- 1 - !" # $ % %% &"' ( ! "## $ %% & ## ' # # !( % # ! # ## # % # % ## '' ! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - )% ' ' ! ! '' # ! " # $ %' * %' * % !! +# & '' ($& '%# ## ' # !,!!# % % !-- !- # # ' !(- !!!!! . # ' ' # ) ## ' % / / 0 # $ 123 455647 23 82769 :; <16 =742>4?< 4@42?3< <16 A9@>6?< 4?9 4B4C9 94<69 !,!! 543369 2? % D!-- !-:;<166?2DC2E27A9@64?974?9 - 3 - $8DC 31DC< F<16 <C2:A?47G& 366H2?@ 6?14?=6>6?< D8 <16 =D>56?34<2D? 16=742>4?<4@69(;64C3>6<B2<14==296?<D? !!!-4?93A886C69@C26EDA32?IAC2636B4349>2<<69 <D <16 D352<47 4?9 <DDH <C64<>6?< 4<6C 16 82769 =742> 56<2<2D? :68DC6 <16 <C2:A?47 366H2?@ =D>56?34<2D? D8 3!!!!! 47D?@ B2<1 2?<6C63< 4< <16 C4<6 D8 . 56C 4??A> 8CD> <16 94<6 D8 56<2<2D? <277<16 94<6 D8 C6472J4<2D? D?3296C2?@ <16 6?<2C6 6E296?=6 D? C6=DC9 <16 <C2:A?47 4B4C969 4 3A> D8 3!(- 47D?@ B2<1 2?<6C63< 4< <16 C4<6D8,.56C4??A>8CD><1694<6D856<2<2D?<277C6472J4<2D? 4?992C6=<69C635D?96?<D4?9K?3AC4?=6=D>54?263 <D 965D32< <16 =D>56?34<2D? 4>DA?< 2? <16 C4<2D D8 !/! 64=1 47D?@ B2<1 2?<6C63< 62?@ 4@@C26E69 :; <16 3429 A9@>6?< 4?9 4B4C9 <16 =742>4?< 5C686CC69 <16 5C636?< 455647366H2?@6?14?=6>6?<D8<16=D>56?34<2D? ? <16 5C636?< 455647 2< 23 =D?<6?969 <14< <16 4>DA?<3 @C4?<69 A?96C 92886C6?< 16493 4C6 >64@6C 16 =742>4?< 143 6L4>2?69 <16 D=<DC :68DC6 <16 <C2:A?47 16 - 4 - D=<DC1434336336951;32=472>542C>6?<D8!.<D<16C2@1< 7DB6C72>:4?9.<D<16B1D76:D9;A<<16<C2:A?47143 6CC692?=D?3296C2?@ C9D8.26.B12=123D?7DB6C 3296 16C68DC6 C6MA63<69 <D 6?14?=6 <16 =D>56?34<2D? 4>DA?< L#,23<16BDA?9=6C<282=4<6356C<16BDA?9 =6C<282=4<6 <16 =742>4?< 3A3<42?69 =CA31 2?IAC; DC C2@1< 8DD< 4?9 8C4=<AC6 :436 D8 C2@1< <1 B12=1 23 @C26EDA3 2? ?4<AC6 L#(4?9 L# 4C6<16923=14C@6=6C<282=4<6316 D=<DC # 233A69 9234:272<; =6C<282=4<6 >4CH69 4< L# 2? B12=1 2< 23 D:36CE69 <14< $2& #42? 6?96C?633 4?9 68DC>2<;DE6CC2@1<8CD?<4?H76K!.*5D3<8C4=<AC6D8C2@1< <1 >6<4<4C347 4?9 :436 D8 ?9 C9 4?9 <1 >6<4<4C3473 4?9 7A:D29 4?9 A?28DC> :D?63* $22& C63<C2=<2D? D8 4?H76 ID2?< >D<2D? <9 8CD> -! 96@C66 <D ! 96@C66 574?<4C 876L2> !.*$222&92882=A7<;2?3MA4<<2?@164E;B62@1<728<2?@B47H2?@ 2? 37D55; 3AC84=6 6<= 4?9 D52?69 <14< <16 =742>4?< 23 14E2?@ 51;32=47 2>542C>6?< D8 !. <D C2@1<7DB6C 72>: 4?9 .<D<16B1D76:D9; - 5 - 64C?69 =DA?367 8DC <16 4556774?< 3<4<69 <14< =D?3296C2?@ <16 2?IAC263 3A3<42?69 :; 12> <16 8A?=<2D?47 9234:272<; 23 <D :6 <4H6? 43 !!. 123 DAC< 82?93 2< C643D?4:76 <D <4H6 C9 D8 . 9234:272<; 4?9 2< =D>63 <D .2?3<649D8.<4H6?:;<16<C2:A?4716<C2:A?47143 C2@1<7; <4H6? <16 2?=D>6 D8 <16 =742>4?< 43 56C <16 =14C< 5C654C69 :; <16 6@47 6CE2=63 A<1DC2<; 16?=6 <16 34>6 ?6693 ?D 2?<6C86C6?=6 2?=6 <16 4@6 D8 <16 =742>4?< 23 ;64C3 <16 >A7<25726C 23 F(G 6?=6 <16 7D33 D8 64C?2?@ =454=2<;2343A?96C/ 3! NN(N.O3!! , 16 <C2:A?47 143 4B4C969 4 3A> D8 3,( <DB4C93>692=476L56?3631634>623=DCC6=<4?9?6693?D 2?<6C86C6?=6 16 =742>4?< B43 1D352<472J69 8DC , 94;3 D?3296C2?@ <16 D==A54<2D? 4@6 4?9 ?4<AC6 D8 2?IAC263 3A3<42?69 :; <16 =742>4?< <123 DAC< 82?93 2< C643D?4:76 <D 4B4C9 4 3A> D8 3!!!! <DB4C93 542? 4?9 3A886C2?@3 3!!! <DB4C93 7D33 D8 4>6?2<263 4?9 3!!!! <DB4C93 <C4?35DC<4<2D? 6L<C4 ?DAC231>6?< 4?9 4<<6?94?< - 6 - =14C@63 16 =742>4?< >2@1< 14E6 ?D< 4<<6?969 4?; D<16C BDCH8DC4<7643<8DAC>D?<136?=616236?<2<769<D43A> D8 3!!! $3! N >D?<13& <DB4C93 7D33 D8 2?=D>6 9AC2?@ 7429 A5 56C2D9 16 <D<47 =D>56?34<2D? 23 43 A?96C/ ) *+,-./0*1-+231 /412 D33D864C?2?@=454=2<; 3!! 692=476L56?363 3,( #42?4?93A886C2?@3 3!!!! D33D84>6?2<263 3!!! C4?35DC<4<2D? 6L<C4 ?DAC231>6?< 4?94<<6?94?<=14C@63 3!!!! , D33 D8 2?=D>6 9AC2?@ 7429 A5 56C2D9 3!!! 2+) - 56 7 ( 64C?69 =DA?3673 8DC <16 ?3AC4?=6 =D>54?263 3A:>2< <14< <16 4>DA?< 4B4C969 :; <16 <C2:A?47 143 :66? 965D32<69:68DC6<16<C2:A?47 ==DC92?@7;<168D77DB2?@DC96C/ $2& 1645564723477DB692?54C<* $22& 16 =742>4?< 23 6?<2<769 <D <D<47 =D>56?34<2D? D8 3, -,( 47D?@ B2<1 2?<6C63< 4< <16 C4<6 D8 ,. 56C 4??A> 8CD> <16 94<6 D8 56<2<2D?<277<1694<6D8C6472J4<2D?* - 7 - $222& 16C635D?96?<D34?9K?3AC4?=6 =D>54?263 4C6 92C6=<69 <D 965D32< <16 6?14?=69 =D>56?34<2D?D83 , 2?<16C4<2DD8!/! B2<12?D?6>D?<18CD><1694<6D8<123DC96C* $2E& ? 3A=1 965D32< <16 =742>4?< 23 56C>2<<69 <D B2<19C4B <16 6?<2C6 6?14?=69 =D>56?34<2D?47D?@B2<12?<6C63<4==CA69D?2< -,7 &% ' $ % 23<D/7D/