- 1 - !" # $%" %%%&' $% " % %## & ! " " Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " #$% & ' " ( " $)*)&+ ( #)& , **$ #$+ #* )+ ( " $)*)&+ ( #)& , **$#$+#*)+ **$ #$+ #* )+ ( " ( " " -" ("""! -" ( " - 3 - "% -" ("""! ./ 010/ .12 34/5/44/6 0.72 133/18 5//879: 1::47/;/6 <= 0./ >?6:@/90 196 A46/4 610/6 $)*)&+ 3122/6 <= 0./ 66707A918 /227A92 3/B718 (?6:/ 10 181<?41:7 79 /227A92 12/ A#)& C./4/<= 0./ 8/149/6 /227A92 (?6:/ .12 1BD?700/6 0./ 4/23A96/90 1BB?2/6 A5 0./ A55/9B/2 3?972.1<8/ ?96/4 /B07A92 **$ #$+#*)+A5 / .1;/ ./146 0./ 14:?@/902 A5 0./ 8/149/6 66707A918 5A4 0./ 010/ 196 0./ 8/149/6 BA?92/8 133/1479: 5A4 4/23A96/90 196 3/4?2/6 0./ /;76/9B/ 196 @10/4718A94/BA46 # 9 <47/5 70 72 0./ B12/ A5 34A2/B?07A9 0.10 A9 %)#)& 10 1<A?0 &))) 1@ 0./ 1BB?2/6 B47@79188= 04/23122/6 790A 0./ 1:47B?80?418 8196 A5 + 79 19614C167881:/C./4/790./;7B07@&C12790./ 514@ .A?2/ 196 641::/6 ./4 0A 0./ 8196 A5 &# # 0.4?20 B8A0. 790A ./4 @A?0. 196 BA@@700/6 - 4 - 5A4B7<8/ 2/E?18 790/4BA?42/ ?40./4 ./ 2B410B./6 ./4 B.//F2 196 B1?2/6 <8//679: 79>?47/2 196 182A 0.4/10/9/6 ./4C70.674/BA92/D?/9B/2752./672B8A2/60./79B76/900A A0./421960./4/<=BA@@700/60./B.14:/6A55/9B/2 * ./81CC122/0790A@A07A9<=&G;7B07@ <=8A6:79:1BA@381790123/4E&./G&$ A5/;18 191:13?4A87B/0107A94/:720/4/61B12/ 196 722?/6 0./ , EH 0A 0./ >?47267B07A918 A?40 ./4/150/4./2/900./;7B07@5A4@/67B18/E1@79107A90A A;/49@/90 A237018 181<?41:7 196 .196/6 A;/4 0./ 79;/207:107A90A0./G 9 #))#)& 1BB?2/6 C12 34A6?B/6 </5A4/ / C12 2?<>/B0/6 0A @/67B18 /E1@79107A9 ./ 2010/@/90A50./;7B07@C124/BA46/6?96/4/B07A9&+*A5 4 3A0 @1.1I14 C12 34/314/6 12 3/4 E# ./ 1407B8/2 2/7I/6 C/4/ 2/90 5A4 /E1@79107A9 ?40./4 79;/207:107A9 C12 01F/9 A;/4 <= 0./ G + C.A 150/4 4/B/730 A5 0./ 4/3A40 196 BA@38/07A9 A5 0./ 79;/207:107A9578/6B.14:/2.//01:179200./1BB?2/6 - 5 - + ./ 1BB?2/6 C12 B.14:/6 5A4 0./ A55/9B/2 3?972.1<8/?96/4/B07A92**$#$+#*196)+A5 /5A4/ 0./ 04718 A?40 0./ 34A2/B?07A9 :A0 /E1@79/6 2&0A$196:A0@14F/6E2&0A&%196"2&0A #./6/5/9B/:A0@14F/6E&7/0./3A407A9A50./ 2010/@/90A5 $ ./ 8/149/6 /227A92 (?6:/ ;76/ 7@3?:9/6 >?6:@/901BD?700/60./1BB?2/6A50./B.14:/6A55/9B/2 C.7B.72?96/4B.188/9:/<=0./010/ % 2217879: 0./ >?6:@/90 0./ 8/149/6 66707A918 .12BA90/96/60.100./04718A?40.120A0188=7:9A4/6 0./ @10/4718 /;76/9B/ A5 & C.7B. 72 BA44A<A410/6 <= 0./ /;76/9B/ A5 A0./4 C709/22/2 196 0./4/5A4/ 0./ 1BD?70018 A5 0./ 1BB?2/6 C12 9A0 34A3/4 / BA90/96/6 0.10 0./ ;7B07@ .12 B10/:A47B188= 2010/6 79 ./4 /;76/9B/ 0.10 0./ 1BB?2/6 <= 792/4079: B8A0. 79 ./4 @A?0. 196 641::79:./40A0./9/14<=57/86BA@@700/6413/A9./4 ./.12672B8A2/60./79B76/900A./4.?2<196@A0./4,79, 81CAC9/4A50./819612C/8812A0./4;7881:/42C.A.1;/ - 6 - 2?33A40/6 ./4 ;/427A9 / BA90/96/6 0.10 0./ 6/81= 79 8A6:79: 0./ BA@381790 .12 <//9 /E38179/6 <= & 79 E&702/85./9B/0./6/81=31407B?8148=791B12/A50.72 910?4/ C./4/ 70 72 /E38179/6 72 9A0 51018 0A 0./ 34A2/B?07A9 H ./ 8/149/6 66707A918 .12 5?40./4 BA90/96/60.10?96/423A0@1.1I14GE#1<81BFB8A0. 196 <19:8/ 37/B/2 14/ 4/BA;/4/6 54A@ 0./ 23A0 C.7B. 5?40./4 8/962 2?33A40 0A 0./ 34A2/B?07A9 B12/ 196 0./ 319B.C709/22/20AE#.1;/182A2?33A40/60./B12/A5 34A2/B?07A9 / 0./4/5A4/ BA90/96/6 0.10 0./ 4/12A92 1227:9/6<=0./04718A?400A1BD?700./1BB?2/6.A8679: 0.10 0./ /;76/9B/ A5 & 72 79574@ 196 9A0 04?20CA40.= /0B.124/2?80/679@72B14471:/A5>?207B/ &) 0./ 8/149/6 BA?92/8 133/1479: 5A4 0./4/23A96/90G1BB?2/6.12BA90/96/60.100./4/7219 79A467910/ 6/81= 79 8A6:79: 0./ BA@381790 196 0./ 04718 A?40.129A07B/62/47A?279574@707/2196BA904167B07A9279 0./ /;76/9B/ A5 & 196 A0./4 34A2/B?07A9 C709/22/2 - 7 - ./@/67B18/;76/9B/6A9A02?33A400.//;76/9B/A5& 196 0./4/5A4/ 0./ 04718 A?40 150/4 BA9276/479: 0./ /9074/ /;76/9B/ 196 @10/4718 A9 4/BA46 .12 1BD?700/6 0./ 1BB?2/6/BA90/96/60.100.72</79:19133/1834/5/44/6 1:17920 0./ >?6:@/90 A5 1BD?70018 /;/9 75 0CA ;7/C2 14/ 3A227<8/0./;7/CC.7B.7251;A?41<8/0A0./1BB?2/6.12 0A</1BB/30/6/.120./4/5A4/2A?:.00A672@7220./ 133/18 && ./ 79B76/90 72 188/:/6 0A .1;/ 01F/9 381B/ A9 %)#)& 10 1<A?0 &))) 1@ 79 0./ 8196 A5 A9/ 121;141> ?812?4 , 9 E& 0./ ;7B07@ .12 2010/6 0.10 2./ 18A9: C70. ./4 .?2<196 & ?2/6 0A CA4F790./8196A5121;141>?812?4279B/0.4//=/142 9 %)#)& 10 1<A?0 &))) 1@ 2./ C12 C12.79: B8A0./2790./514@.A?2/100.1007@/790./9/7:.<A479: 8196 A9/ "A.1@@16 91@614 && 196 .72 041B0A4 647;/4 91@/8= 0./ 1BB?2/6 C/4/ CA4F79: ./ 1BB?2/6 B1@/0A0./381B/C./4/2./C12C12.79:0./B8A0./2196 641::/6./4<=.1960A0./9/14<=2?:14B19/57/860.4?20 - 8 - B8A0.79./4@A?0../86./49/BFB1?2/6<8//679:79>?47/2 <= 2B410B.79: ./4 B.//F 196 BA@@700/6 413/ A9 ./4 ./4/150/4 ./ 0.4/10/9/6 ./4 C70. 674/ BA92/D?/9B/2 75 2./672B8A2/60./79B76/900AA0./421964191C1=54A@0./ 23A0 & ./ BA@381790 C12 8A6:/6 A9 H)#)& 10 1<A?0#))3@9E&70722010/60.100A34A0/B0./4 4/3?0107A9 2./ 676 9A0 672B8A2/ 0./ 79B76/90 0A ./4 .?2<196 A9 0.10 61= .AC/;/4 A9 0./ 9/E0 61= 7/ A9 H)#)&10H))1@2./4/;/18/60.//9074/79B76/90 0A ./4 .?2<196 & @A0./4,79,81C 196 0A 121;141>?812?41960./4/150/42./B1@/0A0./ 3A87B/20107A91968A6:/60./BA@381790 &# H 72 0./ 2B47</ A5 E& / .12 6/3A2/6 0.10A9H)#)&101<A?0&9AA9C./9./C12100./ <?2 20196 & 196 & B1@/ C//379: 196 4/;/18/60./79B76/900A.7@/0AAF0./@0A0./3A87B/ 20107A9196123/40./21=A5&./C4A0/6AC9E& - 9 - &* &$,.126/3A2/60.10A9H)#)& 10 1<A?0 #)) 3@ 0./ BA@38179190 B1@/ 0A 0./ 3A87B/ 20107A9 C70. 1 C4700/9 BA@381790 A9 0./ <1272 C.7B. 1 C4700/9 BA@381790 A9 0./ <1272 C.7B. ./ 4/:720/4/60./B12/196722?/60./ 0A0./A?40 & 6@700/68= 0./ 79B76/90 0AAF 381B/ A9 %)#)&101<A?0&)))1@196BA@381790C128A6:/6 A9 0./ 9/E0 61= 10 #)) 3@ 0 72 0./ BA90/907A9 A5 8/149/6 66707A918 0.10 279B/ 0./ ;7B07@ C12 0.4/10/9/6<=0./1BB?2/61965/1479:./44/3?0107A92./ 676 9A0 672B8A2/ 0./ 79B76/90 0A ./4 .?2<196 196 A0./4 4/8107;/2 A9 0./ 21@/ 61= / .12 0./4/5A4/ BA90/96/6 0.10 6/81= 79 8A6:79: 0./ BA@381790 72 9A0 51018 0A 0./ 34A2/B?07A9 &+ E 72 0./ 2010/@/90 A5 0./ ;7B07@ 4/BA46/6 ?96/4 /B07A9 &+* A5 4 3/4?218 A5 0./ 2176 2010/@/90CA?864/;/180.10A90./21@/61=;7B07@C/90 0A 0./ 9/14<= 57/86 C./4/ ./4 .?2<196 C12 CA4F79: 196 672B8A2/60./79B76/900A.7@0722010/60.100./4/150/4 - 10 - 2./ C12 <4A?:.0 0A 0./ ;7881:/ 196 01F/9 0A 0./ 3A87B/ 20107A90A8A6:/0./BA@381790 &$ ./1<A;/;/427A9:7;/9<=0./;7B07@79E </5A4/ 0./ 8/149/6 "1:720410/ B8/148= 2.AC 0.10 A9 0./ ;/4=21@/61=2./672B8A2/60./79B76/900A./4.?2<196 ./4/5A4/0./BA90/902A5E&201079:0.106?/0A5/14 12 0./4/ C12 0.4/10 <= 0./ 1BB?2/6 /0B 2./ 676 9A0 672B8A2/0./79B76/900A./4.?2<1961964/8107;/2A90./ 21@/61=133/1420A</6A?<05?8 &% H G 2B47</ A5 E& 0.A?:. 2010/6 0.10 ./ 0AAF & 196 A0./42 0A 0./ 3A87B/ 20107A9 C./4/79 ./ C4A0/6AC90./BA@381790122010/6<=&&$, C.A4/:720/4/60./B12/150/44/B/7;79:E&54A@& .129A0101882010/61<A?00./34/2/9B/A5H90./ A0./4.196790./B4A22,/E1@79107A90.A?:../16@700/6 0.10E&C12:A0C4700/9<=H./2010/60.10H 6769A01BBA@319=0./BA@381791900A0./3A87B/20107A9 - 11 - &H BBA4679: 0A 0./ 34A2/B?07A9 0./ 1BB?2/6 792/40/61<81BFBA8A?4B8A0.790A0./@A?0.A5&196 BA@@700/6413/196100.1007@/./4<19:8/2C/4/<4AF/9 ./ 2176 <81BF BA8A?4 B8A0. "& 196 <19:8/ 37/B/2 "C/4/4/BA;/4/654A@0./23A0?96/4E#790./ 34/2/9B/A5319B.C709/22/2,2#196*0729A6A?<0 <A0. 0./ 319B. C709/22/2 .1;/ 2?33A40/6 0./ B12/ A5 34A2/B?07A9.AC/;/470724/8/;1900A2//0.1079E& &.129AC./4/2010/60.10./4<19:8/2C/4/<4AF/910 0./ 07@/ A5 79B76/90 ./4/12 70 72 2010/6 79 E ?40./42./.129A02010/60.100./1BB?2/60.4?201B8A0. 79./4@A?0.79EA90./A0./4.1962./.122010/6 0.100./1BB?2/6./86./4@A?0.1969A2/07:.08= ) 9 ;7/C A5 0./ 1<A;/ 672B4/319B= 9A07B/6 79 E&E1960./6/3A2707A9A5&6/81=798A6:79: 0./BA@381790122?@/27@3A4019B/?40./470729A07B/6 0.100.A?:.0./ C124/:720/4/6A9H)#)&10#)) 3@&*,0./A87B/A9201<8/C.AB1447/60./ 0A 0./A?40.122010/60.10./.196/6A;/40./ 0A0./ - 12 - >?47267B07A918 "1:720410/ A9 #))#)& 10 %)) 1@ / .12047/60A/E381790./6/81=201079:0.100./4/276/9B/A5 0./ 8/149/6 "1:720410/ C12 1<A?0 # F78A@/0/4 1C1= AC/;/40./51B04/@17920.100./79B76/900AAF381B/A9 %)#)& 10 &))) 1@ 0./ BA@381790 C12 8A6:/6 A9 0./9/E061=10#))3@1960./ C124/B/7;/6<=0./ "1:720410/A9#))#)&10%))1@ & 9 0./ 1<A;/ <1BF:4A?96 70 72 9/B/2214= 0A /E1@79/ 0./ /;76/9B/ A5 & 196 A0./4 34A2/B?07A9 C709/22/2 0724/8/;1900A2//0.101314054A@0./;7B07@ 188 0./ A0./4 C709/22/2 /E1@79/6 <= 0./ 34A2/B?07A9 14/ ./1421= C709/22/2 1BBA4679: 0A C.A@ 0./ 79B76/90 C12 914410/60A0./@<=&20A%.1;/2010/60.1010 1<A?0&)))1@C./90./=C/900A0./81960./=21C & ./4 .?2<196 196 ./4 @A0./4,79,81C C//379: 196 C./9 0./= /9D?74/6 C70. 0./@ 0./= 672B8A2/6 0./ 79B76/90 AC/;/4 12 3/4 34A2/B?07A9 0./ 79B76/90 C12 - 13 - 4/;/18/6 <= & 0A ./4 .?2<196 196 @A0./4,79,81C A9 0./9/E061= 90./B12/A5 0./ 3/E A?40.12./860.10180.A?:.0./;7B07@J22A87014=/;76/9B/ 79 @100/42 4/810/6 0A 2/E?18 A55/9B/ 72 :/9/4188= 6//@/6 2?557B7/900A.A86191BB?2/6:?780=0./BA9;7B07A9B199A0 </ 2?20179/6 75 0./ 34A2/B?047EJ2 0/207@A9= 72 5A?96 ?94/871<8/ 196 792?557B7/90 6?/ 0A 76/90757/6 581C2 196 81B?91/ * ./;7B07@7216@700/68=1:/61<A?0=/14210 0./ 07@/ A5 79B76/90 ./4/ 14/ @10/4718 BA904167B07A92 79 ./4/;76/9B/196./4BA@381790E&12C/8812E, ./42010/@/904/BA46/6?96/4/B07A9&+*A54./ /E3819107A9 A55/4/6 5A4 6/81= 79 8A6:79: 0./ BA@381790 72 9A0 2107251B0A4= 12 0./4/ 72 6755/4/90 ;/427A9 :7;/9 79 E& 196 0./ /;76/9B/ A5 & ?40./4 ) G 0./ AB0A4 C.A BA96?B0/6 @/67B18 /E1@79107A9 A5 0./ ;7B07@ .12:7;/957918A3797A9201079:0.100./4/729A/;76/9B/A5 - 14 - 4/B/90 2/E?18 790/4BA?42/ <?0 34/;7A?2 790/4BA?42/ @7:.0 .1;/ .133/9/6 2 3/4 4/3A40,E& 34/2/9B/ A5 <8AA6 201792 2/@7918 201792 196 23/4@10AIA1 C/4/ 9A0 6/0/B0/6790./1407B8/22/905A4/E1@79107A9 ./8/149/666707A918.12BA90/96/60.10 123/40./@/67B18/;76/9B/B/4017979>?47/2C/4/9A07B/6 A9 0./ B.//F A5 0./ ;7B07@ C.7B. 8/962 BA44A<A4107A9 0A 0./ /;76/9B/ A5 & 0.10 0./4/ C12 5A4B7<8/ 2/E?18 790/4BA?42/ BA@@700/6 A9 ./4 / 5?40./4 BA90/96/6 0.10 ) .12 2010/6 0.10 79>?47/2 A9 0./ <A6= BA?86 </ 2?::/207;/A54/272019B/54A@0./;7B07@ + 9 E , 2010/@/90 & .12 9A0 10 188 2010/61<A?02./2?2017979:79>?47/20A./4B.//F90./ B4A22,/E1@79107A9 BA96?B0/6 <= 0./ 6/5/9B/ ) .12 2010/6 0.10 0./ 79>?47/2 @/907A9/6 79 E& @1= </ B1?2/6 <= ;A8?901478= 518879: A9 0./ <8?90 2?451B/ A5 0./ .146:4A?96./5?40./42010/60.102./.129A09A07B/6 19=1<4127A92BA90?27A92A90./C472021960.100./;7B07@ .12 9A0 2010/6 0./ .720A4= A5 2/E?18 1221?80 </5A4/ ./4 - 15 - ?40./4 75 1 816= 72 641::/6 <= 5A4B/ 196 1221?80/6 2/E?188=2./ CA?86.1;/ 2?20179/61<4127A92 BA90?27A92 196 81B/4107A92 A9 C.A8/ A5 0./ 6A4218 123/B0 A5 9/BF <1BF<?00ABF2.19621968/:2196790.72B12/2./.12 9A0 9A07B/6 2?B. 79>?47/2 A9 0./ <A6= A5 0./ ;7B07@ ?40./4 75 0./ ;7B07@ 72 2@A0./4/6 <= B8A0. 2187;1 CA?86 </34/2/90A90./B8A0.1960./2176B8A0.CA?86</2/900A 0./1962187;1CA?86.1;/<//96/0/B0/6<?0790.72 B12/0./.129A02/900./B8A0.?2/6<=0./1BB?2/610 0./07@/A52/E?181221?805A4@/67B18/E1@79107A9 $ 1;79: 1334/B710/6 0./ /;76/9B/ A5 & C/ 14/ A5 0./ ;7/C 0.10 ./4 /;76/9B/ 72 9A0 4/871<8/ 196 04?20CA40.=1969A0215/0ABA9;7B00./1BB?2/6./04718 A?401334/B71079:0./A4181966AB?@/9014=/;76/9B/A9 4/BA46 196 :7;79: /81<A410/ 4/12A92 .12 1BD?700/6 0./ 1BB?2/6 / 5796 0.10 0./ 4/12A92 1227:9/6 14/ 79 1BBA4619B/C70.81C % .72 </79: 19 133/18 34/5/44/6 1:17920 0./ >?6:@/90A51BD?700180.72A?40.120A</4/8107;/8=28AC - 16 - 79 4/;/4279: 0./ A46/4 A5 0./ 04718 A?40 4/96/479: 1BD?70018 F//379: 79 @796 0.10 0./ 34/2?@307A9 A5 799AB/9B/7951;A?4A50./1BB?2/6725?40./4204/9:0./9/6 / 6A 9A0 5796 19= BA@3/8879: 4/12A92 0A 790/45/4/ C70. 0./ >?6:@/90 A5 1BD?70018 3122/6 <= 0./ 04718 A?40 196 4/;/42/0./579679:24/BA46/60./4/79 H BBA4679:8=C/31220./5A88AC79: ./133/1872 6, (%%%&') " *+ ( %) " " " 720A&8A#H