- 1 - ! "#$ # %#! &' %#! ' !" # $ %& ' ($$ ) Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - *! & !" ' ($ ) & & +(*)&& & #"#"+ + #" & & & & $ & $ $& & & , ' * & !" ' ($ ) - 3 - # # $ %& $ !" ' ($$ & #&) & & +(*)&& #"#"+ $ & + #" & , & & - 4 - -$ ( -$ ) ./0123.4./05.167859.4:7023.;.2<2<75.09=.44/923. 4./05.167859.4:7023.0.9;751.52<5>72323.6/9.9 # 3.9. ;.2<2<759 /0. :<4.1 <?;8@5.1 23. 701.0 <5 04<967+ #" 75 23. :<4. 7: 23. 11<2<75/4 0<56<;/4 81@. &/?<4A 7802 /2 <B/A/;80/ (:70 93702 C23. &/?<4A 7802D) 3. ;.2<2<75 >.:70. 23. &/?<4A 7802 <9 :<4.1 >A 23. =<:./51?<5709757:7;/49<5@385580 0/2/;9<5@385580 <923.0.9;751.52<523.9/<1;.2<2<75>.:70.23.&/?<4A7802 9 /@/<592 701.0 :70 ;/A?.52 7: ?/<52.5/56. 7: 9"""E ;.0 ?7523 27 ;.2<2<75.0 7 /51 9""E ;.0 ?752327;.2<2<75.07#23.;.2<2<75<5 &7#"""#"#* <9:<4.1>A23.=<:./5123.?<5709..F<5@.53/56.?.52 * @@0<.G.1>A23.G.0A9/?.701.023. 0/2/;9<5@3 855803/9:<4.1 &7#"""##"# - 5 - &70 23. 9/F. 7: 675G.5<.56. =<:. /51 975 /0. 0.:.00.127/923.;.2<2<75.09/5123.389>/51<90.:.00.127/9 0.9;751.52 ! 3. 4./05.1 67859.4 :70 23. ;.2<2<75.09 =7841 6752.5123/223.701.0:70;/A?.52?/<52.5/56.7:9"""E ;.0 ?7523 <5 :/G780 7: ;.2<2<75.0 7 /51 9""E ;.0 ?7523<5:/G7807:;.2<2<75.07#<9<5/1.H8/2.@<G.523.:/62 23/223.0.9;751.523/998::<6<.52<567?.:07?3<9/G76/2<75/9 4.620<6</5 /51 23. <567?. :07? /@0<684280/4 4/51 2 <9 3<9 :8023.098>?<99<7523/223.<567?.:07?23./@0<684280/44/51 <9 <@570.1 >A 23. &/?<4A 7802 2 <9 80@.1 23/2 701.0 7: ;/A?.52 7: ?/<52.5/56. 7: 9""E ;.0 ?7523 27 23. ;.2<2<75.07#=37<9?<570<9277?./@.0=3.523.701.0<9 ;/99.1 <5 23. A./0 #"+ 2 <9 /497 80@.1 23/2 23. ;.2<2<75.09 /0. <56800<5@ ?70. .I;.59.9 /51 /9 9863 23.0. 3/9 27 >. .53/56.1?/<52.5/56. J 9 :/0 /9 ;.2<2<75.0 7 <9 6756.05.1 <2 <9 80@.1 23/275/6678527:3<@3.067927:4<G<5@23.;.2<2<75.07<9 .52<24.1 :70 3<@3.0 ?/<52.5/56. /51 &/?<4A 7802 .00.1 <5 /=/01<5@9"""E27;.2<2<75.07 - 6 - ./05.1 67859.4 :70 23. 0.9;751.52 75 23. 723.0 3/51 6752.51 23/2 ;.2<2<75.0 7 3/1 ?/00<.1 97?. 723.0 ;.0975 >.:70. ?/00A<5@ 23. 0.9;751.52 /51 9/?. =/9 98;;0.99.1>A23.;.2<2<75.073.3/9/1?<22.1<560799E .I/?<5/2<75 23/2 3.0 :<092 ?/00</@. <9 92<44 98>9<92<5@ 2 <9 :8023.080@.123/223.0.9;751.5217.95723/G.23.<567?.27 ;/A?/<52.5/56.2723.;.2<2<75.09/513.=7841:8023.098>?<2 23/2 ;.2<2<75.0 7 <9 572 .52<24.1 27 /5A ?/<52.5/56. @<G.5 23.:/6223/23.0?/00</@.<9G7<1/5193.3/998;;0.99.13.0 ./04<.0?/00</@..56.3.=784180@.23/223.?/<52.5/56. /=/01.1<5:/G7807:23.;.2<2<75.073/927>.9.2/9<1. + 3<978023/96759<1.0.123.6752.52<7590/<9.1/2 23.$/0/51;.089.123.0.67019 " 3. /@0<684280/4 4/51 <5 23.5/?. 7: 0.9;751.52 <9 572<51<9;82.3.0.9;751.52<9/497=70F<5@/9/54.620<6</5 3. ;.2<2<75.0 7# =/9 /@.1 A./09 =3.5 23. ;.2<2<75 =/9 :<4.17=3.<9/@.1+A./093.67927:4<G<5@3/9@75.8; 9<56. #" 23. A./0 <5 =3<63 23. ;.2<2<75.09 978@32 ?/<52.5/56. 2 <9 /497 572<6.1 23/2 23. 0.9;751.52 <9 <5 - 7 - /00./09 /51 3. 3/9 572 ;/<1 23. ?/<52.5/56. 701.0.1 >A 23. 20</47802 51.023.9.6<068?92/56.923<97802<97:23.G<.= 23/223.;.2<2<75.07#<9.52<24.1:709J"""E;?27=/019 ?/<52.5/56./510.9;751.5293/44;/A23.9/?.:07?23.1/2. 7:23.;.2<2<75>.:70.23<97802/923.0.=/91.4/A<5:<4<5@23. ;.2<2<75>.:70.23<9678027=.G.023<96756.99<75<998>B.62 27 0.9;751.52 ;/A<5@ /00./09 7: ?/<52.5/56. 701.0.1 >A 23. &/?<4A7802=<23<5230..?75239:07?23.1/2.7:23<9701.0 :23./00./097:?/<52.5/56./9701.0.1>A23.&/?<4A7802<9 572 ;/<1 >A 23. 0.9;751.52 23.5 23. 0.9;751.52 93/44 ;/A 9J"""E;.0 ?7523 27 23. ;.2<2<75.0 7# :07? 23. 1/2. 7: ;.2<2<75>.:70.23.&/?<4A7802 # 7:/0/9;.2<2<75.07<96756.05.1<2<9/1?<22.1 <5 23. 60799E.I/?<5/2<75 23/2 93. =/9 ?/00<.1 >.:70. 93. ?/00<.1 23. 0.9;751.52 /51 3.0 :<092 ?/00</@. =/9 98>9<92<5@ /51 9/?. 3/9 572 >..5 /55844.1 >A 23. 67?;.2.52 7802 51.0 23.9. 6<068?92/56.9 23. ;.2<2<75.0 7 <9 572 .52<24.1 27 ?/<52.5/56. /9 93. 3/9 98;;0.99.1 23. :/628? 7: ./04<.0 ?/00</@. - 8 - .56.23.:7447=<5@ <) $723 23. ;.2<2<759 5/?.4A & 7#"""#"#* /51 & 7#"""##"#/0./447=.1<5;/02 <<) 3. 0.9;751.52E389>/51 93/44 ;/A 9J"""E ;.0 ?7523 27=/019 ?/<52.5/56.2723.;.2<2<75.07#:07? 23.1/2.7:;.2<2<75>.:70.23<97802<. 75 "*#"#* <<<) &7#"""#"#*:<4.1>A;.2<2<75.0 7<93.0.>A1<9?<99.1 <G) 3. ?/<52.5/56. /40./1A ;/<1 27 ;.2<2<75.0793/44572>.0.67G.0.1 G) 5 6/9. 23. 0.9;751.52 17.9 572 ;/A /00./09 7: ?/<52.5/56. ;/A/>4. 27 ;.2<2<75.07#<52.0?97:23.<?;8@5.1 701.0 =<23<5 230.. ?75239 :07? 271/A 23.0.9;751.5293/44;/A?/<52.5/56./2 9J"""E;?:07?23.1/2.7:70<@<5/4 ;.2<2<75>.:70.23.&/?<4A7802 G<) 3./?785293/44>.60.1<2.12723.>/5F /6678527:;.2<2<75.07#=3<6393/44>. - 9 - 7;.5.1 >A /;;7<52<5@ ;.2<2<75.0 7 /9 @8/01</57:;.2<2<75.07# G<<) 3. ;.2<2<75.0 7 93/44 :805<93 23. 1.2/<49 7: 23. >/5F /667852 27 23. 0.9;751.52 (& )# * $ $ <92747