Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 49483 (KAR)
BANGARAPPA S/O KAMANNA BELLE v. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY AND ORS
WP/200037/2023 · 2025-01-15
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49483 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49483 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$%" "
& '
! "
#$%%%! "
&
"" ' #$($!%! ) &
""
#$($)%
*
""
#$($)%
" !+
"
*
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
,
" -
"
"
,
"
*
%#!) %- %
"
&
#
,
"
./
,
0
12324545672819::6;<14=689>85457412794;826= ?97@9?;: 46 @582A4 82:367@274 6* 46 5?3B2?274 412 68@28 C29857< 6 %!# D% @942@% !)%-%39::2@CE82:367@2746
12 3245456728 A67427@: 4194 12 >9: 93365742@ 9: 9 C5BB A6BB2A468CE 82:367@274 6* 67*%!%!* 2 8236842@ 46 @;4E 67 $%!%!* 97@ 15: :28F5A2 >9:
A67=58?2@ 2 AB95?2@ 4194 12 >9: >68G57< 2F28 :57A2 4127 9: 9 C5BB A6BB2A468 >541 82:367@274 6* ,127 82:367@2746*:2744129336574?2746=4123245456728=68 93386F9B 46 82:367@274 6) 82:367@274 6) =68>98@2@
- 3 -
54 46 82:367@274 6 57 428?: 6= 9 B24428 @942@ *%(%!- 12 82:367@274 6* 412829=428 9@@82::2@ 9 A6??;75A94567 @942@ %D!%%% 46 82:367@274 6) :49457< 4194 54 19: 76 6CH2A4567 =68 A67=58?94567 6= 412 :28F5A26=41232454567281282:367@2746)4127:2749 38636:9B :;C?5442@ CE 82:367@274 6* 46 82:367@274 6 57 428?: 6= 9 B24428 @942@ !!%%% 12 82:367@274 6* :22?: 46 19F2 5::;2@ 9 A67=58?94567 A2845=5A942 :49457< 4194 54 19: 76 6CH2A4567 46 A67=58? 412 :28F5A2: 6= 412 3245456728 AA68@57<BE 82:367@274 6 A67=58?2@ 412 :28F5A2: 6= 412 3245456728 CE 68@28 @942@ - (%D%! 12829=428 67 )%%D%! %!!%%! 82:367@274 6 5::;2@ 9 A6882A4567 68@28 :49457<4194 57 54:68@28@942@- (%D%!5419@?2745672@4194412 3245456728 >9: 386?642@ =86? 41236:4 6=63289468 46 C5BB A6BB2A46897@419454?;:4C2829@9:I@582A4BE:2B2A42@46 41236:46=C5BBA6BB2A468J45:9BB2<2@4194679A6?3B9574 B6@<2@ CE 9 328:67 79?2@ 15F9797@ 67 !%%! 82:367@274 6 :49E2@ 412 68@28 6= A67=58?94567 6= 412 :28F5A2 6= 412 3245456728 =428 A67@;A457< 97 27K;58E
- 4 -
82:367@274 6 >541@82> 412 :49E 6= A67=58?94567 97@ @582A42@41282:367@2746*4649G2:423:579AA68@97A2 >541412B24428@942@- (%D%!97@412A6885<27@;? @942@ )%%D%! %!!%%! 97@ 68@282@ 412 A67457;945676=412:28F5A26=4123245456728123245456728 A67427@: 4194 9AA68@57<BE 12 8236842@ 46 @;4E 67 !*%-%97@:5<72@41294427@97A282<5:4286>2F28 12 A67427@: 412 82:367@274 6* 97@ 54: @1E9G:19 982 764 9BB6>57< 412 3245456728 46 >68G >541 82:367@274 6* 97@ 412E 982 764 9BB6>57< 412 3245456728 46 :5<7 412 94427@97A282<5:4281232454567285:41282=682C2=682415:
6;84 :22G57< =68 9 @582A4567 46 82:367@274 6* 46 5?3B2?27441268@28 39::2@CE82:367@274 682=2882@ :;389 ) 12B29872@A6;7:2B=684123245456728825428942@ 4129C6F2A674274567:97@AB95?2@419482:367@2746*5: C6;7@465?3B2?27441268@2839::2@CE82:367@2746 97@ :57A2 54 5: 764 @672 97 93386385942 >854 19: 46 C2 5::;2@4682:367@2746*
- 5 -
* B29872@A6;7:2B=6882:367@2746* A67427@2@ 4194 82:367@274 6* 19: 76> 9@@82::2@ 9 A6??;75A94567 @942@ )%!%) 46 82:367@274 6 :49457<419441228:4>15B2@1E9G:196=41297A19E9419@ 49?3282@ 412 82:6B;4567: 6= 412 97A19E94 97@ 19@ 57:2842@ 412 79?2 6= 412 3245456728 46 :22?
9: 5= 412 3245456728 >9: @;BE 93365742@ 2 41282=682 :;C?54: 4194 :423: >6;B@ C2 49G27 :667 9=428 82:367@274 6 39::2:
93386385942 68@28: 67 412 A6??;75A94567 9@@82::2@ CE 82:367@2746* $ 19F2A67:5@282@412:;C?5::567:?9@2CE412 B29872@A6;7:2B=68412324545672897@412B29872@A6;7:2B =6882:367@2746:46*
57A241232454567285:93365742@67*%!%!* 97@ 15: :28F5A2: 982 93386F2@ CE 82:367@274 6 67 (D%!82:367@2746*5:C6;7@57B9>46=9BB57B572 97@A6?3BE>541412@582A45F25::;2@CE82:367@2746 12 AB95? 6= 82:367@274 6* 4194 412 82:6B;4567: 6= 412 97A19E94 >282 49?3282@ 46 57:284 412 79?2 6= 412
- 6 -
3245456728 97@ 4194 9 A6??;75A94567 57 4194 82<98@ 5:
9@@82::2@ 46 82:367@274 6 A97764 98? 82:367@274 6* 46 :463 412 3245456728 =86? >68G57< 94 82:367@274 6*=412324545672819:46C282?6F2@=86?:28F5A268 97E :423: 19F2 46 C2 49G27 9<957:4 412 3245456728 412 :9?2:16;B@C2@672579AA68@97A2>541B9>CEA67@;A457< 97 27K;58E 9: 382:A85C2@ 1282=682 764>541:497@57< 412 AB95?6=41282:367@2746*419441228:4>15B2@1E9G:19 6= 412 97A19E94 19@ 49?3282@ 412 82:6B;4567 C66G 82:367@2746*5:C6;7@46A6?3BE41268@2839::2@CE 82:367@27469::4942@9C6F297@9BB6>4123245456728 46>68G97@:5<741294427@97A282<5:42857A241945:764 @6729@582A4567@2:28F2:46C25::;2@4682:367@2746* 46A6?3BE41268@2839::2@CE82:367@274682:28F57< B5C284E4682:367@2746*4649G2>1942F289A456741945: 9F95B9CB29<957:44123245456728C;4579AA68@97A2>541B9> - 7 4194 F52> 6= 412 ?94428 415: 6;84 39::2: 412=6BB6>57<
- 7 -
5 12>854324545675:
55 @582A45675:5::;2@4682:367@2746*46 =6841>541 A6?3BE 412 68@28 @942@ % !)%-% 39::2@ CE 82:367@274 6 97@ 9BB6> 412 3245456728 46 >68G 97@ :5<7 412 94427@97A2 82<5:428 97@ 9B:6 3823982 412 :9B98E C5BB: 39E9CB2 46 412 3245456728 555 = 16>2F28 82:367@274 6* 19: A6?2 46 G76> 6= 97E ?5:@22@: 68 ?5:A67@;A4 68 ?5:49G2: A6??5442@ CE 412 298B528 @1E9G:196= 41297A19E94 12 :19BB 49G2 72A2::98E9A4567579AA68@97A2>541B9> 5F 4 5: 722@B2:: 46 ?274567 4194 :;A1 9A4567 :19BB C2 67BE 9=428 129857< 412 3245456728 97@A6?3BE57<412@;2386A2::6=B9>
()
&"'
"
5:46!B6)(