Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 49556 (KAR)

MAHADEVAPPA v. ARYAMUNI DIXIT

WP/202772/2025 · 2025-10-27

M G S Kamal

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#$ # # %& ' ! ! " # "$ % "$ & "$ "$ '( )* )'% Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - + ' %%, %% ' ' +'' ) # %%$%$%" % %$% ' % !( '+ ' ' ' + - * ) - * ) ./0/012.3045.613./704183/5.029:9930.;.<5=/7. 13<.3 <:/.< %%$%$%" >:44.< 5= 3.4>12<.2/ 1% .>8/=1??044012.302.;04012./0/0121%16%$% 02/.3?416@70A72:?.16/7.3.4>12<.2/17:45..2 <03.A/.</15.?8/:/.<02/7.3.;.28.3.A13<4@70A7@.3. 4/:2<02902/7.2:?.16/7.>./0/012.3023.4>.A/16B:2<02 =1C" ?.:483029 " :A3.4 982/:4 40/8:/.< :/ .9:2113;0BB:9.:0A783/:B8D:2<<04/30A/ - 3 - % .:32.< A1824.B :>>.:3029 613 /7. >./0/012.3 /:D029/704183//731897/7.3.A13<4485?0/4/7:/2:?. 16 /7. 531/7.3 16 /7. >./0/012.3 7:< 5..2 ?8/:/.< 02 /7. 3.;.28. 3.A13<4 02 3.4>.A/ 16 :613.4:0< B:2< :4 6:3 5:AD :4 12 %$"C, 2. :28?:DD: 7:< >3.6.33.< :2 :>>B0A:/01212&$$C,0.>3013/1/7.?8/:/0125.029 ?:<. 02 /7. 2:?. 16 /7. 531/7.3 16 /7. >./0/012.3 854.E8.2/B= 3.4>12<.2/ 1 7.3.02 AB:0?029 /1 7:;. >83A7:4.</7.:613.4:0<>31>.3/=631?4:0<:28?:DD:02 /.3?4 16 <..< 16 4:B. <:/.< %$"C, 7:< ?:<. :2 :>>B0A:/01212%$"C,4..D029?8/:/012167042:?.02 /7. 3.;.28. 3.A13<4 @70A7 A:?. /1 5. 3.F.A/.< 12 %,$"C,.0/7.3/7.13<.3<:/.<%$"C,02/.3?4 16@70A7?8/:/012162:?.16/7.531/7.316/7.>./0/012.3 @:4.66.A/.<213/7.13<.3<:/.<%,$"C,3.F.A/029/7. 3.E8.4/ 16 3.4>12<.2/ 1 /1 ?8/:/. 704 2:?. @.3. A7:BB.29.< & 2/7.=.:3%$&%$02;0.@16A.3/:026:?0B= :33:29.?.2/4?8/:/012.2/30.4@.3..66.A/.<02/7.2:?. - 4 - 16/7.>./0/012.37.3.:6/.302/7.=.:3%$C3.4>12<.2/ 1 @1D. 8> :2< 60B.< :2 :>>B0A:/012 A7:BB.29029 /7. ?8/:/012 .2/30.4 .66.A/.< 02 /7. =.:3 %$&%$ @0/718/ 3:04029 :2= 15F.A/012 /1 /7. .:3B0.3 ?8/:/012 .2/30.4 7. 4:0< :>>B0A:/012 @:4 020/0:BB= 3.F.A/.< 5= /7. :740B<:3 @70A7 @:4 A:330.< 02 :>>.:B 5.613. /7. 4404/:2/ 1??044012.3 :2< /7.3.:6/.3 5.613. /7. .>8/= 1??044012.3 @71 7:< 3.?:2<.< /7. ?://.3 /1 /7. 4404/:2/ 1??044012.3 7. 4404/:2/ 1??044012.3 8>12 3.?:2< :9:02 3.F.A/.< /7. :>>.:B 60B.< 5= 3.4>12<.2/ 1 .029 :9930.;.< 3.4>12<.2/ 1 >3.6.33.< 3.;04012 >./0/012 >12 @70A7 /7. 0?>892.< 13<.3A:?./15.>:44.<5=/7..>8/=1??044012.3 .6.33029 /1 /7.4. 6:A/8:B :4>.A/4 16 ?://.3 B.:32.<A1824.B613/7.>./0/012.3485?0/4/7:/3.4>12<.2/ 1% @0/718/ /:D029 02/1 A1240<.3:/012 16 /7. 0213<02:/. <.B:=12/7.>:3/163.4>12<.2/1027:;0297042:?. .2/.3.< 02/1 02 /7. 3.;.28. 3.A13<4 12 /7. 5:404 16 >83>13/.< <..< 16 4:B. 1897/ 21/ /1 7:;. 824.//B.< /7. - 5 - 3.;.28. .2/30.4 @70A7 3.?:02.< 82<04>8/.< 613 1;.36183 <.A:<.4 . 485?0/4 /7:/ /7. 13<.3 /7.3.613. 04 823.:412:5B.:2<82484/:02:5B. " 2 3.4>124. B.:32.< A1824.B :>>.:3029 613 3.4>12<.2/ 1 485?0/4 /7:/ /7.4:B. <..< 16 C, 7:4 3.?:02.< 82A7:BB.29.< 7. >31A.44 16 3.;.28. .2/30.4 7:45..2<12.5:4.<12/7.4:0<<..<164:B.7.3.613. 7.485?0/4/7://7..>8/=1??044012.37:4A1??0//.< 21.331302>:44029/7.0?>892.<13<.3.2A.4..D4613 3.F.A/01216/7.>./0/012 , .:32.< <<0/012:B 1;.32?.2/ <;1A:/. F84/06=029 /7. 13<.3 >:44.<5= /7..>8/= 1??044012.3 485?0/4/7://7.13<.304>:44.<5:4.<12/7.<1A8?.2/4 :2</7.3097/4AB:0?.<5=/7.>:3/0.4:2<06/7.=7:;.:2= 683/7.3 930.;:2A. /7.= ?:= 7:;. 3.A1834. 5.613. /7. A1?>./.2/ A183/ 16 A0;0B F8304<0A/012 :<F8<0A:/029 /7.03 3097/4 .:3<.384.</7.3.A13<4 - 6 - ':A/4 2:33:/.< :51;. 02<0A:/. /7:/ /7.3. 04 : AB:0? :2< : 30;:B AB:0? 5./@..2 /7. >./0/012.3 :2< 3.4>12<.2/ 1 02 3.4>.A/ 16 /7. 0??1;:5B. >31>.3/= 2:?.B= =1C" ?.:483029":A3.4982/:4+70B./7. >./0/012.3 AB:0?4 /1 7:;. :AE803.< /7. 3097/ /731897 704 :2A.4/134 3.4>12<.2/ 1 12 /7. 1/7.3 7:2< AB:0?4 /1 7:;. :AE803.< /7. 3097/ 02 /.3?4 16 <..< 16 4:B. <:/.< %$"C,7.3.:>>.:34/15.3.;.28..2/30.44/:2<029 02/7.2:?.16/7.>./0/012.382/0B/7.4:?.043.;.34.<5= /7.0?>892.<13<.3 C +0/718/ :<;.3/029 /1 /7. ?.30/4 16 AB:0?4 :2< 30;:BAB:0?416/7.>:3/0.402/7.B097/16/7.485?0440124 ?:<. 5= /7. >:3/0.4 /704 183/ <..?4 0/ :>>31>30:/. /1 /7.@30/>./0/012@0/7/7.61BB1@029<03.A/0124 0 ./0/012.3 :2< 3.4>12<.2/ 1 :3. :/ B05.3/=/17:;./7.033097/4023.4>.A/16/7. :613.4:0<>31>.3/=02 =1C" ?.:483029 " :A3.4 98/2:4 16 .9:2113 ;0BB:9. - 7 - :0A783/:B8D:2<<04/30A/5.:<F8<0A:/.<02 /7.?:22.3D21@2/1B:@5.613./7.183/ 16A1?>./.2/A0;0BF8304<0A/0120641:<;04.< 00 0BB 48A7 :<F8<0A:/012 04 :;:0B.< /7. 3.;.28. .2/30.4 @70A7 7:;. 5..2 :66.A/.< >8348:2/ /1 /7. 0?>892.< 13<.3 47:BB 3.?:0202/:A/ 000 :3/0.4 47:BB 21/ /:D. :<;:2/:9. 16 /7. A7:29. 02 /7. 3.;.28. .2/30.4 7.= 47:BB 21/A3.:/. :2= /703<>:3/= 3097/402AB8<029 A3.:/029 :2= .2A8?53:2A. 12 /7. 485F.A/ >31>.3/= 0; / 04 ?:<. AB.:3 /7:/ 21 154.3;:/0124 :3. ?:<.1313<.34:3.>:44.<12/7.?.30/413 1/7.3@04.16/7.A:4.@70A7/7.>:3/0.4:3. :/ B05.3/= /1 7:;. :<F8<0A:/.< 5.613. /7. A183/ 16 A1?>./.2/ F8304<0A/012 @70A7 02 48A7 :2 .;.2/ >:44 :>>31>30:/. 13<.3 - 8 - 5:4.< 12 /7. ?.30/4 16 /7. A:4. 02 :AA13<:2A.@0/7B:@ (& %# #' $ +) 04/1 B1% )