Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 49517 (KAR)
SHANKAR S/O (LATE) BASAVARAJ BADGI v. GENERAL MANAGER (HR) AND ANR
WP/205860/2019 · 2025-03-18
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49517 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49517 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!! " !#$
% $&"& '"
"(
!"#$%& '! ! ! " (
(" ! ! " ((
" )
"#*&&&
(
((
" (
(" &*# !" #&&&% '
! (
(
! + ! Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! (
"
% (
" ( ! ," !"
!(#*%&% &&*&% "
! ! " -"
#
! ( &&& ( ! "
(
"
(
" ( #
. "
)!
/0 1023234506 /78 9/7::05;0< 75 46<06 =07635; 4!(#*%&% <720< &&*&% 17880< => 2/0 88382752 05067: 757;06 82720< 78 05067: 757;06 35 2/0 97?80 232:0 4@ 2/0 10232345 4@ 2/0 608145<0524#75A60B09235;/389:73C@467114352C05245 94C1788345720 ;64?5<8 /0 1023234506 /78 7:84 84?;/2 @46 7 <36092345242/0608145<05242494583<06/38711:3972345@46 7114352C052?5<062/089/0C0@46 C1:4>C0524@0105<0528 4@ C1:4>00 >35; D/3:0 35 06E390 164E3<35; 7114352C052 45 94C1788345720;64?5<8 /0 1023234506 945205<8 2/72 /38 @72/06 D78 0C1:4>0< 78 7 78/306 D32/ 2/0 608145<0528 75< <30< <?635; - 3 - 806E390 45 $&& /0 1023234506 945205<8 2/72 /0 D78 05232:0< 24 7114352C052 45 94C1788345720 ;64?5<8 75< 2/060@460781062/00F275214:39>4@2/0608145<0528@3:0<75 711:3972345 800A35; 7114352C052 45 94C1788345720 ;64?5<8 /0 1023234506 D78 97::0< ?145 => 2/0 608145<0528 24 @?6538/ 176239?:76875<2/087C0D78@?6538/0<242/0608145<052845 )&& /0 88382752 05067: 757;06 4@ 2/0 608145<052 4 # 75A 35 206C8 4@ 7 94CC?53972345 <720< &&*&% 35@46C0< 2/0 1023234506 2/72 /38 60G?082 @46 7114352C052 45 94C1788345720 ;64?5<8 D78 542 94583<060< @7E4?67=:>=>2/075A35E30D4@2/03594C04@2/0@7C3:>4@ 2/01023234506@64C7::84?6908/010232345062/051?68?0</38 9:73C => 8?=C32235; 601608052723458 /0 88382752 05067: 757;06 4@ 2/0 608145<052 4 # 75A 7;735 45 %&%&% 75< && 603206720< /38 076:306 8275< 75< 60B0920<2/060G?0824@2/01023234506 ) 035; 7;;630E0< => 2/0 87C0 2/0 1023234506 38 =0@4602/3894?62 * 07650<94?580:@462/01023234506945205<82/722/0 89/0C0@46C?:720<=>2/0608145<0528164E3<35;7114352C052 - 4 - 45 94C1788345720 ;64?5<8 38 7E73:7=:0 24 7 <0105<052 @7C3:> C0C=06 4@ 75 0C1:4>00 71143520< 45 60;?:76 =7838 7;73582 106C75052 E79759> 3@ /0 <308 =0@460 6079/35; 2/0 7;0 4@ >0768 0 945205<8 2/72 2/0 60E380< 89/0C0 38 35205<0< 24 788382 2/0 @7C3:> 24 23<0 4E06 2/0 @3575937: 82635;059> 75< 35<3;059>75<38711:397=:0D32/0@@092@64C&&$&*@462/0 97808 D/060 <072/ 45 C0<397: ;64?5<8 499?6 45 46 7@206 &&$&* 0 945205<8 2/72 7114352C052 45 94C1788345720 =783838;3E0545:>359:06397:75<8?=#827@@97<600945205<8 2/72 2/0 608145<0528 D/3:0 60B09235; 2/0 711:3972345 4@ 2/0 1023234506/7E060:30<?1452/0206C357:=050@3282/722/0@72/06 4@2/01023234506D7805232:0<240945205<82/722/4?;/2/0 @7C3:>14880880<*&%796084@<6>:75<357A/75<75A3E3::7;0 35 3B7>71?67 7:?A 7 8?32 @46 176232345 D78 @3:0< 35 4&75<2/087C0D78<09600<351762<09:7635; 2/722/07?5284@1023234506D06005232:0<24)6<8/760352/0 7@460873< 1641062> 8 7 608?:2 /0 8?=C328 2/72 2/0 @7C3:> 4@ 2/01023234506D7805232:0<24)6<8/7604?24@*&%796084@ :75< 75< 83590 2/060 D060 @4?6 C0C=068 35 2/0 @7C3:> 4@ 2/0 10232345062/01023234506D4?:<=005232:0<247=4?2*796084@ <6> :75< D/39/ 38 542 8?@@393052 24 C002 2/0 500<8 75< - 5 - 509088323080 @?62/06945205<8 2/72 2/0 206C357: =050@32 <?0 242/0<072/4@2/0@72/064@2/0102323450638542352/0/75<84@ 2/0 1023234506 7:450 =?2 7:: 2/0 42/06 2/600 C0C=068 760 05232:0< 24 75 0G?7: 8/760 0 945205<8 2/72 0E05 3@ 2/0 206C357: =050@328 38 27A05 3524 7994?52 2/0 1023234506 D4?:< /76<:>;0278?C4@8$&&&&&#D/39/D4?:<542=08?@@393052 24 C002 2/0 <7> 24 <7> 500<8 75< 50908832308 /38 71762 /0 945205<82/724504@2/083820684@2/01023234506D78C76630< 4@@7@2062/0<072/4@2/0@72/064@2/0102323450675<2/722/0 @7C3:>/7<359?660<:47575<0F105808@462/0C76637;0D/39/ 7:84 /78 24 =0 60173< /060@460 /0 945205<8 2/72 D/720E06 206C357:=050@3282/72D06060903E0</7854D=005?80<?1=> 2/0@7C3:>75<2/01023234506387=84:?20:><08232?2075</7854 C0758 4@ :3E0:3/44< 0 945205<8 2/72 78 106 2/0 89/0C0 @46C?:720< => 2/0 608145<0528 164E3<35; 7114352C052 45 94C1788345720 ;64?5<8 :7?80 333 4@ 2/0
89/0C0 827208 2/72 D/3:0 94583<0635; 75 711:3972345 @46 7114352C052 45 94C1788345720;64?5<8328/4?:<542=060B0920<C060:>452/0 ;64?5< 2/72 2/0 @7C3:> 4@ 2/0 0C1:4>00 /78 60903E0< 2/0 =050@328 ?5<06 2/0 E7634?8 D0:@760 89/0C08 0 2/060@460 945205<8 2/72 B?82 =097?80 2/0 @7C3:> 4@ 2/0 1023234506 /7< - 6 - 60903E0< 2/0 206C357: =050@328 2/72 3280:@ D4?:< 542 =0 7 <38G?7:3@3972345 @46 2/0 1023234506 24 9:73C 7114352C052 45 94C1788345720 ;64?5<8 0 8?=C328 2/72 2/0 89/0C0 38 711:397=:0 24 7:: 0C1:4>008 4@ 2/0 =75A 75< 2/060@460 2/0 1023234506 38 05232:0< 24 9:73C 7114352C052 45 94C1788345720 =7838 2/0 608145<0528 /7E0 @3:0< 7 <0273:0< 82720C052 4@ 4=B0923458 945205<35; 2/72 2/0 9459012 4@ 94C1788345720 7114352C052 38 0E4:E0< 24 /0:1 2/0 @7C3:> 35 <3826088<?0242/0:4884@7=607<076506/0>945205<2/72 2/0 89/0C0 38 2/060@460 @46C?:720< 35 8?9/ 7 D7> 2/72 <389602345 38 E0820< 35 2/0 0C1:4>06 24 788088 2/0 @3575937: 82635;059> @790< => 2/0 @7C3:> 75< 2/0 500< 24 164E3<0 7114352C052 45 94C1788345720 =7838 84 78 24 /0:1 2/0 @7C3:> 23<04E062/0963838238945205<0<2/722/01023234506/78=005 9766>35; 45 7;639?:2?67: 7923E32308 35 2/0 @7C3:> /0:< :75<8 75< 2/060@4602/010232345063854294C1:020:><08232?2075<38542 @7935; 75> @3575937: 82635;059> 84 78 24 164E3<0 /3C 7114352C0524594C1788345720=78382387:84945205<0<2/72 2/0 1023234506 38 35 6090312 4@ 7 8?=8275237: 8?C 4@ C450> 78 206C357: =050@328 75< 2/0 C42/06 4@ 2/0 1023234506 38 7:84 - 7 - <67D35; 1058345 4@ C460 2/75 8%&&&# 75< 2/0 @7C3:> 4@ 2/0 1023234506 38 <67D35; 3594C0 @64C E7634?8 35E082C0528 7C4?5235;2478?C4@8)#/?83238945205<0<2/72 2/0 @7C3:> 38 542 @7935; 75> 82635;059> 75< 2/0 608145<0528 /7E09760@?::>94583<060<2/080781092875</7E0/0:<2/722/0 1023234506 38 542 05232:0< 24 7114352C052 45 94C1788345720 =7838 % 5 7<<32345 32 38 945205<0< 2/72 2/0 838206 4@ 2/0 1023234506387:607<>D46A35;35>5<3972075AD/3:02/042/06 838206 38 7:607<> C76630< 4@@ 75< 38 :3E35; D32/ /06 /?8=75< /060@4603238945205<0<2/722/01023234506<408542/7E02/0 60814583=3:32> 4@ :44A35; 7@206 /38 C42/06 46 /38 8382068 75< D/720E06 C450> 35 2/0 @46C 4@ 206C357: =050@328 :>35; 35 /38 /75<8 75< 2/0 :75< 2/72 /0 4D58 760 B?82 054?;/ @46 2/0 8?820575904@2/0102323450658?114624@/3894520523458/0 60:30<?1452/0B?<;C0524@2/045.=:010F4?62352/09780 4@ E8 H *$I238945205<0<2/72 2/0 608145<0528 760 =4?5< 24 788088 E7634?8 @792468 =0@460 94C35;242/09459:?83452/722/0@7C3:>38<08232?204654275< 352/0160805297802/0608145<0528/7E027A05<?0976075< - 8 - 97?2345 35 /4:<35; 2/72 2/0 1023234506J8
@7C3:> 38 542 <08232?20 75< 2/72 1023234506 38 542 35 500< 4@ 75> 73< 35 2/0 @46C 4@ 164E3<35; 7114352C052 45 94C1788345720 ;64?5<8 5 2/38 60;76< 2/0> 60:30< ?145 2/0 B?<;C0528 4@ 2/0 45.=:0 10F 4?62 35 2/0 9780 4@ E8 H &&* %I 75< ! "#$ E8%
H &&* I 75< & ' "()$ *) (
+ ) H &&$ )$*I 75< ,
)*)( )H& *I /0> 7:84 60:30< ?145 2/0 B?<;C052 4@ 2/0 45.=:0 10F4?62352/097804@,% !E8( - .H *)$)I24945205<2/722/07114352C052 45 94C1788345720 ;64?5<8 38 75 0F9012345 976E0< 24 2/0 ;05067:6?:0@467114352C052
07650<94?580:@462/0608145<052435E320<2/0 722052345 4@ 2/0 4?62 24 550F?60# 24 2/0 D632 10232345 75< 945205<0< 2/72 2/0 206C357: =050@328 D78 7 8?C 4@ 8)&))*#75<78?C4@8%#D782/035E082C052 C7<0=>2/0@72/064@2/01023234506@64CD/39/2/01023234506 D78 076535; 3594C0 4@ 8)# 0 2/060@460 945205<0<
- 9 -
2/727@206<0<?9235;2/0:4757C4?5287E73:0<=>2/0@72/064@ 2/010232345062/0502206C357:=050@328D/39/D78:>35;352/0 /75<8 4@ 2/0 1023234506 75< /38 @7C3:> C0C=068 D78 8)%)# 75< 2/0 C42/06 4@ 2/0 1023234506 D78 <67D35; 1058345 4@ 8%%*%# 0 @?62/06 945205<0< 2/72 2/0 1023234506 /3C80:@ <09:760< 2/72 2/0 @7C3:> 4D50< 7 /4?80 945826?920< 45 7 8320 C078?635; )&. F *&. 72 0:;7?C 75< 4D50< *&% 79608 4@ <6> :75< 35 3B71?6 0 2/060@460 945205<8 2/72 2/0 @7C3:> 38 542 <08232?20 75< 2/060@460 2/0 608145<0528/7E027A05352494583<06723452/07=4E0@792875< /78 63;/2:> 94C0 24 2/0 9459:?8345 2/72 2/0 1023234506 38 542 05232:0<247114352C0524594C1788345720;64?5<8 $ 0 60@0660< 24 2/0 9/0C0 @46 4C1788345720 114352C052 C460 176239?:76:> :7?80 D/39/ 38 0F267920< =0:4D#
/'
- 10 -
0 7:84 60@0660< 24 :7?80 333 4@ 2/0 873< 9/0C0D/39/82720878@4::4D8#
! """ # $ %
&
'
%
(
#
) * *
+ & 0 2/060@460 945205<0< 2/72 2/0 7114352C052 45 94C1788345720=7838D4?:<=04@@060<=>2/0608145<0524#
- 11 -
=75A45:>3579780D/052/0=75A3887238@30<2/722/0@3575937: 945<323454@2/0@7C3:>388?9/2/72=?2@462/0164E383454@75 0C1:4>C0522/0@7C3:>D3::542=07=:024C0022/0963838
/7E0 94583<060< 2/0 8?=C3883458 4@ 2/0 :07650< 94?580: @46 2/0 1023234506 75< 2/0 :07650< 94?580: @46 2/0 608145<0524
863;/2:>945205<0<=>2/0:07650<94?580:@462/0 608145<052475<7863;/2:>/0:<=>2/045J=:010F4?62 35 2/0 9780 4@ , % !
60@0660< 8?167 7114352C0524594C1788345720;64?5<8387<01762?60@64C2/0 60;?:7694?6804@6096?32C05275<38<083;50<24/0:12/0@7C3:> 4@750C1:4>002423<04E0678?<<0596383897?80<<?0242/0 <072/ 4@ 7 =607< 076506 35 2/0 @7C3:> /060@460 32 38 @46 2/0 0C1:4>06 24 <093<0 2/0 206C8 75< 945<323458 4@ 711435235; 7 106845 45 94C1788345720 =7838 5 2/0 9780 45 /75< 2/0 608145<0528 /7E0 0E4:E0< 7 89/0C0 @46 7114352C052 45 94C1788345720=7838 /0 608145<0528 /7E0 7:84 60806E0< 2/0 63;/2 24 788088 2/0 @3575937: 945<32345 4@ 2/0 @7C3:> =0@460 /4:<35; 2/72 2/0 @7C3:> 38 <08232?20 75< <0806E08 3CC0<3720 @3575937:7883827590@4660:30@"5<062/089/0C02/00C1:4>06
- 12 -
3805232:0<2427A035247994?522/03594C04@2/0@7C3:>@64C7:: 84?6908359:?<35;@7C3:>1058345206C357:=050@328164900<84@ 358?6759014:3930875<42/0635E082C052802983K04@2/0@7C3:> 75< :37=3:32308 029 /0 89/0C0 7:84 97828 2/0 =?6<05 45 2/0 10684524=071143520<4594C1788345720;64?5<824?5<0627A0 2/72 /0 D3:: C7352735 164106:> 2/0 42/06 @7C3:> C0C=068 D/4 D060 <0105<052 45 2/0 <090780< 0C1:4>00 75< 35 9780 32 38 164E0< 2/72 2/0 @7C3:> C0C=068 D060 =035; 50;:0920< 46 542 C73527350<164106:>/3846/067114352C052D3::=0206C35720< /060@4602/089/0C078@46C?:720<=>2/0608145<052#75A38 24 058?60 2/72 2/0 @7C3:> 4@ 2/0 <090780< 0C1:4>00 38 27A05 97604@=>164E3<35;757114352C052247C0C=064@2/0@7C3:> ?9/7114352C0528760;3E0545:>352/09:06397:75<8?=#827@@ 97<60 /0 89/0C0 7:84 05E387;08 17>C052 4@ 0F;67237 ?5<06 :7?80$D/39/607<878@4::4D8
, -./0$1$ 12 31-4 56 758$99152$- $5128-2 7 $ -": ) 7 $
9 7 2;< =,=><==! - 13 -
:-":
) 106?87:4@2/09/0C08/4D82/722/089/0C038 4105 24 2/0 <0105<7528 4@ 7:: 106C75052 0C1:4>008 4@ 2/0 =75A /05 7 106C75052 0C1:4>00 <308 2/0 =75A /78 2D4 412345845038032/0624164E3<07114352C0524594C1788345720 =7838=780<452/0@3575937:82635;059>4@2/0@7C3:>462417> 75 0F ;67237 35 :30? 4@ 94C1788345720 7114352C052 2 38 542 A54D5D/02/062/0608145<0528/7E0173<75>0F;67237242/0 @7C3:>4@2/01023234506 * 863;/2:>945205<0<=>2/0:07650<94?580:@462/0 608145<052 4 2/0 1023234506 75< /38@7C3:> C0C=068D060 3560903124@502206C357:=050@3284@78?C4@8)%)# /0 C42/06 4@ 2/0 1023234506 D78 <67D35; @7C3:> 1058345 4@ 8%%*%#D/3:02/0@7C3:>4@2/010232345068D78076535;7 C452/:>3594C04@8)#@64C35E082C0528C7<0=>2/0 <090780<4D0E062/387:450975542=02/0=7838247663E072 2/09459:?83452/722/0711:397523854205232:0<24=071143520< 45 94C1788345720 ;64?5<8 78 2/0 =050@32 4@ 89/0C0 38 7E73:7=:0242/0<0105<75284@7::0C1:4>0084@2/0608145<052
- 14 -
4 # 75A 75< 542 45:> 24 64?1# 46 64?1# 14828 5E7637=:>2/0<0105<75284@7<090780<0C1:4>004@7=75A 76005232:0<242/0<072/=050@328D/39/385427;67238;3E05=> 2/00C1:4>06=?27602/0:0;323C720076535;84@2/0<090780< 0C1:4>00 /0 45.=:0 10F 4?62 35
*) ) % ?(<=
# !
977 ;
<@ /78 60B0920<783C3:76;64?5<67380<=>7=75A24<05>7114352C052 4594C1788345720;64?5<8/4?;/2/38B?<;C0523860@0660<24 7:76;06059/2/087C038542<382?6=0<23::<720
4D0E062/0@7C3:>4@2/010232345064D57/4?80 72 0:;7?C 75< 7 :76;0 7607 4@ *& 9608 % ;?5278 4@ 7;639?:2?67: :75< 72 7A/75<7A3 E3::7;0 35 3B7>71?67 7:?A 2 71107682/722/07?5284@2/01023234506/7<@3:0<78?3235 4&@46176232345D/39/D78<09600<35176235206C8 4@2/0B?<;0C05275<<09600<720<&&$&17880<=>2/0 <<323457:053463E3:?<;03B7>71?6775<2/087C0D78 945@36C0< => 2/0 !6359317: 3826392 ?<;0 3B7>71?67 35 4$& 45 &%&
E05 3@ 32 38 788?C0< 2/72 2/0 7?5284@2/0102323450676005232:0<@4678/760352/01641062308 4@2/0@7C3:>823::2/0@7C3:>D4?:<=0:0@2D32/7:76;0/4:<35;
D/39/ 38 8?@@393052 054?;/ @46 0A35; 4?2 7 <09052 :3E0:3/44<
- 15 -
/0102323450675</38@7C3:>C0C=068D0603560903124@5076:> 8)%)#=035;2/0502206C357:=050@3284@2/0<090780< /0C42/064@1023234506D7875<38<67D35;@7C3:>10583454@ 8%%*%# @64C 2/0 75A 75< 076535; C452/:> 3594C0 4@ 8)#@64C2/035E082C0528C7<0=>2/0<090780</0 2D483820684@2/0 1023234506760C76630<4@@D/3:0/38 C42/06 /787<0905210583458?@@393052054?;/@46/06:3E35;/060@460 2/0 @7C3:> 38 542 35 <360 @3575937: 8267328 60G?3635; 2/0 608145<052#75A 24 164E3<0 75 7114352C052 24 2/0 1023234506
"5<06 2/0 9369?C8275908 2/060 38 54 06646 94CC3220< => 2/0 8838275205067:757;06 4@2/0608145<0524#75A 3554205206273535;2/060G?0824@2/01023234506@467114352C052 4594C1788345720;64?5<8 05902/01023234538)
"*+
'&( &! #17674824* 8C7#@64C1767423::2/005< 3824:4