 95: C<9:?@<> <K<@><G>: 6D ?:F6?A @DA@F<9: 95<9 F><@C<D9 6:N<C@D:A5:?;:>B<;"0<DA869C<?I:A N;"0 96 "0. 96 ;7G;9<D9@<9: 95:@? F><@C G:B6?: 95: ?@G7D<> N"0 @; 95: B@?;9 @DB6?C<9@6D ?:=6?9 ?:8@;9:?:A GH95:<D86><"6>@F:@D?@C: 6'B6?95:6BB:DF: =7D@;5<G>:7DA:?:F9@6D,.++,+++' 6B"<DA :F9@6D 6B F9 5: J7?@;A@F9@6D<> =6>@F: 6D F6C=>:9@6D 6B 95: @DK:;9@8<9@6D B@>:A F5<?8:0;5::9 <; =:? N"0 <8<@D;9 95: A?@K:? 6B 6BB:DA@D8 >6??H "0 5<; G::D F?6;;0:N<C@D:A <9 >:D895 56E:K:? D695@D8 5<; G::D :>@F@9:A E@95 ?:8<?A 96 D:8>@8:DF: 6B 95: A:F:<;:A AC@99:A>H 95: @D;7?<DF: F6C=<DH 5<; D69 <AA7F:A <DH 6?<>:K@A:DF:G79E@9595:F6D;:D995:H869C<?I:AF6=H !"##!$ - 10 - 6B 95: @D;7?<DF: =6>@FH <; N0 D 695:? E6?A; 95: =>:<A@D8 <DA :K@A:DF: <AA7F:A GH 95: <==:>><D9;F><@C<D9; F>:<?>H A:C6D;9?<9:; 95<9 95: <FF@A:D9@;F<7;:AA7:96<F9@6D<G>:D:8>@8:DF:6D95:=<?9 6B 95: A?@K:? 6B 95: 9?7FI G:<?@D8 :8 6 0+.0& E5@F55<;?:;7>9:A@D95:A:<956B C685@;@AA<@D95:?6<A <FF@A:D9A<9:A' 5: ?@G7D<> 6D<==?:F@<9@6D 6B 95: :K@A:DF: 6D ?:F6?A ?:F6?A:A F>:<? B@DA@D8 95<9 A?@K:?6B95:6BB:DA@D89?7FIE<;D:8>@8:D9<DAF<7;:A95: <FF@A:D9 <DA 95: @D;7?<DF: F6C=<DH G:@D8 95: @DA:CD@B@:?6B95:6BB:DA@D8K:5@F>:@;>@<G>:96;<9@;BH95: F6C=:D;<9@6D<C67D9B6?95:>6;;F<7;:A9695:F><@C<D9; : A6 D69 B@DA <DH :??6? 6? =:?K:?;@9H @D 95: B@DA@D8 ?:F6?A:A GH 95: ?@G7D<> E@95 ?:8<?A 96 95: D:8>@8:DF: <8:<K6F<9@6D@DF6C:6B95:A:F:<;:A<DA95:9:??@96?@<> J7?@;A@F9@6D 6B 95: ?@G7D<> <DA <>;6 E@95 ?:8<?A 96 =6;;:;;@D86BA?@K@D8>@F:DF:GH95:A?@K:?6B95:6BB:DA@D8 9?7FI - 11 - + <K@D85:>A95<995:<FF@A:D9@;F<7;:AA7:96 95: ?<;5 <DA D:8>@8:D9 A?@K@D8 6B 95: A?@K:? 6B 95: 6BB:DA@D8 9?7FI G:<?@D8 :8 6 0+.0& 95: <==:>><D9@D;7?<DF: F6C=<DH @; >@<G>: 96 @DA:CD@BH 95: F6C=:D;<9@6D <E<?A:A GH 95: ?@G7D<> <; E:>> <; 95: :D5<DF:A F6C=:D;<9@6D A:9:?C@D:A GH 95@; 67?9 57; 95:F><@C<D9;<?::D9@9>:A96C6A@B@:AF6C=:D;<9@6D7DA:? 95:5:<A6B>6;;6BA:=:DA:DFH<;7DA:? ;,%''P+''')'O*Q;'%''NN Q&'''0%'OQ'! ! ( ;=:?95:A:F@;@6D6B 6D4G>: =:N67?9@D95: F<;: 6B ! "<==:>><D9;F><@C<D9; <?: :D9@9>:A 96 < ;7C 6B #$%$$$&':<F596E<?A;F6D;6?9@7CG:;@A:;<;7C6B (%$$$&' 7DA:? 95: 5:<A 6B >6;; 6B :;9<9: <DA (%$$$&' 7DA:? 95: 5:<A 6B 9?<D;=6?9<9@6D 6B A:<A G6AH<DAB7D:?<>:N=:D;:; )'*+' - 12 - % 57; 95: F><@C<D9; E67>A G: :D9@9>:A 96 C6A@B@:AF6C=:D;<9@6D6D95:B6>>6E@D85:<A; 57; 95: F><@C<D9; <?: :D9@9>:A 96 < 969<> F6C=:D;<9@6D6B %"%##%$$$&'<;<8<@D;9;''''0 <E<?A:AGH95:?@G7D<> & D95:?:;7>9E:=?6F::A96=<;;95:B6>>6E@D8 <* 6'%'+@; G* 6'+'%,'@;)**+,-./01)23 F* 5: @C=78D:A J7A8C:D9 <DA <E<?A 6B 95: ?@G7D<> @; C6A@B@:A 96 <D :N9:D9 95<9 95: F><@C<D9; E67>A G: :D9@9>:A 96 969<> F6C=:D;<9@6D %"%##%$$$&'<; <8<@D;9 ;''''0 <E<?A:A GH 95: ?@G7D<> E5@F5;5<>>F<??H@D9:?:;9<995:?<9:6B&O )23/45*)2' 6+503 7/0'8 6;;6B@DF6C:A7:96A:=:DA:DFH +''' 6;;6BF6D;6?9@7C '''' 6;;6B:;9<9: %''' 6E<?A; 9?<D;=6?9<9@6D 6B A:<A G6AH<DAB7D:?<>:N=:D;:; %''' +3)* ! ! ! - 13 - =:?<DD7CB?6C95:A<9:6B=:9@9@6D9@>>95: A<9:6B=<HC:D9 A* 5: <==:>><D90D;7?<DF: 6C=<DH ;5<>> A:=6;@995::D5<DF:AF6C=:D;<9@6D<C67D9 E@95 <FF?7:A @D9:?:;9 G:B6?: 95: ?@G7D<> E@95@D<=:?@6A6B;@NE::I;B?6C96A<H :* 5: <==6?9@6DC:D9 A:=6;@9 <DA A@;G7?;:C:D9;5<>>G:C<A:<;=:?<E<?A6B 95:?@G7D<> B* 5:<C67D9@DA:=6;@9G:9?<D;C@99:A9695: ?@G7D<>B6?95E@95 8* ?<EC6A@B@:A<E<?A<FF6?A@D8>H .( 7#8 # .( 7%# 8 # "