- 1 - ! "#"$ %&#!# '! !( ! " ! ! ! #$%%% & ' ! #$($%) ) ! #$($%) Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - ! ## #$($%) $ * !! #$($)%& ! &+ ! ! )+ ! ' $" && &&, !! ! ! ! $() ! ! ! ! ! ! -. ! / !/ *! ' ' 01213434561708995:;03<578=74346301683:71 5< >86?8>:9 35 82275@1 049 8225463>163 =430 71375921A34@11<<1A3<75>301?8315<049464348B8225463>163 - 3 - 86? A5@17 04> :6?17 301 5@176>163 ;7863 =430 8BB A5691C:16348B D161<439 46AB:?46; D8AE =8;19 18@1 :7716?176A890>163 783:43F86?16945613A & 134345617 A56316?9 3083 01 49 8 A ;78?:831 =430 593 78?:831 42B5>8 46 :;87 68BF949 =04A0 01 A5>2B131?46301F187,1A56316?93083719256?163 5$ 08? 938731? 8 61= A5:791 46 :;87 1A065B5;F 86? 822B4A834569 =171 46@431? <57 301 2593 5< B1A3:717 01 2134345617822B41?8;84693301984?259386?=8982254631? 898B1A3:71746:;871A065B5;F5631>25787FD8949@4?1 8225463>163 57?17 ?831? $() 86? =89 B8317 A56<47>1? 46 301 F187 ($ 01 2134345617 AB84>9 3083 <75>30165601089D116=57E46;946A171BF 056193BF86? 35 301 <:BB193 98349<8A3456 5< 719256?163 59 86? $ 1 713471? <75> 917@4A1 46 301 F187 &%& 86? =89 A56346:1? <5786530173=5F18791A56316?93083719256?1635$ =89 A5@171? :6?17 5@176>163 ;7863 46 301 F187 ($ 86? 719256?163 5$ =89 :6?17 301 A56375B 86? 9:217@49456 5< 719256?163 5)#64@17943F 16A1 30171 - 4 - =89 8 611? <57 5D384646; 82275@8B 5< 301 8225463>163 5< 301213434561786?8B95358?>4304><5798B87F;786301 719256?163 5 30171<571 >8?1 8 71271916383456 35 301 719256?163 5) <57 82275@8B 5< 8225463>163 5< 301 2134345617 01 719256?163 5) 8??71991? 8 B13317 ?831? %((35301719256?1635$ 3083216?46;?1A49456 5< 301 8A8?1>4A A5:6A4B 5< 301 :64@17943F 301 2134345617 >8F A56346:1 89 8 B1A3:717 46 :;87 1A065B5;F 83 719256?1635$012134345617AB84>93083<75>301656 A57719256?16A19169:1?D13=116301719256?1639<57301 82275@8B5<0498225463>163012134345617A56316?93083 301 471A357 5< 4;017 ?:A83456 08? 8??71991? 8 B13317 ?831? &)%(% 35 301 5>>49945617 86? 746A428B 1A71387F 35 301 5@176>163 5< 876838E8 938346; 3083 30171 871 65 593 78?:831 ?1;711 05B?179 46 :;87 868BF94986?30171<571 301C:8B4<4A8345625991991?DF301 2134345617A5:B?D1371831?891C:4@8B1633559378?:831 A5:79186?0498225463>163D182275@1?898921A48BA891 01 719256?163 5$ 49 93831? 35 08@1 >8?1 91@178B 71C:1939 =430 301 719256?163 59 & 86? ) <57 301 - 5 - 82275@8B5<3012134345617.98225463>16386?358?>43301 2134345617 <57 98B87F ;7863 01 719256?163 5) DF 86 57?17 ?831? &&%&%% 46<57>1? 301 719256?163 5$ 308359378?:83142B5>846:;8768BF949491C:4@8B163 35 3083 5< 593 78?:83456 C:8B4<4A83456 86? 016A1 301 8225463>163 5< 301 2134345617 89 B1A3:717 46 :;87 1A065B5;F >8F D1 A5694?171? 192431 301 8D5@1 301 719256?16392:725731?BF?4?65382275@13018225463>163 5< 2134345617 =04A0 A5>21BB1? 04> 35 <4B1 71271916383456 ?831? %&&% D1<571 301 719256?163 5 & 6 301 >186=04B1 3012134345617713471?56)%$&%& D:3 =89 A56346:1?<578<:7301721745?5<3=5F1879012134345617 301718<3179:<<171?80187371B831?84B>16386?:6?17=163 8 DF2899 9:7;17F 56 &% 1 A56316?9 3083 946A1 30171 =89 65 71925691 <75> 301 ;5@176>163 01 56A1 8;846 9:D>4331? 8 B13317 ?831? %%$&%, 35 301 719256?16357143178346;049187B41771C:19386?95:;03 <57216945686?53017917@4A171B831?D161<4391AB84>1? 3083 ?:746; A35D17 &% 049 =4<1 =89 ?48;6591? =430 A86A1786?30:9 049<4686A48BA56?43456=89271A8745:986? - 6 - 01 <1BB 46 216:7F 01 2134345617 49 30171<571 D1<571 3049 5:73 911E46; <57 8 ?471A3456 35 301 719256?1639 35 82275@1 049 8225463>163 =430 98B87F ;7863 =430 71375921A34@11<<1A386?;78638BBA5691C:16348BD161<439 ) 01 B18761? 916457 A5:691B 71271916346; 301 2134345617 9:D>4331? 3083 301 2134345617 =89 301 56BF A86?4?8318@84B8DB135D182254631?898B1A3:71746:;87 1A065B5;F 83 301 719256?163 5$ 1 9:D>439 3083 301 471A357831 5< 5BB1;4831 ?:A83456 08? 8??71991? 8 A5>>:64A83456 ?831? &)%(% 35 301 5>>49945617 86?1A71387F5<30112873>1635<?:A83456938346;3083 301 A891 5< 301 2134345617 A5:B? D1 371831? 89 8 921A48B A891 86? A5:B? D1 9163 <57 82275@8B 1 A56316?9 3083 <75>301F187% 301719256?1639?4?653046; D:356 30153017086? 3012134345617.9917@4A19=171:91?8986 1G8>4617 46 301 587? 5< 1G8>46179 56 &,&%%) 1 A56316?9 3083 1GA123 301 2134345617 30171 871 653 >86F 593 78?:831 42B5>8 05B?179 46 :;87 31A065B5;F 86? 30171<571 301719256?1639>:9308@1371831?301A8915< - 7 - 3012134345617 898 921A48B A891 86? >:93 08@1 82275@1? 3018225463>1635<3012134345617 17 A56378 18761? ??434568B 5@176>163 ?@5A831 089 <4B1? 8 93831>163 5< 5DH1A34569 A56316?46; 463178B48 308330125935<8B1A3:71708935D1<4BB1?:2DF 8 A86?4?831 =05 2599199198 593 78?:831 C:8B4<4A83456 46301A56A1761?9:DH1A31A56316?930833012134345617 ?4? 653 2599199 8 593 78?:831 C:8B4<4A83456 46 :;87 1A065B5;F D:3 56BF 25991991? 8 42B5>8 46 :;87 1A065B5;F 86? 30171<571 049 8225463>163 A5:B? 653 D1 82275@1? DF 301 719256?1639 1 A56316?9 3083 305:;0 301471A3578315<5BB1;4831?:A8345608?71A5>>16?1? 3537183301A8915<3012134345617898921A48BA891 4308? 65 <57A1 5< B8= 89 301 719256?163 5) =89 :6?17 301 12873>1635<4;017?:A83456349A56316?1?3083301 21343456179B1235@1704974;039<75>301F187%86??4? 653A5>21B3015<<4A48B719256?16393537183049A891898 921A48B A891 <57 82275@8B 3 49 8B95 A56316?1? 3083 301 2134345617 089 A5>1 35 3049 5:73 8<317 6187BF 6461 F1879 - 8 - <75>301?8315<049713471>163 911E46;<5782275@8B5<049 8225463>163 =430 98B87F ;7863 <75> 8 71375921A34@1 ?831 :73017 43 49 A56316?1? 3083 301 1C:4@8B16A1 A1734<4A831 499:1?DF30164@17943F>8FD19:<<4A4163<57318A046;83 301719256?1635$ D:3496539:<<4A4163<5782275@46;301 8225463>16369:225735<3049A563163456 8H:?;>1635< 84@4945616A05<30495:7346 46 49 71B41?:256 $ 08@1A5694?171?3019:D>49945695<301B18761? 16457 5:691B <57 301 2134345617 86? 301 B18761? ??434568B5@176>163?@5A831<57301719256?16359 86? & 18761? A5:691B <57 719256?163 5 86? $ 9:225731? 301 A5631634569 5< 301 B18761? ??434568B 5@176>163?@5A831 34965346?492:313083301213434561725991991? 8 42B5>8 46 :;87 68BF949 86? =89 82254631? 89 8 B1A3:71746:;871A065B5;FDF301719256?1635$@4?1 8225463>163 57?17 ?831? $() 49 917@4A19 =171 - 9 - ;5@1761? DF 301 17@4A1 !86:8B 5< 301 719256?163 5 049 8225463>163 =89 56 31>25787F D8949 86? 301 98>1 =89 71;:B874I1? @4?1 57?17 ?831? %($ 5=1@17 301 917@4A1 A56?434569 A56346:1 35 D1 ;5@1761? DF 301 17@4A1!86:8B,(01719256?1635) 46712BF 35 8 A5>>:64A83456 8??71991? DF 301 719256?163 5$ 217>4331?301213434561735318A0:;871A065B5;F9:DH1A3 35 :6?17;78?:831 93:?1639 83 301 719256?163 5$ 216?46; ?1A49456 5< 301 A8?1>4A 5:6A4B 5< :BD87;8 64@17943F A5>>:64A83456 =89 8??71991? DF 301 471A3578315<5BB1;4831?:A83456353015>>499456175< ?:A83456 86? 1A71387F 12873>163 5< ?:A83456 71C:19346;433537183301A8915<3012134345617898921A48B A891 <57 82275@8B 5< 2134345617.9 8225463>163 3 8221879 3083<75>8A5>>:64A83456?831?&&%&%% 41 6187BF 8<317 &% F1879 <75> 301 B13317 ?831? %(( 301 719256?1635)8<<47>1?308330159378?:83142B5>8 A5:79146:;871A065B5;F491C:4@8B1633559378?:831 C:8B4<4A8345686?016A1 3018225463>1635<3012134345617 >8FD1A5694?171?5=1@17 3019383:9A56346:1?89301 - 10 - 719256?1635986? & =171 :671B16346; 3582275@1301 8225463>163 89 301 2134345617 ?4? 653 2599199 8 593 78?:831 C:8B4<4A83456 01 2134345617 9:D>4331? 8 71271916383456 46 301 F187 &% 35 A5694?17 049 A891 9F>2830134A8BBF 86? 301 98>1 9383:9 A56346:1? 34BB 301 ?8315<049713471>163 , 3 49 653 46 ?492:31 3083 <57 301 2:725919 5< 8225463>163 5< 8 B1A3:717 46 86 84?1? 469343:3456 8 A86?4?831 >:93 2599199 8 593 78?:83456 46 301 A56A1761? ?49A42B461 01 2134345617 8?>4331?BF ?4? 653 2599199 301 984? C:8B4<4A83456 D:3 25991991? 8 42B5>8 =04A0 =89 653 8?>4331?BF 8 9:<<4A4163 C:8B4<4A83456 35 D1 C:8B4<41?<5730125935<8B1A3:717012134345617 =05089 9B123 5@17 049 74;039 <75> 301 F187 % 86? 089 822758A01?30495:7346301F187&%& A86653A5>21B301 719256?1639 35 82275@1 049 8225463>163 3083 355 =430 71375921A34@1 1<<1A3 <75> 301 ?831 5< 049 464348B 8225463>163 5 ?5:D3 3049 5:73 089 8BB 301 9F>2830F <57 301 2134345617 946A1 30171 871 653 >86F 1G21739 46 - 11 - :;871A065B5;F86?4?18BBF301719256?1639>:9308@1 371831? 301 A891 5< 301 2134345617 89 8 921A48B A891 86? >:9308@138E1693129DF4>25946;A56?434569:25604>35 5D3846859378?:8345646A1 2134345617?4?6532599199 301C:8B4<4A83456 30495:73A86653499:186F>86?8>:935 5@17A5>1 8 >86?8357F 275@49456 46 B8= 86? ?471A3 301 82275@8B5<3018225463>1635<3012134345617 ( 6 3083 @41= 5< 301 >83317 3049 21343456 B8AE9 >174386?49 !)* '#( # ' 4935/B5/&