- 1 - ! "" #$%&#'#%'' ( ! " # " $%&%!' ( ) $%&%('( "!* ) "( " +& "!+$ ! " $ ('!% , " )''%('(% Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - -('(% " "" !(( !!%( %( %!( -+" . / 0 1 ( 2$3 " !4&4 5 5 ) " ) # ) ! 367.89:; 366:3< .0 => 7?: 6:7.7.89:/ @9;:/ :A7.89 +& 8B?3/37.>33C3/.D@/3D0?339?.73 ('( /:3; 1.7?:A7.89!+ ! 8B A?:;@<:;307:039;A?:;@<:; /.=:0 /:2:97.89 8B 7/8A.7.:0 E:9;E:97 A7 ('!% 3003.<.9C 7?: /:C@<3/ =3.< C/397:; => <:3/9:; .07/.A7 39; :00.890 )@;C: 3;C./. 2.;: 8/;:/ ;37:; ''%('(% .9 /.E: 8-('(% 8B @/@E.7D3< 8<.A: 737.89 .07 3;C./.B8/7?:8BB:9A:06@9.0?3=<:@9;:/:A7.890!(( !!%( %( %!( 39; :A7.89 -+ 8B ?3/37.>3 >3>3 39?.73 ('( 39; :A7.890 . / 0 1 ( 2$3 8B A?:;@<:; 307:0 39; A?:;@<:; /.=:0 /:2:97.89 8B 7/8A.7.:0 A7 !4&4 ?:/:.9 3B7:/ /:B://:; 78 30 F A7, - 3 - ( "3A70<:3;.9C787?:A30:3/:30@9;:/ ?: 0:A89; /:0689;:973AA@0:; 130 366/:?:9;:; 39; /:E39;:;78G@;.A.3<A@078;>.9/.E:8-('(%B8/7?: 8BB:9A:0 6@9.0?3=<: @9;:/ :A7.890 !(( !!%( %( %!( 39;-+8B7?:?3/37.>3>3>339?.73 ('( 39; :A7.890 . / 0 1 39; ( 2$3 8B 7?: A?:;@<:; 307:039;A?:;@<:;/.=:0 /:2:97.898B7/8A.7.:0 A7 !4&4 ?: 0:A89; /:0689;:97 7?:/:3B7:/ B.<:; 39 366<.A37.890::D.9C/:C@<3/=3.< 1?.A?A3E:78=:3<<81:; => 7?: 8@/7 =:<81 89 ''%('(% 0@=G:A7 78 A:/73.9 A89;.7.890?:03.;8/;:/C/397.9C=3.<.09813003.<:;=> 7?: 2.A7.E6:7.7.89:/ 89 7?: C/8@9; 7?37 98 987.A: 130 .00@:;787?:2.A7.E6/.8/787?:C/3978B=3.< 1?.A?.0.9 A<:3/ 2.8<37.89 8B 7?: E39;37: 8B <31 <3.; ;819 => 7?: 89,=<: 6:H 8@/7 .9 1 ('(!%!' - 4 - :3/; 7?: <:3/9:; A8@90:< B8/ 7?: 6:7.7.89:/ <:3/9:;A8@90:<B8//:0689;:978( 39;7?:<:3/9:;.C? 8@/782:/9E:97 <:3;:/B8/7?:737: + 9 7?: 6/:0:97 366:3< 7?: 2.A7.E 0::D0 A39A:<<37.89 8B =3.< 08<:<> 89 7?: C/8@9; 7?37 7?: 8/;:/ :9<3/C.9C 7?: 0:A89; /:0689;:97 89 =3.< .0 .9 A897/32:97.898B:A7.89!% 8B7?:A7?:.00@: /3.0:;.00I@3/:<>A82:/:;=>7?:G@;CE:978B7?:89,=<: 6:H8@/7.9 0@6/3 1?:/:.9.7?30 =::9A37:C8/.A3<<>?:<;7?37C/397.9C=3.<1.7?8@73;?:/.9C 78 7?: E39;378/> /:I@./:E:97 8B 987.B>.9C 7?: 2.A7.E @9;:/:A7.89!% 2.7.37:07?:8/;:/ % 96:/@03<8B7?:.E6@C9:;8/;:/ .7.0:2.;:97 7?377?:<:3/9:;.07/.A739;:00.890)@;C:?30B3.<:;78 .00@:987.A:787?:2.A7.E30/:I@./:;@9;:/:A7.89!% 8B7?:A797?.0C/8@9;3<89: 7?:8/;:/C/397.9C =3.< .0 /:9;:/:; @90@073.93=<: =:.9C A897/3/> 78 7?: 0737@78/> E39;37: 39; 7?: 0:77<:; 680.7.89 8B <31 <3.; ;819=>7?:89,=<:@6/:E:8@/7.97?:3=82:$/:B://:; - 5 - G@;CE:9792.:18B7?:3;E.77:;989$.00@39A:8B987.A: 7?:366:3<;:0:/2:078=:3<<81:; AA8/;.9C<> 7?:B8<<81.9C8/;:/.06300:; .?:366:3<.0 .. ?: .E6@C9:; 8/;:/ ;37:; ''%('(% 6300:; => 7?: <:3/9:; .07/.A7 39; :00.890 )@;C: 3;C./. .9 /.E: 8-('(% 8B @/@E.7D3< 8<.A: 737.89 B8/ 7?: 8BB:9A:0 6@9.0?3=<: @9;:/ :A7.890 !(( !!%( %( %!( 39; -+ 8B 7?: ?3/37.>3 >3>3 39?.73 ('(39;:A7.890. / 0 1 39;( 2$3 8B 7?:A70739;00:730.;: ... ?: 0:A89; /:0689;:97 0?3<< 0@//:9;:/ =:B8/: 7?: G@/.0;.A7.893< 8@/7 89 8/ =:B8/: !!(('(% - 6 - .2 ?: 2.A7.E .0 ;./:A7:; 78 /:E3.9 6/:0:97 =:B8/:7?:8@/789!!(('(% 2 ?: <:3/9:; .07/.A7 39; :00.890 )@;C: 3;C./. .0 ;./:A7:; 78:H6:;.7: 39; A890.;:/39; ;.0680: 8B 7?: =3.< 366<.A37.89 3B/:0? 07/.A7<> .9 3AA8/;39A: 1.7? <31 39; 3B7:/ A8E6<>.9C 1.7? 7?: /:I@./:E:970 @9;:/ :A7.89 !% 8B 7?: A7 )$ #' ! ) .078!<8