Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 49446 (KAR)
SMT. NIRMALA v. ARUNKUMAR J. BAHL PATIL CHAWL AND ANR
MFA/200132/2021 · 2025-09-22
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49446 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49446 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!! ""#
""$#%! ! &! '##(#( # #%%
)(*
# #%%
! "
! ! "#$ %$
$
"&'&#%
(
$) %*%$$%$
Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
( ( +
(
( %%'$%$% (
,%$% +
(
(
! "&'&#% -
. "
#
"&'&#%
$ ! ! "#$ %$
"#%%%'%
(
) $$%*$%$&
$
- 3 -
( ( +
(
%%'$%$%
,%$% +
(
(
( -
(
(
/ ! '"
( 0$%% $$%$ 12 31456 78 9:5 ;4<1=<>9 255?1>@5>:<>;5=5>9<>6( 0$% #$%$ 123145678 >2AB<>;5 ;0=C<>8 ;:<445>@1>@ 192 41<714198 90 C<8 ;0=C5>2<910> <2 <D<B656 1> A6@=5>9 <>6 <D<B6 6<956 %%'$%$% C<2256 1> 0,%$% + 78 9:5 661910><4 5>10B1E14A6@5<>6 661910><4 16<B30B2:0B9F9:5 9B17A><4-
$ :53<;9245<61>@903141>@039:5;4<1=C591910><B5 <230440D2
- 4 -
:5;4<1=<>9<>6:5B:A27<>6166<CC<:<E570<B656 <> <A90GB1;?2:<D 75<B1>@ B5@129B<910> 0! G*#,++ <40>@ D19: 09:5B C5B20>2 0> #%'$% , :5> 9:5 2<16 <A90G B1;?2:<D ;<=5 >5<B 1B>< B022 < 0062 <> 75<B1>@ B5@129B<910>0G%#(G#,';<=53B0=0CC021952165<>6 9:56B1E5B039:52<16E5:1;45D<26B1E1>@9:52<16E5:1;451>< :1@:2C556B<2:<>6>5@41@5>9=<>>5B:54029;0>9B040E5B 19 <>6 6<2:56 <@<1>29 9:5 2<16 <A90GB1;?2:<D 6A590 D:1;: 9:5;4<1=<>9<>609:5B22A29<1>561>HAB152:5;4<1=<>931456 ;4<1= C591910> 255?1>@ ;0=C5>2<910> :5 9B17A><4 <2252256 9:5 ;0=C5>2<910> <>6 C<2256 9:5 <D<B6 :5 ;4<1=<>9 :<2 CB535BB56<CC5<4255?1>@5>:<>;5=5>9039:5<D<B6<=0A>9 :5 >2AB<>;5 ;0=C<>8 :<2 ;:<445>@56 192 41<714198 90 C<8 ;0=C5>2<910>0>9:5@B0A>69:<99:56B1E5B039:50335>61>@ E5:1;45 :<6 >0 E<416 6B1E1>@ 41;5>25 <2 0> 9:5 6<95 03 9:5 <;;165>9<>69:51>95B529<D<B656<9*I125J0B719<>9
5<B6 9:5 45<B>56 ;0A>254 30B 9:5 ;4<1=<>9 <>6 9:545<B>56;0A>25430B9:5>2AB<>;5;0=C<>8
- 5 -
#
5<B>56 ;0A>254 30B 9:5 ;4<1=<>9 D0A46 ;0>95>6 9:<9 9:5 ;4<1=<>9 D<2 <@56 85<B2 <>6 2:5 D<2 <> <@B1;A49AB<44<70AB5B<>69:5<;;165>9:<29<?5>C4<;51>9:5 85<B$% , 2C5B9:5;:<B9CB5C<B56789:5 5@<45BE1;52 A9:0B19830B259945=5>903612CA9521>9:5 0?
6<4<9:9:5 >0910><41>;0=531J5630B9:585<B$% ,122'+&%G<>69:5 9B17A><4 :<2 5BB56 1> 9<?1>@ 9:5 1>;0=5 <9 2,%%%G C5B =0>9: 5 3AB9:5B 2A7=192 9:<9 " 0;90B D:0 :<2 122A56 J$G612<74198 ;5B9131;<95 :<2 29<956 9:<9 9:5 ;4<1=<>912:<E1>@#I612<7141980341=7<>69:59B17A><4:<2 5BB56 1> 9<?1>@ 9:5 612<714198 30B D:045 7068 <9 %I 5 2A7=192 9:<9 9:5 ;4<1=<>9 :<2 2A29<1>56 3B<;9AB5 03 =16 2:<39 03 B1@:9 :A=5BA2 <>6 1>HAB8 90 <> 585 <>6 2:5 D<2 <6=199561>9:5:02C19<430B+6<820>2165B1>@9:52<=5 9:5 ;0=C5>2<910> <D<B656 30B C<1> <>6 2A335B1>@ 4022 03 <=5>19152 4022 03 1>;0=5 6AB1>@ 4<16 AC C5B106 <995>6<>9 ;:<B@52<B50>40D5B2165<>6B5KA1B525>:<>;5=5>9 & 5<B>56 ;0A>254 30B 9:5 ;4<1=<>9 2A7=192 9:<9 9:5 >2AB<>;5 ;0=C<>8 :<2 <4B5<68 2<9123156 192 41<714198 1> <>09:5B ;4<1= C591910> <B121>@ 0A9 03 9:5 2<=5 <;;165>9 1> - 6 - 0,$%$% + <>6 65C021956 9:5 5>91B5 <D<B6 <=0A>9 D19: 1>95B529 <>6 9:5B530B5 19 12 5290CC56 3B0= 9<?1>@ 9:5 ;0>95>910> 9:<9 19 12 >09 41<745 90 C<8 9:5 ;0=C5>2<910> <=0A>9 0> 9:5 @B0A>6 9:<9 9:5 6B1E5B 03 9:5 0335>61>@ E5:1;4512>09:0461>@E<416<>65335;91E56B1E1>@41;5>;5<20> 9:56<95039:5<;;165>9 , 5<B>56 ;0A>254 30B 9:5 >2AB<>;5 ;0=C<>8 D0A46 ;0>95>6 9:<9 9:5 9B17A><4 :<2 <2252256 612<714198 <9 %I CB0C5B48 :5 ;0=C5>2<910> <D<B656 A>65B 9:5 09:5B :5<62 <B5 HA29 <>6 CB0C5B :5 6B1E5B 03 9:5 0335>61>@ E5:1;45 D<2 :0461>@ 41;5>25 <>6 :5 D<2 6B1E1>@ :5<E8 @0062 E5:1;45 <>6 9:5B5 12 < E104<910> 03 C041;8 ;0>61910><>69:5B530B59:5>2AB<>;5;0=C<>812>0941<745 30BC<8=5>903;0=C5>2<910><D<B656 + <E1>@:5<B69:545<B>56;0A>25429:120AB9:<2 C5BA256 9:5 1=CA@>56 A6@=5>9 <>6 09:5B 60;A=5>92 C4<;560>B5;0B6 ' J 12 9:5 5J9B<;9 03 6B1E1>@ 41;5>;5 03 9:5 6B1E5B 03 9:5 0335>61>@ E5:1;45 15 G%#(G#,' 2 C5B - 7 - 9:5 2<16 60;A=5>9 9:5 6B1E5B 03 9:5 0335>61>@ E5:1;45 D<2 <A9:0B1L56906B1E5 E5:1;45 2C5BJ$G;0C803 9:5 >2AB<>;5 041;8 9:5 4<65> D51@:9 03 9:5 0335>61>@ E5:1;45G%#(G#,'12 $*%%?@20>2165B1>@9:52<=5 9:5 6B1E5B 03 9:5 0335>61>@ E5:1;45 D<2 >09 :0461>@ E<416 6B1E1>@ 41;5>;5 <2 0> 9:5 6<95 03 9:5 <;;165>9 90 6B1E5 9:5 0335>61>@ E5:1;45 <>6 9:5B5 12 E104<910> 03 9:5 C041;8 ;0>61910>:5B530B59:5>2AB<>;5;0=C<>8:<290C<89:5 ;0=C5>2<910> <=0A>9 D19: 1>95B529 <>6 B5;0E5B 9:5 2<=5 3B0=9:50D>5B * :5;4<1=<>9 :<22A29<1>563B<;9AB503 =16 2:<39 03 B1@:9 :A=5BA2 <>6 1>HAB8 90 <> 585 :5 ;4<1=<>9 :<2 A>65B@0>52AB@5B8<>6900?9B5<9=5>9909:55851>HAB8<>6 2:5 12 <6=19956 1> 9:5 :02C19<4 30B + 6<82 1> 865B<7<6 12 9:5 0;90B D:0 :<2 122A56 J$ 612<714198 ;5B9131;<95 D:5B5A>65B 9:5 612<714198 2A335B56 78 9:5 ;4<1=<>91229<956<2#I03ACC5B41=7:50;90B:<2>09 29<956D:<9129:5612<71419830B9:5D:04570680>2165B1>@ 9:5 2<=5 9:5 9B17A><4 :<2 B1@:948 9<?5> 612<714198 03 9:5 D:0457068<9 %I - 8 - % :5<;;165>9:<29<?5>C4<;51>9:585<B$% , 2 C5B9:5;:<B9CB5C<B56789:5 5@<45BE1;52 A9:0B1989:5 >0910><4 1>;0=5 31J56 30B 9:5 85<B $% , 12 2'+&%G 0>2165B1>@ 9:5 2<=5 9:5 9B17A><4 :<2 5BB56 1> 9<?1>@ 9:5 1>;0=5 <9 2,%%%G :5 9B17A><4 :<2 B1@:948 <CC4156 =A491C415BF ,->E15D039:5<70E59:5;4<1=<>9125>9194590
4022033A9AB51>;0=5<2A>65B +,- - -./+ 0>2165B1>@ 9:5 3B<;9AB5 <>6 1>HAB8 90 9:5 585 9:5;4<1=<>9125>9194590D<B62C<1><>62A335B1>@1><2A=03 2&%%%%G<2<@<1>292$&%%%G<>62&%%%%G90D<B62 4022 03 <=5>19152 <2 <@<1>29 2 &%%%G :5 ;4<1=<>9 12 5>91945 90 4022 03 1>;0=5 6AB1>@ 4<16 AC C5B106 30B 9:B55 =0>9:2 15 2'+&%G M =0>9:2 N 2$,$&%G <2 <@<1>29 2 $%%%G <2 <D<B656 78 9:5 9B17A><4 2 9:5 ;4<1=<>912<6=199561>9:5:02C19<430B+6<829:5;4<1=<>9 12 5>91945 90 <995>6<>9<>6 ;0>E58<>;5 ;:<B@52 1><2A= 03 2+%%%G <2 <@<1>29 2 $%%%G <2 <D<B656 78 9:5 9B17A><4:59B17A><4:<2B1@:948<D<B656=561;<45JC5>252 - 9 - 032'$&#G>E15D039:5<70E59:5;4<1=<>9125>91945 90909<4;0=C5>2<910><2A>65B #0 123+45617+2897 5617+2897 2:2;313 <= 8>9+?;8 022033A9AB51>;0=5 2 ,'%%%G $ <1><>62A335B1>@2 2&%%%%G 02203<=5>19152 2&%%%%G # 022 03 1>;0=5 6AB1>@ 4<16 AC C5B1062'+&%M=0>9:2 2$,$&%G & 995>6<>9 <>6 ;0>E58<>;5 ;:<B@52 2+%%%G , 561;<45JC5>252 2'$&#G 820 + @ $ :5 ;4<1=<>9 12 5>91945 90 909<4 ;0=C5>2<910> 03 2,*&%#G <2 <@<1>29 2$ +#&#G <2 <D<B656 78 9:5 9B17A><4 D19: 1>95B529 :5 9B17A><4 :<2 <D<B656 1>95B529 <9 9:5B<9503*IC5B<>>A=:5B<95031>95B529<D<B65678 9:5 9B17A><4 12 0> :1@:5B 2165 :5 ;4<1=<>9 12 5>91945 90 1>95B529 <9 9:5 B<95 03 ,I C5B <>>A= 3B0= 9:5 6<95 03 C591910>9144192B5<41L<910> >E15D039:5<70E59:530440D1>@ " 1 09:<CC5<42<B5<440D561>GC<B9) - 10 - 11 :5 A6@=5>9 <>6 <D<B6 6<956 %%'$%$% C<2256 1> 0,%$% + 78 9:5 661910><45>10B1E14A6@5<>6 661910><4 16<B12=0613156<2A>65B < :5;4<1=<>9125>9194590909<4 ;0=C5>2<910>032,*&%#G<2<@<1>29 2$ +#&#G<2<D<B656789:59B17A><4 D19:1>95B529<99:5B<9503,IC5B<>>A= 3B0= 9:5 6<95 03 C591910> 9144 192 B5<41L<910>) 7 :5 >2AB<>;5 ;0=C<>8 2:<44 C<8 9:5 2<16 <D<B6 <=0A>9 D19: 1>95B529 <>6 B5;0E5B 9:5 2<=5 3B0= 9:5 0D>5B 03 9:50335>61>@E5:1;45) ; :5 >2AB<>;5 ;0=C<>8 2:<44 65C0219 9:5 2<16 <D<B6 <=0A>9 D19: 1>95B529 D19:1> < C5B106 03 51@:9 D55?2 3B0= 9:12 6<8 3<141>@ D:1;: 19 12 41<745 90 C<81>95B529<99:5B<9503*IC5B<>>A= 6 :5 <=0A>9 65C021956 78 9:5 >2AB<>;5 ;0=C<>8 2:<44 75 9B<>2=19956 909:59B17A><430B9:D19: - 11 - 5 529 03 9:5 0B65B C<2256 78 9:59B17A><4B5=<1>2A><495B56 #3 )#(#(* '" 1290 40 '