- 1 - ! " # $ $$ %&' ( ! " # $%&$'!() $%*%('! " "# + $%*%!'! # ", ! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # # !)! # # ') !! "'"' %)&"'!) # # - - . # ! /01 233425 01 60547 89 :/4 ;520<2=: 144>0=? 4=/2=;4<4=:@6:/4;@<34=12:0@=2?20=1::/4A7?<4=:2=7 2B2C772:47') !! "'"'3211470=@ %)&"'!)89:/4 4=0@C 0D05 A7?4 2=7 770:0@=25 212D2>2592= 6@C 1/@C:E:/4:C08A=25F " = ! '& "'!) :/4 ;520<2=: <4: B0:/ 2= 2;;074=: 2=7 1A664C47 ?C04D@A1 0=GAC041 /4 ;520<2=: :@@> :C42:<4=: 0= :/4 /@130:25 /4 ;520<2=: 60547 ;520< 34:0:0@= 144>0=?;@<34=12:0@=846@C4:/4:C08A=25 /4:C08A=2526:4C ;@=1074C0=?:/44=:0C44D074=;4@=C4;@C72B2C74721A<@6 1 (*()'$ 25@=? B0:/ 0=:4C41: 2: :/4 C2:4 @6 H 34C 2==A<6C@<:/472:4@634:0:0@=:055C4250I2:0@= ??C04D4789 :/4 1207 A7?<4=: 2=7 2B2C7 :/4 ;520<2=: 3C464CC47 :/4 - 3 - 3C414=: 233425 144>0=? 4=/2=;4<4=: @6 :/4 ;@<34=12:0@= 2B2C74789:/4:C08A=25 42C7 :/4 2C?A<4=:1 @6 :/4 542C=47 ;@A=1451 6C@<8@:/10741 ( 42C=47;@A=1456@C:/4;520<2=:2334552=:<20=59 ;@=:4=747 :/2::/4 ;520<2=: 1A1:20=47 6C2;:AC4 @63C@J0<25 :0802 C0?/: 2=7 @:/4C <A5:0354 ?C04D@A1 0=GAC041 4 B21 27<0::47 0= :/4 /@130:25 @= ! '& "'!) 2=7 701;/2C?47 @= "! '& "'!) "21141147:/470128050:9@6:/4;520<2=:2: (!H:@:/45@B4C50<8 A::/4:C08A=25/21;@=1074C47!(H :@B2C71B/@548@79 /4;520<2=:<4:B0:/:/42;;074=:0= :/4942C"'!)2=7/010=;@<401:@84:2>4=21 1 !'"%'$ 34C<@=:/2134C:/4;/2C:3C432C4789:/42C=2:2>24?25 4CD0;41 A:/@C0:9 @ 2<@A=: 01 ?C2=:47 A=74C :/4 /427 6A:AC4 <470;25 4J34=141 2=7 :/4 ;@<34=12:0@= 2<@A=: ?C2=:47A=74C@:/4C/42712C4@=5@B4C1074 % /4;520<2=:B212?47%942C12=7B21B@C>0=? 212=2?4C2:2:45;KA20=4C251D: :7 2=7?4::0=?2 1252C9 @6 1 !*'''$ 34C <@=:/ A: /4 /21 =@: 3C@7A;47 - 4 - 2=90=;@<43C@@6 /4:C08A=25/21;@=1074C47/010=;@<42: 1 '''$ 34C <@=:/ 4 <4: B0:/ :/4 2;;074=: @= ! '& "'!) 1 34C :/4 ?A07450=41 @6 :/4 2C=2:2>2 :2:4 4?25 4CD0;41 A:/@C0:9 /01 0=;@<4 :@ 84 :2>4= 2: 1 !'"%'$ 34C <@=:/ 4 1A1:20=47 6C2;:AC4 @6 C0?/: 3C@J0<25 :0802 21 34C J ) L 0=GAC9 ;4C:060;2:4 2=7 0: 01 2 ?C04D@A10=GAC9 4B21/@130:250I476@C234C0@7@6!%7291 /4 :C08A=25 /21 C0?/:59 21141147 :/4 70128050:9 @6 :/4 ;520<2=: 2=7 :/01 @AC: 60=71 =@ C421@= :@ 0=:4C64C4 0= :/4 12<4 /45@11@66A:AC40=;@<4B@A578421A=74C- 1 !'"%'$+!"+!&+!(HM 1 ")%%"'$ & /4 :C08A=25 /21 2B2C747 2 1A< @6 1 &)%%'$ A=74C:/4/427@6<470;254J34=141 /412<401;@CC4;:2=7 =4471 =@ 0=:4C64C4=;4 42C=47 ;@A=145 6@C :/4 2334552=:;520<2=:1A8<0:1:/2::/4;520<2=:/21A=74CB4=: 1AC?4C9 2=7 /4 =4471 2=@:/4C 1AC?4C9 6@C C4<@D25 @6 :/4 0<352=:1 /4C46@C4:/01@AC:60=710:C421@=2854:@?C2=:2 1A< @6 1 ''''$ A=74C :/4 /4271 @6 6A:AC4 <470;25 4J34=141 - 5 - ) @=1074C0=? :/4 =2:AC4 @6 :/4 0=GAC041 2=7 :/4 34C0@7 @6 /@130:250I2:0@= :/01 @AC: 60=71 0: C421@=2854 :@ 4=/2=;4 :/4 ;@<34=12:0@= ?C2=:47 A=74C :/4 /427 @6 320= 2=7 1A664C0=? :@ 1 ''''$ 2=7 5@11 @6 2<4=0:041 :@ 1 "''''$ /4;520<2=:<0?/:/2D4=@:2::4=7472=9B@C> 2:5421:6@C234C0@7@66@AC<@=:/1 4=;4/4014=:0:5476@C 21A<@6 1 (!'''$ 1 !'"%'$+(<@=:/1 :@B2C715@11 @60=;@<47AC0=?5207A334C0@7 401251@4=:0:5476@C21A< @6 1 ''''$ 6@C :C2=13@C:2:0@= 4J:C2 =@AC01/<4=: 2=7 2::4=72=:;/2C?41 4=;4:/4:@:25;@<34=12:0@=B@A5784 21A=74C- ) *+,-./0*1-+231 /412 ! 20=2=71A664C0=?1 1 ''''$ " @11@66A:AC40=;@<4 1 ")%%"'$ @11@62<4=0:041 1 "''''$ ( @11@60=;@<47AC0=?5207A3 34C0@7 1 (!'''$ % 470;254J34=141 1 &)%%'$ & #A:AC4<470;254J34=141 1 ''''$ ) C2=13@C:2:0@= 4J:C2 =@AC01/<4=: 2=7 2::4=72=: ;/2C?41 1 ''''$ 2+) -5657 * /4 :C08A=25 /21 2B2C747 0=:4C41: 2: :/4 C2:4 @6 H /412<401C47A;47:@&H34C2==A< - 6 - 42C=47 ;@A=145 6@C :/4 =1AC2=;4 ;@<32=9 1A8<0:1 :/2: :/4 ;@<34=12:0@= 2<@A=: 2B2C747 89 :/4 :C08A=25/21844=743@10:4725@=?B0:/0=:4C41: !' ;;@C70=?59:/46@55@B0=?@C74C- 0 /423342501255@B470=32C:, 00 /4 ;520<2=: 01 4=:0:547 :@ :@:25 ;@<34=12:0@=@6 1 ((')'$25@=?B0:/0=:4C41: 2: :/4 C2:4 @6 &H 34C 2==A< 6C@< :/4 72:4 @6 34:0:0@= :055 :/4 72:4 @6 C4250I2:0@= 21 2?20=1: 1 (*()'$2B2C74789:/4:C08A=25, 000 /4 0=1AC2=;4 ;@<32=9 01 70C4;:47 :@ 743@10: :/4 4=/2=;47 ;@<34=12:0@= @6 1 !(%&''$ 25@=? B0:/ 0=:4C41: B0:/0= 2 34C0@7 @6@=4<@=:/6C@<:/472:4@6:/01@C74C, 0D = 1A;/ 743@10: :/4 ;520<2=: 01 34C<0::47 :@ B0:/7C2B 4=:0C4 2<@A=: 25@=? B0:/ 0=:4C41:2;;CA47:/4C4@= -,7 %$ ' # 01:@ -! 5@ -(