- 1 - !" # $% # $% "%&" ## '&( ) !"#$ % & ' ' ( ) )) !"#! Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * ' ** ' !"+$ % & ' * ( * * #,&( * ' * $,$$ * ' -' ' ' #+$, * ' . . ' - 3 - % & . ( /01 233425 67849 4:;0<7 #,&( <= ;/4 <;<9 '4/0:541:;""&/494072=;4994=49948;<21>;/4:;?=<9 1/<9;(/21@447=0548@A;/4:520B27;1@407C2CC904D48@A ;/4E68CB47;2782F29882;48$,$$321148@A;/4 907:0325 470<9 0D05 68C4 278 ' '0E2A23692 07 '<#+$, *2:;1 C0D07C 9014 ;< ;/4 =0507C <= ;/4 233425 @904=5A1;2;48294;/2;<7$$2;2@<6;$,$2B ;/4 84:42148 F21 39<:44807C <7 2 B<;<9:A:54 @42907C 94C01;92;0<7< ,7429/2EE08<70D0552C4<7 <G2369 - 2C25G<; <28 ; ;/2; ;0B4 2 03349 D4/0:54 @42907C 94C01;92;0<7 < $! !" :2B4 =9<B ;/4 <33<10;4 8094:;0<7 2; 2 /0C/ 13448 278 07 2 921/ 278 74C50C47; B27749 /4 890D49 <= ;/4 1208 03349 D4/0:54 F21672@54;<:<7;9<5;/4D4/0:54278821/482C2071;;/4 B<;<9:A:54 1 2 94165; <= ;/4 2=<941208 2::0847; ;/4 84:42148161;20748C904D<6107E690412788048<7;/413<; - 4 - , /4:520B27;1=0548234;0;0<7678494:;0<7++ <= ;/4 :; 144G07C :<B34712;0<7 =<9 ;/4 842;/ <= ;/4 84:4214825<7CF0;/07;4941;/484:42148F2147C2C48 072C90:65;6925F<9G/2D07C;/9440990C2;4852781F/494/4 :65;0D2;48 16C29:274 278 F21 429707C 27 07:<B4 <= 1$$$$$ 349 B<7;/ /4 :520B27;1 /2D4 5<1; ;/409 429707CB4B@49 7149D0:4<=16BB<719413<7847;<1278 23342948 ;/9<6C/ ;/409 94134:;0D4 :<671451 278 =0548 ;/409 F90;;47 1;2;4B47;1 847A07C ;/4 2D49B47;1 B284 07 ;/4:520B34;0;0<7 ! 7;/4@2101<=;/43542807C1<=;/4329;041;/4 520B190@6725=92B48;/4011641278;/4942=;4994:<9848 ;/44D0847:4/4:520B27;107<9849;<39<D4;/4:214 4H2B074834;0;0<749<B<;/49<=;/484:4214821 27827<;/49F0;741121 278C<;4H/0@0;488<:6B47;1 72B45A H ;< H 7 ;/4 <;/49 /278 9413<7847; - 5 - < 716927:4<B327AC<;4H2B07480;1 ==0:4921 278C<;4H/0@0;488<:6B47;172B45AH + /4 520B1 90@6725 @A ;/4 0B36C748 E68CB47;/458;/2;;/42::0847;;<<G352:4<7 2::<67; <= 921/ 278 74C50C47; 890D07C <= ;/4 <==47807C D4/0:54 @A 0;1 890D49 21 2 94165; <= F/0:/ ;/4 84:42148 161;20748 07E69041 278 16::6B@48 ;< ;/4 07E69041 /4 90@6725 =69;/49 /458 ;/2; ;/4 :520B27;1 294 47;0;548 ;< 2 :<B34712;0<7<= 1!#!$$ 25<7CF0;/07;4941;2;;/4 92;4<=+I322788094:;48;/49413<7847;<1278 E<07;5A 278 14D49255A 502@54 ;< 843<10; ;/4 :<B34712;0<7 2B<67; 25<7C F0;/ 07;4941; 407C 2CC904D48 ;/01 233425 /21@447=0548 # /4 5429748 :<67145 =<9 ;/4 :520B27;1 /21 920148;/4=<55<F07C:<7;47;0<71 " 90 27C272C<682 '092829 5429748 :<67145 23342907C =<9 ;/4 :520B27; /21 :<7;47848 ;/2; ;/4 2::0847; <::69948 864 ;< ;/4 74C50C47:; 890D49 <= ;/4 - 6 - 03349 @42907C 4C< $! !" E61; @4:2614 :/29C41/44;01=05482C2071;;/4@<;/890D49<=;/4D4/0:54 278 ;/4 84:42148 /4 90@6725 /21 /458 ;/2; 84:42148 /21251<:<7;90@6;48$I;<;/42::0847;/01=07807C01 :<7;929A ;< ;/4 B2;49025 2D2052@54 <7 94:<98 4 =69;/49 :<7;47848;/2;21349;/41G4;:/0;01D49A:5429;/2;;/4 90849 <= ;/4 03349 /21 :9<1148 ;/4 B08854 278 :<B4 4H;94B4 90C/; 1084 <= 9<28 278 :26148 2::0847; /4 90@6725 /21 49948 07 /<5807C ;/2; 84:42148 /21 :<7;90@6;48$I<=;/42::0847; 7 94134:; <= J627;6B /4 /21 :<7;47848 ;/2; 2; ;/4 ;0B4 <= 2::0847; 84:42148 F21 429707C 1$$$$$ 349 B<7;/ /4 90@6725 /21 21141148 7<;0<725 07:<B4 <= ;/4 84:42148 1!!$ 349 B<7;/ F/0:/01<7;/45<F491084 $ 4:<785A /4 /21 :<7;47848 ;/2; 4D47 ;/<6C/ ;/4 84:42148 F21 2 @2:/45<9 ;/4 :520B27;1 294 B<;/49 27867B299048101;49;/4A29425547;0945A84347807C63<7 - 7 - ;/407:<B4<=;/484:4214890@6725071;428<=8486:;07C ,98<=;/407:<B4<=;/484:42148=<93491<7254H347141 /21 8486:;48 !$I <= ;/4 07:<B4 <= ;/4 84:42148 4 =69;/49:<7;47848;/2;07D04F<=E68CB47;<=34H<69; 07 ;/4 :214 <= ;/4:520B27;1294 $I<=;/407:<B4<=;/484:42148=<9=6;69439<134:;1 21;5A /4 /21 :<7;47848 ;/2; 07 D04F <= ;/4 E68CB47; <= <7?@54 34H <69; 07 ;/4 :214 <= !"#42:/<=;/4:520B27;129447;0;548=<9:<B34712;0<7 <= 1$$$ 42:/ 67849 ;/4 /428 <= >5<11 <= 5<D4 278 2==4:;0<7 278 :<71<9;06B? 47:4 /4 1<6C/; =<9 47/27:4B47;<=:<B34712;0<7 /45429748:<6714523342907C=<9;/40716927:4 :<B327A/21:<7;47848;/2;;/42::0847;<::699482;;/4 B08854 <= ;/4 9<28 ;/4 84:42148 90849 <= ;/4 B<;<9:A:54 /28 :<716B48 25:</<5 /4 :2B4 07 2 921/ 278 74C50C47; - 8 - B27749 278 821/48 2C2071; ;/4 03349 5<99A 64 ;< 0B32:; /4 =455 8<F7 278 16::6B@48 ;< ;/4 07E69A /494=<94 90@6725 /21 90C/;5A /458 ;/2; 84:42148 :<7;90@6;48 $I <= ;/4 2::0847; 4 =69;/49 :<7;47848 ;/2;3<50:4/2D4=0548:/29C41/44;2C2071;;/484:4214821 F455 21 890D49 <= ;/4 03349 2C2071; ;/4 84:42148 ;/4 :/29C4 01 =0548 =<9 27 <==47:4 36701/2@54 67849 4:;0<7 #,$&(<= 2784:;0<7"!<=;/4:;/494=<94 0; 01 D49A :5429 ;/2; 84:42148 F21 74C50C47; 07 ;/4 2::0847; , 7 94134:; <= J627;6B 01 :<7:49748 /4 /21 :<7;47848 ;/2; 4D47 ;/<6C/ ;/4 :520B27;1 /2D4 :520B48 ;/2; 84:42148 F21429707C 1$$$$$ 349 B<7;/@6; ;/4A /2D4 7<; 39<86:48 27A 8<:6B47; ;< 41;2@501/ ;/4 12B4 /494=<94 90@6725 /21 90C/;5A 21141148 7<;0<725 07:<B4 <= ;/4 84:42148 21 1#!$ 349 B<7;/ 4 =69;/49 :<7;47848 ;/2; 107:4 :520B27;1 /2D4 =20548 ;< 41;2@501/;/407:<B4<=;/484:4214890@6725/2190C/;5A 7<;2F29848=6;69439<134:;1 - 9 - 21;5A /4 /21 :<7;47848 ;/2; :<71084907C ;/4 2C4 278 2D<:2;0<7 <= ;/4 84:42148 ;/4 <D49255 :<B34712;0<7 2F29848 @A ;/4 90@6725 01 E61; 278 9421<72@5447:41<6C/;=<9801B01125<=;/4233425 ! 4298 ;/4 5429748 :<67145 =<9 ;/4 329;041 278 3496148;/4E68CB47;2782F298<=;/490@6725 + /4:214<=;/4:520B27;101;/2;<7$$ 2; 2@<6; $,$ 2B ;/4 84:42148 F21 90807C ;/4 B<;<9:A:54 @42907C 4C< , F/47 ;/4A 942:/48 7429 /2EE08<70 D0552C4 <7 <G2369 - 2C25G<; <28 /4 890D49 <= 03349 D4/0:54 @42907C 94C01;92;0<7 < $! !":2B4=9<B;/4<33<10;48094:;0<7F0;/ /0C/ 13448 278 07 2 921/ 278 74C50C47; B27749 821/48 2C2071; ;/4 B<;<9:A:54 64 ;< 0B32:; ;/4 90849 <= ;/4 B<;<9:A:548048 # < 39<D4 ;/4 :214 ;/4 :520B27; < /21 4H2B0748 21 1/4 940;492;48 ;/4 1;2;4B47; 07 ;/4 :520B 34;0;0<7 /4A 251< 4H2B0748 <74 6782332 21 - 10 - 274A4F0;7411F/</21:2;4C<90:255A1;2;48;/2;;/4 2::0847; <::69948 864 ;< 921/ 278 74C50C47; 890D07C <= 890D49<=;/403349 BB4802;45A2=;49;/42::0847;;/4 :<B35207; /21 @447 5<8C48 2C2071; ;/4 890D49 <= ;/4 03349/4* F2194C01;49482C2071;84:4214821F455 21 ;/4 890D49 <= 03349 /4 3<50:4 /21 892F7 ;/49<6C/ 1G4;:/ 25<7C F0;/ ;/4 13<; 327:/272B2 *69;/49 =9<B ;/4 9<6C/ 1G4;:/ 0; 01 D49A :5429 ;/2; ;/4 890D49 <= ;/4 03349 :2B4 =9<B ;/4 4H;94B4 90C/; 1084 278 821/48 2C2071; ;/4 B<;<9:A:54 /4 90849 <= ;/4 B<;<9:A:54 F21 251< 90807C ;/4 12B4 07 2 921/ 278 74C50C47; B27749 D47;/<6C/:/29C41/44;;/4<==47:4678494:;0<7"! <=;/4:;/21@447B47;0<748 7;/43<1;B<9;4B943<9; 0; 1/<F1 <75A 14B0 80C41;48 =<<8 07 ;/4 1;<B2:/ <71084907C 255 ;/414 2134:;1 F4 294 <= ;/4 <3070<7 ;/2; @<;/ 890D49 <= ;/4 03349 21 F455 21 ;/4 90849 <= ;/4 B<;<9:A:54 F21 74C50C47; 07 :26107C ;/4 2::0847; /4 890D49 <= ;/4 03349 /21 :<7;90@6;48 ;< "$I <= ;/4 - 11 - 2::0847; /4 84:42148 /21 :<7;90@6;48 ;< $I ;< ;/4 2::0847;<;/2;4==4:;01164<01B<80=048 " 7 94134:; <= J627;6B 01 :<7:49748 4D47 ;/<6C/;/4:520B27;1/2D4:520B48;/2;;/484:42148F21 429707C 1$$$$$ 349 B<7;/ 4H:43; 39<86:07C ;/4 16C29:274@05517<8<:6B47;1/21@44739<86:4;<1/<F ;/2; :520B27; F21 429707C 1$$$$$ 349 B<7;/ 7849 ;/61 :09:6B1;27:41 ;/4 90@6725 /21 90C/;5A 21141148 ;/4 7<;0<725 07:<B4 <= ;/4 84:42148 21 1#!$ 349 B<7;/ 7 D04F <= E68CB47; <= 34H <69;07:214<= $I07:<B4<=;/4 84:42148/21 ;<@4 28848 =<9 =6;694 39<134:;1 /61 ;/4 07:<B4 <= ;/4 84:42148 :<B41 ;< 1$+!$ D47 ;/<6C/;/494294;F<:520B27;104B<;/4927867B299048 101;49<=;/484:42148;/484:42148F212@2:/45<92;;/4 ;0B4<=;/42::0847;278;/494=<94!$I<=;/407:<B4<= ;/484:42148/21;<@48486:;48/490@6725/2190C/;5A 8486:;48 !$I <= ;/4 07:<B4 <= ;/4 84:42148 ;<F2981 3491<725 4H347141 /61 ;/4 07:<B4 <= ;/4 84:42148 - 12 - :<B41;< 1$,! /4B65;03504923350:2@54;<;/42C4 C9<63 01 >#? /61 ;/4 :520B27;1 294 47;0;548 ;< :<B34712;0<7 <= * +, & 1$,!KK#( <7 2::<67;<=>5<11<=84347847:A? 7 2880;0<7 ;/4 :520B27;1 294 47;0;548 ;< :<B34712;0<7<= 1+!$$ <72::<67;<=>5<11<=41;2;4? 278 :<B34712;0<7 <= 1+!$$ <7 2::<67; <= >=674925 4H347141? $ 7 D04F <= ;/4 52F 5208 8<F7 @A ;/4 6394B4 <69;07;/4:214<= &16392( :520B27;<B<;/49<=;/484:421480147;0;548 =<9 1$$$ 67849 ;/4 /428 <= .5<11 <= =05025 :<71<9;06B. :520B27; < 101;49 <= ;/4 84:42148 01 47;0;548 =<9 :<B34712;0<7 <= 1$$$ 42:/ 67849 ;/4 /428<=>5<11<=5<D42782==4:;0<7? /61;/4:520B27;129447;0;548;<;/4=<55<F07C :<B34712;0<7 - 13 - -./0*1230405/6 53/6/02/15* -40230'*( <11<=84347847:A 1$+,$$ *6749254H347141 1+!$$ <11<=41;2;4 1+!$$ <11<=5<D42782==4:;0<7 1$$$ <11<=*05025:<71<9;06B 1$$$ 217 * !+, 7;/494165;;/4=<55<F07C<984901321148 2( /4233425011778/530.162 @( /4 E68CB47; <= ;/4 520B1 90@6725 01B<80=048 :( /4 :520B27;1 294 47;0;548 ;< 2 ;<;25 :<B34712;0<7 <= * !+, 21 2C2071; 1!#!$$ 2F29848@A;/490@6725 8( /4 716927:4<B327A018094:;48;< 843<10;"$I<=;/4:<B34712;0<72B<67;25<7C F0;/ 07;4941; 2; +I 32 @4=<94 ;/4 90@6725 F0;/07 2 3490<8 <= 10H F44G1 =9<B ;/4 82;4 <= 94:403;<=:<3A<=;/01E68CB47; - 14 - 4( /4 233<9;0<7B47; 843<10; 278 9454214<=2B<67;1/255@4B28407;49B1<=;/4 2F298<=;/490@6725 5, '# ( % 5, '"%&"( % 01;<5<,#