Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 49401 (KAR)
CHAYA W/O VINAYAK KOSHTI v. NAVEEN S/O BALACHANDRA AND ANR
MFA/200365/2020 · 2025-10-27
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49401 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 49401 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#! "# #$
!! %$& '
! "# # $
#
%&
# '%
#(
) #%
% &
! "# % &)$
" $
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
% &
&
("$ & % *
&
% & % ) % *) ) & & +,-. &
%
% #
% % # /) *) % # #& 0#
% & &
%
% 1#%
1#%
#
"1#% $
23/ 455647 ,896-
6:.3+8 ("$ +; %+.+- 623:76/ :. * "26-6384;.6- -6;6--69 .+ 4/ <.26 :.0$ 24/ =668 ;3769=>.26:743?48.=638@4@@-36A69=>.26B,9@?68.489 4C4-9 94.69 ) 54//69 => 997
683+- 3A37 ,9@6489% 3B4>45,-38% +*) )
) &4:./ @3A38@ -3/6 .+ .26 ;3738@ +; .26 455647 =-36;7> /.4.69 4-6 .24. +8 D )) ) C268 .26 :743?48. 47+8@ C3.2 .2-66 +.26- ;4?37> ?6?=6-/ C6-6 .-4A6738@ 38
- 3 -
%42389-4 6-.3+ 4- =64-38@ -6@3/.-4.3+8 +D* +8)-+49;-+? 3B4>45,-.+,7=4-@4/3964.4=+,. D 4? C268 .26 /439 A623:76 C4/ 864- #23?4 83A6-/47
:2++7 +8
3894@3 -+49 .26 9-3A6- +; .26 /439 4-9-+A63.C3.2423@2/5669489384-4/248986@73@68. ?4886- 26 7+/. :+8.-+7 +A6- 3. 24/ .,-.769 489 ;677 38 4 93.:2 864-=> .26 -+49 / 4 -6/,7. +; .26 4;+-6/439 4::3968..26:743?48./,/.43869@-36A+,/38B,-36/489C4/ 2+/53.473E69
26:743?48.;3769456.3.3+8,896-
6:.3+8+;.26 :./66F38@:+?568/4.3+8 .C4/5764969.24./26/568. 2,@6 4?+,8. .+C4-9/ ?693:47 6G568/6/ :+8A6>48:6 :24-@6/ 6.: . C4/ ;,-.26- 5764969 .24. .26 4::3968. +::,--69 5,-67> +8 4::+,8. +; .26 -4/2 489 86@73@68. 9-3A38@+;.26+;;68938@A623:76=>3./9-3A6-
D 8 /6-A3:6 +; 8+.3:6 .26 -6/5+8968. +/ 489 ) 45564-69 .2-+,@2 :+,8/67 489 ;3769 C-3..68 /.4.6?68. 968>38@.264A6-?68./?49638.26:743?56.3.3+8
- 4 -
8 .26 =4/3/ +; .26 5764938@/ +; .26 54-.36/ .26 743?/-3=,847;-4?69.263//,6/489.26-64;.6--6:+-969 .266A3968:626:743?48.C4/6G4?386926-/67;4/ 489-4A3+547 6-?4C4/6G4?38694/)489@+. 6G23=3.699+:,?68./84?67>G.+GD 8=6247; +; .26 -6/5+8968./ 8+ C3.86// C4/ 6G4?3869 =,. @+. 6G23=3.69 9+:,?68. 84?67>G26 743?/ -3=,847 => .26 3?5,@869 B,9@?68. 38.6- 4734 2679 .24. .26 4::3968. .++F 574:6 +8 4::+,8. +; -4/2 489 86@73@68. 9-3A38@+;.26+;;68938@A623:76=>3./9-3A6-4/4-6/,7.+;
C23:2 .26 :743?48. /,/.43869 38B,-36/ 26 -3=,847 ;,-.26-2679.24..26:743?48.3/68.3.769.+4:+?568/4.3+8 +; / D ( 47+8@ C3.2 38.6-6/. 4. .26 -4.6 +; H 54 489 93-6:.69 .26 -6/5+8968. 8/,-48:6 +?548> .+ 965+/3. .26 :+?568/4.3+8 4?+,8. 47+8@ C3.2 38.6-6/. #638@4@@-36A69.265-6/68.45564724/=668;3769
26 764-869 :+,8/67 ;+- .26 :743?48.24/ -43/69 .26 ;+77+C38@:+8.68.3+8/
- 5 -
"4$ &3-/.7> .24. .26 :743?48. 24/ /,;;6-69 @-36A+,/ 38B,-36/489/26C4/6G4?3869=>.26+,-.+??3//3+86- 455+38.69 => .26 +,-. -3-4A3 +547 6-?4) 6,-+/,-@6+8 +; 6,-+/:368:6/ 38 /.6- % +/53.47 #48@47+-6 8 23/ 6A3968:6 26 24/ :4.6@+-3:477> /.4.69 .24. 9,6 .+ .26 4::3968.47 38B,-36/ .26 :743?48. 24/ /,;;6-6993/4=373.>+; H;+-C23:2/263//,;;6-38@;-+? 54-4576@34489.26:743?48.3/,84=76.+C47F4899+26- 94>.+94> C+-F 489 /26 3/ ,84=76 .+ ?+A6 C3.2+,.
.26 /,55+-.+;484..6896-.37726-74/.=-64.226-3=,84724/ 6--6938:+8/396-38@.2693/4=373.>+87>.+486G.68.+; H C23:2 3/ +8 .26 7+C6- /396 6 ;,-.26- :+8.68969 .24. 38 A36C +; .26 B,9@?68. +; .26 +80=76 56G +,-. 38 .26 :4/6 +;
38 :4/6/ +; 56-?4868. 93/4=76?68. 38:,--69 4/ 4 -6/,7. +; 4 ?+.+- 4::3968..26:743?48.:48/66F454-.;-+?:+?568/4.3+8 ;+- ;,.,-6 7+// +; 38:+?6 .26 :743?48. 3/ 68.3.769 ;+- :+?568/4.3+8.+C4-9/;,.,-65-+/56:./
- 6 -
"=$ 4/.7> .26 :743?48. 24/ /,/.43869 @-36A+,/ 38B,-36/ A68 4;.6- 93/:24-@6 ;-+? .26 2+/53.47 /26 C4/ 8+. 38 4 5+/3.3+8 .+ 93/:24-@6 26- -6@,74- C+-F
26 24/ /,;;6-69 7+. +; 5438 9,-38@ .-64.?68. +8/396-38@ .26 /4?6 .26 :+?568/4.3+84C4-969=>.26-3=,847,896-.262649/+; 17+//+;4?683.36/115438489/,;;6-38@/1489;,.,-6?693:47 6G568/6/ 4-6 +8 .26 7+C6- /396 68:6 26 /+,@2. ;+- 477+C38@.26455647 ( 8 .26 +.26- 2489 .26 764-869 :+,8/67 ;+- .26 -6/5+8968. 8/,-48:6 +?548> 24/ -43/69 ;+77+C38@ :+,8.6-:+8.68.3+8/I
"4$ &3-/.7> 26 24/ :+8.68969 .24. :+8/396-38@ .26 38B,-36/ /,/.43869 => .26 :743?48. 6A3968:6 +; 9+:.+- 93/4=373.>:6-.3;3:4.6489?693:47-6:+-9/.26-3=,84724/ -3@2.7>4 69.2693/4=373.>4. H.+.26C2+76=+9>
"=$ 6:+897> 26 :+8.68969 .24. .26 :743?48. 3/ 4@69 4=+,. ) >64-/ 489 .26-6 3/ 5+//3=373.> +; -6:+A6-> ;-+? .26/43938B,->68:6.26:+?568/4.3+84C4-969=>.26
- 7 -
-3=,847,896-.262649/+;17+//+;4?683.36/115438489 /,;;6-38@/1 489 ;,.,-6 ?693:47 6G568/6/ 4-6 B,/. 489 -64/+84=764893.9+6/8+.:477;+-38.6-;6-68:6
":$ 4/.7>38A36C+;.263A3/3+8#68:296:3/3+8+;.23/ +,-. 38 .26 :4/6 +; (#)**+, (* ,-. +/*0( 12 $*-3,+*(/,-$ ,-. +/*0( % 45
6 74 ,-. 8--*8+*. 9,++*0( .:(;(*. - <4
& .26 -4.6+;38.6-6/.4C4-969=>.26-3=,8474.H54+8.26 :+?568/4.3+84?+,8.3/+8.2623@26-/396.26/4?63/.+ =6-69,:69.+H56-488,?::+-938@7>26/+,@2.;+- 93/?3//47+;.26455647
64-9 .26 764-869 :+,8/67 ;+- .26 54-.36/ 489 56-,/69.26B,9@?68.4894C4-9+;.26-3=,847 *
. 3/ 8+. 38 93/5,.6 .24. .26 :743?48. 24/ /,/.43869 38B,-36/ 38 .26 -+49 .-4;;3: 4::3968. .24. +::,--69 +8 D )) ) 9,6 .+ -4/2 489 86@73@68. 9-3A38@ +; .26 +;;68938@ A623:76 => 3./ 9-3A6- ,6 .+ .26 /439 4::3968. .26:743?48.24//,;;6-69.26;+77+C38@38B,-36/
- 8 -
"4$ /.-,:.,-69C+,89DGD:?+A6--3@2.,556-6>6I
"=$ =748F86//+;-3@2.6>6I
":$ 4=-4/3+8DGD:?+A6--3@2.:266F
"9$ .6896-86//+A6-=+.2.26B+38. "6$ 4=-4/3+8GD.2:?+A6--3@2.67=+C
26 743?/ -3=,847 24/ 455+38.69 .26 +,-. +??3//3+86-
-3-4A3 +547 6-?4 6,-+/,-@6+8 +; 6,-+/:368:6/38/.6-% +/53.47#48@47+-64/) C26-638 26 24/ :4.6@+-3:477> /.4.69 38 23/ 6A3968:6 .24. .26 :743?48. 3/ ,84=76 .+ ?+A6 26- 7+C6- 73?= /26 3/ /,;;6-38@;-+?54-4576@34/263/,84=76.+C47F4899+26- 94>.+94>C+-F489/263/,/38@.26C2667:243-;+-26- ?+A6?68. 489 26 +53869 .24. .26 :743?48. 24/ /,;;6-69 H 93/4=373.> 26 -676A48.
5+-.3+8 +; .26 6A3968:6 +; 9+:.+-3/6G.-4:.6926-638=67+CI
!" #$%& '
" ' ( ' )'* ( +)
,(
"-
- 9 -
" , '-" "
'(
. / -
(,
%
") ( !0'( (0 ( '( 1*,
2/ *
( 0,",3
4
&4 (-" '
, &0
""
"
53 ! ,,
6
'
7
( /)( ( * 3 4
,
"
(- -0 -
(
) '0
( '0 , ," 3 - 4
," (,
3389 (+)(, '0
( '0 , ," 3 - 4
*0 8338 1( &46
'
,7
(
*
-
, , * 4
), -
, *0
7:
""
(,
),
7 ;6! <6 , 144&! '( (
)' ("
, 3=
+8/396-38@ .26 6A3968:6 +; .26 9+:.+- ?693:47 -6:+-9/ 4@6 +; .26 :743?48. C6 4-6 +; .26 +5383+8 .24. .26C2+76=+9>93/4=373.>24/.+=64 694. H
- 10 -
) 26-3=,84738.264=/68:6+;5-++;+;38:+?624/ 4 69 ?+8.27> 38:+?6 +; .26 :743?48. 4. / 5?C23:23/B,/.4895-+56-4898+38.6-;6-68:63/:47769 => .23/ +,-. 8 A36C +; .26 B,9@?68. +; .26 +80=76 56G+,-.38.26:4/6+;")'( $D H+;.26 38:+?624/.+=649969.+C4-9/7+//+;;,.,-65-+/56:./ 26 4@6 +; .26 :743?48. 3/ ) >64-/ 26 ?,7.35736- 45573:4=76.+.264@6@-+,5+;.26:743?48.3/<08-6 96.6-?384.3+8489-64 ?68..26:743?48.3/68.3.769 .+ 4 /,? +; /) "/( J)JJ H$ ,896-.262649<7+//+;;,.,-638:+?60
,6 .+ .26 4::3968. .26 :743?48. 24/ /,;;6-69 @-36A+,/38B,-36/48993/4=373.>4. H
2624//,;;6-69 7+. +; 5438 9,-38@ .-64.?68. 489 /26 24/ .+ /,;;6- ,82455386// C3.2 .26 93/4=373.> /.4.69 => .26 9+:.+- .2-+,@2+,.26-73;6+8/396-38@.26/4?6C64-638:73869 .+ 68248:6 .26 :+?568/4.3+8 4C4-969 => .26 -3=,847 ,896- .26 2649 +; 15438 489 /,;;6-38@/1 ;-+? /
- 11 -
.+/ 489,896-.262649+;17+//+;4?683.36/1 ;-+?/ .+/ D &,-.26- 9,6 .+ .26 4::3968.47 38B,-> .26 :743?48. 24/ /,;;6-69 H 93/4=373.> 489 /26 3/ ,84=76 .+ ?+A6 ;-+?.26=69489.26-6;+-6/26-6K,3-6/+864..6896-;+- 26-/,55+-..37726-74/.=-64.2+8/396-38@.266A3968:6 +; 9+:.+- 489 38B,-> /,;;6-69 => .26 :743?48. 3. C+,79 ?66. .26 689/ +; B,/.3:6 3; 4 /,? +; / 3/ 4C4-969 .+C4-9/ <;,.,-6 ?693:47 6G568/6/ 489 ;,.,-6 4..68948.:24-@6/0C23:2/24778+.:4-->48>38.6-6/. +8/396-38@.2684.,-6+;38B,-36/.26:+?568/4.3+8 4C4-969 => .26 -3=,847 ,896- +.26- 2649/ 3/ B,/. 489 -64/+84=76
2,/ .26 :743?48. 3/ 68.3.769 .+ .26 ;+77+C38@ :+?568/4.3+8
- 12 -
9;*-(,+:-=-.*0 .:*0*-+*,.( (,>,0.*.
?)+/* 0:?=-,@ %(& (,>,0.*. ?)+/:( =0+ %(& 438489/,;;6-38@/
%693:476G568/6/ *)( *)( +//+;64-838@9,-38@ 7439,556-3+9
+//+;;,.,-664-838@ :454:3.>+84::+,8.+; 56-?4868.93/4=373.> D ) +//+;4?683.36/489 ;,.,-6,82455386//
..68948.936. :+8A6>48:6489+.26- :24-@6/ D D &,.,-6?693:476G568/6/ 489;,.,-64..68948. :24-@6/
+,@ 7<
<
(
8.26-6/,7..26;+77+C38@+-96-3/54//69
4$ 264556473/,@@>*.:-;,0+ =$ 26B,9@?68.+;.26743?/-3=,8473/?+93;369
- 13 -
:$ 26:743?48.3/68.3.769.+4.+.47:+?568/4.3+8 +;/)))D( 9$ 26 8/,-48:6 +?548> 3/ 93-6:.69 .+ 965+/3. .26 :+?568/4.3+8 4?+,8. 47+8@ C3.2 38.6-6/. ;-+? .26 94.6 +; ;3738@ +; .26 :743? 56.3.3+8 .377 .26 94.6 +; -6473E4.3+8 C3.238 4 56-3+9 +; /3G C66F/ ;-+? .26 94.6 +; -6:635. +; :+5> +; .23/ B,9@?68. 6G:7,938@ 38.6-6/. ;+- .26 :+?568/4.3+84C4-969,896-.262649+;<;,.,-6 ?693:476G568/6/489;,.,-64..68948.:24-@6/0 6$
8A36C+;B,9@?68.+;.263A3/3+8#68:2+;.23/ +,-.38.26:4/6+;A# B"/,5-4$ .26 68248:69 :+?568/4.3+8 /2477 :4--> 38.6-6/. 4. H 56- 488,? 26 8/,-48:6 +?548> 3/ 93-6:.69.+54>H56-488,?+8.2668248:69 :+?568/4.3+8 ;$ 26 455+-.3+8?68. 965+/3. 489 -6764/6 +; 4?+,8./2477=6?49638.6-?/+;.264C4-9+; .26-3=,847
- 14 -
@$ 26 68248:69 :+?568/4.3+8 4?+,8. /2477 =6 -6764/69 38 ;4A+,- +; .26 :743?48. 4;.6- 9,6 3968.3;3:4.3+8 2$
8A36C+;.26+-96-94.69 D ) )54//69=> .23/ +,-. .26 :743?48. 3/ 8+. 68.3.769 ;+- 38.6-6/. +8 .26 68248:69 :+?568/4.3+8 ;+- .26 9674>6956-3+9+;*)94>/38;3738@.26455647
.6 %!& #
.6 % #$ & #
% 3/.+
7+D #