- 1 - ! "## $ ! ! "# $ $! $! % # & $! '(' ) !$ * ! $ +(* '( % '(' ! !$ +(* # # Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! ! ! % '(' ! ! ! &# ,! $ $! '(' * ! ! !! $! '(' ) - &! *- " # ! ! . &! # &! $! $! . ' ! # &! # ! / &! & - 3 - # / &! & 01230 4056 78449: 56 6;849< =1: 8<756651> ?540 409 @1>69>4 1= A140 409 B8:4596 54 56 48C9> 2B =1: =5>8; <56B168; 98:< ;98:>9< @12>69; 8BB98:5>3 =1: 409 8BB9;;8>4B945451>9: 8>< ;98:>9< @12>69;6 8BB98:5>3 =1: :96B1><9>4 16 8>< * 409 :96B9@45D9 >62:8>@9 17B8>596 95>3 833:59D9< AE 409 F2<379>4 8>< 8?8:< <849< B8669< 5> 1 . * AE 409 <<5451>8;9>51:5D5;&2<398><97A9: $8;8A2:835 =1: 601:4 G409 :5A2>8;H B945451>9: 56 A9=1:9 4056 12:4 699C5>39>08>@979>41=409@17B9>68451>8712>4 * 09 =8@428; 784:5I 1= 409 @869 56 4084 5> 409 8@@5<9>4 4084 1@@2::9< 1> * 5>D1;D5>3 409 848 271 1?>9< AE :96B1><9>4 16 8>< 8>< 5>62:9< AE :96B1><9>4 1* 409 B945451>9: 626485>9< =:8@42:9 1= - 4 - ;27A:86@8:8;8:98945451>9:64849<408409?868<75449<41 1D9:>79>4 16B548; 8;C09< 409:98=49: 605=49< 41 9<87 16B548; 8>< 409> ?86 605=49< 41 1D9:>79>4 16B548; 2;A8:38 ?09:9 09 ?86 5>B8459>4 =:17 * * 41 *. *A24<5<>14B:1<2@98>E<1@279>4641601?409 6879 09 B945451>9: 8BB:18@09< 409 :5A2>8; 699C5>3 @17B9>68451>@1>49><5>3408409?86839<E98:68><08< 8>5>@1791= 6 B9:71>40AE?1:C5>3861AA;9: 8440945791=8@@5<9>429414098@@5<9>48;5>F2:5960956 2>8A;941<1056F1A8698:;59:8><8662@0@;8579<8<9J2849 @17B9>68451> ' 09B945451>?861BB169<AE409:96B1><9>41* K >62:8>@9 17B8>E @1>49><5>3 4084 409 @17B9>68451> @;8579<?860530;E9I1:A548>457835>8:E8><2>49>8A;98>< 54<9>59<4098395>@1798><1@@2B8451>1=409B945451>9: 9=1:9409 :5A2>8;409B945451>9:?869I875>9< 86# 4091@41:?869I875>9<86#8><<1@279>4684 I6 41 ' ?9:9 78:C9< 5> 9D5<9>@9 1 9D5<9>@9 ?86 ;9< AE 409 :96B1><9>46 =49: 098:5>3 8:3279>46 AE 409 - 5 - B8:4596 409 :5A2>8; 8?8:<9< @17B9>68451> 1= 6.+ 2><9:<5==9:9>4098<686A9;1? 8:45@2;8:6 712>4 8 1?8:<6 5>F2:E B85> 8><62==9:5>3 6 A 1?8:<6 79<5@8; 9IB9>696 6 @ 1?8:<6=11<8><9I4:8 >12:56079>4 8>< 79<5@8;8449><8>4 6 < 1?8:<6@1>D9E8>@9 6' 9 1?8:<6 ;166 1= 5>@179 <2:5>34:98479>4 6.' = 1?8:<6 B9:78>9>4 <568A5;54E 6*' 3 9B:5D8451> 1= =242:9 879>54596 6' 148;@17B9>68451> 6.+ . 33:59D9< AE 409 J28>427 1= @17B9>68451> 8?8:<9<AE409 :5A2>8;409B945451>9:565>40568BB98; ( 98:>9< @12>69; 8BB98:5>3 =1: 409 8BB9;;8>4 B945451>9: 62A7546 4084 409 @17B9>68451> 8?8:<9< AE 409 :5A2>8;561>409;1?9:65<98><54086>14B:1B9:;E8669669< 409 @17B9>68451> 2><9: 409 098<6 1= ;166 1= 879>54596 5> ;5=9;1661==242:95>@1798><1409:098<6 - 6 - + ;98:>9< @12>69; 8BB98:5>3 =1: :96B1><9>4 1* K >62:8>@9 17B8>E <9=9><6 409 57B23>9< F2<379>4 8>< 8?8:< 64845>3 4084 409 @17B9>68451>1= 6.+568<9J2849 09 4964571>E 1= # @12B;9< ?540 568A5;54E 9:45=5@849?12;<601?4084409B945451>9:08<62==9:9<:5304 65<9< =:8@42:9 84 ;27A8:68@:8; 8:98 8>< 409:9 ?9:9 49><9:>966 1= 8>< * D9:49A:8 09 # ?01 086 8669669< 409 <568A5;54E 38D9 9:45=5@849 64845>3 4084 409 B945451>9:5662==9:5>3=:17<568A5;54E1='L91B5>9<4084 409:956>9:D9@17B:96651>?05@0086:962;49<5><568A5;54E 09 :5A2>8;@1>65<9:9<409<568A5;54E84'L8><8?8:<9<409 @17B9>68451> 4 56 B9:45>9>4 41 >149 4084 84 409 4579 1= 8@@5<9>4 409 B945451>9: ?86 839< E98:6 8>< ?1:C5>3 86 1AA;9: D5<9>4;E409F1A1=409B945451>9:5641654=1:;1>3 <2:8451> 8>< 409:9=1:9 409 5>F2:E 41 409 ;27A8: 8:98 <9=5>549;E@826965>@1>D9>59>@9410579>@9409<568A5;54E 8669669<AE409 :5A2>8;84'L8BB98:641A91>409;1?9: 65<98><4096879>99<641A95>@:9869<41(L9>@9AE :9485>5>3 >1451>8; 5>@179 84 6.' B9: 71>40 409 - 7 - @17B9>68451>2><9:409098<1=;1661=5>@1791>8@@12>41= <568A5;54E 56 @8;@2;849< 86 6.' I I (L I + M 6*( AE 8<1B45>3 72;45B;59: 1= G+H =1: 409 839 1= E98:6 1>69J29>4;E @1>65<9:5>3 409 >842:9 1= 409 5>F2:596409;1661=5>@179<2:5>3;85<2BB9:51<56@8;@2;849< =1:4?171>40686 6.'IM 6 ' 09 :5A2>8; 086 8?8:<9< 8 627 1= 6' 2><9: 409 098< ;166 1= 879>54596 5> ;5=9 1>65<9:5>3 409 >842:91=5>F2:5968><4098391=409B945451>9:54?12;<A9 F2648><B:1B9:418?8:< 6 '2><9:4056098< > 409 8A69>@9 1= 8>E <1@279>46 41 601? 409 79<5@8; 9IB9>696 409 :5A2>8; 086 8?8:<9< 8 627 1= 6 ?05@0 56 86 311< 86 8?8:<5>3 >1 @17B9>68451> =1: 79<5@8; 9IB9>696 09:9=1:9 86 8385>64 6 8?8:<9< AE 409 :5A2>8; 8 627 1= 6' 56 8?8:<9< 2><9:4056098< * 09 :5A2>8; 086 8?8:<9< 8 627 1= 6 41?8:<6B85>8><62==9:5>3409687956F2648><B:1B9: - 8 - ' 09 :5A2>8; 086>14 8?8:<9<8>E @17B9>68451> 41?8:<6>12:56079>48><8449><8>4H6@08:396>;E8627 1= 6' 086 A99> 8?8:<9< 41?8:<6 @1>D9E8>@9 1>65<9:5>3 409 >842:9 1= 5>F2:596 626485>9< 86 8385>64 6' 8 627 1= 6 56 8?8:<9< 2><9: 409 098<6 @1>D9E8>@9 >12:56079>4 8>< 71<9:849 8449><8>4 @08:396 @@1:<5>3;E4098BB9;;8>4B945451>9:569>454;9<=1: 4148; @17B9>68451> 1= 6 +( 86 A9;1? 86 8385>64 6.+8?8:<9<AE409 :5A2>8; ; 1 98<6 ?8:<AE 409 :5A2>8; ?8:<AE4056 12:4 >F2:E B85> 8>< 62==9:5>3 6 6 9<5@8;9IB9>696 6 6' 1>D9E8>@9 9I4:8 >12:56079>4 8>< 8449><8>4H6@08:396 6' 6 * 166 1= 5>@179 <2:5>34:98479>4 6.' 6 ' ' 1661==242:95>@179 6*' 6*( 166 1= 879>54596 5> ;5=9 6' 6 ' 148;@17B9>68451> 6.+ 6 +( 966?8:<AE409 :5A2>8; 6.+ 148;9>08>@979>4 6'( - 9 - . > 409 :962;4 409 8BB98; <969:D96 41 A9 8;;1?9< 8><09>@9409=1;;1?5>3 5 098BB98;568;;1?9<5>B8:4 55 09 57B23>9< F2<379>4 8>< 8?8:< B8669<AE409 :5A2>8;5609:9AE71<5=59< 555 09 8BB9;;8>4 56 9>454;9< =1: 8 627 1= 6'( ?540 5>49:964 84 409 :849 1= L B9: 8>>27=:17409<8491=B945451>45;;:98;5N8451>5> 8<<5451> 41 ?084 086 A99> 8?8:<9< AE 409 :5A2>8; 5D 09 :96B1><9>4 1* K >62:8>@9 17B8>E 56 <5:9@49< 41 <9B1654 409 9>08>@9< @17B9>68451>8;1>3?5405>49:964?5405>8B9:51< 1=?99C6=:17409<8491=:9@95B41=8@1BE1= 4056F2<379>4 < %# & # 5641 ;1* $