- 1 - !" # # $% # $% ## &'( ) !"!! # $ # " "% #" & ' () ' !&& !) Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " " ' % # %"!& )*" !) !!" #' + # * &$ "'' (, $ '" # * &" ' % " & , ! # % %"' " "# ,* " " ' ' % "& # " -!"% -!"%" ' - 3 - % -!"% $ ./0 122314 /0 56 7.3 841/91:7033;/:< =>?3:.1:8393:7 >= 8>923:017/>: 1?/0/:< >@7 >= A@B<93:7 1:B 1C1?B B173B ,/:"#>,* 21003B567.3BB/7/>:14 3:/>? /D/4 %@B<3 1:B %"' 1/8.@? >:46 >: 7.3 <?>@:B >= E@1:7@9 .3B173>=188/B3:7/:D>4D393:7>=D3./843/:A@?6 0@071/:3B 56 ?/ 1?101221 >: >= @BB/ 1?101221 1:B 4/15/4/76 7> 216 8>923:017/>: 1?3 :>7 /: B/02@73 .3 >:46 B/02@73 /0 /: ?302387 >= /:1B3E@173 8>923:017/>: 1C1?B3B 56 7.3?/5@:141023?7.31223441:7 , 31?B 97 17/4 .1:7151/ @5.10. 431?:3B 8>@:034 12231?/:< =>? 7.3 1223441:7 841/91:7 1:B ?/ @5.10. "14412@? 431?:3B 8>@:034 12231?/:< =>? ?302>:B3:7 > :0@?1:83 >921:6 #/B3 >?B3? B173B * :>7/83>=7./0122314>:?302>:B3:7>/0B/023:03BC/7. 97 17/4 .1:7151/ @5.10. C/7. 144 D3.393:83 0@59/773B7.177.3?/5@:14.1071;3:7.3/:8>93177.3?173>= 0 8>:0/B3?/:< 7.3 1<3 >= 7.3 1223441:7 1224/3B - 4 - 9@47/24/3?FG1:B71;3:7.3B/015/4/7607173B567.3 >87>?10 7.3?3/01:192@717/>:15>D3;:33>=?/<.743<.>C3D3?=1/43B 7> 1BB H 7>C1?B0 '@7@?3 ?>02387@0 C.3?3/: 7.3 /:A@?/30 ?30@473B /: B/015/4/76 17 H 7> 7.3 C.>43 5>B6 > 140> 7.3 8>923:017/>: 1C1?B3B @:B3? 318. .31B 3I8327 @:B3? 7.3 .31B93B/8143I23:0301?3>:7.34>C3?0/B3.>@<.7.3 B>87>?.1007173B10@9>=0 /07>53?3E@/?3B=>? 1?7/=/8/14 4/95 7>C1?B0 '@7@?3 "3B/814 I23:030 7.3 ?/5@:14 .10 :>7 1C1?B3B 1:6 8>923:017/>: 88>?B/:<46 0>@<.7 7> 144>C7.31223141:B3:.1:837.38>923:017/>: 3=@7/:< 7.3 0@59/00/>:0 >= 431?:3B 8>@:034 12231?/:< =>? 7.3 841/91:7 1223441:7 ?/ @5.10. "14412@? D3.393:746 0@59/773B 7.17 /: 7.3 1503:83 >= 1:6 /:8>93 2?>>= 7.>@<. 7.3 /:8>93 =/I3B =>? 7.3 631? 10 23? 7.3 8.1?7 /0 0( 7.3 ?/5@:14 .10 71;3: 7.3 0193 17 0 8>:0/B3?/:< 7.3 =187 7.17 .3 C10 2>00300/:< ?/D/:< /83:03 >C3D3? .3 C10 0.>C: 10 C>?;/:< 10 1: 1<?/8@47@?/07 1:B 1 0.32.3?B 140> .3 B/015/4/76 /0 71;3: 10 HC./8.>@<.77>.1D3533:17(H7.>@<.7.3192@717/>: /015>D3;:337.307@929310@?/:</09>?37.1:(890 .>@<. 7.3 8>923:017/>: @:B3? >7.3? .31B0 3I8327 93B/814 - 5 - 3I23:03012231?07>53>:7.34>C3?0/B35@7/:D/3C>=71;/:< 7.3B/015/4/7617H1:B0>140>7.3/:8>93170 10 1<1/:070( 7.38>923:017/>:1C1?B3B567.3?/5@:14 /0 A@07 1:B 2?>23? 1:B B>30 :>7 ?3E@/?3 =>? 1:6 ?3 8>:0/B3?17/>:88>?B/:<460>@<.77>B/09/007.3122314 ) 1D/:<.31B7.3431?:3B8>@:03412231?/:<5>7.7.3 21?7/30 23?@03B 7.3 3:7/?3 122314 2123?0 0> 140> 7.3 ?/14 >@?7 38>?B 7.3 >:46 2>/:7 7.17 C>@4B 1?/03 =>? >@? 8>:0/B3?17/>:/010=>44>C0 ( @?1:0C3?7>7.315>D32>/:7=>?8>:0/B3?17/>:/0 F21?746/:1==/?917/D3G=>?7.3=>44>C/:< > B>@57 7.3 1223441:7 .10 0@==3?3B /:A@?/30 C./8. .10?30@473B/:192@717/>:>=43<15>D3;:33.32.>7><?12.0 =>?7.8>9/:< /: 7.3 ?/14 >@?7 38>?B 8431?46 0.>C0 7.17 7.3 192@717/>:15>D3;:331:B7.307@929310@?/:</0:>707173B !@7108>@4B53033:=?>97.32.>7><?12.0/7/07.308.3B@43 - 6 - /:A@?607173B@:B3?7.3924>6330>923:017/>:87.>@<. 7.3 /:8>93 /0 71;3: 10 0 1<1/:07 0( =/I3B @:B3? 7.3 8.1?7 2?321?3B 56 7.3 3<14 3?D/830 @7.>?/76 4>>;/:< 7> 7.3 1D>817/>: >= 7.3 1223441:7 0> 140> .3 C10 2>00300/:< 7.3 19>@:7 17 0 71;3: 56 7.3 ?/5@:14 /0 A@07 1:B 2?>23? 1:B B>30 :>7 8144 =>? 1:6 /:73?=3?3:83 .3 ?/5@:14 .10 :>7 8>:0/B3?3B 7.3 8103 =>? 1BB/:<H7>C1?B0'@7@?3?>02387@07>7.33I/07/:</:8>93 /: 73?90 >= 7.3 41C 41/B B>C: 56 7.3 >:-543 23I >@?7 /: C.3?3/: 7.3 >:-543 23I >@?7 .1B 1: >8810/>: 7> 8>:0/B3? 7.3 B/015/4/76 1003003B 17 )*H .3 >:-54323I>@?7.1071;3:7.34>00>=31?:/:<10H1:B 1BB3B =@7@?3 2?>02387@0 7> 7.3 3I/07/:< /:8>93 1:B 1C1?B3B 8>923:017/>: >:0/B3?/:< 7.3 8103 >= 7.3 122314 1:B /: 7.3 8103 >: .1:B /7 /0 A@07 1:B 2?>23? 7> 1BB H 7>C1?B0 7.3 3I/07/:</:8>9371;3:567.3?/5@:14/30 7>C1?B0 '@7@?3?>02387@0 1 (2022) 15 SCC 620 - 7 - * 88>?B/:<46 7.3 4>00 >= '@7@?3 1?:/:< 1218/76 C>@4B8>9307>0 JHIII H$1<1/:070( 567.3?/5@:14 >>;/:< 7> 7.3 8>923:017/>: 1C1?B3B @:B3? D1?/>@0 .31B0 3I8327 93B/814 3I23:030 7.36 1?3 144 >: 7.3 4>C3? 0/B3 C.3: 8>921?3B 7> 7.3 /:A@?/30 0@==3?3B 56 7.3 1223441:77/0>:?38>?B7.177.31223441:7C10/:217/3:7=>? B160 1:B >23?173B .3 ?/5@:14 .10 :>7 8>:0/B3?3B 7.3 8103 >= 7.3 1223441:7 =>? 1C1?B/:< '@7@?3 "3B/814 I23:030 B302/73:>7/8/:<7.177.3?3/01:192@717/>:15>D3;:33C./8. ?3E@/?30 =/I17/>: >= 1?7/=/8/14 4/95 : 7.303 8/?8@9071:830 7.3 8>923:017/>: 1C1?B3B 56 7.3 ?/5@:14 ?3E@/?30 ?3 8>:0/B3?17/>:1:B?3B373?9/:17/>: 88>?B/:<46 >: ?3B373?9/:17/>: 7.3 3:.1:83B 8>923:017/>:C>@4B8>9307> >00>==@7@?331?:/:<81218/76 0 1/:1:B0@==3?/:< 0 , '>>B1:B:>@?/0.93:7 0 "3B/8143I23:030 0, '@7@?3 93B/814 3I23:030 =>? =/I17/>: >= 1?7/=/8/14 4/95 2?>07.37/8 4/95$ 0 ) >00>=193:/7/30 0 - 8 - ( >00 >= /:8>93 B@?/:< 41/B @2 23?/>B I)$ 0* *+, - ./ .3 1223441:7 /0 3:7/743B =>? 1 0@9 >= - ./ C./8. /0 ?>@:B3B >== 7> - / 10 1<1/:07 0*, 1C1?B3B 56 7.3 ?/5@:14 88>?B/:<46 7.3 1223441:7 /0 3:7/743B =>? 3:.1:83B 8>923:017/>: >= -! !/C./8.0.14481??6/:73?307177.3?173>=)H23? 1::@9=?>97.3B173>=237/7/>:7/44?314/017/>: '>? 7.3 =>?<>/:< ?310>:0 7.3 2>/:7 =>? 8>:0/B3?17/>: /0 1:0C3?3B88>?B/:<46C321007.3=>44>C/:< /$ .3122314/0 !" //$ .3A@B<93:71:B1C1?BB173B,/:"# >,* 21003B 56 7.3 BB/7/>:14 3:/>? /D/4 %@B<3 1:B %"' 1/8.@? /0 .3?356 9>B/=/3B 1:B 3:.1:83B 7> 0()) C./8. 0.144 81??6 /:73?307177.3?173>=)H23?1::@9=?>97.3?173 1224/817/>:7/44?314/017/>: - 9 - ///$ 302>:B3:7 > K :0@?1:83 >921:6 0.144 B32>0/7 7.3 3:7/?3 3:.1:83B 8>923:017/>: 14>:< C/7. 188?@3B /:73?307 07173B 53=>?3 7.3 8>:83?:3B?/5@:14C/7./:)C33;0=?>97.3B173>= ?383/27>=8>26>=7./0>?B3? /D$ 2>:B32>0/7>=7.319>@:78>:0/B3?/:<7.31<3>= 7.3 1224/81:7 1 0@9 >= 0, 14>:< C/7. 7.3 188?@3B /:73?307 0.144 53 B32>0/73B /: 1:6 :17/>:1451:;=>?123?/>B>==/D3631?0 D$ .3 5141:83 19>@:7 >= 0()) 14>:< C/7. 7.3 188?@3B /:73?307 0.144 53 ?343103B /: =1D>@? >= 7.31223441:7>:2?>23?/B3:7/=/817/>: D/$ >>?B3?107>8>070 0/ &# ( % 0/ &( % " /07>4> L