- 1 - !" #$%$ $ && ' ( ) ! ""# " $ % $ & $ ' ()%(#& $ $ " $ %((" $ Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * '$ & #( ! "") " ! "") ! ((" % ! ""# ( $ " $ ((" # %( ! ""# - 3 - " $ ((" ! "# # ! "# ! ! "# * '$ "( +!, $ - " , +#$& - (( - (("(() !) "(( $ ("("(( "" "((" $ ' & - $$- ("(" - . - / $- 0 - 4 - *% $ ' 0 & 12 3425267 833289 :5 ;:92< => 712 ?65?@@255;?9 398:67:;;5 8558:9:6A 712 @B6@?44267 ;:6<:6A5 B; 712 @B?475 =29BC C1242=> 712 5?:7 :657:7?72< => 712 398:67:;;5 522D:6A8<2@98487:B6B;7:79286<@B652E?267:89429:2;B; 3B55255:B6 :6 42532@7 B; 712 5?:7 5@12<?92 34B3247:25 @8F27B=2<:5F:552< " 12;8@75928<:6A7B712@852:6=4:2;84285 ;B99BC5 12398:67:;;5@98:F7B=27128=5B9?72BC6245B;712 5?:7 5@12<?92 34B3247:25 855247:6A 7187 712 58F2 @B657:7?72712:486@25748934B3247:257:5712:4@8527187 712 86@257B45 68F29> 18468338 86< 1:G8338 18< FB47A8A2<71258:<34B3247:2586<;B442<2F37:B6B;712 FB47A8A2 712 398:67:;;5 18< 2849:24 :657:7?72< 8 5?:7 :6 B) B; ))# BC2G24 712 58:< 5?:7 @8F2 7B =2 C:71<48C6C:71712928G2B;712B?477B;:928;42515?:7 - 5 - B6 712 58F2 @8?52 B; 8@7:B6 ?45?867 7B 5?@1 C:71<48C8971234252675?:7:6 B""B;"(("185 =226 ;:92< C1242:6 712 398:67:;;5 18G2 5B?A17 <2@98487:B6B;BC62451:386<3B55255:B6@B6726<:6A7187 712 <2;26<8675 18G2 6B 52F=986@2 B; 4:A17 7:792 B4 :6724257 BG24 712 5?:7 34B3247:25 12 398:67:;;5 18G2 ;?47124 @B6726<2< 7187 712 <2;26<8675/ @98:F B; BC62451:3 :5 =852< B6 @2478:6 ?642A:57242< 5892 <22<5 3?43B472<9>2H2@?72<=>712398:67:;;5/86@257B45:6) % C1:@18@@B4<:6A7B712398:67:;;5<B6B7@B6G2>86> G89:<7:792B4BC62451:3:698C 12398:67:;;5@98:F:6A7B=271292A8912:45B; 184868338 86< 1:G8338 855247 7187 712> 18G2 5?@@22<2< 7B 712 5?:7 5@12<?92 34B3247:25 => C8> B; :6124:786@2 67187342F:52712398:67:;;5@B6726<7187 712 BC62451:3 B; 712 34B3247:25 185 98C;?99> <2GB9G2< ?3B6 712F 86< 71242;B42 712> 842 267:792< 7B 8 <2@98487:B67187712>8427128=5B9?72BC6245B;7125?:7 34B3247:25B652E?267:899>712>18G25B?A178<:42@7:B6 - 6 - 7B 712 <2;26<8675 7B <29:G24 G8@867 3B55255:B6 B; 712 58F2 % 3B6524G:@2B;7125?FFB65712<2;26<8675 8332842<:6@B?4786<;:92<8<278:92<C4:772657872F267 12>@872AB4:@899><26:2<7187712398:67:;;18<86>7:792 B4 :6724257 :6 712 5?:7 986< 65728< 712 <2;26<8675 8G2442< 7187 712 398:67:;;/5 342<2@255B45 18< :6 ) %I 5B9<71234B3247>7B712<2;26<8675=><?9>2H2@?72< 5892<22<5971B?A1712525892<22<5C2428<F:772<9> 6B7 42A:57242< 712 <2;26<8675 @B6726<2< 7187 7:792 6B627129255 G2572< :6 712F => G:47?2 B; 71B52 :6574?F2675 29>:6A B6 712 8552472< 5892 <22<5 712 <2;26<8675 3B:672< B?7 7187 2674:25 7B 7187 2;;2@7 C242 F8<2:6712B;;:@:89986<42@B4<5712:468F25C242<?9> 42@B4<2<85712BC6245B;71234B3247> 6 712 89724687:G2 712 <2;26<8675 3928<2< 7187712>18G2=226:6@B67:6?B?5B326328@2;?986< - 7 - 8<G2452 3B55255:B6 B; 712 5?:7 986< ;B4 FB42 7186 ;:;7> >284512>8552472<71875?@1?6:67244?372<3B55255:B6 1854:3262<:67B8G89:<7:792:6712:4;8GB?4 6712=85:5 B;71252@B67267:B65I7:792=>G:47?2B;712) (/55892 <22<5 86< 7:792 => 8<G2452 3B55255:B6 712 <2;26<8675 348>2<71877125?:7=2<:5F:552<85=2:6AC:71B?7F24:7 # 12398:67:;;586<712<2;26<86758<<?@2<B489 86< <B@?F26784> 2G:<26@2 7B 5?=57867:872 712:4 42532@7:G2 @98:F5 ;724 8 ;?99 74:89 712 928462< 4:89 B?47 B6 2H8F:687:B6 B; 712 2G:<26@2 865C242< 55?2 B:671262A87:G21B9<:6A7187712398:67:;;518<;8:92< 7B 2578=9:51 712:4 7:7927B 712 5?:7 986<5 124:89 B?47 ;?47124 865C242< 55?2 B :6 712 62A87:G2 <2@984:6A 7187 712 <2;26<8675 895B 18< 6B7 5?@@22<2< :6 34BG:6A BC62451:3B;7125?:7986<5 ! B7C:715786<:6A71:57124:89B?47C267B6 7B865C2455?2B#:67128;;:4F87:G2B68689724687:G2 ;:6<:6A68F29>7187712<2;26<867518<324;2@72<712:4 - 8 - 7:792 => G:47?2 B; 8<G2452 3B55255:B6 6 9:A17 B; 71:5 987724 ;:6<:6A 712 4:89 B?47 <:5F:552< 712 398:67:;;5/ 5?:7 ) 12398:67:;;5@844:2<712F87724:686833289 =2;B42 712 33299872 B?47 :6 B!) "(( 86< @B672572< =B71 712 ;:6<:6A5 86< <2@422 B; 712 4:89 B?476:7542G:2C71233299872B?47422H8F:62<712 B48986<<B@?F26784>2G:<26@286<BG247?462<7124:89 B?47/5 @B6@9?5:B6 B6 55?2 B# 1B9<:6A 7187 712 <2;26<867518<6B72578=9:512<7187712>18<324;2@72< 7:792=>8<G24523B55255:B62G24712925571233299872 B?47 <:5F:552< 712 833289 B6 712 :6<2326<267 A4B?6< 7187712398:67:;;518<;8:92<7B2578=9:51712:4BC67:7927B 7125?:7986<586<71?52G26C:7171242G24589B655?2 B#<2@9:62<7BA4867429:2;:6;8GB?4B;712398:67:;;5 ( -229:6A 8AA4:2G2< => 712 @B6@?44267 J?<AF2675 :6 712 B?475 =29BC 712 398:67:;;5 =2:6A ?65?@@255;?9 :6 4:89 B?47 86< 33299872 B?47 18G2 - 9 - 342;2442<712342526752@B6<833289>B4<24<872<! !"(#71:5B?478<F:772<712833289B6712;B99BC:6A 5?=57867:89E?257:B65B;98C +,-+,./ , /01/23,2+34 506/2+,/ 437 /'+(3,-'++( 1:5 B?47 185 1284< 712 928462< @B?6529 833284:6A ;B4 712 42532@7:G2 3847:25 86< 185 @842;?99> 324?52< 712 3928<:6A5 85 C299 85 712 B489 86< <B@?F26784> 2G:<26@2 8<<?@2< => =B71 5:<25 12 34:F84> ;B@?5 B; 71:5 B?47/5 2H8F:687:B6 :5 B6 712 ;:6<:6A5 42@B4<2< => 712 4:89 B?47 <2@984:6A 712 - 10 - <2;26<8675 7B 18G2 8@E?:42< BC62451:3 => C8> B; 8<G24523B55255:B6 " 2;B428<G247:6A7B7125?=57867:89E?257:B6B; 98C;48F2<;B4@B65:<2487:B6:7CB?9<=28334B34:8727B 42;247B3848A48315%7BB;712398:6786<3848A48315 "7B%B;712C4:772657872F267C1:@1842F8724:897B 712@B674BG245>86<71258F28422H748@72<=29BC 848A4831B5%7BB;712398:67 !" #$ %"! # & ' " " ( ) " " * + $,+-.+ ( ) - 11 - /"#,+ $,,0 1 " 2 #$% # & & " 3 " 4 " 5 " 6 848A48315B5"7B%B;712C4:772657872F267 $% 2 7 ! ! ! - 12 - ! 8 ! $- #$ % - 9 :' " #$ #%!; #-! 4! /( # $ - #$ 9 ; 4 # "# %%$! %%% %%-! % ! " < 1 7 $,+.++ 5 ! $,+.++ 2 - 13 - ! " # # $ % - ' 7 ! ! ! ! !! 3 6 6 8 428<:6A B; 3848A48315 % 7B B; 712 398:67:7 :52G:<2677187712398:67:;;5748@2712:47:7927B 712 5?:7 986<5 714B?A1 712:4 86@257B45 86< 855247 7187 712> 18G2 5?@@22<2< 7B 712 34B3247:25 => :6124:786@2 12><:53?72712<2;26<8675/@98:FB;BC62451:3B6712 A4B?6<7187712 8992A2<5892 748658@7:B65 527 ?3 =>712 <2;26<8675 842 ?65?33B472< => 86> G89:< B4 42A:57242< - 14 - :6574?F2675 86< 71242;B42 :6 712 2>25 B; 98C 6B 7:792 @B?9<18G2=226@B6G2>2<7B712<2;26<8675 % B6G24529>8324?589B;3848A48315"7B% B; 712 C4:7726 57872F267 42G2895 7187 712 <2;26<8675 C1:92 8@D6BC92<A:6A 712 B4:A:689 BC62451:3 B; 712 398:67:;;5/86@257B45@B6726<718771258:<86@257B455B9< 7125?:7986<57B712<2;26<8675?6<24?642A:57242<5892 <22<5 2H2@?72< :6 712 >284 ) % 6 7187 =85:5 712> 8552478@E?:5:7:B6B;BC62451:34:A175BG247125?:7986<5 6 712 89724687:G2 712 <2;26<8675 18G2 3928<2< 7187 712> 18G2 =226 :6 @B67:6?B?5 B326 86< ?6:67244?372< 3B55255:B6B;7125?:7986<5;B4FB427186;:G2<2@8<25 86<71242=>18G2324;2@72<712:47:792=>C8>B;8<G2452 3B55255:B6 12 4:89 B?47/5 @B6@9?5:B6 B6 55?2 B 68F29>7187712398:67:;;5;8:92<7B2578=9:51712:47:7927B 7125?:7986<5:5G?96248=927B524:B?5B=J2@7:B6:7:56B7 B69>324G2452=?7895B<:42@79>:6@B65:57267C:718@9284 - 15 - 8<F:55:B6 F8<2 => 712 <2;26<8675 :6 712:4 BC6 3928<:6A5 6 3847:@?984 3848A4831 B; C4:7726 57872F267:6862849:245?:7=27C22671258F23847:25:2 B) B; ))#86< :63848A4831 B; 712 C4:7726 57872F267 :6 712 3425267 5?:7 @B678:65 86 ?62E?:GB@89 8<F:55:B6 7187 712 398:67:;;5/ 86@257B45 129< 8=5B9?72 BC62451:3 B; 712 5?:7 986<5 86< 7187 71B52 986<5 18< =226 @B6G2>2< => 712 398:67:;;5/ 86@257B45 7B 712 <2;26<8675 ?6<24 ?642A:57242< 5892 <22<5 > 5?@1 8G24F267712<2;26<8675@B6@2<27CB@4:7:@893B:675':& 7187712398:67:;;5/86@257B45C24274?286<98C;?9BC6245 B; 712 34B3247> 86< '::& 7187 86> 74865;24 2;;2@72< C85 ?6<24?642A:57242<:6574?F2675 # 6 98C 8<F:55:B65 :6 3928<:6A5 @844> 532@:89 C2:A17 86< 842 B4<:684:9> =:6<:6A B6 712 3847> C1B F8D25 712F ?@1 8<F:55:B65 @866B7 9:A179> =2 BG244:<<26=>712B?47C:71B?7@BA2674285B61268 - 16 - <2;26<8678<F:75712G24>7:79271878398:67:;;8552475:7 426<245712=?4<26B6 712398:67:;; 7B34BG27187 7:792 8 984A29>;B4F892H24@:52?69255B;@B?452712<2;26<867 8<<?@25 5?=57867:G2 2G:<26@2 7B @B674BG247 712 8<F:55:B6 ! 242 C:71B?7 86> ;?47124 F8724:89 B4 3245?85:G2 2G:<26@2 @B6748<:@7:6A B4 :F3?A6:6A 712 8<F:55:B6:63848A4831B;712C4:772657872F267712 4:89 B?47 B?A17 6B7 7B 18G2 42J2@72< 712 398:67:;;5/ @98:F B; 7:792 12 ;:6<:6A 42@B4<2< B6 55?2 B :6 <:542A84< B; 712 @9284 8<F:55:B6 :6 712 C4:7726 57872F267 :5 71?5 F86:;2579> 324G2452 86< 38938=9> 244B62B?5 ) 1:5B?47F?57895B7?467B7124:89B?47/5 74287F267 B; 55?2 B# C1:@1 @B6@2462< 712 3928 B; 8<G2452 3B55255:B6 6 <B:6A 5B :7 :5 :F32487:G2 7B 2F3185:5271877124:89B?4783328457B18G2267:429> :A6B42< B4 5?FF84:9> <:5@84<2< 712 8<F:55:B65 F8<2 - 17 - => 712 <2;26<8675 :6 3848A48315 86< % B; 712 C4:772657872F267 "( 1:92 :7 :5 74?2 7187 8 <2;26<867 F8> :6 8334B34:872@:4@?F5786@258<B378<2;265:G25786@27187 :5:6@B65:57267B42G26@B6;9:@7:6A:671289724687:G2712 32@?9:84;8@75 B; 71:5 @852<2F86< 7187 A428724 @842=2 78D26 :6 2G89?87:6A C187 712 <2;26<8675 712F529G25 18G23928<2<242712<2;26<86758<F:77187398:67:;;5/ 86@257B45129<8=5B9?727:7927B7125?:7986<586<855247 7187 71B52 86@257B45 5B9< 712 986<5 7B 712 <2;26<8675 ?6<24 ?642A:57242< 5892 <22<5 8G:6A 71?5 5B?A17 7B 748@2712:47:792<:42@79>;4BF712398:67:;;5/86@257B45712 <2;26<8675 842 =B?6< 7B 51BC C126 712:4 3B55255:B6 =2@8F2 8<G2452 7187 :5 712 342@:52 3B:67 :6 7:F2 ;4BF C1:@1712:43B55255:B6C851B57:927B712:6724257B;712 398:67:;;5 86< C127124 712 398:67:;;5 18< 6B7:@2 B; 5?@1 8<G2452@98:F - 18 - " 1:5 @4:7:@89 :6A42<:267 68F29> 712 B6527 B; 1B57:9:7>86<712D6BC92<A2B;712398:67:;;5C8562:7124 3928<2< C:71 86> 532@:;:@:7> 6B4 34B3249> @B65:<242< => 7124:89B?47>;8:9:6A7B26A8A2C:71712<2;26<8675/ BC68<F:55:B65:63848A4831'86<%&B;712C4:7726 57872F267 712 4:89 B?47 F:552< 712 <B@74:689 42E?:42F267718783928B;8<G24523B55255:B6F?574257 ?3B68@92843928<:6AB;C126712@98:F7?462<1B57:92 86<C:7142532@77BC1BF71871B57:9:7>C85<:42@72<6 71:5 @B672H7 712 3928<:6A5 :6 3848A4831 C2:A1 128G:9> 8A8:657 712 <2;26<8675 86< 712 4:89 B?47/5 BF:55:B6 7B 8@@B4< 712F <?2 :F3B4786@2 :5 8 524:B?5 ;98C:6:754285B6:6A "" ?46:6A6BC7B712J?<AF267B;71233299872 B?47 71:5 B?47 ;:6<5 7187 712 33299872 B?47 185 8<B372<8C1B99>F:5@B6@2:G2<8334B8@1253:7218G:6A @872AB4:@899>42@B4<2<8;:6<:6A7187712<2;26<867518G2 6B7 324;2@72< 712:4 7:792 => C8> B; 8<G2452 3B55255:B6 712 33299872 B?47 185 487124 :62H39:@8=9> 34B@22<2< - 19 - 7B 2F=84D ?3B6 86 ?662@25584> 26E?:4> 7B?@1:6A ?3B6 712398:67:;;5/8992A2<@98:FB;FB47A8A2:6;8GB?4B;712 <2;26<8675 " 5 712 ;:689 ;8@7;:6<:6A 8?71B4:7> 712 33299872 B?47 C85 <?7>=B?6< 7B 422H8F:62 712 3928<:6A5 B; 712 4:G89 3847:25 7B <2724F:62 C127124 712 398:67:;;5/ 7:792 7B 712 5?:7 986<5 C85 2G24 :6 A26?:62 <:53?72 398:6 428<:6A B; 3848A4831 B; 712 C4:7726 57872F267928G256B4BBF;B48F=:A?:7>712<2;26<8675 18G2:6?62E?:GB@89724F58<F:772<7187712398:67:;;5/ 86@257B45 C242 712 B4:A:689 86< 8=5B9?72 BC6245 B; 712 5?:734B3247:2586<7187712<2;26<8675842748@:6A712:4 7:792 714B?A1 71B52 G24> 86@257B45 B6 712 57426A71 B; ?642A:57242<5892<22<5?@1868<F:55:B6B324872585 8 @9284 8@D6BC92<AF267 B; 712 398:67:;;5/ BC62451:3 6@2 71:5 8<F:55:B6 :5 F8<2 712 E?257:B6 B; ;?47124 5@4?7:6>:67B712398:67:;;5/7:792<B256B784:52 - 20 - "% 12 33299872 B?47 1BC2G24 ;8:92< 7B A:G2 <?2 C2:A17 7B 71:5 2H39:@:7 8<F:55:B6 86< :65728< <:G2472< :75 877267:B6 7B 712 E?257:B6 B; C127124 712 398:67:;;5 18< @98:F2< 42<2F37:B6 B; 8 FB47A8A2 :6 ;8GB?4B;712<2;26<8675:58F87724718718<6B=284:6A C1875B2G24 B6 712 3425267 34B@22<:6A5 7 F?57 =2 6B72< 7187 712 398:67:;;5 18< 2849:24 C:71<48C6 712 5?:7 522D:6A42<2F37:B6B;FB47A8A2C:719:=247>7B:657:7?72 8 ;4251 5?:7 86< 712 3425267 8@7:B6 :5 B62 3?429> ;B4 <2@98487:B6 B; BC62451:3 86< @B652E?267:89 3B55255:B6 =852< B6 7:792 1242;B42 712 E?257:B6 B; 42<2F37:B6 C85C1B99>;B42:A67B7125@B32B;71234252679:7:A87:B6 " 8G:6A ;B?6< 7187 712 <2;26<8675 ;8:92< 7B 2578=9:51712:43928B;8<G24523B55255:B671233299872 B?47B?A177B18G2899BC2<71283328986<<2@422<712 5?:7:6;8GB?4B;712398:67:;;575<2@:5:B67B6B627129255 <:5F:55712833289<253:72712@92848<F:55:B6B;7:792:6 3848A4831 86< 712 8=526@2 B; 86> 5?578:68=92 <2;26@2 :5 F86:;2579> 244B62B?5 86< 42;92@75 8 - 21 - ;?6<8F267899> ;98C2< 8334B8@1 7B 712 83342@:87:B6 B; 3928<:6A5 86< 2G:<26@2 @@B4<:6A9> 5?=57867:89 E?257:B65 B; 98C B':& :5 865C242< :6 86< 5?=57867:89 E?257:B6 B; 98C B'::& :5 865C242< :6 ,840/+,/3,- 68966 6<F:55:B6:6928<:6A5 " 8G:6A @842;?99> 42G:2C2< 7123928<:6A5 :7 :5 @9284 7187 3848A4831 B; 712 C4:7726 57872F267 @B678:6586?68F=:A?B?58<F:55:B6=>712<2;26<8675 712> 8<F:7 7187 712 398:67:;;5/ 86@257B45 C242 8=5B9?72 BC6245B;7125?:7986<586<71877128992A2<74865;245 7B 712 <2;26<8675 C242 2;;2@72< => ?642A:57242< 5892 <22<5 187 8<F:55:B6 :6 98C :5 =:6<:6A 86< F?57 =2 A:G26 <?2 C2:A17 86< 2;;2@7 7 :5 :F34B324 ;B4 86> @B?4774:89 B4 833299872 7B <:542A84< 5?@1 86 8<F:55:B6 C:71B?7574B6A@B?6724G8:9:6A2G:<26@2B4J?57:;:@87:B6 - 22 - 655?2B'98:67:;;5/:792& "# 12 74:89 @B?47/5 ;:6<:6A 7187 712 398:67:;;5 ;8:92<7B34BG2712:47:792@866B75786<>G:47?2B;712 <2;26<8675/ 8<F:55:B6 :6 712:4 BC6 3928<:6A5 712 ;B?6<87:B6897:792@98:F2<=>712398:67:;;5B?A177B18G2 =226 8@@2372< 12 42J2@7:B6 B; 398:67:;;5/ 7:792 B6 71:5 :55?2:6;8@2B;5?@18<F:55:B65:5F86:;2579>244B62B?5 86<G:7:87257187;:6<:6A 655?2B#'<G2452B55255:B6928& "! 12 <2;26<8675/ 3928 B; 8<G2452 3B55255:B6 3425?33B525 8 3B55255:B6 1B57:92 7B 712 398:67:;;5/ :6724257 27 712 <2;26<8675 18G2 897BA27124 ;8:92< 7B 3928< B4 98724 34BG2 712 3B:67 :6 7:F2 C126 712:4 3B55255:B6 =2@8F2 8<G2452 B4 7B 51BC 7187 5?@1 1B57:9:7> C85 =4B?A17 7B 712 877267:B6 B4 D6BC92<A2 B; 712 398:67:;;5 12:4 BC6 8<F:55:B6 B; 7:792 :6 3848A4831 :5 C1B99> :6@B65:57267 C:71 8 =B68 ;:<2 1B57:92 3B55255:B6 12 74:89 @B?47/5 ;8:9?42 7B 5E?8429> 26A8A2 - 23 - C:71 7187 8<F:55:B6 86< 712 98@D B; 62@25584> 3928<:6A B6 B6527 B; 8<G245:7> 426<245 :75 8<G2452 3B55255:B6 ;:6<:6A ?65?578:68=92 12 833299872 @B?47 4:A179> 42J2@72< 7187 <2;26@2 =?7 7126 ;8:92< 7B A:G2 2;;2@7 7B 718742J2@7:B6 $:5398@2<6E?:4>:67BB47A8A286<2<2F37:B6 ") 12 833299872 @B?47/5 <2@:5:B6 7B 2672478:6 :55?25B;FB47A8A242<2F37:B6<253:7218G:6A2H342559> 129<7187712<2;26<8675<:<6B78@E?:427:792=>8<G2452 3B55255:B6 :5 C1B99> 2H74862B?5 7B 712 3425267 5?:7 C1:@1 :5 B62 ;B4 <2@98487:B6 B; 7:792 86< @B652E?267:89 3B55255:B6 12 398:67:;;5 18< 2849:24 8=86<B62< 712 34:B442<2F37:B65?:7,712><B6B734252679>429>B67187 @8?52B;8@7:B612833299872@B?47/52H@?45:B6:67B712 FB47A8A2 E?257:B6 C85 =2>B6< 712 5@B32 B; 712 3928<:6A5 86< 7B 7187 2H7267 :75 8334B8@1 :5 ;?6<8F267899>;98C2< - 24 - $B442@7:53B5:7:B6 ( 8G:6A 29:F:6872< 712 <2;26<8675/ 8<G2452 3B55255:B6<2;26@286<:69:A17B;712=:6<:6A8<F:55:B6 B; 7:792 :6 712 3928<:6A5 712 B69> 92A899> 5?578:68=92 B?7@BF2 :5 7187 712 398:67:;;5 842 267:792< 7B 712 429:2; @98:F2< :6 712:4 5?:7 8 <2@98487:B6 B; 712:4 7:792 86< 8 <:42@7:B6;B4<29:G24>B;3B55255:B6 ':&1252@B6<833289:5899BC2< '::& ?<A2F267 :6 B!) "(( @B6;:4F:6A J?<AF26786<<2@422B;74:89B?47:6 B"" "((":51242=>52785:<2 ':::& 7 :5 <2@9842< 7187 712 398:67:;;5 842 712 8=5B9?72 86< 98C;?9 BC6245 B; 712 5?:7 986<5 '<25@4:=2< :6 712 5@12<?92 7B 712 398:67& => G:47?2 B; :6124:786@2 86< 712 8<F:55:B65:67123928<:6A5 ':G& 12 <2;26<8675 842 <:42@72< 7B <29:G24 G8@8673B55255:B6B;7125?:7986<57B712 398:67:;;5 C:71:6 8 324:B< B; 71422 FB6715 - 25 - ;4BF712<872B;71:5<2@422;8:9:6AC1:@1 712398:67:;;5 F8> 78D2 3B55255:B6 5?=J2@7 7B98C 'G& 12 <2;26<8675 51899 =284 712 @B575 B; 712 5?:7 'G:& 48C<2@4228@@B4<:6A9> -: '$ $( % :57B"9B