- 1 - ! "# $#%!! # &&'()&!!(( * ! " #$ # %& ' Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - () * ) ) + , - ! ' " ) + ) )) ! ( ) *)+ ". ) +)", ) " " ! ) ) - " % + ' *', '" ) ) ) & !! ! ) ! " ) & + / ) " - 3 - 0 ' *) 0 ' , 12 3245627 89:6;23 <95 =12 52;>28=?@2 >45=?2; 14@2 <?327 4 A9?6= 4>>3?84=?96 :6725 28=?96 !& 5B 9< !;=4=?6C=14==12D14@289E>5?;27=12E4==25 467 " E4D F2 G:4;127 ?6 =25E; 9< 89E>5?;2 467 43;9 4<<?74@?= 9<914EE27 4;;46 3? H >2=?=?9625 9 467 4;E226 2C:E H 52;>96726= 9 452 <?327 4396C B?=1 =12;4?74>>3?84=?96 4@?6CC962=159:C1=124@25E26=;9<=12;4?7 4<<?74@?=; 9< =12 52;>28=?@2 >45=?2; =12 9<<2682; 4332C27 4C4?6;==12>2=?=?9625;452:672528=?96;&!! 5B 28=?96 ! 9< 67?46 )2643 972 467 28=?96; ! 467 9< 9B5D )591?F?=?96 8= & 6 @?2B 9< =12 A:7CE26= 9< =12 96IF32 :>52E2 9:5= ?6 =12 84;2 9< B1252?6 1 (2012) 10 SCC 303 - 4 - =12 960F32 :>52E2 9:5= 14; ?;;:27 C:?723?62; <95 89E>59E?;29<;:8184;2;=12E4==25E4DF27?;>9;279< ?6=25E;9<;2==32E26= ! 12 >45=?2; B19 452 >52;26= F2<952 =1?; 9:5= 452?726=?<?27FD=12?552;>28=?@247@984=2; 2682>598227=9>4;;=12<9339B?6C *?, 12>2=?=?96?;+,,-./ *??, 12 26=?52 >598227?6C; ?6 5?E2 9% 52C?;=2527 FD =12 434F:54C? ?=D 9E26 )93?82 =4=?96 >267?6C96=12<?329<=12773?@?3':7C2*',J'" 434F:54C??;G:4;127 *???, 12 >2=?=?9625; 452 48G:?==27 <95 =12 9<<2682; :6725 28=?96; & !! 5B ! 9< 67?46 )264397246728=?96;!4679<9B5D)591?F?=?968= & - 5 - *?@,4?3F967;2K28:=27?<46D;=467846823327 6 @?2B 9< 7?;>9;43 9< =12 E4?6 >2=?=?96 9792; 69= ;:5@?@2 <95 896;?7254=?96 467 =12 ;4E2?;43;97?;>9;279< !/) &! ( % ) ?;= 93 9 )