Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 46872 (KAR)
MOHAMMED FAHEEM AND ANR v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER AND ORS
WP/203290/2023 · 2025-03-27
Chillakur Sumalatha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46872 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 46872 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!" #
$% " & ' (
!"#$
%
&& '
%(%) * !"#$
+&
, & )
)-
& !"#$
%
!"#$
!"#$
Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
# )& ,- * !"#$
+& , #-
. & %%' %%
& .
& '$#%$%% & &
/ & & ) & %""0 $% $$ )
*
- .
&
&
%$%$%% )
&%/
& & 12 & .
3
,&3 -
4567 6887798:; 477< &5=89 9456:47 >?@:A49 BC? 64D64A4:=A68C58=5:<5E@F56C5:768E89456:47>?@:A49
- 3 -
?: 64>?67 G?6 D4=8=8?:46A 5A B499 5A 685998E56H@:
5C@E56 9456:47 778=8?:59 ?I46:F4:= 7I?>5=4 BC? 64D64A4:=A599=C464AD?:74:=A % C8A B68= D4=8=8?: 8A G8947 A44E8:; =C4 ?@6= =? 8AA@45B68=8:=C4:5=@64?G>46=8?6568J@5AC8:;=C4?6746 75=47 '$#%$%% BC8>C B5A D5AA47 K< 64AD?:74:= ? 8:
5:7>?:A4J@4:=9<=?
7864>= 64AD?:74:= ? =? F@=5=4 =C4 :5F4 ?G D4=8=8?:46 ?8:=C464I4:@464>?67A
456:47>?@:A49G?6=C4D4=8=8?:46AA@KF8=A=C5= D4=8=8?:46?D@6>C5A47=C495:757F45A@68:;%5>64A8:
<?%"" ?G C8==5 I8995;4 8756 59@J 5:7 8A=68>= G6?F D4=8=8?:46 ?% @:746 5 64;8A=4647 A594 7447 C4645G=46 D4=8=8?:46A ;5I4 5: 5DD98>5=8?: =? =C4 5C5A897568756=?F@=5=4=C4:5F4?GD4=8=8?:46?8:
=C4 64I4:@4 64>?67A 456:47 >?@:A49 59A? A=5=4A =C5= 599?=F4:=8AF574@:7465:765:=@94A5:7:?=@:746 =C4 56:5=5E5 >C47@947 5A=4A 5:7 >C47@947 68K4A ,&6?C8K8=8?: ?G 65:AG46 ?G 46=58: 5:7A- >= (" ,G?6
- 4 -
AC?6= 1& >=2- C464G?64 =C4 ?6746 D5AA47 K< =C4 5C5A8975664G@A8:;=?F@=5=4=C4:5F4?GD4=8=8?:46?
8: =C464I4:@4 64>?67A 8A @:H@A=8G85K94 456:47 >?@:A49 =C464G?64A44EA=?D5AA:4>4AA56<?6746A # 456:47 778=8?:59 ?I46:F4:= 7I?>5=4 A@KF8=A=C5==C?@;C=C495:7B5A599?==47=?5F4FK46?G A>C47@947>5A=4A@>C599?=F4:=8A:?=@:746=C4&>= C@A 64AD?:74:= ? 5C5A89756 ?@;C= =? C5I4 4:=46=58:47 =C4 5DD98>5=8?: ?G =C4 D4=8=8?:46A 456:47 778=8?:59 ?I46:F4:= 7I?>5=4 =C464K< A44EA =? D5AA :4>4AA56<?6746AB8=C57864>=8?:=?64AD?:74:=?=?7? =C4:447G@9
456:47 >?@:A49 G?6 =C4 D4=8=8?:46A D95>47 64985:>4@D?:=C4?674675=47$$%$%?G=C8A?@6=8: .&?%$%$%BC4648:5=D565;65DC'?G=C4?6746 =C8A?@6=C4975A@:746
- 5 -
! "
!
! #
$
%
"
"
&
"
"'((" ! !"
"
)
*
"$ +
' 456:47 778=8?:59 ?I46:F4:= 7I?>5=4 C8FA49G A=5=4A =C5= =C4 5C5A89756 ?@;C= :?= =? C5I4 D5AA47 =C4 8FD@;:47 ?6746 64H4>=8:; =C4 64J@4A= ?G =C4 D4=8=8?:46A5:7=C5==C44FK56;?@:746&>=7?4A:?= 5DD9< =? =C4 A@KH4>= D6?D46=< C464G?64 =C8A ?@6=
- 6 -
>?:A8746A 74A865K94 =? 599?B =C4 B68= D4=8=8?: C@A B68= D4=8=8?:8A599?B47B8=C=C4G?99?B8:;
i. C4 ?6746 75=47 '$#%$%% BC8>C B5A D5AA47K<4AD?:74:=?5C5A89756 8756 I874 6746 K4568:; ?
8AJ@5AC47 ii. 4AD?:74:= ? 8A 7864>=47 =? F@=5=4 =C4 :5F4 ?G D4=8=8?:46 ? 8: =C4 64I4:@464>?67A8:64AD4>=?G=C4A@KH4>= 95:7B8=C8:5D468?7?G48;C=B44EAG6?F =C475=4?G64>48D=?G>?D<?G=C8A?6746
)'
&* " ( %
) 8A=?9?'