Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 49439 (KAR)

SHAIK MOHAMMED v. REVANSIDH AND ANR

MFA/200506/2022 · 2025-02-07

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"" ## $% & ' ! ! " # ! $ % &$'#( ( ! ) &$#*( !%(+ ! #*((*(' # " LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.02.11 11:13:34 - 0800 - 2 - % % #, #" % ! -#,.**& ) " % % ! #*(*(#!$*/(*#$ % % ! 0 " 0 " 123456171238149:;8-17<:35612==177285284561 31-=:84185:(>?8-;328919:@=28A *( 1?8B 2BB3?1C14 DA 561 E;4B@185 284 2F234 =2--14 ?8 !$*/(*#$ 42514 #*(*(# DA 561 7123814 44?5?:827 18?:3 ?C?7 ;4B1 284 272D;32B? 561 =15?5?:813 ?- D1<:31 56?- :;35 ?8 2==127 -11G?8B1862891@185:<5619:@=18-25?:8 - 3 - * 61 <295;27 @253?H :< 561 92-1 231 5625 :8 #(*(*#$561=15?5?:813F2-3?4?8B2@:5:39A971D123?8B 1B:&/&&/23;?-13D123?8B1B:&&& .'(92@1<3:@:==:-?514?3195?:82849:77?414F?56561 =15?5?:81331-;75?8B?8?8E;3?1-5:6?@8561-2?4299?4185 61 -;<<1314 @;75?=71 ?8E;3?1- @@14?2517A 61 F2- -6?<514 5:6:-=?5276?5B;==228456185:6?B613<29?7?5A25 ?423 1 F2- ?8 =25?185 <3:@ #(*(*#$ 5: #,*(*#$ 1 9:8518414 5625 61 F2- 2B14 :< $ A123- 284 F2- 28 171953?9?28 284 5185 F:3G13 284 1238?8B -(****& =13 @:856 1 624 2==3:29614 561 3?D;827 -11G?8B 9:@=18-25?:8 *' 8 D1?8B -13C14 F?56 561 8:5?91 561 31-=:84185-2==12314D;531-=:84185:(27:81<?714561 F3?5518 -5251@185 61 31-=:84185 :( & ?8-;32891 9:@=28A 9:851-514 561 =15?5?:8 9:85184?8B 5625 561 9:@=18-25?:8972?@14?-6?B67A1H:3D?5285?@2B?823A284 ;85182D715418?145612B1?89:@12842C:925?:8:<561 =15?5?:813 5 F2- 9:8518414 5625 56131 F131 C?:725?:8 :< 561 513@- 284 9:84?5?:8- :< 561 =:7?9A :< 561 :<<184?8B C16?971 6131<:31 ?5 31=;4?2514 ?5- 7?2D?7?5A 5: =2A 28A 9:@=18-25?:8 - 4 - * 613?D;827<32@142==3:=3?251?--;1-284561 =15?5?:813 F2- 1H2@?814 2- # 284 5F: 4:95:3- F6: 2--1--145614?-2D?7?5AF1311H2@?814(284284 H# 5: H(* F131 @23G14 ?8 561 1C?41891 : 1C?41891F2-714:8D1627<:<56131-=:84185- *. <513 6123?8B D:56 -?41- 561 3?D;827 2F23414 561 9:@=18-25?:8 :< -',**& ;8413 561 <:77:F?8B 6124-& 7 : 124- :@=18-25?:8 F23414 # 2?8284-;<<13?8B -#***& ( 551842859623B1-<::4284 9:8C1A28919623B1- -***& :--:<<;5;31?89:@1 -$'**& ' 14?9271H=184?5;31 -,**& :--:<?89:@14;3?8B53125@185 -##$**& . :--:<2@18?5?1-2848;53?5?:8 <::4 -#****& :5279:@=18-25?:8 -',**& - 5 - *, 6?71 9:@?8B 5: 561 9:897;-?:8 561 3?D;827 6174 5625 56131 ?- #.I 4?-2D?7?5A 5: 561 =15?5?:813 284 ?8 561 2D-1891 :< 28A =3::< :< ?89:@1 8:5?:827 ?89:@1 :< -##,*&F2-24:=5142846:74?8B562561F2-2B14$ A123-@;75?=7?13:<#F2-24:=514DA?5 *$ 1?8B 2BB3?1C14 DA 561 -2?4 E;4B@185 561 =15?5?:813?-D1<:3156?-:;35?82==127 */ 6171238149:;8-172==123?8B<:3561=15?5?:813 F:;74 -;D@?5 5625 56131 F131 *, <3295;31- 7:-- :< *. 51156 61 3?D;827 62- 2F23414 2 -;@ :< -#***& :87A;84135616124:<=2?8284-;<<13?8B5?-9:8518414 5625-1C1327C?-?5-5:5616:-=?527<:3561=;3=:-1:<<?H?8B :<5614185;31-F13127-:8:59:8-?413142845619:-5:< 5614185;31284?@=7285-28431@:C27:<561?@=7285-2- -52514 DA ( 284 ?- 8:5 25 277 9:8-?41314 DA 561 3?D;8275?--;D@?55145625561<;895?:8274?-2D?7?5A:<561 =15?5?:813 62- 8:5 D118 =3:=137A 2==319?2514 DA 561 3?D;827 5 ?- =:?8514 :;5 5625 56:;B6 ( 624 -52514 5625 56131 ?- 2 4?-2D?7?5A :< '$I 61 3?D;827 F?56:;5 - 6 - 2==7A?8B ?5- @?84 2- 5: F625 1H5185 ?5 F?77 5328-7251 ?85: <;895?:827 4?-2D?7?5A 62- 24:=514 561 -5284234 :< 52G?8B #34 :< 561 =6A-?927 4?-2D?7?5A 2- 2 <;895?:827 4?-2D?7?5A 6131<:31 61 9:8518414 5625 561 9:@=18-25?:8 2F23414 DA5613?D;827?-:85617:F13-?41 #* 61 7123814 9:;8-17 2==123?8B <:3 561 31-=:84185:(&?8-;328919:@=28AF:;749:851845625 561 3?D;827 ?- E;-5?<?14 ?8 52G?8B 561 4?-2D?7?5A 25 #.I 618561=15?5?:8136248:5=7291428A@2513?275:-6:F 6?-2C:925?:8619:85184-56255619:@=18-25?:82F23414 DA 561 3?D;827 ;8413 561 31@2?8?8B 6124- ?- 27-: 241J;251 284 8: ?84;7B1891 31J;?314 DA 56?- :;35 5 ?- =:?8514 :;5 5625 :87A *( 51156 62C1 D118 7:-5 61 1862891@185972?@14?-8:5E;-5?<?2D71 ## =13;-27 :< 561 319:34- F:;74 4?-97:-1 2- =13 H. > F:;84 9135?<?9251 H, > 4?-9623B1 -;@@23A 284 H/ > 4?-2D?7?5A 9135?<?9251 561 =15?5?:813 624 -;-52?814561<:77:F?8B?8E;3?1-& - 7 - # %3295;31:<561D?725132728513?:3@14?27284=:-513?:3 F277-:<@2H?7723A-?8;-1-28461@:-?8;-1- ( %3295;31:<7251327F277:<71<5:3D?5 %3295;31:<D:81A82-27-1=5;@ ' :85617?=- %3295;31:<D:56561D:81-:<5613?B65<:3123@:=18 F:;84:85613?B6571B .%3295;31:<7:F137?@D:<#34:<5613?B65<?D;72 #( 61-1 4:9;@185- 27-: -6:F 5625 561 <3295;31- F1315312514F?562%284=725?8B159284F:;84 41D3?41@185F2-4:811F2-?8=25?185<:342A- # 61 ( F6: 62- ?--;14 561 4?-2D?7?5A 9135?<?9251 -5251- 5625 56131 F131 <3295;31 :< D:56 561 D:81-:<5613?B65<:3123@%3295;31:<5613?B657:F1334 :< 561 <?D;72 61-1 <3295;31- 9:853?D;51 @;96 5: 561 4?-2D?7?5A 99:34?8B 5: 6?@ 56131 ?- 2 4?-2D?7?5A :< '$I :;5:<F6?96*I?-2553?D;5145:561;==137?@D284'*I - 8 - 5: 561 7:F13 7?@D 1 62- :=?814 5625 561 <3295;31- 231 @27;8?514 61 F6: ?- 2 4185?-5 62- ?--;14 561 4?-2D?7?5A 9135?<?9251 2- =13 H/+ 62- 8:514 5625 56131 F2-<3295;31:<561@2H?7723A-?8;-<3295;31:<561:3D?527 <3295;31 :< 561 82-27 -1=5;@ 61 =15?5?:813 624 7:-5 *( 51156 6131 F131 <3295;31- :< * 51156 75?@2517A 61 :=?814 5625 56131 ?- 2 4?<<?9;75A <:3 561 =15?5?:813 <:3 @2-5?925?:8 1 :=?814 5625 31=729?8B 561 @?--?8B 51156 28453125@185:<561<3295;31451156F:;74?8C:7C129:-5 :<-#.***&1:=?81-562556131?-28114<:3:< 561 <3295;314 51156 <?H?8B :< 561 93:F8 159 ( 27-: -52514 5625 56131 ?- 2 8114 <:3 2D:;5 -$****& <:3 31@:C27:<561?@=7285- #' 618 F1 1H2@?81 561 2D:C1 ?8E;3?1- -;<<1314 DA 561 =15?5?:813 ?5 ?- 1C?4185 5625 61 D1?8B 2 @28;27 F:3G13+ D1?8B 2 5185 F:3G13 :3 28 171953?9?28 ?5 31J;?31- @:C1@185DC?:;-7A561=15?5?:81362--;<<1314<3295;31- :<D:56D:81-:<5614:@?82856284 C?41857A5625F:;74 92;-1 4?<<?9;75A 5: ;-1 6?- 3?B65 6284 284 61 ?- 2 171953?9?28 61 <3295;31 :< 561 <?D;72 ?- 27-: 28 ?8E;3A - 9 - F6?96 F:;74 92;-1 6?8432891 ?8 @:C1@185 6131<:31 F618 ( 62- :D-13C14 5625 <;895?:827 561 =6A-?927 4?-2D?7?5A25'*I284*I284:=?81-5625561F6:71D:4A 4?-2D?7?5A ?- '$I ?5 F2- 31J;?314 DA 561 3?D;827 5625 ?5 -6:;74 62C1 41275 F?56 561 2--1--@185 :< 561 <;895?:827 4?-2D?7?5A # 61 3?D;827 F?56:;5 4?-9;--?8B 28A56?8B 62- 61745625#34:<561F6:71D:4A4?-2D?7?5A?-5:D152G18 2-561<;895?:8274?-2D?7?5A61E;4B@185:<=1H:;35?8 561 92-1 :< 2- F177 2- !"72?44:F8 56252--1--?8B561<;895?:8274?-2D?7?5A?-5:D14:81DA561 3?D;827 61 @14?927 1H=135- 928 :87A -2A 2D:;5 561 =6A-?9274?-2D?7?5AD;5561A9288:5:=?81?831-=195:<561 <;895?:827 4?-2D?7?5A 8 5625 C?1F :< 561 @25513 9:8-?413?8B5612C:925?:8:<561=15?5?:813284561825;31 :<561?8E;3?1--;<<1314DA6?@56?-:;35?-:<561:=?8?:8 5625561<;895?:8274?-2D?7?5A62-5:D152G1825(I 1 2 - 10 - #. 5?-=135?81855:8:5156255613?D;82762-8:5 252772F2341428A9:@=18-25?:8?831-=195:<561<;5;31 @14?927 1H=18-1- 6131 F131 <3295;31- 5: 561 @2H?7723A -?8;-284616247:-55F:51156284:5613<:;351156624 -;<<1314 <3295;31- 6131 F2- 31J;?31@185 :< 93:F8?8B 159 56?- 2-=195 F2- 81C13 9:8-?41314 DA 561 3?D;827?82--1--?8B5619:@=18-25?:885619:8-?41314 :=?8?:8:<56?-9:;35<:331@:C27:<561?@=7285-?5F:;74 D1=3:=135:2F2342-;@:<-(***&2845:2F2342 -;@:<-,***&?831-=195:<5619:-5:<5614185;31- 284-;9631725141H=18-1-8277561=15?5?:813?-185?5714 <:3<;5;31@14?9271H=18-1-25-#*****& #, 61 =15?5?:813 D1?8B 2B14 / A123- ?- 8:5 ?8 4?-=;51 6131<:31 561 2==3:=3?251 @;75?=7?13 F:;74 D1 K#L 61 3?D;827 62- 52G18 561 8:5?:827 ?89:@1 25 -##,*& F6?96 ?- ?8 9:8-:82891 F?56 561 8:5?:827 ?89:@1 =31-93?D14 DA 561238252G2 5251 1B27 13C?91- ;56:3?5A <:3 -15571@185 :< 4?-=;51- D1<:31 561 :G 4272568;@=51188;@D13:<E;4B@185-56?-:;3562- - 11 - 6174 5625 561 B;?417?81- ?--;14 DA 561 238252G2 5251 1B2713C?91-;56:3?5A<:3-15571@185:<4?-=;51-D1<:31 :G&427256 31B234?8B 8:5?:827 ?89:@1 ?- ?8 B181327 9:8<:3@?5A F?56 561 F2B1- <?H14 ;8413 561 ?8?@;@ 2B1- 95 6131<:31 561 7:-- :< <;5;31 ?89:@1 :8 299:;85:<4?-2D?7?5A?-9279;725142--##,*&H#(H# H(IM-($,*& #$ :8-1J;1857A5617:--:<?89:@14;3?8B56172?4 ;==13?:462-5:D12--1--14<:32=13?:4:<@:856-284 56131<:312-;@:<-(*&62-5:D12F23414;8413 56?-6124 #/ 613?D;82762-2F234142-;@:<-#***& ;8413 5616124 :< =2?8 284 -;<<13?8B-8 561 9:8-?41314 :=?8?:8 :< 56?- 9:;35 561 -2@1 62- 5: D1 18628914 5: -****& (* 613?D;82762-2F234142-;@:<-#****& ;84135616124:<7:--:<2@18?5?1-?87?<15?-3171C2855: 8:51<3:@5614?-9:@<:35:<<3295;31:<56182-27D:81284 :3D?5 284 561 7:-- :< 51156 ?5 ?- B:?8B 5: 62;85 561 =15?5?:813 <:3 561 31-5 :< 6?- 7?<1 6:;B6 56?- ?8E;3A 62- - 12 - 8:59:853?D;514<:3561<;895?:8274?-2D?7?5A5614?-9:@<:35 :8 299:;85 :< ;-1 :< 4185;31- :3 93:F8?8B 284 -;96 3172514 ?8E;3?1- 62- 5: D1 299:;8514 <:3 56131<:31 561 9:@=18-25?:8;84135616124:<7:--:<2@18?5?1-?-5:D1 186289145:-,***& (# :8-?413?8B561@;75?=71?8E;3?1--;<<1314DA561 =15?5?:813 284 6?- 31J;?31@185 5: C?-?5 4185?-5 2- F177 2- 56131B;7236:-=?5275619:8C1A28911H=18-1-255184285 9623B1-159?-186289145:-#****& (( 61 9:@=18-25?:8 2F23414 DA 561 3?D;827 ;8413 561 31@2?8?8B 6124- 4:1- 8:5 9277 <:3 28A ?8513<131891DA56?-:;35 ( 18915612==177285?-185?5714<:3561@:4?<?14 9:@=18-25?:8;84134?<<131856124-2-D17:F 2?8284-;<<13?8B -****& 55184285 9623B1- %::4 284 :8C1A28919623B1- -#****& :--:<<;5;31?89:@1 -($,*& 14?9271H=184?5;31 -#*****& :-- :< ?89:@1 4;3?8B 561 72?4 ;= =13?:4 -(*& :--:<2@18?5?1- -,***& :527 1--2F23414DA3?D;827 862891@185 -,//***& -',**& ()*)& - 13 - (' 6;- 561 2==177285 ?- 185?5714 <:3 18628914 9:@=18-25?:8 :< -'**& F?56 ?85131-5 284 56131<:31 561 2==127 41-13C1- 5: D1 277:F14 ?8 =235 1891561<:77:F?8B ? 612==127?-# ?? 61 ?@=;B814 E;4B@185284 2F234 =2--14 DA 5613?D;827?-@:4?<?14DA2F234?8B2-;@:< ()*)& ?8 244?5?:8 5: F625 62- D118 2F23414DA5613?D;8275:B15613F?56?85131-5 25 .I =2 <3:@ 561 4251 :< =15?5?:8 5?77 ?5- 3127?N25?:8 ??? 1-=:84185 :( & 8-;32891 :@=28A ?- 4?319514 5: 41=:-?5 561 185?31 9:@=18-25?:8 2@:;85 F?56?8 2 =13?:4 :< -?H F11G- <3:@ 561 4251:<56?-:3413 - 14 - ?C 61:5613 9:84?5?:8- ?8 31-=195 :<56141=:-?5 15931@2?8;82751314 4& $" & " ! ?-5:#7: