- 1 - !!"#!$! % "&"'""! ""'' ()* + ! ! " #$ % &'( &"' &#)#'$* $ # % &'( &"' + Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - &#)#'$* ' $% + &#)#"," % '- "$ ! %%"*' "! % % ",,#$,$$ $'$,") % % . &! /01234/01567/839:;<:349=2/9 $ 4=90>>/0?=9;=?/2050=89334/0@012:;34/1=<680? =8 :$'$,")203/2",,#$,$$>099/2<A34/:613:; - 3 - /8=:1=B=?625/08222? 03090B0C0?A08 ;:194:13 D34/1=<680?E! ' 8F61/2 G?0=7083 05/2 $ A/019 @:1C=85 09 0 /8=:1 >/103:17/3@=34080GG=2/83:8,'""$,"*082;=?/2 0G?0=7>/3=3=:8G?0=7=85G:7>/8903=:8:;9"#,,,,,&4/ 1=<680?0;3/1G:89=2/1=85/83=1//B=2/8G/:81/G:1251083/208 07:683 :; 9'(,$& @=34 =83/1/93 03 34/ 103/ :; H >/1 08867;1:7203/:;F6257/833=??=391/0?=I03=:8 551=/B/2<A34/90=2:12/134=90>>/0?=9>1/;/11/2 =8@4=G4=3=97/83=:8/234030>>/??083@0909/8=:1:>/103:1=8 03A02//>34040170G/63=G0?9?=7=3/2082/018=859",,,& >/17:8340824/;=?/24=990?01AG/13=;=G03/=834031/50123=9 ;6134/1 G:83/82/2 3403 34:654 34/ :G3:1 099/99/2 34/ 2=90<=?=3A09')H34/31=<680?40930C/834/907/09""H /@09027=33/2=834/4:9>=30?:8,'""$,"*0822=9G4015/2 :8 "#""$,"* 082 3469 4/ @09 4:9>=30?=I/2 ;:1 "$ 20A9 %6134/1 34/ 07:6839 51083/2 682/1 34/ :34/1 4/029 01/ 7/05/1 34/1/;:1/ 1/J6/93/2 ;:1 /8408G/7/83 :; 34/ G:7>/8903=:8 - 4 - # 27=33/2?A 34/ 0>>/??083 @09 @:1C=85 09 0 /8=:1 >/103:1 =8 34/ 0<:B/ 90=2 G:7>08A ;1:7 >093 ", A/019 082 @09 /018=85 9",,,& >/1 7:834 082 0;3/1 34/ 1/?/B083 2/26G3=:89 4/ @09 5/33=85 0 8/3 90?01A :; 9""(*)& >/1 7:834082=3=93:</G:89=2/1/2;:134/>61>:9/:;G0?G6?03=:8 / @09 05/2 $ A/019 03 34/ 3=7/ :; 0GG=2/83 4/8G/ 34/ 76?3=>?=/1 =9 3: </ 30C/8 09 D"E 9 >/1 K* L :682 /13=;=G03/ 34/ 0>>/??083 96930=8/2 =8310 083/1=:1 2=930? 102=69 ;10G361/ 1=543 9=2/ 082 0<109=:8 :B/1 1=543 4082 @4=G4 01/ 51=/B:69=880361/4/0>>/??083/K07=8/234/:G3:109$ 0824/=996/22=90<=?=3AG/13=;=G03/682/1K"'0824/9303/2 3403 34/ 0>>/??083 96930=8/2 ;10G361/ :; 1=543 ;:1/017 :>/103/2! 082 4/ 099/99/2 34/ 2=90<=?=3A 09 ')H /8G/ "'12 :; ')H G:7/9 3: "$H 1:682/2 :;; 3: "'H 4/1/;:1/34/?:99:;34/;6361//018=85G0>0G=3AG:7/93: ""(*)K"$K"K"'HM$",,& 4/ 31=<680? 51083/2 9"#,,,,& ;:1 7/2=G0? /K>/89/90820?9:9',,,,&;:1;6361/7/2=G0?/K>/89/9082 =38//298:=83/1;/1/8G/ - 5 - * :89=2/1=8534/>/1=:2:;4:9>=30?=903=:880361/:; =8F61=/9 96930=8/2 <A 34/ >/3=3=:8/1 34=9 :613 ;=829 =3 1/09:80<?/ 3: 51083 08 07:683 :; 9#,,,,& ;:1 >0=8 082 96;;/1=859$#,,,&;:1?:99:;07/8=3=/90829',,,,&;:1 31089>:1303=:8/K3108:61=947/83082033/82083G4015/9 ) /7=5438:340B/033/82/208A:34/1@:1C03?/093 ;:10>/1=:2:;:8/7:83434/1/;:1/G:89=2/1=8534/;0G33403 4/ 96930=8/2 51=/B:69 ;10G361/9 34=9 :613 ;=829 =3 1/09:80<?/ 3: 51083 08 07:683 :; 9""(*)& 3:@0129 ?:99 :; =8G:7/ 261=85?0=26>>/1=:2 ( 8 0?? 34/ 3:30? G:7>/8903=:8 G:7/9 3: 9##)#*)&@=34=83/1/930334/103/:;H>/108867;1:7 34/203/:;>/3=3=:83=??1/0?=I03=:8 ", 4/ 0@012 G:7>/8903=:8 >099/2 <A 34/ 1=<680? =97:2=;=/209682/1 ,-./ 012342/ ":99:;;6361//018=85G0>0G=3A $",,& $0=808296;;/1=85 #,,,,& ':99:;07/8=3=/9 $#,,,& /2=G0?/K>/89/9 "#,,,,& - 6 - #1089>:1303=:8 /K310 8:61=947/83 082033/82083G4015/9 ',,,,& :99 :; /018=85 261=85 ?0=2 6> >/1=:2;:1:8/7:834 ""(*)& *:99:;;6361/7/2=G0?/K>/89/9 ',,,,& 3-5 6 GG:12=85?A 34/ G?0=7083 =9 /83=3?/2 ;:1 08 /8408G/2 G:7>/8903=:8:;9""("*& "" 834/1/96?334/;:??:@=85:12/1=9>099/2 =! 4/0>>/0?=9 ==! 4/G?0=7083=9/83=3?/2;:103:30?G:7>/8903=:8:; 9##)#*)& @=34 =83/1/93 03 34/ 103/ :; H >/1 08867;1:734/203/:;>/3=3=:83=??1/0?=I03=:8 ===! /9>:82/83:'L896108G/G:7>08A4090?1/02A 2/>:9=3/2 34/ 07:683 0@012/2 <A 34/ 31=<680? 34/1/;:1/ /9>:82/83 :' =9 2=1/G3/2 3: 2/>:9=3 34/ /8408G/2 G:7>/8903=:8 :; 9""("*& @=34 =83/1/930334/103/:;H@=34=8"7:834;1:734/ 203/:;34=9:12/1 - 7 - =B! 8 96G4 2/>:9=3 34/ 0>>/??083 =9 >/17=33/2 3: @=34210@ 34/ 07:683 0?:85 @=34 =83/1/93 0GG16/2 :8=3 /.6 ('""!* &! =93:"?:#"