- 1 - ! " # $% % $% &%!# ##'& ( ) ! " # $%"%!& '!# $%"%!&! !&&&% ! ( # Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # # !)! #$!*"" + # ,)&!, !)&*&!" # - - % - ./0 122314 /0 5/436 78 9.3 1223441:9 $ 239/9/;:3< 5;< 3:.1:=3>3:9 ;5 =;>23:019/;: 10 1?1/:09 9.3 @A6?>3:9 1:61B1<6210036789.3<43:/;</C/4 A6?31:6 1417A<1?//:;,)&!,61936!)&*&!" & 31<69.3431<:36=;A:0345;<9.31223441:91:6 9.3<302;:63:9; - 3 - & .3=103;59.3239/9/;:3<735;<39.3</7A:14/0 9.199.3239/9/;:3<.105/4361=41/>239/9/;:A:63<3=9/;: !,, ;5 9.3 =9 5;< =41/>/:? =;>23:019/;: 19 0,%&&&&$ 5;< 9.3 /:@A</30 0A091/:36 78 ./> /: 9.3 <;169<155/=1==/63:9;:!&&!1917;A9!&!&1>9 /0=;:93:63678./>9.19;:9.301/66193B.3:.3B10 2<;=336/:?/:13>2;<1D9;B1<609.3.1<1:1/<101?/ 9; ?; 9; ./0 /:09/9A93 19 9.19 9/>3 9.3 ;<<8 731</:? 3?;$$$)*E! =1>3 /: 1 ./?. 02336 <10. 1:6 :3?4/?3:9>1::3<1:6610.369;9.33>2;<1DA39; B./=. .3 .10 0A091/:36 ?</3C;A0 /:@A</30 1:6 .3 B10 9<31936 10 /:219/3:9 3 .10 023:9 >;<3 9.1: 0&&&&&$ 9;B1<60 >36/=14 9<319>3:9 A3 9; 9.3 1==/63:9.3/00A553</:?6/017/4/981:6;:C1</;A0.3160.3 .10=41/>369.3=;>23:019/;: &E .3 <302;:63:9 ; F /:0A<1:=3 =;>21:8 12231<36735;<39.3</7A:149.<;A?./90=;A:0341:65/436 9.3 B</993: 09193>3:9 63:8/:? 9.3 <10. 1:6 :3?4/?3:9 - 4 - 6</C/:? ;5 9.3 6</C3< ;5 9.3 4;<<8 1:6 63:/36 9.3 1?3 /:=;>31:6;==A219/;:;59.3239/9/;:3<9.10140;91G3: 9.3 ?<;A:6 1C1/41743 A:63< 3=9/;: !)& ;5 =9 3:=32<18365;<6/0>/00/:?9.3=41/>239/9/;: &% 1036;:9.317;C324316/:?09.3</7A:14.10 5<1>369.35;44;B/:?/00A30$ ! " # $$ % & '& (!)**)*+,-. ( ' & (!)**)*+,- ''$ / '$$ . ' $ . ' " # $ ' #. #. - 5 - &, .3 239/9/;:3< ./>0345 3D1>/:36 10 ! 1:6 6;=9;< 3D1>/:36 10 1:6 ?;9 >1<G36 D0! 9; !) 6;=A>3:90 :73.145;59.3<302;:63:90:;;<143C/63:=3 .10 733: 436 3D=329 >1<G/:? 9.3 D! F /:0A<1:=3 2;4/=8 &) 593< .31</:? 9.3 1<?A>3:90 9.3 </7A:14 1:0B3<369.3/00A3;!/:9.3155/<>19/C3 /00A3;/: 9.3 :3?19/C31:6/00A3;21<948 /: 9.3 155/<>19/C3 1:6 21<948144;B369.3=41/>239/9/;:78?<1:9/:?=;>23:019/;: 19 0!*,*&&$ 78 5/D/:? 9.3 4/17/4/98 ;: 9.3 /:0A<1:=3 =;>21:810734;B$ 4 ; 3160 ;>23:019/;: B1<636 ! 1/:0.;=G1:61?;:8 0,&&&&$ 36/=143D23:030 0!%&&$ #;;66/39:;A</0.>3:9 =;:C381:=31:6;9.3</:=/63:914 3D23:030 0&&&$ E ;00;5/:=;>36A</:?9<319>3:9 23</;6 0!&&&$ % ;00;5/:=;>39;B1<6023<>1:3:9 6/017/4/98 0)!E&&$ , /0122;/:9>3:91:66/0=;>5;<9 1:64;00;51>3:/9/30 0&&&&$ ;914 0!*,*&&$ - 6 - &" #334/:?1??</3C36789.301>39.3239/9/;:3</0 735;<39./0;A<95;<3:.1:=3>3:9;59.3=;>23:019/;: &* .3431<:36=;A:0345;<9.31223441:9=;:93:636 9.199.;A?.9.36;=9;<.10733:;2/:369.199.36/017/4/98 /017;A9!%H1:6.3B100A553<365<;>5<1=9A<37A99.3 </7A:14.1091G3:;:48%H9;B1<609.36/017/4/98B./=./0 C3<8 >31?<3 .3 /:=;>3 91G3: 78 9.3 </7A:14 /0 140; C3<8 >31?<3 19 0)&&&$ 23< >;:9. C3: 6A</:? 9.3 23</;6 ;5 9<319>3:9 9.3 4;00 ;5 /:=;>3 /0 91G3: 19 0!&&&$ B./=. /0 140; C3<8 >31?<3 .3 6/0=;>5;<9 1:66/0122;/:9>3:96A39;/:@A</300A091/:3678./>.3/0 :;9 1743 9; 0/9 5;< 4;:? 9/>3 /: 9.3 =.1/< B./=. /0 :;9 2<;23<48 =;:0/63<36 78 9.3 </7A:14 3:=3 2<1836 5;< 3:.1:=/:?9.3=;>23:019/;:1>;A:9 !& 0 $ 9.3 431<:36 =;A:034 5;< 9.3 <302;:63:9 ; F /:0A<1:=3 =;>21:8 0A22;<936 9.3 @A6?>3:9 1:6 1B1<6 ;5 9.3 </7A:14 1:6 =;:93:636 9.19 9.3 </7A:14 .10 =;:0/63<36 144 9.3 1023=90 1:6 </?.948 ?<1:936 9.3 =;>23:019/;: B./=. /0 @A09 1:6 2<;23< 1:6 9.3<3/0:;:3369;3:.1:=39.301>33:=32<18365;< 6/0>/00/:?9.3122314 - 7 - !! 1C/:? .31<6 9.3 1<?A>3:90 23<A036 9.3 <3=;<60 9.32;/:9 9.19 B;A46 1</030 5;< 9./0;A<9 1<310 A:63<$ $ # & "# $1 '$" ' #2. ! :0;51< 10 9.3 51=9A> ;5 9.3 1==/63:9 ;: !&!&!1917;A9!&!&1>/0:;96/02A936/:=39.3 /00A3 ;! 1:0B3<36 /: 51C;A< ;5 9.3 239/9/;:3< B./=. /0 :;96/02A936789.3/:0A<1:=3=;>21:81:64/17/4/98/0140; :;9 6/02A936 .3<35;<3 ;:48 9.3 =;:0/63<19/;: 5;< 9./0 ;A<9<3?1<6/:?=;>23:019/;:1B1<636789.3</7A:14/0 @A091:62<;23<;<:;9 ! : 23<A014 ;5 9.3 <3=;<60 9.3 </7A:14 .10 =;:0/63<369.3/:=;>3;59.3239/9/;:3<190)&&&$23< >;:9.5;<9.31==/63:961936!&!&!==;<6/:?9;;A< C/3B9.3/:=;>391G3:789.3</7A:14/0=;<<3=99.3<3/0 - 8 - :;;9.3<6;=A>3:902<;6A=36789.3239/9/;:3</:;<63<9; 0.;B9.19./0/:=;>3/0>;<39.1:0)&&&$23<>;:9. .19 121<9 0!%&&$ .10 733: 1B1<636 9;B1<60 9.3 >36/=143D23:0309.19140;:;96/02A936789.3/:0A<1:=3 =;>21:8 9.;A?. 9.3 239/9/;:3< .10 =41/>36 0&&&&&$ 7A9 9.3 6;=A>3:90 1<3 2<;6A=36 5;< 0!%&&$ B./=. /0 @A09 1:6 2<;23< :0;51< 9;B1<60 5;;6 6/39 :;A</0.>3:9 =;:C381:=3 1:6 ;9.3< /:=/63:914 3D23:030 1: 1>;A:9 ;5 0&&&$ /0 1B1<636 9.19 140; <3C3140 9.19 /9 /0 @A09 1:6 2<;23< .3 1223441:9 B10 16>/9936 9; 9.3 .;02/914 5;< ;:48 9B; 6180 1:6 B10 6/0=.1<?36 .3<35;<3 9.3 IA309/;: ;5 ?<1:9/:? >;<3 1>;A:96;30:;91</03 !E ./01==/63:9B10;==A<<366A39;9.3:3?4/?3:9 6</C/:? ;5 9.3 4;<<8 6</C3< B.; =1>3 /: ./?. 02336 1:6 610.369;9.33>2;<1D;59.3239/9/;:3<1:66A39;9.3 01/61==/63:99.3239/9/;:3<0A091/:369B;/:@A</309.19/0 - 9 - 6/55A03 6/0= 7A4?3 ;5 $E E$% =1A0/:? /:63:919/;: ;5 0A76A<14021=31:61:;9.3</:@A<8/06/55A036/0=7A4?319 $E%$,=1A0/:?/:63:919/;:;51:93</;<#=;4A>: .;A?. 9.3<3 1<3 :; 3D93<:14 /:@A</30 7A9 9.3 0=1::/:? <32;<901809.19.3.100A091/:36/:93<:14/:@A</306A39; 9.3 7A4?/:? ;5 6/0= 19 $E %$, 1:6 E$% 43C340 35/:/93489.3239/9/;:3<.100A553<364;9;521/:1:61?;:8 6A39;/:93<:14/:@A</309.;A?./9/0:;9C/0/743;B3C3< 9.3 /:@A</30 1<3 ?</3C;A0 /: :19A<3 .3<35;<3 ?<1:9/:? 0,&&&&$ A:63< 9.3 21/: 0.;=G 1:6 1?;:8 /0 C3<8 >31?3<10:19A<3;5./01C;=19/;:/00/99/:?;:1=.1/<1:6 .3=1::;90/9;:1=.1/<5;<4;:?9/>33:=3B32<;2;03 9; 3:.1:=3 9.3 1>;A:9 9; 0)%&&&$ 9;B1<60 21/: 0.;=G 1:6 1?;:8 78 4;;G/:? /:9; 9.3 51=90 1:6 =/<=A>091:=30;59./0=103 !% .3</7A:14.101B1<6360&&&&$9;B1<60 4;00;51>3:/9/30.3:19A<3;5/:@A<8/06/55A036/0=7A4?3 19$E1:6E$%=1A0/:?/:63:919/;:;50A76A<14021=3 - 10 - 35/:/9348 /9B/44=1A035A9A<36/017/4/98 1:6.3=1::;90/9 5;< 1 4;:? 9/>3 1:6 .3 .10 9; 0A553< 9.<;A?.;A9 ./0 4/53 A=.73/:?9.3=1031B1<6/:?0&&&&$/04/9943>31?3< 4;;G/:? /:9; 9.3 51=90 1:6 =/<=A>091:=30 ;5 9.3 =103 B3 2<;2;039;3:.1:=31:;9.3<0!%&&&$A:63<9./0.316 ==;<6/:?48 B3 2<;2;03 9; 1B1<6 0E%&&&$ 9;B1<60 4;00 ;5 1>3:/9/30 /:09316 ;5 0&&&&$ 1B1<636 78 9.3 </7A:14 !, 323:6/:? ;: 9.3 4;00 ;5 /:=;>3 9;B1<60 6/017/4/98 9.3 </7A:14 .10 </?.948 91G3: 9.3 >;:9.48 /:=;>3 19 0)&&&$ 1:6 >A49/24/3< /0 1224/36 78 !)1:6 6/017/4/98 91G3: 19 %H 1:6 1==;<6/:?48 9.3 9;914 4;00 ;5 /:=;>3 9;B1<60 6/017/4/98 /0 19 0)!E&&$ 3 6; :;9 /:=4/:39;/:93<53<3B/9.9.3=;>23:019/;:1B1<636789.3 </7A:149;B1<604;00;55A9A<3/:=;>36A39;6/017/4/98 !) .3<35;<3 9.3 =41/>1:9 /0 3:9/9436 5;< 9;914 3:.1:=36=;>23:019/;:A:63<9.35;44;B/:?.3160$ - 11 - 4 ; 3160 ;>23:019/;: B1<636 789./0;A<9 ! 1/:1:61?;:8 0)%&&&$ 36/=143D23:030 0!%&&$ #;;66/39 :;A</0.>3:9 =;:C381:=31:6;9.3< /:=/63:9143D23:030 0&&&&$ E ;00;5/:=;>36A</:? 9<319>3:923</;6 0!&&&$ % ;00;5/:=;>3 9;B1<6023<>1:3:9 6/017/4/98 0)!E&&$ , /0122;/:9>3:91:6 6/0=;>5;<91:64;00;5 1>3:/9/30 0E%&&&$ ;914 3001B1<636789.3 </7A:14 0,*&&$ 0!*,*&&$ ;9143:.1:=3>3:9 0&&&&$ !" 3:=3 122314 6303<C30 9; 73 144;B36 /: 21<9 .3<35;<39.35;44;B/:?( / .3122314/0 // .3 @A6?>3:9 1:6 1B1<6 61936 !)&*&!" 210036 /: ;,)&!, 210036 78 9.3 </:=/214 3:/;< /C/4 A6?3 1:6 1417A<1?//0>;6/5/36 - 12 - /// .3 1223441:9 /0 3:9/9436 5;< 1: 3:.1:=36 =;>23:019/;: ;5 0,*&&$101?1/:090!*,*&&$ 1B1<636 78 9.3 </7A:14 B./=. 0.144 =1<<8 /:93<309 19 9.3 <193 ;5 ,H 23< 1::A>5<;>9.36193;5239/9/;:9/449.3 6193;5<314/J19/;: /C .3 3:9/<3 1>;A:9 /: 632;0/9 0.144 73 <34310369;9.31223441:9 *+ '%( % *+ '&%!#( % /09;!4;)