Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 49452 (KAR)

RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE CO. LTD v. SIDDAMMA W/O LATE GAJANAND NAGARE AND ORS

MFA/200658/2017 · 2025-03-22

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !! " !!# $ %"%" ""&&'( ) *+ ""&&'( !) "" %'( !) "" %'( !) * + ! ! "#$ " % ! "#& " ! Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '&(&) $ ! * '%! '+,,, '#)) * %- ! %, )( %)%$$ +$ * %+ ) %)+ )&!%)# * * + ! ! * "%. " - 3 - % ! * ")+ " $ ! "&$ " % / ! * '&(&) # ! * '%! '+,,, '#)) * $- % ! - ! %, )( %)%$# +$ * %+ ) %)+ $&!%)# * "" %* + ! "#$ " - 4 - % ! "#& " ! '&(&$)% * * ! ! * '%! '+,,, '#))# % '#))# % #%% * %+ ) %)+ * )&!%)# "" %* - 5 - + ! * "%. " % ! * ")+ ! $ ! "&) " % / ! * '&(&$)% * * ! ! * '%! '+,,, '#))# % '#))# - 6 - #%% * %+ ) %)+ * $&!%)# * * " " 0 * * %! "0 * * 1232 4552463 78 912 :3;<4:=2 >?54:8 4:@ <>33 >7A2=9B>:3 78 912 529B9B>:2<3 4<B32 >;9 >C 912 A;@D?2:9 4:@ 4E4<@ B: > )&!%)# 4:@ > $&!%)# @492@ %+')'%)+78912624<:2@ 2:B><BFB6*;@D24:@64:@ % 12 C4=9;46 ?49<BG >C 912 =432 9149 B3 <262F4:9 4<2 43 726>E" - 7 - : %')('%)# 49 47>;9 + &5 ? >:2 ;<84H4:9143 <B@2<4:@ 4A4:4:@435B66B>:<B@2<E2<25<>=22@B:D>:64:@ ?4<D4<>4@>:912B<>9><8=62724<B:D> '%& '&.$ 24<;F<4A1471442?2:94:H2<><<8724<B:D> '% '+,,, =4?2 C<>? >55>3B92 @B<2=9B>: B: <431 4:@ :2D6BD2:9 ?4::2< 4:@ =>66B@2@ 9> 912 ?>9>< =8=62 <23;69B:D B: @2491 >C ;<84H4:914991235>94:@ 4A4:4:@E1B6294HB:D9<249?2:9B: 912 1>35B946 12 529B9B>:2<3 B: > )&!%)# 4<2 912 54<2:93>C912@2=2432@ ;<84H4:914:@912529B9B>:2<3B: > $&!%)# 4<2 912 EBC2 @4;D192< 4:@ C4912< >C @2=2432@ 4A4:4:@ 128 =64B? =>?52:349B>: B: <2352=9 >C @2491 >C @2=2432@ ;<84H4:91 4:@ 4A4:4:@ =>:92:@B:D 9149 ;<84H4:91 E43 4 9462:92@ D<4@;492 14FB:D @2D<22 324<=1B:D C>< 4 A>7 4D2@ 47>;9 %% 824<3 12 E>;6@ 14F2 24<:2@43;?59;>;33464<84:@912<2C><291284<22:9B962@C>< =>?52:349B>: 12529B9B>:2<3B:> $&!%)#=>:92:@2@ 9149 @2=2432@ 4A4:4:@ E43 4D2@ %. 824<3 E><HB:D 43 4 ?43>: 24<:B:D 3 ()))!' 52< ?>:91 4:@ 43 3;=1 9128 4<2 2:9B962@C><4@2I;492=>?52:349B>: - 8 - $ : B33;4:=2 >C :>9B=2 <235>:@2:9 > %':3;<4:=2 >?54:8 B: 7>91 912 529B9B>:3 45524<2@ 4:@ <23B392@ 912 =64B?3 235>:@2:9> >E:2<>C4:H2<><<8@B@:>945524< 4:@912<2C><2:>9B=2E4332<F2@78E48>C3;739B9;92@32<FB=2 78E48>C5;76B=49B>:B:2E35452< # 235>:@2:9> %':3;<4:=2>?54:8=>:92:@2@9149912 4662D2@4==B@2:9E43:>9@;29>912:2D6BD2:9@<BFB:D786><<8 @<BF2< 7;9 B9 E43 @;2 9> 912 :2D6BD2:=2 >C 912 <B@2<' ;<84H4:91 9E434662D2@9149912<B@2<>C912?>9><=8=6243 E266 43 912 @<BF2< >C 912 6><<8 E2<2 :>9 14FB:D F46B@ @<BFB:D 6B=2:=234:@912<278912<2B3FB>649B>:>C92<?34:@=>:@B9B>:3 >C9125>6B=8 B992<?2@912529B9B>:39>3;CC2<78:>: A>B:@2< >C :2=2334<8 54<98 >E:2< 4:@ B:3;<2< >C 912 ?>9>< =8=62 4:@ 9149 912 =>?52:349B>: =64B?2@ B3 2G><7B94:9 4:@ B?4DB:4<8 & >91 912 529B9B>:3 E2<2 9<B2@ 3254<49268 55<>5<B492 B33;23E2<2C<4?2@4:@9122FB@2:=2>C912529B9B>:2<3E43629 B: 12 >CCB=B46 >C 912 :3;<4:=2 >?54:8 9239BCB2@ 72C><2 912 <B7;:46=>:92:@B:D91499124:H2<><<8724<B:D> % - 9 - +,,, E43 :>9 14FB:D 4 F46B@ 52<?B9 9> 568 B: 4<:494H4 4:@ 912<2C><2912<272B:DFB>649B>:>C912=>:@B9B>:3>C9125>6B=8 9126B47B6B981439>72C4392:2@;5>:912>E:2<>C9126><<8 . C92< 124<B:D 7>91 912 3B@23 912 <B7;:46 4E4<@2@ =>?52:349B>: >C 3 +%$)))!' B: > )&!%)# 4:@ 3 ,+,.))!'B:> $&!%)# + 2B:D 4DD<B2F2@ 78 912 34?2 912 :3;<4:=2 >?54:8 143455<>4=12@91B3>;<9B:> %)).&!%)+> )&!%)#4:@> %)).&(!%)+B:> $&!%)# 4:@ 912 =64B?4:93 14F2 455<>4=12@ 91B3 >;<9 B: > %)))++!%)+ > )&!%)# 4:@ > %)))+(!%)+> $&!%)# ( 12 <B7;:46 <2=><@3 B: 7>91 912 529B9B>:3 14F2 722: 32=;<2@ B:=2 912 4552463 4<B32 >;9 >C 912 34?2 4==B@2:9 91284<294H2:;59>D2912<C><=>:3B@2<49B>: , 124<D;?2:9378912=>;:326C><9124552664:934:@912 =>;:326C><912=<>33>7A2=9><3!529B9B>:2<3E2<2124<@ - 10 - ) >9B=29>912>E:2<>C9126><<8E43@B352:32@EB913B:=2 12E43564=2@2G54<9272C><2912<B7;:46 12 624<:2@ =>;:326 45524<B:D C>< 912 :3;<4:=2 >?54:8E>;6@3;7?B99149E12:912<2B345>3B9BF22FB@2:=2 7891499126><<8E43:>914FB:D4F46B@52<?B99>568B: 912 9492>C 4<:494H44:@3;=12FB@2:=214FB:D:>9<27;992@ 9126B47B6B989>548912=>?52:349B>:31>;6@14F2722:C4392:2@ ;5>: 912 >E:2< >C 912 ><<8 2 3;7?B93 9149 91>;D1 394923 B: 912 =<>33'2G4?B:49B>: 9149 12 14@ :>9 B33;2@ 4:8 :>9B=29>912>E:2<1B32FB@2:=2>C@2:B46>C6B47B6B98C><E4:9 >C 4 F46B@ 52<?B9 B3 :>9 <27;992@ >C4< 43 912 I;4:9;? >C =>?52:349B>: B3 =>:=2<:2@ 312 @2C2:@3 912 B?5;D:2@ A;@D?2:93 348B:D 9149 B9 B3 4@2I;49268 4332332@ 78 912 <B7;:46 % 12624<:2@=>;:32645524<B:DC><912529B9B>:2<33;7?B9 9149 912 :>9B>:46 B:=>?2=>:3B@2<2@78 912 <B7;:46 B3>: 912 6>E2<3B@24:@912<B7;:46143:>94@@2@C;9;<25<>352=93B: 92<?3>C91264E64B@@>E:B:912=432>C !"#$ - 11 - %& ' (") *$+ 2:=2 12 322H 2:14:=2?2:9 >C 912=>?52:349B>: >C4<4391252<?B9B3=>:=2<:2@12<26B23 >:912A;@D?2:9B:912=432>C,-./&012".34560/0 737-02381-0397/: $ 12 C4=9 9149 912 5>6B=2 4C92< B:F239BD49B>: C>;:@ :2D6BD2:=2>:912 54<9>C912@<BF2<>C912 6><<84:@CB62@912 =14<D231229 4D4B:39 1B? B3 :>9 @B35;92@ 12 =14<D231229 5<>@;=2@ 78 912 529B9B>:2<3 4:@ >912< 2FB@2:=2 4F4B64762 >: <2=><@E43=>:3B@2<2@78912<B7;:464962:D914:@B9E43126@ 9149912:2D6BD2:=2E433>626878912@<BF2<>C9126><<8 :4 =4<2C;6652<;346>C9125>6B=25452<3912<2B3:><243>:9>1>6@ 9149912<2E434:8=>:9<B7;9><8:2D6BD2:=2>:91254<9>C912 @2=2432@ ;<84H4:9 12FB2E94H2:78912<B7;:467432@>: 9125>6B=2542<3B3C;668A;39BCB4762 # 12 A;@D?2:9 B: 912 =432 >C ,-./ &012 ".345 6483@>E:B:=492D><B=4692<?39149E12:2F2<912<2B3FB>649B>: >C 912 52<?B9 912 :3;<4:=2 >?54:8 143 9> 548 912 =>?52:349B>:EB916B72<989><2=>F2<91234?2C<>?912>E:2< 1 %)+. .() 2 %)(+ &&( - 12 - >C912F21B=62 12<2C><2E12:912<2B32FB@2:=2>:<2=><@B: 912C><?>C9239B?>:8>C9149912<2E43:>F46B@52<?B9B9 E43 B:=;?72:9 ;5>: 912 >E:2< >C 912 ><<8 9> =>?2 C><E4<@ 4:@34891491B3F21B=625>332332@F46B@52<?B9 214FB:D:>9 2:92<2@ 4:8 @2C2:=2 B9 143 9> 72 126@ 9149 912 6><<8 E43 :>9 14FB:D4F46B@52<?B9 1B34352=9E43:>9=>:3B@2<2@78912 <B7;:46 :912<23;699124552664:9':3;<4:=2>?54:8B39> 72@B<2=92@9>548912=>?52:349B>:EB916B72<989><2=>F2<912 34?2C<>?912>E:2<>C9124:H2<><<8 & :7>9191232529B9B>:3912<B7;:46143126@9149912<2B3 :> =>:=6;3BF2 2FB@2:=2 9> 31>E 912 B:=>?2 >C 912 @2=2432@ 52<3>:3 4:@ 43 3;=1 :>9B>:46 B:=>?2 143 9> 72 =>:3B@2<2@ 7FB>;368 912<2 B3 :> =>D2:9 2FB@2:=2 E1B=1 5<>F23 912 B:=>?2 >C 912 @2=2432@ 12 D;B@26B:23 B33;2@ 78 C>< 329962?2:9 >C @B35;923 72C><2 912 >H @4649 5<23=<B72 4 :>9B>:46B:=>?2>C3 +&))!'52<?>:91C><912824<%)# : 912;?5922::;?72<>CA;@D?2:9391B3>;<9143126@9149912 D;B@26B:23B33;2@78912 4<2B:D2:2<46=>:C><?B98EB91 912 E4D23 CBG2@ 78 912 B:B?;? 4D23 =9 12<2C><2 78 4@@B:D #)J 9> 912 :>9B>:46 B:=>?2 >C 3 +&))!' 912 - 13 - 455<>5<B492 ?;69B56B=4:@ E>;6@ 72 3 +&))!' K 3 $)))!' L 3 )&))!' . >C4< 43 912 I;4:9;? B3 =>:=2<:2@ 912 C4=9 9149 912 @2=2432@ ;<84H4:91 E43 4D2@ %% 824<3 4:@ 43 3;=1 912 455<>5<B492?;69B56B2<M(NB3:>9B:@B35;92 2:=29126>33>C @252:@2:=8 B3 =46=;6492@ 43 3 )&))!' G % G ( G &)JL$#)))!' 78 @2@;=9B:D &)J 9>E4<@3 1B3 52<3>:46 2G52:323 43 12 E43 4 74=126>< : 4@@B9B>: 9> B9 4 3;? >C 3 &%)))!' 9>E4<@3 6>33 >C 6>F2 4:@ 4CC2=9B>: 3 ,&))!' 9>E4<@3 6>33 >C 239492 4:@ 3 ,&))!' 9>E4<@3 C;:2<46 2G52:3231439>724E4<@2@ :912<23;69912529B9B>:2<3B: > )&!%)# 4<2 2:9B962@ C>< 4 9>946 =>?52:349B>: >C 3 %%&)))!' 1;3 912<2 31466 72 4: 2:14:=2?2:9 >C 3 &)%)))!' + 12@2=2432@ 4A4:4:@E434D2@%.824<34:@433;=1 912455<>5<B492?;69B56B2<M+NB3:>9B:@B35;92 2:=29126>33 >C @252:@2:=8 B3 =46=;6492@ 43 3 )&))!' G % G + G %!$L#%()))!' 78 @2@;=9B:D !$<@ 9>E4<@3 1B3 52<3>:46 2G52:323 :4@@B9B>:9>B943;?>C3 &%)))!'9>E4<@36>33 - 14 - >C6>F24:@4CC2=9B>:3 ,&))!'9>E4<@36>33>C2394924:@ 3 ,&))!' 9>E4<@3 C;:2<46 2G52:323 143 9> 72 4E4<@2@ > 463> 4 3;? >C 3 $(.))!' 4E4<@2@ 78 9<B7;:46 9>E4<@3 ?2@B=462G52:323:22@:>9=466C><B:92<C2<2:=2 :912<23;69 912 529B9B>:2<3 B: > )&!%)# 4<2 2:9B962@ C>< 4 9>946 =>?52:349B>: >C 3 &&+.))!' 12<2 31466 72 4: 2:14:=2?2:9>C3 &+()))!' ( >< 912 4C><234B@ <243>:3 912 4552463 CB62@ 78 912 :3;<4:=2 >?54:8 4:@ <>33 7A2=9B>:3 CB62@ 78 912 529B9B>:2<3@232<F29>72466>E2@B:54<9 2:=2912C>66>EB:D" B124552463CB62@78912:3;<4:=2>?54:84:@912 <>33>7A2=9B>:3CB62@78912529B9B>:2<34<2466>E2@B:54<9 BB 12 B?5;D:2@ A;@D?2:9 4:@ 4E4<@ 54332@ 78 912 <B7;:46B3?>@BCB2@ BBB12529B9B>:2<3B:> )&!%)#4<22:9B962@C>< 4 3;? >C 3 &)%)))!' 4:@ 912 529B9B>:2<3 B: > $&!%)# 4<2 2:9B962@ C>< 4 3;? >C 3 &+()))!' B: - 15 - 4@@B9B>:9>E149143722:4E4<@2@78912<B7;:4646>:DEB91 B:92<23949912<492>C.J5 4 C<>?912@492>C529B9B>:9B66B93 @25>3B972C><2912<B7;:46 BF :3;<4:=2 =>?54:8 B3 @B<2=92@ 9> @25>3B9 912 =>?52:349B>: 4?>;:9 EB91B: C>;< E22H3 C<>? 912 @492>C 912 <2=2B59>C912=>58>C91B3A;@D?2:9 B72<98B3<232<F2@9>912 :3;<4:=2>?54:89><2=>F2<91234?2C<>?912>E:2<>C912 F21B=62 F 12 <239 >C 912 92<?3 4:@ =>:@B9B>:3 <2D4<@B:D 455><9B>:?2:9 @25>3B9 29= ><@2<2@ 78 912 <B7;:46 <2?4B:3 ;:4692<2@ FB124?>;:9B:@25>3B9BC4:831466729<4:3?B992@ 9>912=>:=2<:2@<B7;:46C><91EB91 @!' '%" ) %! B39> " 6> "&, "