Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 49476 (KAR)
THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER AND ANR v. MARUTI @ MARTHAND AND ORS
MSA/200107/2024 · 2025-03-22
Anant Ramanath Hegde
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49476 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49476 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!
"
#
$$%& '
!
"
#$
%
& ' $
(
' & )*$
+ ' & )$
, ' &
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
)--$
.
' & )**$
/ $
' & )-0$
'! 1
2) )
2
- $
"
#$
#%#%3
! '! $
-%
*#%2
$
! 4
$$
' $
!5$
4'-
2 $
$
!
)
- 3 -
) 6
# #)6 %
/(7.
89::/,;<.(==/(>9:+?@8/+/</A9,9(7?;A@8/ >(<.(,BC9:9@9;<8/>(<.;A7/:=;<./<@;-D(:(,BC97/.
C<./7 /,@9;< *#% <;@9A9,(@9;< .(@/. 5 C<./7 @8/ (<. ,BC9:9@9;< ,@ 8/ =/,9(> (<. ,BC9:9@9;< AA9,/7 8(: ./@/7E9</. @8/ E(7F/@ G(>C/ ;A @8/ >(<. (@ *'1 - 8/>(<.>;:/7:;CH8@7/A/7/<,/8//A/7/<,/ ;C7@ (>>;D/. +? 7/A/7/<,/ 9< =(7@ (<. ./@/7E9</. @8/ E(7F/@G(>C/;A@8/>(<.(@4'1=/7(,7/ * 8/97:@==/>>(@/;C7@;<(==/(>A9>/.+?@8/ >(<.>;:/7(>>;D/.@8/(==/(>9<=(7@(<../@/7E9</.@8/ E(7F/@G(>C/;A@8/>(<.(@*--0'1=/7(,7/
.E9@@/.>?@8/>(<.(,BC97/.D(:(.7?>(<.
- 4 -
0 8/+/</A9,9(7?9:+/A;7/@89:;C7@(::(9>9<H@8/ E(7F/@G(>C/./@/7E9</.+?@8/97:@==/>>(@/;C7@ 4 /(7</.,;C<:/>A;7@8/(==/>>(<@D;C>.7/A/7@;
@8/ IC.HE/<@ ;A ;;7.9<(@/ /<,8 ;A @89: ;C7@ 9< ;'* D8/7/9< @8/ >(<. 9< @8/ :(E/ (D(>91 G9>>(H/ (>CF >(<. 9:@79,@ (>(+C7(H9 D(: (,BC97/.
C<./7 @8/ :(E/ <;@9A9,(@9;< .(@/. 5 8/ ;;7.9<(@/ /<,8 ;A @89: ;C7@ 9< @8/ (A;7/E/<@9;</. IC.HE/<@8(:./@/7E9</.@8/E(7F/@G(>C/;A@8/>(<.(@ *5'1 =/7 (,7/ (<. 7/.C,/. @8/ E(7F/@ G(>C/ ./@/7E9</.+?@8/97:@==/>>(@/;C7@A7;E*--0'1 @;*5'1=/7(,7/
/(7</.,;C<:/>(==/(79<HA;77/:=;<./<@;
D;C>. A(97>? :C+E9@ @8(@ @8/ 7/:=;<./<@J: >(<. 9: (>:; >;,(@/.9<@8/:(E/G9>>(H/(D(>919<>(<.(>CF.9:@79,@ (>(+C7(H9 (<. 9: (>:; (,BC97/. C<./7 @8/ :(E/ <;@9A9,(@9;< .(@/. 5 .E9@@/.>? @8/ >(<.
(,BC97/. 9: ( .7? >(<. 8C: 8/ D;C>. :C+E9@ @8(@ @8/
- 5 -
7/:=;<./<@ 9: /<@9@>/. @; E(7F/@ G(>C/ ;A @8/ >(<. 9: (@ *5'1(<.<;@*--0'1 5 89: ;C7@ 8(: =/7C:/. @8/ IC.HE/<@ 9< ;'*7/A/77/.@;(+;G/
8/ >(<.: 9<G;>G/. 9< +;@8 ,(:/: (7/ A7;E (D(>91 G9>>(H/ >(<. @(>CF( (>(+C7(H9 .9:@79,@ 8/ <;@9A9,(@9;< C<./7 /,@9;< *#% ;A @8/ ,@ 9: .(@/.
5 (<. @8/ >(<.: 9<G;>G/. 9< +;@8 ,(:/: (7/ .7? >(<.: @9::@(@/.@8(@@8/7/9:<;.9AA/7/<,/9<@8/<(@C7/ ;A @8/ >(<. <./7 @8/ ,97,CE:@(<,/: @8/ 9E=CH</. IC.HE/<@(<../,7//=(::/.+?@8/97:@==/>>(@/;C7@ 8(G/@;+/E;.9A9/./<,/@8/A;>>;D9<H)
9% ==/(>9:(>>;D/.9<=(7@ 99% 8/9E=CH</.IC.HE/<@(<.(D(7.=(::/.
+? @8/ 97:@ ==/>>(@/ ;C7@ 9< ;' .(@/. 4 (7/ E;.9A9/.
- 6 -
999% 8/ E(7F/@ G(>C/ ./@/7E9</. (@ *5'1 =/7 (,7/ D9@8 (>> :@(@C@;7? +/</A9@:(<.9<@/7/:@ 9G% ;;7./7(:@;,;:@: G% 8/ 7/E(9<9<H =(7@ ;A @8/ ./,7// ;A @8/ 97:@==/>>(@/;C7@9:<;@.9:@C7+/.
()
%
& #
9:@;)>;)-