- 1 - ! " # $!%!&!! !!&& '( ) * ! "# $ % & '!"(")(( "(*) Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "* !! "#+ ) !,, ) - ' !")"* !! "#)+ ' !! "#+ $ % '. ! '. *)-) & ' ' *)%& ' ' ) ( ++"'/ ' - 3 - 0 % 12341 516 788679 :; 9:;56< =2> 2><6>; ?:51 516 @2A;6A52=967>A6<@23A;69=2>B25151687>5:6;:5:;57C6A 38=2>=:A79<:;82;79 1:; 788679 :; =:96< 747:A;5 516 D3<4E6A5 7A< 7?7><<756<)87;;6<BF5166A:2>:G:93<46 7A< :A47;343>:A 2(2= )16=7@5;2=516@7;67>651752A#75 7B235 ) 8E ?1:96 516 <6@67;6< 7;7G7>7D ?7; 8>2@66<:A4 2A 6>2 896A<2> B67>:A4 >64:;5>75:2A 2!")"* 52?7><; 3957A783>7 2A 3<479 " 7G7>746>6 >27< 516 <>:G6> 2= 516 2>>F B67>:A4 642!"(")(( ;52886< 516 G61:@96 2A 516 ;:<6 2= 516 >27< ?:51235 4:G:A4 ;:4A79 7A< ?:51235 7AF 87>C:A4 9:415; 516>6=2>6 7;7G7>7D 1:5 516 92>>F 7A< ;3;57:A6< :AD3>:6;52516167<7A<96=5;:<62=516B2<F7A<<:6<2A 516;825 - 4 - 16>6=2>6 1:; 87>6A5; =:96< 7 @97:E 865:5:2A B6=2>6 516 >:B3A79 @97:E:A4 @2E86A;75:2A 2= ;)" 16 >:B3A79 @2A;:<6>:A4 516 6A5:>6 6G:<6A@6 2A >6@2>< 17; @79@39756< 52579 @2E86A;75:2A 75 ;#((" B35 7;516>6 ?7; @2A5>:B352>FA649:46A@6 2A51687>52=B251<6@67;6<7A<516<>:G6>2=51692>>F:5 17; 169< @2A5>:B352>F A649:46A@6 75 H 2A 516 87>5 2= <6@67;6< 7A< H 2A 516 87>5 2= 516 <>:G6> 2= 516 92>>F 7A< 516>6BF 7?7><6< 7 @2E86A;75:2A 2= ;+))" ?:51 :A56>6;5 75 (H 87 =>2E 516 <756 2= 865:5:2A 5:99 >679:;75:2A BF <:>6@5:A4 >6;82A<6A5 2 I :A;3>6> 2= 516 92>>F52<682;:5516;7E6 44>:6G6<BF516;7:<D3<4E6A57A<7?7><516 @97:E7A5; 17G6 8>6=6>>6< 51:; 788679 :A ?1:@1 :5 :; @2A56A<6< 5175516@2E897:A5:; 4:G6A 747:A;5 516<>:G6> 2= 516 2==6A<:A4 G61:@96 :6 92>>F B67>:A4 >64:;5>75:2A 2!"(")(( B35 516 >:B3A79 6>>6< :A 129<:A4H A649:46A@62A51687>52=516<6@67;6<16<6@67;6<?7; 746< ) F67>; ?2>C:A4 7; 92>>F <>:G6> 7A< 67>A:A4 - 5 - ;" 86> E2A51 B35 516 >:B3A79 17; 57C6A 1:; :A@2E6 2A9F 75 ;" 86> E2A51 7A< E674>6 7E23A5 ?7; 4>7A56< =2> =3A6>79 6J86A;6; 7A< 5>7A;82>575:2A @17>46; 7A< 92;; 2= 6;5756 16>6=2>6 >6K36;56<=2>6A17A@6E6A52=516@2E86A;75:2A ( 67><5167>43E6A5;2=B251;:<6; * 123415167886997A5;;5756<5175516<6@67;6< ?7; <>:G6> 7A< 74>:@3953>:;5 7A< 67>A:A4 ;)" 86> E2A51 516F =:96< <>:G:A4 9:@6A@6 3A<6> J+ 7A< 79;2 ;797>F @6>5:=:@756 3A<6> J B35 516F 17G6 A25 6J7E:A6< 516 6E892F6> 7A< =7:96< 52 8>2G6 516 :A@2E6 16>6=2>6 7; 86> 516 43:<69:A6; 2= 516 !7>A757C7 5756 64796>G:@6;3512>:5F516>:B3A7917;>:4159F57C6A1:; A25:2A79:A@2E675*"86>E2A51 # ; 86> 516 82;5 E2>56E >682>5 <6@67;6< ?7; 746< F67>; 16 >:B3A79 17; 57C6A 516 746 2= 516 <6@67;6<7;F67>;B7;:A42A51682;5E2>56E>682>5 16 <756 2= B:>51 2= 516 <6@67;6< ?7; ;12?A 7; - 6 - (++ 7A< 16 E65 ?:51 7A 7@@:<6A5 2A # 7A< 513; 16 ?7; 746< F67>; 7; 2A 516 <756 2= 7@@:<6A56A@6516E395:89:6>?7;>:4159F57C6A7;L#M + ; 86> 516 @:575:2A 2= 5162AMB96 86J 23>5 :A 516 <:@53E 2= 516 =353>6 8>2;86@5; @2A;:<6>6< BF 516>:B3A7975H:;D3;57A<8>286> :A@6516<6@67;6<?7;7B7@1692>516>:B3A79 17; >:4159F <6<3@56< H 2= 516 :A@2E6 52?7><; 1:; 86>;2A796J86A;6; 16>6=2>6 516 92;; 2= <686A<6A@F @2E6; 52 ;**(("%*NH"HJJ#& '3>516> 7; 86> 516 43:<69:A6; 2= 516 2AMB96 86J23>5:A516<:@53E2= ! " 7A< # 1 (2017) 16 SCC 680 2 (2018) 18 SCC 130 - 7 - $ % & $ '5167886997A5;B6:A451687>6A5;2=516<6@67;6< 7>6 6A5:596< =2> ;" 67@1 52?7><; 92;; 2= =:9:79 @2A;2>5:3E ) 16F 7>6 79;2 6A5:596< =2> 7A 7E23A5 2= ;)" 3A<6> 516 @2AG6A5:2A79 167<; :6 92;; 2= 6;57567A<=3A6>796J86A;6;7;86>516@:575:2A:A516@7;6 2= 6A@6 516 @2E86A;75:2A :; >67;;6;;6< 7; 3A<6> 2;;2=<686A<6A@F ;**((" 2;;2=@2A;2>5:3E ;#" 2AG6A5:2A79167<; ;)" +,- . / 16 >:B3A79 17; 169< @2A5>:B352>F A649:46A@6 2A51687>52=516<6@67;6<75H7A<51752=516<>:G6> 2=51692>>F75H16@97:E7A5;=:96<516@97:E865:5:2A 3 (2020) 9 SCC 644 - 8 - 747:A;5 516 2?A6> 7A< :A;3>6> 2= 516 92>>F ?12 7>6 >6;82A<6A52;7A<7A<79;25162?A6>7A<:A;3>6>2= 5166>2896A<2>?127>6>6;82A<6A52;)7A<16 E7AA6> 2= 7@@:<6A5 ;12?; 5175 ?1:96 516 <6@67;6< ?7; >:<:A4516E252>@F@9616<7;16<51692>>F87>C6<2A516 ;:<6 2= 516 >27< 7A< :5 ?7; 87>C6< ?:51235 7AF 87>C:A4 9:415; 7A< ;:4A79; 67>A6< @23A;69 =2> >6;82A<6A5 2" :A;3>6>2=51692>>F7>436<517551692>>F?7;87>C6<A67> 865>2983E87A<516>6?7;;3==:@:6A59:415:A47551755:E6 167@@:<6A517<2@@3>>6<757B235)8E279;216 @2A56A<6<5175516>:<6>2=516E252>@F@9617;A2<>:G:A4 9:6A@6 7A< 516 >:B3A79 @2A;:<6>6< 799 516;6 7;86@5; 7A< >:4159F =:J6< 516 @2A5>:B352>F A649:46A@6 2= H 2A 516 87>52=516<6@67;6<679;2;5756<5175516@17>46;1665 ?7;=:96<747:A;5B251516>:<6>2=516E252>@F@967A<516 <>:G6>2=51692>>F ( 396 2= 516 396; 2= 516 27< 643975:2A; +#>67<;7;3A<6> - 9 - ( )"* + , -. )* + ++ / - 10 - ! ! ! " * ; 86> 516 ;7:< 396; 516 <>:G6> 2= 516 E252> G61:@96;1799A2587>C516G61:@962A516E7:A>27<A516 8>6;6A5@7;6516<>:G6>2=51692>>F17<87>C6<516G61:@96 2A516E7:A>27<?:512354:G:A4;:4A79;7A<87>C:A49:415; 16>6=2>6 516 7>43E6A5 2= 516 967>A6< @23A;69 =2> >6;82A<6A525175516>6?7;;3==:@:6A59:415:A4A67>516 865>2983E8@7AA25B67@@6856<7;E6>687>C:A4:5;69=:; A25 86>E:556< 16 >:<6> 2= 516 E252>@F@96 <7;16< 516 92>>F7A<1617<A2<>:G:A49:@6A@616>6=2>651:;23>5 =:A<; :5 >67;2A7B96 52 =:J 516 @2A5>:B352>F A649:46A@6 2A 51687>52=516>:<6>2=516E252>@F@96:6516<6@67;6<75 H7A<51752=516<>:G6>2=51692>>F75#H - 11 - # 6;82A<6A5 2;) 7A< " 516 2?A6> 7A< :A;3>6> 2= 516 E252>@F@96 ?6>6 6J2A6>756< =>2E 516 9:7B:9:5F 16>6=2>6 >6;82A<6A5 2 B6:A4 516 :A;3>6> 2= 51692>>F:;<:>6@56<5287F#H2=51652579@2E86A;75:2A 2=;##((":6;+#"792A4?:51:A56>6;5 75(H87 + A516>6;395516=2992?:A42><6>:;87;;6< %:& 16788679:;7992?6<:A87>5 %::& 16 7886997A5; 7>6 6A5:596< =2> 52579 @2E86A;75:2A2=;+#"792A4?:51:A56>6;575(H 87=>2E516<7562=865:5:2A5:99>679:O75:2A %:::& 6;82A<6A5 2"A;3>7A@6 2E87AF :; <:>6@56< 52 <682;:5 516 7=2>6;7:< @2E86A;75:2A 7E23A5 ?:51:A2A6E2A51=>2E516<7562=51:;D3<4E6A5=75799 7AF6J@6;;7E23A5:;<682;:56<BF516E516F7>66A5:596< =2>>6=3A<2=516;7E6 %:G& A ;3@1 <682;:5 516 @97:E7A5; B6:A4 516 87>6A5; 2= 516 <6@67;6< 7>6 86>E:556< 52 ?:51<>7? 516 - 12 - 6A5:>67E23A5792A4?:51:A56>6;57@@>36<2A:5:A7A6K379 8>282>5:2A !0/ '&!! ) % :;5292