- 1 - ! " # $%&!%!% '!( ! " # $ % " # & ' () * Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ( +, + ' ( + + ( $ ! " &- '"# '"## %%, %%. $ % , ( /( % ' $ %% . % + - 3 - + 0 " +0 # 123 45626278 23 9: 615 125; <=28236>?62@5 ;;2A5> ?>8?6?B? 55>?@?>2 2C?= 2=265< ?CC>25@5< 9: 615 ?D?>< <?65< % , 4?335< 9: 615 45A2?E ?8< AFG2326278;;2A5>28>5345A67;5885617>?4>7H5A6G8<5> 5A6278 %"# 7; 615 ?8< AFG2326278 A6 28 65>=3 7; D12A1 615 1?3?D?><5< ? 3G= 7; 3,%&(?3 A7=4583?62784?:?9E528>5345A67; ?A>53&.CG86?37; E?8<28:7(&326G?65<?6@2EE?C57;=9?EC?E?8< ?EGB?E?9G>?C2 236>2A6 % 15 ?;7>53?2< E?8< D?3 3G9H5A6 =?665> 7; ? 8762;2A?6278 <?65< /% 233G5< ;7> 615 4G>4735 7; ?AFG2326278 7; E?8<3 ;>7= 5885617>? 4>7H5A6 565>=28?6278 7; A7=4583?6278 28 >5345A6 7; 615 E?8<3 ?AFG2>5< G8<5> 6123 8762;2A?6278 D?3 3G9H5A6 =?665> 7; 4>7A55<28C3287'&(% /4>7<GA5<?6885IG>5 - 4 - & 157G>6287'&(% /6?B28C6158?6G>5 7;615E?8<33G9H5A6=?665>7;6154>7A55<28C3615>5G8<5> ?3 ?C>2AGE6G>?E D56E?8< 1?3 ?D?><5< A7=4583?6278 7; 3&& (45>?A>59:7><5><?65<%,% '4?335< 615>5G8<5> ' 44?>586E: >5E:28C G478 615 3?2< 7><5> 615 >53478<5867'15>528=?<5?8?44E2A?6278G8<5>5A6278 %7;615A6355B28C4?>26:A628CG4786153?=5?8< >5E:28C G478 615 HG<C=586 ?8< 7><5> 4?335< 28 615 ?;7>53?2< 7'&(% / 615 1?3 ?D?><5< 615 ?=7G86?3?97@5 528C ?CC>25@5< 615 456262785> 23 95;7>5 6123 7G>6 , 5?>85< A7G835E >2 >G4?3?C?> ?62E ?445?>28C;7>615456262785>3G9=26361?66157><5>4?335< 9:615?6885IG>5 23D2617G6?44E2A?62787;=28< 8 61?6 15 1?3 5>>7857G3E: >5E25< G478 615 7><5> 28 - 5 - 7'&(% /?8<1?3?44E25<615>?65?44E2A?9E567615 ?C>2AGE6G>?E D56E?8< D15>5?3 615 E?8< 95E78C28C 67 >53478<586 7' ?AFG2>5< D12A1 23 615 3G9H5A6 =?665> 7; 6152=4GC85<?D?><23?<=2665<E:?<>:E?8<53G9=263 6123CE?>28C5>>7>A7==2665<9:61528?D?><28C615 A7=4583?62786>5?628C615E?8<7;615>53478<5867'?3 ?C>2AGE6G>5 D56E?8< 1?3 A?G35< 1GC5 ;28?8A2?E E733 67 615 4G9E2A 5IA15FG5> 5 ;G>615> 3G9=263 61?6 615 456262785> 1?3?E>5?<:<5473265<?3G=7; 3&,',&(95;7>56123 7G>6 D12A1 3G936?862?EE: 3?623;253 615 ?=7G86 7; A7=4583?6278 2; A?EAGE?65< ?3 <>: E?8< ?8< 317GE< 615>5 95?8<2;;5>58A54?:?9E59:615456262785>7@5>?8<?97@5 615 3?2< ?=7G86 615: ?>5 >5?<: ?8< D2EE28C 67 3G936?862?EE: A7=4E: D261 615 7><5> 58A5 355B3 ;7> ?EE7D28C61545626278 . 8>5347835615E5?>85<A7G835E?445?>28C;7> 615 >53478<586 7' ?6 615 7G6356 3G9=263 61?6 615>5 23 287><28?65 <5E?: 28 ;2E28C 615 D>26 45626278 A1?EE58C28C 615 - 6 - 7><5> <?65< % , 5 3G9=263 61?6 5@58 617GC1 615>5235>>7>?44?>58678615;?A57;615>5A7><28D12A1 61545A2?E?8<AFG2326278;;2A5>1?36?B58615<>:E?8< 95E78C5<67>53478<5867'?3D56E?8<?8<C>?865<615 A7=4583?6278 615>578 9: 4?33?C5 7; 62=5 615 2865>536 4?:?9E5 78 615 A7=4583?6278 2635E; 1?3 =7G865< D12A1 D7GE< 95 5FG?E 67 615 ?=7G86 2; A?EAGE?65< 5@58 ?3 <>: E?8< 8 ;G>615>?8A5 67 6153?=515 3G9=263 ? =5=77; A?EAGE?6278 28 65>=3 7; D12A1 15 3G9=263 61?6 615 456262785> 23 362EE E2?9E5 67 4?: ?8 ?<<26278?E ?=7G86 7; 3%,'&(53G9=26361?65@582;615456262781?367 95?EE7D5<?337GC166795A7865865<9:615456262785>26 =?: 95 <2>5A65< 67 4?: 615 3?2< 3G= 7; 3%,'&( 61?6D7GE<=5566154G>4735?8<3?623;:61558626E5=5867; >53478<586 5?><5>G35<615>5A7><3 - 7 - / 15 7><5> G8<5> A1?EE58C5 <?65< % , ?D?><28C A7=4583?6278 7; 3,%&( 28 >5345A6 7; E?8< =5?3G>28C ?A>53 ?8< &. CG86?3 28 :7(& 95E78C367>53478<5867&239?35<78615HG<C=586?8< ?D?><<?65<%,% '4?335<287'&(% / 3?E>5?<:8765<?97@5615E?8<3G9H5A6=?665> ;7> A7832<5>?6278 3?2< 4>7A55<28C3 D?3 ?C>2AGE6G>?E D56E?8< <=2665<E: E?8< 3G9H5A6 =?665> 28 615 2836?86 4562627823?<>:E?8<15615>5;7>528615A7832<5>5< @25D 7; 6123 7G>6 1?3 C>733E: 5>>5< 28 876 6?B28C 6123 ?345A6 2867 A7832<5>?6278 C728C 67 615 @5>: >776 7; 615 9?323 78 D12A1 615 A?EAGE?6278 23 =?<5 ?8< 615 A7=4583?627823?D?><5< 76D26136?8<28C 615 ?97@5 ?3 ;?2>E: 3G9=2665< 9:E5?>85<A7G835E;7>615>53478<5867'2;615?=7G86 23 A?EAGE?65< 62EE <?65 ?3 4?:?9E5 78 615 <>: E?8< 615 456262785> D7GE< 95 E2?9E5 67 4?: ? 676?E 3G= 7; 3.%,& ( 5=7 7; A?EAGE?6278 3G9=2665< 9: 615 >53478<586 7' 23 5I6>?A65< 15>5G8<5> ;7> 2==5<2?65 >5;5>58A5+ - 8 - %% 2 '"# 762;2A?6278 + /% 22 D?>< + & % . 222 I65867; E?8< + A>53&.G86?3 2@ ?6G>5 7; E?8<?3 5>?D?>< + <>:E?8< @ ?323 G<C=586 + '/(% /<?65< %,% '?D?><5< 3&& (45>?A>5;7> >>2C?65<E?8< @2 58A5615A?EAGE?6278;7>615<>:E?8<23?3 G8<5>+ 7> 615 <>: E?8< %(& 7; 615 2>>2C?65< E?8< 25 3&& %(&J%%,.(45>?A>5 " ?A>5 J ' G86?3# "A>5 &. G86?3 J %&. CG86?3# %%,.(' ,'%45>CG86?3 @22 E?8< @?EG5 ,'%%&. + J&&.'( @222 & K 7E?62G= + J' ',( 2I %K << ?>B56 @?EG5 /% 67 % . ".,<?:3# + J&'.,%( I 76?E"@22L @222L2I# + J 3+% & ,%( I2 /K 7; 2865>536 & % . 67 & % + J 3+'..,( - 9 - 58A5615=5=7;7>A?EAGE?6278 % 5?>85< A7G835E ;7> 615 456262785> <753 876 <234G65 615 9?323 7; A?EAGE?6278 =?<5 ?3 ?97@5 5?>85< A7G835E;7>>53478<5867'782836>GA62783G9=26361?62; 615 456262785> 23 <2>5A65< 67 4?: 615 ?<<26278?E ( 9?E?8A5 ?=7G86 ?3 45> 615 A?EAGE?6278 615 58626E5=586 7; 615 >53478<5867'D7GE<95 3?623;25< 5?>85< A7G835E ;7> 615456262785>1?38779H5A6278;7>6153?=5 G9=233278 23 6?B58 78 >5A7>< 15 45626278 23 <234735<7;D261615;7EE7D28C<2>5A62783+ I22 K 7; 2865>536 ;>7= & % 67 % % % ",%,<?:3# 78# + J 3+%',&( I222 76?E"L2 L22# + J 3+.%,& ( I2@ 5334?2< + J 3+&,',&( I@ ?E?8A5 + J 3+%,'&( 15>5;7>56159?E?8A5?=7G8623 3+%,'&( - 10 - 15 456262785> 31?EE 4?: 615 676?E A7=4583?6278 3.%,& ( 67 >53478<586 7' 7> 123 E5C?E >54>53586?62@53?3615A?35=?:95 28A5 615 456262785> 23 36?65< 67 1?@5 ?E>5?<: <5473265< ? 3G= 7; 3&,',&( 95;7>5 6123 7G>6 >53478<586 7' 7> 123 E5C?E >54>53586?62@53 ?>5 58626E5< 67 >5A52@5 ( 355B >5E5?35 7; 615 3?=5 3G9H5A6 67 536?9E23128C 615 2<58626:95;7>561237G>6 15 456262785> 31?EE 4?: 9?E?8A5 3G= 7; 3%,'&( 67 >53478<586 7' 7> 615 E5C?E >54>53586?62@53 ?3 615 A?35 =?: 95 D26128 ? 45>27< 7; D55B3 ;>7= 615 <?65 7; >5A5246 7; A5>62;25<A74:7;61237><5> - 11 - 6 23 =?<5 AE5?> 61?6 2; ?8:2865>5361?3 ?AA>G5< 78615?=7G86?E>5?<:<5473265<6153?=531?EE ?E37 95 6?B58 2867 A7832<5>?6278 ?8< ?<HG36 ?AA7><28CE: !)* '%!%( & ( 2367+E7+' 6+4B