- 1 - !" #"$"" "!! %& %'' ( !"#$% & ! " "'(% # ) * # ) " " # Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) " " # ) + """" # ) ( "" # ) " # ) $ # # ) ' " # ) # ) "" # - 3 - ) * & " # ) &, # ) # " # ) + " # ) ( " " # ) #" # ) " " # ) ' # - 4 - ) !" #" &- $&'% & & ! % ('' !% & *('* !('* & % " # ) $ " & # $ ." # $" ! ." # % /0 122033145 60748 5/0 749:;<145 74 ;7<0 :('* :9 74=/14>;>;13 :37?0 5157:4 :4 5/0 9730 :9 5/0 301;40= ==757:413 7@5;7?5 14= 0@@7:4@ #>=80 17?/>; @755748 15 74=/14>; !/0;0741950; ;090;;0= 5: 1@ A5/0;713:>;5B%7@7<2>847485/0:;=0;=150=('' 1??025748 5/0 A"B ;02:;5 9730= 6C 5/0 4D0@57815748 997?0; 14=?3:@7485/0?;7<7413?1@0 - 5 - 01;= <5 >E151 >8>; 301;40= ?:>4@03 9:; 5/0 122033145 14= ;7 #1<1=1; /1/16>==74 301;40= 78/ :>;5 :D0;4<045 301=0; 9:; ;0@2:4=045 : 5150;71/1450@/ 1573301;40=?:>4@039:;;0@2:4=045 :@5:' 0;>@0=5/0<150;713@:4;0?:;= * 4 D70F :9 5/0 ;7D13 ?:450457:4@ >;80= 6C 301;40=?:>4@039:;6:5/5/021;570@5/02:7455/15F:>3= 1;7@09:;<C?:4@7=0;157:47@ C14@F0;5:5/016:D02:7457@745/0AB9:; 5/09:33:F748 /0122033145/0;0741@749:;<1459730=5/097;@5 749:;<157:4 F75/ >;13 :37?0 5157:4 74=/14>; 18174@5 1??>@0=:@5:13308748?:<<7@@7:4:95/0:9904?0@ 2>47@/1630>4=0;0?57:4@*(***' '+F0?57:4:95/0 4=714 0413:=0+'!9:; - 6 - @/:;5A B%14=0?57:4@*!%!;%!@%14=*!%!D1%:95/0 ?/0=>30= 1@50@ 14= ?/0=>30= ;760@ ! ;0D0457:4 :9 5;:?7570@%<04=<045?5'!9:;@/:;5A! ;0D0457:4 :9 5;:?7570@%<04=<045?5'!9:;@/:;5A! % ?5B%@5157485/15:4('*'*F/04@/013:48F75//0; 91<73C<0<60;@F1@749;:45:9/0;/:>@01335/01??>@0= 9:;<748 5/0<@03D0@ 745: 14 >431F9>3 1@@0<63C ?;7<74133C 7457<7=150= 5: ?1>@0 5/07; =015/ 14= 74@7@50= /0; 5: F75/=;1F5/0?:<237145F/7?/7@13;01=C9730=/0C/1D0 ;090;;0= 5: 5/0 ?1@50 :9 5/0 749:;<145 1@ @/0 603:48@ 5: @?/0=>30=?1@50@F75/147450457:45:/><737150/0;745/0 2>637?231?014=1@@1>350=5/0749:;<14514=:5/0;@F75/ ?3>6 14= :5/0; =01=3C F012:4@ 5 7@ @5150= 5/15 5/0 1??>@0= /1D0 1@@1>350= 5/0< 97D0 :; @7G 57<0@ 6>5 5/0 749:;<145 /1= 4:5 9730= 14C ?:<231745 /0 ?/1;80 @/005 F1@ 9730= 18174@5 5/0 749:;<145 14= /0; 91<73C <0<60;@ :4 5/0 61@7@ :9 5/0 ?:<231745 5/0C /1= ;087@50;0= 14= 5/0;09:;05/01??>@0=/1D00<6:3=0414=?:<<7550=5/0 :9904?0 43C F/04 5/0 1375/ ;8147H157:4@ 2;:50@50= 609:;05/02:37?0@5157:45/0& ?1<05:60;087@50;0= - 7 - 950;74D0@578157:45/0 4D0@57815748997?0;/1@ 9730= A"B 97413 ;02:;5 :4 ''('* @515748 5/15 1 913@0 ?1@0 /1@ 6004 ;087@50;0= 6C 5/0 749:;<145 =>0 5: 733F733 605F0045/0 5F:91<7370@ 4 04I>7;C 75 F1@ 9:>4=5/15 4: @>?/ 74?7=045 1@ 133080= /1= :??>;;0= :4 ('*'* /0 0C0F7540@@0@ ;090;;0= 5: 6C 5/0 749:;<145 70 <;0@/ 14= /7@ @:4 6/7@/0J 1;0 ?3:@0 1@@:?7150@ :9 5/0 749:;<145 14= 0D04 5/0C /1D0 4:5 87D04 1 @5150<045 ;081;=748 :??>;;04?0 :9 5/0 74?7=045 1@ @5150= 6C 5/0 749:;<145 /045/04078/6:>;@F0;004I>7;0=16:>55/0 74?7=0454:40:95/0<@5150=16:>55/074?7=0455/15/1= :??>;;0= :4 ('*'* 6>5 5/0C /1D0 @5150= 5/15 4: @>?/74?7=045/1@51J04231?0 57@13@:@5150=5/155/0 <:67302/:40?133;0?:;=14=5:F0;3:?157:4F1@1413C@0= 14= 75 @/:F0= 5/15 5/0 1??>@0= F0;0 74 =7990;045 3:?157:4@ 6>5 4:40 :9 5/0< F0;0 15 5/0 @?040 :9 :??>;;04?0 /0 F7540@@0@ ?750= 6C 5/0 749:;<145 14= 0G1<740= 6C 5/0 4D0@57815748 997?0; /1D0 87D04 ?:45;1=7?5:;C @5150<045@ 4=0; @>?/ ?7;?><@514?0@ 14 - 8 - :2747:4 F1@ 9:;<0= 5/15 4: @>?/ 74?7=045 /1= :??>;;0= 14=5/0;09:;0A"B97413;02:;5?1<05:609730= + /0 <150;713@ :4 ;0?:;= =7@?3:@0 5/15 0D04 5/:>8/A"B97413;02:;5F1@9730=:4''('*5/0@1<0 F1@ 1??0250= 6C 5/0 301;40= ;713 :>;5 :4 ('' 1950; 7@@>748 4:57?0 5: 5/0 749:;<145 14= 87D748 :22:;5>475C5:97305/0:6E0?57:4@">55733(''4: 2;:50@5205757:4F1@9730=F/7?/;0@>350=741??0257485/0 A"B97413;02:;51@20;:;=0;=150=('' ( /0 ;713 :>;5 F/730 21@@748 5/0 :;=0; 7<2>840= =150= ('' /1@ 51J04 745: ?:4@7=0;157:4 1335/0<150;713@:4;0?:;=745/0378/5:95/0@5150<045@:9 5/0 F7540@@0@ ;0?:;=0= 6C 5/0 4D0@57815748 997?0; 14= 5/0?:4?3>@7:41;;7D0= 156C/7< 9:; 5/02>;2:@0:9 973748 A"B97413;02:;514=1??0250=5/0@1<0 57@5/0?:450457:4:95/0749:;<1455/1516:>5 5: *' 20;@:4@ /1D0 815/0;0= :4 5/0 =150 :9 74?7=045 F75/=01=3CF012:4@14=?3>6@31220=14=1@@1>350=/0; - 9 - ?;7<74133C 7457<7=150= /0; 14= 5/0C /1D0 13@: 1@@1>350= /0; 91<73C <0<60;@ 450;0@57483C 4:40 :9 5/0< /1D0 @>@51740= 14C 74E>;70@ 5 7@ @5150= 5/15 74?7=045 /1= :??>;;0= :4 ('*'* 6>5 5/0 ?:<237145 F1@ 9730= :4 '*'* 1950; 5/0 1375/ ;8147H157:4 <1=0 14 045;C 14=1??:<21470=5/0749:;<145/0;07@4:;01@:4F/C 5/0 749:;<145 14= 5/0 :5/0; 74E>;0= /1D0 4:5 9730= 5/0 ?:<231745 7<<0=71503C /0 ?:450457:4 :9 5/0 301;40= ?:>4@039:;5/01220331455/155/097;@5749:;<157:43:=80= 6C 5/0 749:;<145 7<<0=71503C F1@ 4:5 1??0250= 6C 5/0 2:37?0=:0@4:5974=1231?0745/097;@5749:;<157:44:;75 974=@14C@>22:;59;:<14C=:?><045 /0 0C0F7540@@0@ <;0@/ 14= 6/7@/0J /1D0 @5150=5/1516:>5'5:*'20;@:4@/1D01@@1>350=5/0< <0;?730@@3C 6>5 4:40 :9 5/0< /1D0 @>@51740= 74E>;C /0;0 7@ 4: 0G2314157:4 9:; 5/0 @1<0 /0 4078/6:>;748 20;@:4@ F0;0 04I>7;0= 6C 5/0 4D0@57815748 997?0; 14= 5/07; @5150<045@ F0;0 ;0?:;=0= 33 5/0@0 F7540@@0@ - 10 - ?:4@7@50453C@5150=5/154:@>?/74?7=045/1=:??>;;0=:4 5/0=150;090;;0=5:6C5/0749:;<145 ' 450;0@57483C 5/0 4D0@57815748 997?0; /1@ ?:330?50= 5/0 <:6730 ?133 3:?157:4 14= 513370= 75 F75/ 5/0 5:F0; 3:?157:4 5: 9:;< 14 :2747:4 5/15 4:40 :9 5/0 1??>@0=F0;02;0@045155/0@?040:9:??>;;04?01@:45/0 =150 14= 57<0 :9 5/0 @: ?1330= 74?7=045 4=0; 5/0@0 ?7;?><@514?0@ =:4:5974=14C;01@:45:@>@20?55/0A"B ;02:;59730=6C5/0 4D0@57815748997?0; /0 ?:450457:4 :9 5/0 301;40= ?:>4@03 9:; 5/0 1220331455/154:;01@:41630:22:;5>475CF1@87D045:5/0 122033145 5: 9730 :6E0?57:4 ?144:5 60 1??0250= 1@ 5/0 A"B ;02:;5 ?1<0 5: 60 9730= :4 ''('* 14= 7<<0=71503C 4:57?0F1@7@@>0=5:5/012203314514=5733(''4: :6E0?57:4 F1@ 9730= 14= 1??:;=7483C 5/0 97413 ;02:;5 F1@ 1??0250=6C5/0;713:>;5 =:4:5974=14C733081375C74 5/0@17=:;=0;4:;14C;01@:45:7450;90;0F75/5/0@1<0 04?0 14@F0; 5/0 16:D0 2:745 74 5/0 A408157D0B 14= 2;:?00=5:21@@5/09:33:F748 - 11 - /0;7<7413220137@ )& %""' $ 7@5:3:+