- 1 - ! "# $#%# && '%( ) ! " # $ ! %# & Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '( ! ! ) ## ) ! '' # '##* '+'##* ! ) ! '(#,,, '- #( '##* ! ! ))) )! ) ) ! . ! % # . ! /"0123/4/"05/1&6758/4"99/"0:5;<6023/"99/44"52"51 23/4/"05/1&6758/4"99/"0:5;<6023/0/89651/52 ' 3:8"99/"4:8";":582"&65&700/52<:51:5;:5"87:2<60 :5=75&2:65 3/87:2:81/&0//1"511/</51"528&4":>:81:8>:88/1 3/87:2:8<:4/1:50/89/&26<23/9069/02?$/"0:5;? 6 %@-% >/"870:5; '#A "82@/82 "51 A 6023@6723 $6751/1 65 23/ /"82 $? 06"1 B/82 $? 3678/ 6< 1/</51"52 6023 $? 3678/ 6< - 3 - !/22"99" "51 6723 $? 06"1 :5 "41/C"5"3"44: :44";/ 360"970 "47D 4":52:<<&4":>823"223/8":19069/02?B"8;0"52/1263:> $?23/6C/05>/52 4":52:<<>"D/8"0/</0/5&/263:85">/:5 )60>6 ' % 3/1/</51"52&652/82/123/87:26523/90/>:8/23"2 23/ 9069/02? $/"0:5; 462 6 %@-% >/"870:5; -AE%#A :5 ? 6 ''6<"41/C"5"3"44::44";/B"8;0"52/12623/<"23/06< 23/ 1/</51"52 $? "47D" /C/469>/52 6"01 360"970 :5 23/ ?/"0,+ - 3/ 0:"4 6702 3"8 1/&0//1 23/ 87:2 3/ ):082 99/44"2/67021:8>:88/123/"99/"4 3:8"99/"4:8"1>:22/165( #* '##26&658:1/023/ <6446B:5;87$82"52:"4F7/82:6586<4"B G 3/23/0 23/ 67028 $/46B &6741 1/&4"0/ 23/1/</51"52"823/"$86472/6B5/06<23/9069/02? :5"87:2<60$"0/:5=75&2:656523/$"8:86<"5:887/ 2623"2/<</&2H"51 ' 3/23/023/67028$/46B&6741"&&/9223/ 87:2 9069/02? "8 $/:5; 23/ 87$@1:C:8:65 6< " 9462 57>$/0/C/5B:2367223/0/$/:5;>72"2:65/520:/8 :523"20/;"01H - 4 - ( 2 :8 562:&/1 23"2 56 1/&0// :8 ;0"52/1 1/&4"0:5; 23/ 1/</51"52"823/6B5/0"511/&0//;0"52/1:8654?<60:5=75&2:65 :5<"C6706<23/94":52:<< /5&/<:08287$82"52:"4F7/82:656<4"B <0">/1"$6C/16/8562"0:8/ + 8 <"0 "8 8/&651 87$82"52:"4 F7/82:65 6< 4"B :8 &65&/05/1:2:8562:&/123"223/0/:856:887/0/4"2:5;2623/87$@ 1:C:8:656<23/9069/02? /5&/23/8":187$82"52:"4F7/82:656< 4"B"48616/8562"0:8/ * 5 &658:1/0:5; 23/ >"2/0:"48 94"&/1 65 0/&601 23:8 6702:86<23/C:/B23"223/<6446B:5;87$82"52:"4F7/82:656<4"B B6741"0:8/<60&658:1/0"2:65 G3/5 $623 23/ 9"02:/8 26 23/ 906&//1:5; &4":> 9688/88:65 6< 23/ 9069/02? $"8/1 65 23/ 6C/05>/52 ;0"52 B3/23/0 23/ 67028 $/46B "0/ =782:<:/1 :5 ;:C:5; " <:51:5; 65 9688/88:65 6< 23/ 9069/02?B:236720/</0/5&/2623/2:24/1//180"52 01/08IH , )06> 23/ 1/8&0:92:65 836B5 $? 23/ 94":52:<< :2 :8 /C:1/52 23"2 23/ /E2/52 6< 23/ 9069/02?>/52:65/1:5 23/ 87:2 :8 >7&3 4/88 23"5 23/ /E2/52 6< 23/ 9069/02? 6C/0 B3:&3 23/ 1/</51"52 :8 &4":>:5; 0:;32 B3:&3 :8 1/8&0:$/1 :5 23/ B0:22/5 - 5 - 82"2/>/52 2 :8 "486 <6023&6>:5; <06> 23/ 1/8&0:92:65 6< 23/ 9069/02? >/52:65/1 :5 23/ 94":52 23"2 1/</51"52A8 9069/02? :8 "1="&/522623/87:29069/02? # 623670283"C/&65&700/524?;:C/5"<:51:5;23"223/ 94":52:<<:8:59688/88:656<23/9069/02? 3/1/</51"523"8<":4/1 26 /82"$4:83 23/ "44/;/1 ;0"52 :5 23/ 5">/ 6< 23/ <"23/0 6< 23/ 1/</51"52 3/ 1/</51"52 3"8 94"&/1 0/4:"5&/ 65 23/ 1/&0// 9"88/1 $? 23/ 0:"4 6702 ";":582 23/ "5&3"?"2 :5 6 (+,,% "51 &4":>/1 23"2 3/ :8 :5 9688/88:65 6< 23/ 9069/02?"8>/52:65/1:523/B0:22/582"2/>/52 1>:22/14?23/ 94":52:<< :8 562 " 9"02? :5 6 (+,,% "51 23/ 8":1 1/&0// 16/8 562$:51 23/94":52:<< 2 :8 "486 82"2/1 23"2 "5&3"?"2 1:1 562&652/8223/8":187:2"51:2B"8C:027"44?"5/E9"02/1/&0// 51/0 23/8/ &:0&7>82"5&/8 23/ <:51:5;8 6< 23/ 6702 23"2 23/ 1/&0//16/8562$:5123/94":52:<<&"5562$/<6751<"742B:23 ' 2 :8 "486 562:&/1 23"2 23/ 94":52:<< 26 /82"$4:83 3:8 9688/88:650/4:/16523/0/96026<23/67026>>:88:65/0 3/ 67028 3"C/ 3/41 23"2 23/ 0/9602 6< 23/ 6702 6>>:88:65/0 - 6 - &"5562$/23/$"8:826/82"$4:839688/88:65"512:24/ 6<"742&"5 $/<6751B:2323/8":1<:51:5;"8B/44 % 2:8562:&/1:523/94":5223"223/94":52:<<3"8"88/02/1 3:89688/88:656<23/9069/02?$"8/16523/16&7>/52"2 E8 26 -B3:&3"0/5622:24/1//18 :5&/23/94":52:<<3"8"88/02/1 3:8 2:24/ "51 86 "486 23/ 1/</51"52 23/ <:51:5; 0/4"2:5; 26 23/ 9688/88:658367413"C/$//5$"8/16523/2:24/1//18 /5&/:5 23/"$8/5&/6<2:24/1//1823/0:"46702&67415623"C/1/&:1/1 23/ F7/82:65 0/4"2:5; 26 9688/88:65 B3/5 $623 23/ 9"02:/8 "88/02/123/:09688/88:65$"8/1652:24/ - 51/023/&:0&7>82"5&/8B:23672;6:5;2623/>/0:28 6< 23/ 0/89/&2:C/ &4":> 6< 23/ 9"02:/8 23:8 6702 :8 6< 23/ C:/B 23"2 $623 23/ 9"02:/8 836741 $/ ;:C/5 "5 69960275:2? 26 4/"1 $/22/0/C:1/5&/:587996026<23/:00/89/&2:C/&4":> 51/0 23/ &:0&7>82"5&/8 23/ 87$82"52:"4 F7/82:65 6< 4"B :8 "58B/0/1 3641:5; 23"2 23/ <:51:5; 0/4"2:5; 26 9688/88:65 B:23672 0/</0/5&/ 26 2:24/ 1//1 :8 562 =782:<:/1 3/ >"22/0 :8 0/>:22/12623/0:"46702<60<0/83&658:1/0"2:65 ( /5&/23/<6446B:5; - 7 - : 3/ :>97;5/1 =71;>/52 "51 1/&0// 1"2/1 '' # '##*9"88/1:5 6 '+'##*9"88/1$?23/ :C:4!71;/0 5 360"970"5123/=71;>/52"51 1/&0//:5 6 '(#,,,1"2/1'- #( '##*9"88/1 $?23/:C:4!71;/!0 360"970"0/8/2@"8:1/ :: 3/ >"22/0 :8 0/>:22/1 26 23/ 0:"4 6702 <60 <0/83 &658:1/0"2:65:5"&&601"5&/B:234"B ::: 2 :8 >"1/ &4/"0 23"2 $623 23/ "99/44"52 "51 23/ 0/89651/52 "0/ 9/0>:22/1 26 4/"1 <0/83 /C:1/5&/ :5 87996026<23/:0&4":> :C 2 :8 <7023/0 >"1/ &4/"0 23"2 23:8 6702 3"8 562 /E90/88/1"5?69:5:656523/>/0:286<23/&4":>6< /:23/06<23/9"02:/8 C "02:/8 83"44 "99/"0 $/<60/ 23/ 0:"4 6702 65 *! B:23672 "B":2:5; <60 "5? <7023/0 562:&/ <06>23/0:"46702 C: 0:"46702/&6018$/0/2705/1 +, '# ( % 05:826 46 --